September 18, 201511 yr So with the offense finally showing what they're capable of, it's entirely possible the Marlins make zero changes to their starting lineup (counting Bour as the first baseman) ...the exception probably just being trading someone like Ozuna to bring in some of the pitching we need. With all the turnaround we thought we needed, how many of you would be ok with these exact starting eight position players for 2016?
September 19, 201511 yr Better late than never? The rotation has been a mess, but it really is a shame that the offense took this long to get rolling. Of course, now that it is rolling, that can mean good things for next season, however, that assumes no slumps once again. The team can be this good, but it can also be as bad as it was in the earlier part of the season. That is where the lack of depth in the minors hurts us. No one can come in and be the spark plug call-up.
September 19, 201511 yr I would not be ok with this starting lineup if the plan is to trust them on an every day basis. A guy like Justin Bour, for example, has no business starting against left-handed pitchers next year. I also hope we get a backup catcher who's capable of starting and not dooming the team in the case that Realmuto struggles next year, which seems entirely possible. I hope they don't trade Ozuna for pitching since it's unlikely they'd get a great pitcher in return for him, and I hope they keep Dietrich on the bench and use him properly. What's going to happen next year is that they're going to fall in love with guys and trust them on an every day basis which will set them up for failure. It happens every year with this team. They don't seem to believe in platoons at all, and that is a terrible thing, especially for a team that does not spend money.
September 19, 201511 yr What's going to happen next year is that they're going to fall in love with guys and trust them on an every day basis which will set them up for failure. No reason to wait and see then, we already know the future.
September 19, 201511 yr I would not be ok with this starting lineup if the plan is to trust them on an every day basis. A guy like Justin Bour, for example, has no business starting against left-handed pitchers next year. I also hope we get a backup catcher who's capable of starting and not dooming the team in the case that Realmuto struggles next year, which seems entirely possible. I hope they don't trade Ozuna for pitching since it's unlikely they'd get a great pitcher in return for him, and I hope they keep Dietrich on the bench and use him properly. What's going to happen next year is that they're going to fall in love with guys and trust them on an every day basis which will set them up for failure. It happens every year with this team. They don't seem to believe in platoons at all, and that is a terrible thing, especially for a team that does not spend money. So just Bour should be replaced? You're kinda agreeing with my point about the majority of this starting lineup staying intact if you're just wanting to replace Bour. The bench I agree with you on though.
September 19, 201511 yr Author I would not be ok with this starting lineup if the plan is to trust them on an every day basis. A guy like Justin Bour, for example, has no business starting against left-handed pitchers next year. I also hope we get a backup catcher who's capable of starting and not dooming the team in the case that Realmuto struggles next year, which seems entirely possible. I hope they don't trade Ozuna for pitching since it's unlikely they'd get a great pitcher in return for him, and I hope they keep Dietrich on the bench and use him properly. What's going to happen next year is that they're going to fall in love with guys and trust them on an every day basis which will set them up for failure. It happens every year with this team. They don't seem to believe in platoons at all, and that is a terrible thing, especially for a team that does not spend money. While the thrifty Marlins might have broken convention by shelling out $325-million for Giancarlo Stanton, they're still reluctant to spend big on sabermetrics. After going through five managers and five losing seasons in five years, they are looking to hire, um, interns to get their analytics program off the ground. Baseball America has called Miami "among the game's more scouting-orientated organizations," which is simply code for a non-sabermetric approach. GM Dan Jennings has a scouting background and new skipper Mike Redmond doesn't have an inclination for metrics, having spent most of his catching tenure with the Marlins and Twins, who are also analtyics skeptics.
September 19, 201511 yr So just Bour should be replaced? You're kinda agreeing with my point about the majority of this starting lineup staying intact if you're just wanting to replace Bour. The bench I agree with you on though. I don't think Bour should be replaced; I think he should be platooned with a right-handed bat. And I also think that, while Dietrich is technically a bench player, he should be playing about 4x per week depending on matchups, occasionally filling in for Prado or Ozuna against RHP. I'm ok with the group, but they won't maximize their potential by just playing the same guys every day as this organization likes to do.
September 19, 201511 yr The Marlins need to enter 2016 with the possibility in mind that Stanton only plays 50% of the games next season.
September 19, 201511 yr The Marlins need to enter 2016 with the possibility in mind that Stanton only plays 50% of the games next season. Why? If Stanton only plays 50% of the games next season, they're already done anyway.
September 19, 201511 yr I've been away a few days how did I miss this thread? It certainly has been more entertaining these last few weeks watching the fish. Decent pieces are in place, sadly no one will be helping from the farm system for a while, I really don't want to see a repeat of 2012 or this year anytime soon, the Marlins can't afford to make big money mistakes
September 19, 201511 yr Dietrich needs to play whenever there's a righty pitching. Have him replace Prado or Ozuna when a righty is in. I wouldn't trade Ozuna because you know injuries are inevitable and we'd be selling low. Get rid of Ichiro. Get a real backup catcher. Get Bour a platoon partner. Get 2 SP's (one high end, one decent). Bullpen is fine with the pieces we have. Hire me as an analytic intern. World Series 2016.
September 19, 201511 yr While the thrifty Marlins might have broken convention by shelling out $325-million for Giancarlo Stanton, they're still reluctant to spend big on sabermetrics. After going through five managers and five losing seasons in five years, they are looking to hire, um, interns to get their analytics program off the ground. Baseball America has called Miami "among the game's more scouting-orientated organizations," which is simply code for a non-sabermetric approach. GM Dan Jennings has a scouting background and new skipper Mike Redmond doesn't have an inclination for metrics, having spent most of his catching tenure with the Marlins and Twins, who are also analtyics skeptics. This post brought to you by Joe Frisaro!
September 20, 201511 yr Just peeked at the record and the remaining schedule after today... Not to take Tylenol for a brain tumor and act like everything is ok but it's pretty miraculous that we have a solid chance to reach 70 wins this year.
September 20, 201511 yr but it's pretty miraculous that we have a solid chance to reach 70 wins this year. DJ is a miracle worker
September 20, 201511 yr Certainly feels good for Dee Gordon to validate my thoughts this time last year about the Marlins making a big push to acquire him. He as been everything I had hoped for and certainly more, I hope there's a few people here that will admit to some crow eating on this. It would have been nice if Justin Bour actually had a shot to earn that starting spot from the get go. I think a few others agreed with me on that before the year, but not many. The BB/K numbers in the minors always pointed to a pretty damn good future when you consider the power he offers. Would be nice if he could learn to walk a little more, but what a diamond in the rough, a minor league Rule V guy... Wow. Adeiny coming out and having the kind of year he had put up is fantastic. I don't think anyone can say he didn't have the ability to be what he is now, but the question was could he actually do it? Great to see he can put things together. Prado being Prado. Another 3 WAR season from one of the most consistent players in the game, certainly a trade that worked out for both teams. I was slightly concerned Marlins Park would kill him, and it has hurt the power a little, but the guy can simply hit. Realmuto certainly has a lot he can improve on, and considering he's a 2 WAR player already, what a dynamite player he can be when he actually starts to get better. It's nice to have a catcher to be excited about, our newfound Charles Johnson. Could end up being a very similar player to CJ, and that's exciting.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.