Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Jazz to Yankees

Featured Replies

ESPN posted their listing of underrated players and man I sure am shocked Jazz isn't on it. The way some hype him up you'd think his probably three total seasons worth of baseball combined surely would have qualified him. Wow. Someone better contact whoever wrote that piece and bitch them out.

54 minutes ago, hovertical said:

ESPN posted their listing of underrated players and man I sure am shocked Jazz isn't on it. The way some hype him up you'd think his probably three total seasons worth of baseball combined surely would have qualified him. Wow. Someone better contact whoever wrote that piece and bitch them out.

But to be fair.. Jazz isn’t underrated in my opinion.

 

I get what you’re saying and because it’s ESPN they would put him on that list to tell the sports world about some hidden treasure. Problem is that he plays on Yankees and already been an All Star and video game cover model even without doing anything so amazing in his career yet. So even by ESPN reporting standards that would be a bit of a stretch.

 

To me underrated for sure would be someone like Sandy Alcantara who a couple of years ago was having one of the best seasons a pitcher could hope for and at some points in that year was pretty much the best pitcher in MLB. I know he made the all star team that year but still you wouldn’t see him on the cover a video game even though he deserved it much more than Jazz.

15 minutes ago, SirFishFan said:

But to be fair.. Jazz isn’t underrated in my opinion.

 

I get what you’re saying and because it’s ESPN they would put him on that list to tell the sports world about some hidden treasure. Problem is that he plays on Yankees and already been an All Star and video game cover model even without doing anything so amazing in his career yet. So even by ESPN reporting standards that would be a bit of a stretch.

 

To me underrated for sure would be someone like Sandy Alcantara who a couple of years ago was having one of the best seasons a pitcher could hope for and at some points in that year was pretty much the best pitcher in MLB. I know he made the all star team that year but still you wouldn’t see him on the cover a video game even though he deserved it much more than Jazz.

I haven’t seen the ESPN top underrated players yet but Zack Wheeler should be on it.  I was thinking Sandy before your post but this is current not 2 yrs ago.   

Jazz isn’t underrated because they overrated him. Is that what you’re saying?

36 minutes ago, Nicebeinghere said:

I haven’t seen the ESPN top underrated players yet but Zack Wheeler should be on it.  I was thinking Sandy before your post but this is current not 2 yrs ago.   

Jazz isn’t underrated because they overrated him. Is that what you’re saying?

Yeah kind of.. he’s definitely overrated.. and I’m not saying that in a mean or bad way. It’s just true.. a lot of players have accomplished twice as much as Jazz did and never got close to the press and publicity that Jazz has got. I’m not saying he doesn’t have the potential to be that superstar player, I’m just saying that he probably hasn’t earned it yet. 
 

He would be truly underrated if he was quietly putting up .300/25 Hr/85 rbi seasons the past 3 years and never got talked about on a national sports level or anything.

 

Just as an example, let’s compare Jazz with a former Marlins infielder named Dan Uggla. First three seasons:

 

image.thumb.png.04b7f48513bf6f44c50754b9cc0ae0e5.png
 

Vs Jazz Chisholm Jr first three full seasons (won’t count 2020):

 

 

image.thumb.png.9e0b7621fa08bd9676134b49fd02e193.png


 

Now of course you can bring up the very fair point that Jazz has been on the IL for most of his career so that is not a fair comparison to Uggla who played almost every game those years and there is no way of knowing exactly what Jazz could have done had he played full seasons healthy. But I think that is exactly the point. How a player who hasn’t played long enough and consistently enough gets treated like the next Derek Jeter it seems sometimes. With the national news and attention and video game covers. Most players would need like at least 3-4 all star appearances and maybe an MVP to get that type of attention. 😂

 

I made this point many times on this forum in the past.. but the way I look at it really just comes down to business/marketing decisions. In other words MLB wants to reach that market of urban youth that the NFL and especially the NBA dominates. And the reality is that MLB doesn’t have hardly any players that can fit that bill.. so when Jazz came along, even though he hadn’t really done anything of note yet, they pounced on that one so fast. 😂

I mean realistically.. how many young and exciting and flashy players in the MLB that can reach that urban market are there? Maybe like 5, I don’t know. Tim Anderson was one a few years ago. Maybe Mookie Betts, possibly Acuña or Tatis Jr.. but it’s slim pickings in MLB from a marketing standpoint. 😂


So yeah, I wouldn’t consider Jazz underrated just because he hasn’t done enough consistently to be undervalued or not rated highly enough, and I would say he definitely falls in the category of Overrated just in the sense of he hasn’t done enough on the field consistently to really earn all the attention he’s getting. Honestly I wish him well and I hope he can stay healthy going forward and have a long and successful career.

 

With all that being said.. once he wins that first WS with the Yanks.. expect to see the commercials with him increase and him becoming a household name. 

 

 

 

 

image.png

Edited by SirFishFan

9 minutes ago, SirFishFan said:

Yeah kind of.. he’s definitely overrated.. and I’m not saying that in a mean or bad way. It’s just true.. a lot of players have accomplished twice as much as Jazz did and never got close to the press and publicity that Jazz has got. I’m not saying he doesn’t have the potential to be that superstar player, I’m just saying that he probably hasn’t earned it yet. 
 

He would be truly underrated if he was quietly putting up .300/25 Hr/85 rbi seasons the past 3 years and never got talked about on a national sports level or anything.

 

Just as an example, let’s compare Jazz with a former Marlins infielder named Dan Uggla. First three seasons:

 

image.thumb.png.04b7f48513bf6f44c50754b9cc0ae0e5.png
 

Vs Jazz Chisholm Jr first three full seasons (won’t count 2020):

 

 

image.thumb.png.9e0b7621fa08bd9676134b49fd02e193.png


 

Now of course you can bring up the very fair point that Jazz has been on the IL for most of his career so that is not a fair comparison to Uggla who played almost every game those years and there is no way of knowing exactly what Jazz could have done had he played full seasons healthy. But I think that is exactly the point. How a player who hasn’t played long enough and consistently enough gets treated like the next Derek Jeter it seems sometimes. With the national news and attention and video game covers. Most players would need like at least 3-4 all star appearances and maybe an MVP to get that type of attention. 😂

 

I made this point many times on this forum in the past.. but the way I look at it really just comes down to business/marketing decisions. In other words MLB wants to reach that market of urban youth that the NFL and especially the NBA dominates. And the reality is that MLB doesn’t have hardly any players that can fit that bill.. so when Jazz came along, even though he hadn’t really done anything of note yet, they pounced on that one so fast. 😂

I mean realistically.. how many young and exciting and flashy players in the MLB that can reach that urban market are there? Maybe like 5, I don’t know. Tim Anderson was one a few years ago. Maybe Mookie Betts, possibly Acuña or Tatis Jr.. but it’s slim pickings in MLB from a marketing standpoint. 😂


So yeah, I wouldn’t consider Jazz underrated just because he hasn’t done enough consistently to be undervalued or not rated highly enough, and I would say he definitely falls in the category of Overrated just in the sense of he hasn’t done enough on the field consistently to really earn all the attention he’s getting. Honestly I wish him well and I hope he can stay healthy going forward and have a long and successful career.

 

With all that being said.. once he wins that first WS with the Yanks.. expect to see the commercials with him increase and him becoming a household name. 

 

 

 

 

image.png

This is why I oppose the new rule changes, it unlocks stats for certain players who get the spotlight for growing the sport.  If a player can get this much media exposure for achieving half less then its not out of the realm of suspicion for the league to pad their stats either.  People can turn a blind eye, but they do this for teams as well. I have no hesitation knowing the Braves are one of those teams, Acuna jr being one of the names you mentioned.  Anyway, I don’t hate Jazz he’s only do his job as a marketing vessel. Yeah I agree, if  the Yanks win the WS Jazz will be a household name. 

45 minutes ago, SirFishFan said:

Yeah kind of.. he’s definitely overrated.. and I’m not saying that in a mean or bad way. It’s just true.. a lot of players have accomplished twice as much as Jazz did and never got close to the press and publicity that Jazz has got. I’m not saying he doesn’t have the potential to be that superstar player, I’m just saying that he probably hasn’t earned it yet. 
 

He would be truly underrated if he was quietly putting up .300/25 Hr/85 rbi seasons the past 3 years and never got talked about on a national sports level or anything.

 

Just as an example, let’s compare Jazz with a former Marlins infielder named Dan Uggla. First three seasons:

 

image.thumb.png.04b7f48513bf6f44c50754b9cc0ae0e5.png
 

Vs Jazz Chisholm Jr first three full seasons (won’t count 2020):

 

 

image.thumb.png.9e0b7621fa08bd9676134b49fd02e193.png


 

Now of course you can bring up the very fair point that Jazz has been on the IL for most of his career so that is not a fair comparison to Uggla who played almost every game those years and there is no way of knowing exactly what Jazz could have done had he played full seasons healthy. But I think that is exactly the point. How a player who hasn’t played long enough and consistently enough gets treated like the next Derek Jeter it seems sometimes. With the national news and attention and video game covers. Most players would need like at least 3-4 all star appearances and maybe an MVP to get that type of attention. 😂

 

I made this point many times on this forum in the past.. but the way I look at it really just comes down to business/marketing decisions. In other words MLB wants to reach that market of urban youth that the NFL and especially the NBA dominates. And the reality is that MLB doesn’t have hardly any players that can fit that bill.. so when Jazz came along, even though he hadn’t really done anything of note yet, they pounced on that one so fast. 😂

I mean realistically.. how many young and exciting and flashy players in the MLB that can reach that urban market are there? Maybe like 5, I don’t know. Tim Anderson was one a few years ago. Maybe Mookie Betts, possibly Acuña or Tatis Jr.. but it’s slim pickings in MLB from a marketing standpoint. 😂


So yeah, I wouldn’t consider Jazz underrated just because he hasn’t done enough consistently to be undervalued or not rated highly enough, and I would say he definitely falls in the category of Overrated just in the sense of he hasn’t done enough on the field consistently to really earn all the attention he’s getting. Honestly I wish him well and I hope he can stay healthy going forward and have a long and successful career.

 

With all that being said.. once he wins that first WS with the Yanks.. expect to see the commercials with him increase and him becoming a household name. 

 

 

 

 

image.png

Uggla was 26 his first year and jazz is currently 26 and im sure uggla would have done great if moved to CF 😂 
 

jazz is making like  $2m a year and vastly outperforms his contract. 🤔 he’s a 2.9 WAR player this year and could get to 4 if he comes back soon. 
 

he is a super fun player to watch, can be electric and has shown flashes of brilliance which is why he’s rightfully in spotlight. He plays with passion and has fun doing it and is a unique personality in the best of ways.

Who exactly is overrating him?

4 minutes ago, pollythewog said:

Uggla was 26 his first year and jazz is currently 26 and im sure uggla would have done great if moved to CF 😂 
 

jazz is making like  $2m a year and vastly outperforms his contract. 🤔 he’s a 2.9 WAR player this year and could get to 4 if he comes back soon. 
 

he is a super fun player to watch, can be electric and has shown flashes of brilliance which is why he’s rightfully in spotlight. He plays with passion and has fun doing it and is a unique personality in the best of ways.

Who exactly is overrating him?

I like Augustin, who’s been great since trade, but the chances he ever is as valuable as jazz are pretty slim - 3-4 WAR player with a 5-6 WAR ceiling if (yes big if) healthy 

13 minutes ago, pollythewog said:

I like Augustin, who’s been great since trade, but the chances he ever is as valuable as jazz are pretty slim - 3-4 WAR player with a 5-6 WAR ceiling if (yes big if) healthy 

are you saying Jazz is typically a 3-4 war player when he's never gotten higher than 2.5?

were you the one who told Ng that Avi is a perennial 30hr guy?

Edited by hovertical

2 minutes ago, hovertical said:

are you saying Jazz is typically a 3-4 war player when he's never gotten higher than 2.5?

were you the one who told Ng that Avi is a perennial 30hr guy?

I qualified it with an “if healthy” which obviously is a big if. He is currently at 2.9 on FG WAR and he will land in 3.5-4 range this year 

19 minutes ago, pollythewog said:

I qualified it with an “if healthy” which obviously is a big if. He is currently at 2.9 on FG WAR and he will land in 3.5-4 range this year 

The league average for a 3B full time is 2 WAR.  he’s barley above average for a guy who has speed and power.  He’s a duel threat yet he’s just above average.

You must be focused primarily on the small sample size after he got traded?  3 weeks vs the 3 yrs? 

On 8/19/2024 at 4:30 PM, pollythewog said:

I qualified it with an “if healthy” which obviously is a big if. He is currently at 2.9 on FG WAR and he will land in 3.5-4 range this year 

You said he was a 5-6war guy if healthy but claimed he's usually a 3-4war player normally. 

1 hour ago, hovertical said:

You said he was a 5-6war guy if healthy but claimed he's usually a 3-4war player normally. 

I said 5-6 is his ceiling! I’d put 50 cents he gets at least 1 5+ WAR season in next 4 years 

Just now, pollythewog said:

I said 5-6 is his ceiling! I’d put 50 cents he gets at least 1 5+ WAR season in next 4 years 

You said a 5-6 war ceiling if healthy lol

2 minutes ago, hovertical said:

You said a 5-6 war ceiling if healthy lol

Players don’t hit their ceilings every year. I think a healthy jazz in the infield is typically a 3-4 WAR guy and he’ll have an outlier (ceiling) 5+ WAR year or 2 in his career. These aren’t superstar numbers but they are also very good coupled a personality that is irreplaceable 

1 minute ago, pollythewog said:

Players don’t hit their ceilings every year. I think a healthy jazz in the infield is typically a 3-4 WAR guy and he’ll have an outlier (ceiling) 5+ WAR year or 2 in his career. These aren’t superstar numbers but they are also very good coupled a personality that is irreplaceable 

If jazz doesn’t hit 3.5 WAR this year ban me @Michael

20 minutes ago, pollythewog said:

I said 5-6 is his ceiling! I’d put 50 cents he gets at least 1 5+ WAR season in next 4 years 

5' 6" seems short for a ceiling.

59 minutes ago, rmc523 said:

5' 6" seems short for a ceiling.

This forum has a way of turning everyone into a comedian sooner or later.

54 minutes ago, SirFishFan said:

This forum has a way of turning everyone into a comedian sooner or later.

If you can't beat them, join them lol.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.