Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Soler Opts Out (Is Also a Silver Slugger Finalist)

Featured Replies

28 minutes ago, TaiwanMarlins said:

Because they reluctant to spend, Rangers buy the WS title and Marlins also do it in the 1997.

Its more than just spending, but I understand your point. There was many teams that spend a ton and dont even make the playoffs. And many teams that dont spend a ton and did make the playoffs. But its true, better free agents cost more money obviously. But if you throw money just for the sake of spending, you will land a team that is soulless and has no identity or plan. 

48 minutes ago, Admin said:

I don't agree with the statement that the 1997 Marlins bought the WS. I've heard it before and never have agreed with it.

Why ? they spent big in the 96/97 off-season then win the WS in the 1997, I think that's "bought the WS".

2 hours ago, Admin said:

I don't agree with the statement that the 1997 Marlins bought the WS. I've heard it before and never have agreed with it.

I think it's just the idea that they signed FA's who played key roles on this team. Leiter, Fernandez, Brown, White, Alou, Bonilla, Eisenrich.

I mean, these days its not uncommon to have so many free agents make up your starting lineup / roster. Back then, it wasn't the norm.

I get what your saying, we also brought trades and homegrown talent to the lineup in CJ, Renteria, Floyd, Sheff (Kinda), Conine, and Hernandez.

The signings were spread across two years, which is why it doesn't feel like a buying frenzy.

1 hour ago, TaiwanMarlins said:

Why ? they spent big in the 96/97 off-season then win the WS in the 1997, I think that's "bought the WS".

They had the 8th highest payroll in 1997 and they did not have the biggest increase in payroll year to year compared to 1996. They didn't buy it. Sure they spent more than usual but if a WS can be bought, several other teams including the Indians should have won it instead.

Also, several key contributors to the 1997 title were also on the 1996 team.

Personally, I don't think the Marlins will be in the playoff mix this upcoming season. It's shitty timing and not all Bruce's fault but with Sandy being out all season, Soler leaving (not faulting Bruce for this either), a very weak FA class, and Jazz still being a giant enigma....yeah I don't think they'll get there. 

That said, there should be some answers they'll get this year: 

* Is Jazz really our CF?  If he is injured for large chunks of the season again and/or performs poorly with the bat.  I think it's time they move on from him. 

* Is Braxton really as good as he was this year or was it more of a fluke season

* Is Max Meyer a viable starter or just a bp arm

* Can Edwards get on base frequently enough to be in the lineup every day (hopefully leading off)

* Will Skip let the guys who have speed actually run and steal bases (also just putting guys in motion would likely help)

*Which version of Jesus Sanchez will we see and is he too a viable starting every day OF.

 

So yeah, these are a LOT of questions but I think we'll get answers to most of these this season.  I wish there was a strong FA class and that Bruce could spend some $ to get some pieces but yeah, barring trades (from an already thin system) I don't see much happening this upcoming season that they can use to capitalize on some of the good will from this past one.  I think the next season we'll truly be able to look forward to is '25.  Granted, Jazz could go off and be a legit healthy superstar, Bell could continue doing good things for us and Burger could replace most of Soler's power in the lineup (something it seems people forget to think about because we had Segura for such a long stretch of the season). 

Jazz, Burger, Sanchez, and Bell can all put up some decent power numbers if they stay healthy.  I don't see where there's this whole "we're missing so much power now" keeps coming from.

On 11/3/2023 at 10:19 AM, Admin said:

I don't agree with the statement that the 1997 Marlins bought the WS. I've heard it before and never have agreed with it.

we change our mind eventually because it's the right thing to do

10 hours ago, pollythewog said:

No QO was extended which us certainly a cheap ass bruce thing 

So you lose a draft pick for the <1% chance at best Soler accepts it? What’s the real drawback?

6 minutes ago, WillyumKeef said:

So you lose a draft pick for the <1% chance at best Soler accepts it? What’s the real drawback?

And if he does somehow accept it, you get him for another contract year. No drawback to offering it. Clearly motivated by being cheap.

1 hour ago, Admin said:

And if he does somehow accept it, you get him for another contract year. No drawback to offering it. Clearly motivated by being cheap.

The cheapness doesn't bother me as much as the stupidity. 

He is NOT accepting that QO. If you're cheap you need first round draft picks.

4 minutes ago, WillyumKeef said:

The cheapness doesn't bother me as much as the stupidity. 

He is NOT accepting that QO. If you're cheap you need first round draft picks.

Yeah, I think I said it here a few days ago but I am 99% sure he would have declined that QO. Just such a dumb decision here.

11 minutes ago, Admin said:

Yeah, I think I said it here a few days ago but I am 99% sure he would have declined that QO. Just such a dumb decision here.

Thanks for confirming that Soler would have taken the QO

  • Author

Why are we so sure Soler would have declined it? It would have been $20.5M which would have been the most he'd get paid in a year so far by $5.5M. Has he specifically stated that he wants a multi-year deal somewhere and thinks he can get near that much per year Would Soler have honestly been worth $20.5M just to DH?

 

Sure, we have to fill that power gap now, but him leaving opens up a lot of possibilities to improve the team overall, especially on the defensive side of things now that Bell can be the DH full time.

1 minute ago, Michael said:

Why are we so sure Soler would have declined it? It would have been $20.5M which would have been the most he'd get paid in a year so far by $5.5M. Has he specifically stated that he wants a multi-year deal somewhere and thinks he can get near that much per year Would Soler have honestly been worth $20.5M just to DH?

 

Sure, we have to fill that power gap now, but him leaving opens up a lot of possibilities to improve the team overall, especially on the defensive side of things now that Bell can be the DH full time.

Seems like he’s sure to get 2/25 or 2/30 somewhere but if he had a great year at 1/20 could say same thing in next year FA

His body is going to be in shambles going forward. He'd be crazy not to chase term at this point. 

In a weak FA class he's getting 3 years imo 

4 hours ago, WillyumKeef said:

His body is going to be in shambles going forward. He'd be crazy not to chase term at this point. 

In a weak FA class he's getting 3 years imo 

I feel like he's going after pension and benefits while chasing dollars this contract.

Not sure Bendix in time to make this decision or not because he's just hired but it's just not impressed if it's his first big move as a POBO.

Best case scenario : Soler smart enough to decline the QO and we got the draft pick. 

Worst case scenario : Soler stupid enough to accept the QO and hits terrible in the next season. 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.