Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins2003

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Marlins2003

  1. Baseball is about runs. Centerfield is usually a spot braced for SB's, and a high OBP, which create runs. In the "forgotten" Runs Created stat it shows Borchard creating only 55 runs in 600 AB's throughout his career. This is an incredibly low number. His OBP is at a career .283 which is definitely not good, and granted last year, he had a career year with his .318 OBP. But speed and runs, is where the league trend is in CF for the most part. Even if he hits 20 homeruns, this will not make up for his lack of run production. Homeruns are severely overrated when it comes to creating runs. We are losing so much of at this position with Borchard. Borchard hit well in pinch situations, but I can almost gurantee he will definitely contribute the least amount of any starter. I'd rather see Reed, Sanchez, or Abercrombie. yes yes yes well done yes//// Finally Except it's wrong. Perhaps better put missing part of the equation. This kind of stat use, while interesting ignores the possibility that a player, especially a player who so far has had limited playing time and much of it in late innings, inserted in the lineup for some specialty reason, can get better with more experience and playing time. Not all players come out of the box ala Miguel Cabrera. Take any random group of fifty or a hundred ballplayers and look at their numbers over their first 1,000 ABs. My guess is those who stuck around will improve as they are used more and learn. It takes a while for your average (and that word is not being used disparagingly) MLB player to come up and get adjusted to the caliber of pitching in the bigs where fastballs aren't straight as string and move like curveballs in the minors, and curveballs break like they were falling off a table rather than a few inches at AA. I have no idea whether Borchard ever becomes an everyday major league ballplayer or not, but I also think (respectfully) no one can say with any certainty that he won't. He claims to have made adjustments to his swing this spring working with Presley. Maybe it works and we have a terrific piece of talent on our hands, or it may not and he's gone by July. But to look back over 537 ABs over five years and come to a defintive conclusion about the guy I say is premature at best.
  2. It's interesting that leading the charge to kill the Marlins chances are Broward and Palm Beach county democrats. Hopefully they'll come to understand if they want anything for their constituents this session they ought to get in line because the majority of republicans in both houses can cripple both counties' desires for their own pork barrel projects. And let them go back to Boca and Ft Lauderdale and explain THAT to their consituents. ( Knows SoFlaFish is going to really enjoy this post )
  3. (not really sure why you found that comment so interesting 03) a shame that Billy Butler wouldn't crack the team out of Spring, but he is going to be a good one I thought it was a wonderfully sarcastic and TELLING comment about KC through the eyes of an opposing scout. Obviously you didn't.
  4. Somehow I suspect this was a story that was agent driven more than anything else, or some minion in Marlins' FO was tasked with making a list of every "available" (read non-DLed and breathing) centerfielder and Pagan crept on it. He's not the worst ballplayer in the world but with this team wrestling with what to do with Cody Ross and trying to figure out whether they are carrying 12 or 13 pitchers (I read a quote from Fredi somewhere this morning that if you did the math indicated he was now leaning towards twelve pitchers after earlier saying he'd go with 13) for the life of me I don't know how a ballplayer of his caliber fits in here. I think most would agree he's no upgrade over the choices we have. On a side note (not worth starting another thread) Joey Gathright, who is having a pretty good spring is fighting for his life in KC. Interesting read even if you're not interested in him as our centerfielder especially the Billy Butler remark at the end of the story. http://www.kansascity.com/mld/kansascity/16913339.htm
  5. Am I the only one who thinks perhaps Berardino is softening his usual ugly rhetoric regarding the Marlins this spring? It has after all been almost four years since the Fish gave the scoop of Torborg's firing to the Herald (after Mike had been one of, or perhaps the most vocal team supporter in the press) and set Berardino off, declaring his jihad against the Fish. Perhaps someone has finally brought the two parties together or the Marlins have reached out or Mike has finally said enough is enough but I sense a change in his columns that is at the very least refreshing. I certainly hope it's true this time. There's been a few hit and miss attempts in the past. Maybe this one will stick.
  6. heres your quote Willits is doing his usual .350 BA/.480 OBP, "the man is a machine", that is spring training correct if your opinion is" the man is a machine",then look at these stats and tell me what these guys are 22ab .364/.391/.409 22ab .364/.375/.545 28ab .214/.214/.357 seems all are pretty much comparable wouldnt you agree?? just a question I'll hang up and listen to your reply No.
  7. Q: Is anyone listening to the game and if so is the wind blowing out? I see four (4) homeruns and lots of doubles and a couple of triples, just wondering.
  8. It's funny how some roto league guru says the standard by which Jason Wood should be measured is that of one of the best bench performances in the NL in years in Wes Helms, and it is so. I don't hear people demanding the same of Aaron Boone or even Jeremy Hermida, let alone anyone else fighting for a bench job. who would that be? Are you volunterring for the job? You suggested that someone says the standard that Jason Wood should be measured is that to West Helms of 2006. Who was that someone? Who's West Helms? Is this all you got out of my post? I guess the substance of it is meaningless huh. You for example say Jason Wood is not "good", whatever that means. All I'm saying is onfield performance is going to determine who makes the roster and who doesn't. This is after all really a thread about Cody Ross.
  9. It's funny how some roto league guru says the standard by which Jason Wood should be measured is that of one of the best bench performances in the NL in years in Wes Helms, and it is so. I don't hear people demanding the same of Aaron Boone or even Jeremy Hermida, let alone anyone else fighting for a bench job. who would that be? Are you volunterring for the job?
  10. It's funny how some roto league guru says the standard by which Jason Wood should be measured is that of one of the best bench performances in the NL in years in Wes Helms, and it is so. I don't hear people demanding the same of Aaron Boone or even Jeremy Hermida, let alone anyone else fighting for a bench job. If Wood makes the team, great, if not so be it. If he does he will have done so because a) he earned it and b) because is it is believed he can contribute more than some other player. It's irrelevant how old he is he's shown through his years of minor league play and innings played he still has the stamina for the job. It's irrelevant how much MLB service time he has and it's irrelevant that he didn't make it here sooner. The latter really speaks to a lack of understanding of what happens as minor league players reach a certain age where regardless of their play they are going to be passed over in favor of significantly younger players. It actually speaks well of the Marlins, as it did when they hired a throwback like Jack McKeon instead of going with conventional wisdom and hiring someone younger or the confidence they've placed in Josh Willingham, Dan Uggla and now Owens and Lindstrom. And how much different is Wood's situation than a 35 year old rookie pitcher named Jim Morris? I'm reminded of the tryout scene in "The Rookie" where the scout pulls Jim Morris aside and says (paraphrasing) "...You know Jim if I call the front office and tell them I just had a 35 year old pitcher trying out they'll think I'm crazy. But if I don't call them and tell them I have a pitcher throwing 95 mph I'll be fired." That's the situation Jason Wood has put the Marlins organization in since last September and he's not backing off the throttle. Give the guy some credit, ninety-nine other guys would be mowing lawns right now. What I don't hear is he can't play his position anymore and to me the debate starts and stops right there. These things do happen. But in all fairness infrequently. I don't think too many complained about Lenny Harris' numbers .300+ BA at 41 years of age. All that matters is Wood's defensive and offensive contributions when called upon. He isn't Wes Helms, he may be better at some things and worse at others, but if he makes it and does what he needs to when asked to do it, I say great. BTW, he's at 1B today and 1-3 at the plate so far which in the twisted world of stats drops his average to .462. ----------- About this Jeremy Reed thing, what's he offer the Marlins they don't already have? We have a speedy defensive centerfielder with a questionable bat who in fact may be faster. If we want offense, we have guys who certainly will out hit him. And looking at the Mariners, even knowing thier GM has been accused of being one of the worst in the game if he can count to 25 he has to know all he's doing is clogging up his active roster (I believe Ross is out of options) so it's probably a better move to just move Reed for the prospect and keep things simple.
  11. I guess lost in this was the point I was trying to make about how a few hits either way make such a huge difference in numbers and the perceptions that grow from the when the sample is small.
  12. (Borchard was loathed by my friends who are White Sox fans, pretty much saying if it had anything to do with baseball he was awful at it) That probably says more about your choice of friends and their knowledge of the game than it does about Borchard's playing ability. Borchard proved last season he can play the game defensively (at least as a corner outfielder, school is still out on his potential in CF) and offensively his ten homeruns in 230 ABs equates to a 25+ HR season if he played everyday. Additionally (and this is just my own little thing no one has to agree with the methodology or validity of the claim) I like to look at what it would take to make a player's numbers respectable, in this case I looked at what it would take to get Borchard from a .230 BA to a .275 BA. The answer was ten (10) more hits. Knowing the game is one of inches and a little luck (good and bad) I see potential there for improvement. One additional hit in every 23 ABs last season changes people's perception of him completely. Aside from my nasty little comment at the start of this post ( :notworthy ) I'm willing to bet if Borchard had come in and hit .275 with ten homeruns in 230 ABs this conversation wouldn't be taking place and most people would be generally happy with performance, urging the FO to install him in CF. Keep in mind alot of those ABs were solos coming off the bench as a pinch-hitter. I have no idea what he'd do in an everyday role but I don't think he should be written off too quickly. He has the "potential" to succeed at this game and showed glimpses of it last season and this spring. It's anyone's guess whether he does the job or not, but I'm not ready to bet against the guy.
  13. He doesn't have to be better than anyone else, he just has to contribute when asked to. I do think the one thing working against him is the presence of Aaron Boone. Maybe, and it's a real longshot Beinfest becomes enarmored enough with Wood's play (operative word is "play") that he finds a "better situation" for Boone that leaves everyone feeling good and no worse off than they were when camp opened. But admittedly purely wild speculation. Right now though you have to think Wood stays over Ross and Amezega gets more OF playing time as a result.
  14. Ramp, respectfully, saying Jason Wood isn't good is just prejudice. He's done everything that's been asked of him, he's made the most of the opportunities offered him, and yeah he's 37 years old but he's going out there and doing his thing, which is more than can be said for some others on the roster. At some point "good" stops being defined as 27 and a stud when both your BA and OBP are hoving around .500. Without looking my guess is his OPS has to be in the 1.2 range. The guy has played every infield position this spring, made a great play at 2B playing there, has acquitted himself at 3B and 1B, he is what he is. No is making him out as a superstar, at least I'm not, but you have to root for the guy if for no other reason than he's delivering. You could say he's everything Reggie Abercrombie wasn't five tools or no five tools. That said, this thread I believe is about Cody Ross' trade value (putting aside the fact his wife is stunningly beautiful) if it's true that GMs on other teams have some interest in him it has to be based on what they saw last season rather this ST. For a number of teams, Ross is not the worst kind of guy to have coming off the bench or platooning, he is capable of getting scary good in streaks, I think though his value lies in rounding out a bigger package rather than him alone. He's aminimum wage guy which helps, but not a standalone talent. Frankly if Fredi is intent on 13 pitchers it's hard to see how he sticks unless another roster spot opens up and at this point I don;t expect that. In the end I suspect the Marlins get what they can for him at the deadline and he moves on.
  15. No one has to have it explained to them that I've been following a small group of ready for primetime CFers on the Royals and Angels all off-season. Thought I'd post a quick update in light of the Matthews thing looking like it's near resolution without a suspension. At LA - Terry Evans had a good spring, had been returned to the minors, the fourth most ready for MLB in LA. Gorneault is still in MLB camp as are Murphy (2) and Willits (1). Murphy is killing the ball, Willits is doing his usual .350 BA/.480 OBP, the man is a machine, the three of them fighting for one bench job now that Matthews is back in CF. Murphy is hitting .321/.340 with 2hrs and 18rbi. Both Murphy and Willits could start tomorrow on half or more of the teams in baseball. Unbelievably Willits started off slowly having had his arm in a cast the better part of the winter but has been a man posessed since the Matthews thing flared up as his numbers show. That .480 OBP would seem impossible were it not for the fact he did the same thing in AAA last season posting the highest OBP in minor league ball. In KC - There's three guys who are fighting it out for a bench job as Sanders, DeJesus and Brown settle in. Our old friend Joey Gathright is having a good spring, .375 BA/ .450 OBP, Shane Costa, who won the job coming out of camp last spring until a muscle tear sent him to the minors for rehab has been hampered by a bad back but had a good winter ball season, is at .286/.360 but in only 21 ABs. Mitch Maier, the youngest and best of the three offensively and defensively is already in the minor league camp, squeezed out early. BA thinks alot of him. The big problem for the three guys mentioned is like their counterparts in LA, they are about to squeezed out of possible work by a new crop of phenom prospects who are about to push them to the side. Gathright and Costa could play CF today and have at the big league level, Maier is half a season either in the bigs or AAA away from being ready. Maier supposedly has the best defensive outfielder in the system and had a massive AFL. Things are starting to fall into place in LA and KC and some of these guys are going to be without MLB jobs regardless of their skills. There may be an ass for every seat but that doesn't mean we are in a position right now to match up on a trade although both teams are admittedly weak in minor league pitching prospects. Can't say, won't say one of them will wind up playing for the Fish come opening day but I'll bet one of them winds up starting somewhere before the season starts. Just sort of a headsup. No crystal ball, no inside anything. Just six or seven guys who fit what I think is the Marlins mold, mid-twenties, skilled but permanently blocked by even better players with younger guys crawling up behind them eager to make the bigs as well. And they all can hit.
  16. if that is true the i apologize i may have thought you were down on him I think you're confusing Ramp with someone who shall go nameless.
  17. If AB is healthy and the Marlins want to make the deal, I'm down with that. People can't have it both ways. All off-season there's been a loud chorus of complaints the FO is unwilling to commit $$ to improve the bullpen, so there shouldn't be any complaining (about the act, people of course can complain they brought in the wrong guy) if and when they do. It isn't like we're talking Frankyn German or Todd Wellemeyer again. If it costs Petit or a high prospect (and let's take Gaby and Volstad out of the mix for conversation sake) so be it. If Benitez can come in and give us even 75% of what he did in 2004, that would be 35 saves (and let's say an ERA a full run higher than 2004, around 2.29), it bolsters the pen right on down the line and would be a marked improvement over our previous closer. It also gives closer candidates a veteran to learn from while affording them the opportunity to close perhaps 20-30-40% of the save opportunities without the pressure of having to do it night after night. It's a win - win. I look at it this way. What's it going to cost to acquire the next Ugueth Urbina if we're in contention this year and come July everyone is looking for a monster closer? We all know the price we paid in 2003, imagine what it would be in today's dollars and players. Of course first Benitez has to be convincingly healthy, and the trade reasonable. But I for one would be thrilled to see the guy out there again "if" he can do the job. And if so, do the deal sooner rather than later. We have a better chance of being in contention come July with a healthy Armando Benitez all season than half. If Loria wants to open up his wallet and bring the big man back, you won't hear me complaining. ------ I understand mlbtraderumors.com knows who killed Kennedy too. We already have one Reed, we don't need another. But it's a great idea they have there. We give the Giants a pitching prospect, the Mariners get Benitez and we get Reed :banghead Reed could be DFAd by the end of May at the rate he's going. Reed is working overtime this spring just to keep his OBP over the Mendoza line. We just sent Reggie down, why in the name of God would we want JR ????? God, they're awful.
  18. If you Google news search Alaly Soler and get past the fifteen pages of stories regarding his release there's a couple of interesting quotes like the one below: "While most of the focus yesterday was on the starter, Oliver Perez, could the forgotten Alay Soler wind up crashing the party? Soler followed Perez with two scoreless innings in the Mets' 5-4 loss to the Tigers, and manager Willie Randolph had nothing but praise for the Cuban defector, who had fallen off the radar screen lately. "He's in a lot better shape," Randolph said. "When I'm working out in the morning, he's right next to me, hitting the treadmill and hitting the weights and stuff. When you see him from a distance on the field, he did look a lot slimmer. Give him some credit."" http://www.amny.com/sports/baseball/ny-spm...eball-headlines
  19. I take this as a very good sign. Clearing a spot on the active roster is an important move.
  20. All I remember was how happy Baltimore fans were when he shipped out.
  21. You're looking at what he's owed this season, not necessarily what it would cost to get him which like Benitez will be some combination of $$ and prospect talent. Admittedly I'm ambivalent on him but "if" the report is true he is at least on their radar screen. Well that's even worse if we have to give up a solid prospect just to lower his cost. Seriously, what kind of player would he cost to get him below $1.5mil? Garcia? Petit? Tucker? I think you mssed the point Ramp, or maybe I'm wrong, but I don't think the D'Backs just say "Okay pay his salary and he's yours...". Whatever the price (amount of salary the Marlins would pick up) whether it be $1.00 or $3.6 million Arizona is going to want player compensation as well.
  22. You're looking at what he's owed this season, not necessarily what it would cost to get him which like Benitez will be some combination of $$$ and prospect talent. Admittedly I'm ambivalent on him but "if" the report is true he is at least on their radar screen.
  23. I guess three teams in less than half a season doesn't send a loud enough message :banghead Pretty darn good ballplayer who like so many before him had his body betray him. Maybe some AL team will take a chance as an emergency DH/PH/#3C. Good luck.
  24. ` As of January 13, 2007 Stan Meek was still a member of the Marlins organization and identified as Director of Scouting. There's an interview with him online (can't get to it as it's a premium service) but I doubt he's left since then or there would be news on one of the conventional news services. See Jan 13, 2007 on list (towards the bottom of the page) at this site: http://yankees.scout.com/4/3.html
  25. How did garcia look? The radio guys for the Mets sounded pretty impressed. The thing is...being realistic...he isn't exactly facing what I would call "real" major leaguers. He's holding his own but that's about all you can say. It would be something else if he did that in the fourth inning.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.