Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins2003

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Marlins2003

  1. If Nolasco goes to the pen as the closer, and you get Baldelli by giving up (I shudder just thinking about it) Johnson, Olsen or Sanchez, who picks up the TWO starting pitcher slots you've lost?
  2. Mesa is worse then Danny Kolb...might as well throw a pitching machine out there as closer. Reminds me I haven't heard "Robot Baseball" in a while.
  3. upton has too much major league time to be on the lists If you go to Sickels' website and look at his list of top 20 Tampa Bay prospects for 2006, Upton was nowhere to be seen. Sickels had already written him off in the sense hefound twenty players better in the organization, I'd bet 100 bucks on this not being true. Sickels did not include him because he is not eligible, too much playing time in MLB. No way in hell the Rays have 20 better prospects than Upton. Upton was still in the minors when this was written. He wasn't called up until August 1st. This was published July 4th. http://www.minorleagueball.com/story/2006/7/4/183057/5440 It was Sickels choice who to include and what his definition of a prospect was. Upton did play a bit in 2004, although none in 2005 and not in 2006 until being called up.
  4. I just found this. From Joe Frisaro writing for SportingNews.com dated December 1st: " RHP Carlos Martinez, who had Tommy John surgery in July, is doing some soft tossing and showing he is ahead of schedule. Still, the righthander isn't expected to return before mid-season." http://www.sportingnews.com/yourturn/viewtopic.php?t=154741
  5. I would agree with Swift that if Benitez is fit, bring him back. Forget Jones or Mesa. In the alternative find a solution among the various candidates we already have. But it all really comes down to the condition of Benitez, not just his knees but his arm as well. I think on a number of levels he "could" be the next step in this team learning how to win at this level. Even if he can only go three days a week, he would mean a tremendous amount to a team that blew so many games in the middle of last summer.
  6. Martinez had ligament replacement surgery (TJ) the first week of July. I'm not an expert in any of this so if there is one here feel free to correct but isn't the elbow immobilized for six months or so (usually in hard cast)? The normal course of things is for there to be atrophy so a long regimen of exercise is required to strengthen not only the new ligament but all the rest in the area. I can't imagine how he could be throwing now (I am NOT saying it's impossible) since usually even tossing the ball, short then long toss are the last things before the doctor gives his okay to start "throwing". Maybe the guy is a freak. Maybe Dr. Andrews (I assume he did it) has a new rehabilitation technique he's trying but it seems awful soon to me.
  7. See my comments in the Mench thread.
  8. why wouldn't the royals go after a younger guy instead? they need to get young, and start from scratch. That is the million dollar question. If you look the number of quality position prospects in their organization and then our minor league pitching prospects, I've thought for awhile the teams match up perfectly. I would have even considered moving a starter if the package was deep and comprehensive enough but even prospect for prospect trading between us could strengthen both teams. Moore is either going to be judged a genius or a fool by this time next season. I'm baffled, absolutely awestruck at the money they've committed regardless of the players with the minor league system they're developing.
  9. upton has too much major league time to be on the lists If you go to Sickels' website and look at his list of top 20 Tampa Bay prospects for 2006, Upton was nowhere to be seen. Sickels had already written him off in the sense he found twenty players better in the organization, which is not to say he won't be a ML player. or is without skills. Not totally down on him, gives him some props but sees talent moving past him quickly thus (I surmise) his absence from this list. And he only came up about three weeks before Delmon Young who is on the list.
  10. Just like so many other of these kinds of lists, BJ Upton has become a non-entity, so far has he fallen in the eyes of those who judge minor league talent. Ditto the Fab 50 list which he once was #1. And Sickels doesn't come across as a guy with an axe to grind. You might disagree with his assessment here or there but you can usually expect straight talk from the guy.
  11. Beau, didn't read somewhere a quote from Ozzie that the White Sox need a fulltime, everyday centerfielder if they expect to win? Personally, Anderson's stats scare the heck out of me. But frankl as I don;t ever y that's all I can go by, his minor league and major league stats remember seeing him play.
  12. Two words: Scott Boras
  13. My memory is a little hazy, have we ever tried Hermida in Center? I have a vague memory of him in center but im not sure. maybe it was just a game or two. I wouldnt mind seeing an outfield of Willingham, Hermida, Ross. He started six games in center field, played in nine for a total of 53 innings in 2006.
  14. I have no idea how ailing either one really is (Benitez vs Jones) but if all was equal I'd take Armando's arm any day.
  15. I mean really, for almost exactly the same money, would you rather have Reggie Abercrombie or Ryan Church? Can we stop with this? There's little to hint that Abercrombie will be given the same amount of playing time as he was last year. And it's not for almost the same exact money. The talent of the player we'd have to give up to acquire Church, Anderson, Taveras, Pence, Cabrera, etc. would likely have more value than the few thousand dollars it'd cost to pay their salaries. The goal is to win a World Series eventually, not simply to get better production from the CF spot. A world series will require a CF SUBSTANTIALLY better than Abercrombie. Let me rephrase. If Reggie Abercrombie has a roster spot on opening day our front office has failed miserably. I'm going to fully disagree with that statement. Also, like 3Username said, if the Nats want Gio Gonzalez for Ryan Church.... that means they would want one of our top prospects. Look elsewhere It might be worth considering a) that was reported in a Philly newspaper story not on the Phillies website or confirmed multiple places that GG was the target and at the very same time the story was coming out the Phillies were in fact trading GG away, and b) even if that was what they asked for it seems to me that there's a lot of room for negotiation between a Rodrigo Lopez and Gio Gonzalez where two intelligent general manager's could find some agreement. Would you trade Petit for him? I would. Would I trade a couple of the can't miss the majors Marlins top fifty Maverickball prospects*? You betcha. Would I trade anyone not in our top four *or five* pitching prospects? Yes. Contrary to Rferry's belief championship teams ARE built incrementally, one player at a time, and Church would be an upgrade over our failed CFer and our fourth and fifth outfielders right now and able to play either corner as well if called upon because of injury or trade (Jacobs for example). And besides, you can trade him tomorrow if you want. Not to mention he's lefty and hits lefties better than any of the three above. But then again he hits righties better than any of them too. And he's minimum wage. It a no lose. Not everything is black or white, if it were no deals would ever get done. There's plenty of wiggle room to make a deal here. And if not this deal, make a better one, but don't ignore the opportunity when it's right there staring you in the face. I know I'm repeating myself but a bird in the hand... * talking about the ones posted to date.
  16. I mean really, for almost exactly the same money, would you rather have Reggie Abercrombie or Ryan Church? Can we stop with this? There's little to hint that Abercrombie will be given the same amount of playing time as he was last year. And it's not for almost the same exact money. The talent of the player we'd have to give up to acquire Church, Anderson, Taveras, Pence, Cabrera, etc. would likely have more value than the few thousand dollars it'd cost to pay their salaries. The goal is to win a World Series eventually, not simply to get better production from the CF spot. A world series will require a CF SUBSTANTIALLY better than Abercrombie. Let me rephrase. If Reggie Abercrombie has a roster spot on opening day our front office has failed miserably.
  17. Yesterday the Nationals turned down Rodrigo Lopez, 9-18, 5.90 ERA, arbitration elgible and earning almost $4 million a year for Ryan Church. Probably the wisest move of the Winter Meetings. But that said Philly claims Washington wanted Gio Gonzalez who of course was unavailable because he was being packaged in the Chicago trade and frankly would have been overpaying as well. If the Marlins are even considering looking at one of the weakest hitting* OFers in the game in Anderson, why the heck, with all the pitching prospects we have stockpiled aren't they reaching out to Washington to at minimum bolster their reserves and have a fall back player available in case nothing better comes our way? I mean really, for almost exactly the same money, would you rather have Reggie Abercrombie or Ryan Church? I've heard the Frank Robinson comments and considering the source I suspect there's two sides to the story. I know he didn't want to go to Mexico this winter as asked. If you look at his numbers the last two years (I exclude 2004 in Montreal, too few at bats over too many games to be relevant) and in 464 at bats he's hit .280+, an OBP of .360+/-, has 19 homeruns, 77 rbis and a .850+/- OPS beside playing a good centerfield and cheap, and can be had a for a pitching prospect. A bird in the hand is worth two in the bush. The FO knows they'll be drafting five more pitchers in the 2007 draft for goodness sake go sign the guy and then, if you can find better, great. I never bad-mouth players, I always say hey they worked hard to make it here, I respect that, but Reggie Abercrombie is the worst player I've seen in a Marlins uniform (talking outfielders here) since Junior Felix. Every day I see his name on the 25 man roster speaks poorly of this franchise. I'm not saying Ryan Church is Jim Edmonds but He sure is an improvement over what we have now and even if it's a baby step, it's in the right direction. *ranks 186th in BA and 177th in OBP among all ML outfielders
  18. For the life of me the one thing I don't understand about this morning is why the Devil Rays, who by their own admission are so starved for pitching, would rather sell off the first pick in the draft for a measely $100k when they could have taken this kid Joakim Soria who by most reports has been tearing up the Mexican League, for a lousy $25,000 look see. I guess that's what you get when you don't have a general manager, rather a bean-counter who prefers the title "Executive Vice President of Baseball Operations". Just craziness.
  19. Cristhian Martinez, rhp, Tigers BIO Thanks :thumbup I missed the pick when happened (on the phone) and from then all I heard was his last name. Good thing we picked up another pitcher. lol. Actually, not knowing a thing about him, at first glance his stats look pretty good. I really wonder which one of the picks that were already taken by their turn came around was their original choice? Maybe Ramp will know.
  20. Whats the difference between the AAA phase and the MLB phase? They just need to stay on the AAA roster the entire time instead? Are different players eligible for each? It depends which roster they were on. There are three phases - MLB - AAA - AA I believe Kevin Cave was lost in the AA draft by the Marlins
  21. Depending on the real condition of his knees and his health generally, there's going to be enough youth around him to perhaps allow him to not have to pitch two-three nights in a row. After all what the Marlins appear to be doing is throw the kids out there and see if someone rises to the ocassion and become the closer of the future.
  22. There is a difference between ignoring the Rule 5 draft and not picking people up..... Thanks for the contribution...I was typing on the fly as the draft was starting and the Marlins had just passed. Dan Jennings says they didn't participate because the pick they wanted had already been taken. The other two (listening to Dan Jennings on the internet) ???? Martinez (never mentioned first name) Lorenzo Scott
  23. An interesting thing I just learned on Rule 5 pickups - when a team decides not to keep a player picked, he goes through waivers, every other team has a chance to pick up those Rule 5 rights before he goes back to his original team.
  24. AAA Josh LaBandeira, another middle infielder, to the marlins
  25. Florida passes on the entire AA phase

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.