Everything posted by Marlins2003
-
Girardi vs Loria
I will say I'd rather keep Beinfest and his scouts han Girardi and his coaches. Yep. The interesting thing is that if Girardi leaves, does anyone think Loria will retain his staff? This Loria/Girardi rift could mean that none of the staff returns (they might not want to anyway). We might have to start all over here. And you really think someone's going to want to come to a job where the should be manager of the year is fired? Ooooooooh boy. People, let me rephrase that, qualified people, would be falling over themselves to get a chance at this job.
-
Girardi vs Loria
I think this has more to do with Loria being a prick, than about if someone could possibly do a better job
-
Girardi vs Loria
I'm just curious '03, is there any journalist that you don't have a problem with? Hundreds if not thousands. In fact in another thread I praised Capozzi. And generally I like Olney's work and Jason Stark's and even LeBatard's because I understand he's a columnist and not a reporter.
-
Girardi vs Loria
I don't believe these stories...even as a guy who dislikes Girardi, I find it hard to swallow that he wanted to play Miggy at 1B...someone is just trying to make him look retarded. Girardi may have made a lot of bonehead decisions...but Miggy at 1B?!?! Who did he want to play 3B? There were various stories last season and this spring about Miggy having a 1st baseman's mitt and taking practice there, and the Miggy at first thing has been talked about here from time to time. When you think of Miggy's level of conditionng early on, it might not have been the worst idea, but at the same time, if there were two guys going into April you wanted content in their roles on this team, it was Willis and Cabrera. As long we keep getting half of any part of the story, from either camp, which is what's happening here, I don't see how anyone can intelligently come to a conclusion about what is really at play here. And any time Dave Hyde is your source, OMG be careful.
-
Treanor: "South Floridians should be ashamed"
If Matt Treanor doesn't think there were 30,000 people there last night he needs glasses. I haven't seen the terrace boxes, outfield and upperdeck that crowded all season. And I think anyone else who was in attendance would agree as well.
-
Girardi vs Loria
it's absolutely terrible that we are a legitimate playoff threat and this is overshadowing everything...just terrible Yes it is Ramp but for reasons I think are missed here by most. If you took all of the published quotes of Loria's press conference yesterday, from the various published sources, and simply put them in a different order, the story becomes one that is completely different. It appears from reading every account, the number one thing on Loria's mind was the "team" and how well the team has done and is doing. He says he (and the fans) should be focused on their play and our wildcard chances. Sounds good to me. When he speaks about the work of the front office and the organization it is in the context of the phrase "as well", not ignoring the manager's role, but remembering how those present to a person heaped scorn on the organization for what happened last fall, reminding those in attendance it wasn't by accident that the team as assembled was the product of a strong front office, and that they were the same people who guaranteed South Florida 100-120 loses this season, the same people who called a $15 million (actually $20 million but who's counting) an embarrassment to baseball, who after all, and who have been after Loria's head since day one in 2002 when took over the team. I'd love to hear the press conference in its entirety to make up my own mind rather than be told what was said with a prejudicial tone. I thought Loria's comments about the team far outweighed anything else, but let's face it, once Steve Wine, Marlins-hater extraordinaire starting pumping out the first of his three poisonous pieces last night you knew how the press generally was going to play this. I give Capozzi credit for quoting more of the press conference than anyone else. You'll find his take, and what was actually said, if not in its entirety or order, much different from what how this story is being exploited this morning http://www.palmbeachpost.com/marlins/conte...6loriafeed.html honestly I love Joe, he's done a lot of good, obviously...and as Tim Kurkjian said on BBTN, he's gonna be firing the Manager of the year, and Joe's gonna get snatched up the second he becomes available...but in the end, Fredi Gonzalez will do just as good of a job... if Loria hates Joe so much. First of all, considering Girardi is making peanuts, this idea that the Marlins will fire him, thus losing what could be a windfall of compensation, from a business standpoint, makes zero sense. If Loria really wanted to be vindictive, and I don't think he does, he could afford to let Girardi rot at home for the next two years if he wanted. But if the rift is unrepairable, then Girardi will be allowed seek employment elsewhere, but not before Admin Beinfest extorts a king's random in talent for him. We don't know what was said by whom in the heat of the moment and we certainly don't know that Loria hates Girardi. We really don't know what was said or if there really is still a rift. As much as its easy to put all the blame on Loria because he's a convenient target there are several things Girardi could have said that would have caused ANY owner to want to fire him. And we don't know if it's Girardi who secretly wanted out and used this as an excuse to free himself from his three year contract. One thing I find fascinating is how silent the players has been on this. Sure, there's comments here or there supporting their manager but I'm surprised, even anonymously, none have let slip any of the details of that Saturday night in the clubhouse. My guess is, it was Girardi who acted badly, perhaps rudely and worse, and at least until the season is over, the players have reason to remain silent. The worst that happens if they rat out the owner is they get traded, but ratting out the manager has even more disasterous consequences for their careers, and thus I believe the silence. When I read Greg Stoda somehow trying to diefy Jeff Torborg, or insult the fans of South Florida by ignoring the 30,000+ in the stands last night and castigating the Sunday crowd which has come to understand that sitting through an afternoon Marlins game in August is truly hell on earth, one begins to realize how little the author cares about the franchise or more importantly its fans. I suspect in Stoda's mind, every penny wasted on Marlins tickets should rightfully be spent filling almost never sold-out Dolphins games. But such is life in South Florida. It's not only the politics that has caused the Magic City to be known almost universally as a banana republic.
-
Miami still Alive.
Your sources told you there was "no roof" Marlins2003? I am curious. The parking revenue part is kind of funny to me. The parking revenue would be there all loria has to do is by the two lots right near by and then charge for parking. The parking dynamics are much different in a downtown area. That was an assumption on my part. I assumed when told the stadium configuration hadn't been acceptable to the Marlins that they were talking about the roof. I was, and am in hurry, just really came home for a minute to see what others had.
-
Miami still Alive.
Just got back. (EDIT: I mean I've been out, someone just asked me if I was at a meeting regarding this. My apologies if it sounded that way. But was told what I wrote below) It boiled down to no roof and no parking (revenue). Sounds like Dolphin Stadium. Worse than the Orange Bowl proposal. It was the wrong site (at least as offered) in the first place. At least for now the "Florida Marlins" name is safe. In negotiations, walking away is sometimes the best thing to do if you eventually want to make a deal. Let's see what the GMCVB does to sweeten the pot or find a parking solution that doesn't rob the franchise of that necessary revenue stream.
-
Could the Glass Slipper work?
"The land just isn't there for a traditional roof" very true. So what is the solution in your mind? If I remember correctly, the original Bi-Centennial Park rendering showed a clamshell-like roof structure that sections folded in on themselves, one under another, providing shade to the upperdeck. I'm sure someone has a pic of it kicking around. Don't know if something like that might be cost effective in today's economy or not. Obviously building a single roof structure that moves on rails is going to be cheaper. And another thought, just pie in the sky, thinking outside the box, perhaps there are "air rights" available so the roof might actually retract over an adjacent property. Crazier things have happened.
-
Descarga Deportiva Reports
Whatever happens in Hialeah, win or lose, the county has shown alot of good faith by dealing with the water treatment issue that the DCA demanded, swiftly. And I might mention were it not for the Hialeah proposal and the immediacy of it, the city fathers in Miami wouldn't have a fire under their butts to get back in game. So, my hat is off to Hialeah however this turns out.
-
Could the Glass Slipper work?
I'd like to remind everyone the AstroDome has survived several storms well enough. I'd also like to remind everyone the costs of keeping a space air conditioned instead of having it open, close, and then re-air condition should be less theoretically. Wrong. In a perfect world perhaps, but not in south florida. If that were the case then all stadiums with retractable roofs would be domed instead. Look at Chase, there's reason they open and close their stadium and it's economics. Ditto Houston. Large, highly efficient cooling systems make a retractable roof cost effective and keep down utility usage. You simply don't understand the massing of the building, the heat load, the humid air, the cost of running air conditioning 365 days a year, 24 hours a day unless you want mold and various other officious problems plaguing your facility, which btw were a major problem inside the Astrodome from day one.
-
Could the Glass Slipper work?
One of the problems one runs into with an enclosed venue down here, in this case one with approximately 40,000 seats, is the cost of climate control, air conditioning and dehumidifying the place. There are many, many beautiful nights in South Florida where an open air stadium would suffice and in many ways would enhance the fan experience. The objective of a retractable roof is guarantee fans comfort regardless of the weather, and in the longrun is more economical to operate. By "doming" the venue, you are driving operating costs through the roof (no pun intended).
-
News and information about the new stadium thread
Basesloadedwalk, what from his article created an argument? When 2003 disputed the accuracy of the reporting, saying he doesn't believe that all the parties involved in the Miami negotiation would pull it off this quickly or efficiently and that Hialeah still has the edge. Then someone else got into a debate with 2003 over his skepticism, which lasted a few posts. Let me clarify what I said...again. Parties may come together with a plan or an agreement in pricicpal but until a number of boards, agencies and ultimately at least the two municipal governments (city and county) take and approve by vote a specific package of binding agreements acceptable to all parties, nothing is in concrete. Then there's the Feds, if any of the money being allocated comes from grant money for inner city projects (which is part of what I've heard) they will have to approve the use as well. There's planning and zoning boards, mitigation, flood zone management (the state and the feds), etc. Not saying something doesn't ultimately happen but it isn't four guys in a room saying "okay, let start digging tomorrow". No one wants a stadium more than me and the idea of never having to go to another game at hell on earth, better known as Dolphin Stadium would thrill me to death, but realistically, there's a process that has to take place and it isn't quick or without landmines. I would think if there was an agreement in principal it would take at least ninety days, ninety business days, just in drafting all memorandums of understanding, letting out of bids for bond issuance, contracts between the parties, etc. My point about Hialeah was that they are further into the process and have less issues to deal with but it wasn't that I had a preference of one over the other. It's always easier to deal with one landowner with a vacant piece of land than trying to deal with multiple owners. Look at what happened at the Orange Bowl site where land speculators (read, friends of Manny and Joe) swept in and gobbled up big tracts of land surrounding the OB, hoping to make a killing on appreciation, or in the alternative, threatening to take the slow emininent domain/appraisal/forced arbitration/lawsuit route to get their price. I think what some are confusing is "agreeing to agree" and "legally binding all the parties together under laws, ordinances and charter of the governmental entities involved". It's like telling your girlfriend "let's get married", and six months later actually tieing the knot.
-
News and information about the new stadium thread
Was there anyone but one commissioner who mentioned building downtown without a roof, and then only as a possibility? I haven't anything else that really even suggested that as a possibility.
-
City of Miami in the mix: Good or bad news?
Marlins2003 - Great post. I have a comment and a question. My comment is that I see no way that Hialeah can generate enough revenue to the special taxing district to cover the current funding gap. As I pointed out a few months ago in another thread, by my calculations they would need to generate over a billion dollars in improvements, and even then it would be at a cost of property tax dollars that might otherwise go to funding schools or essential services in the area. Given what I've heard about the immediate area, I can't see the bond community rallying around it without massive amounts of guaranteed future developments locked in place. My question has to do with the franchise tax. What is the source of this revenue? Property taxes? Sales taxes? Ticket taxes? Hotel taxes? Something else? And why would Hialeah have any less of a claim to that money compared to Miami? To the first part, it is depends on what is built on the land, it's density, height and ultimately it's value. If a bunch of Value-Stor mini-warehouses are built it's one thing, if the property development is towards a high-rise office park (think immediately south of MIA across 836) the value could be staggering. As for the usual red herring regarding schools and essential services in the area, if nothing is built (the site is never developed, there is zero tax revenue. 20% of something is better than 100% of nothing. To the last part. If after three years of writing about this you don't know, then you don't want to know. Here's link, do your own research. http://www.miamidade.gov/taxcollector/ Concerns over TIF revenue are anything but a red herring. If nothing is built, then no tax revenue is needed for those services in the first place. Many cities are abandoning or limiting TIF revenue as a funding source because in the long run it either puts an undue burden on the services which are normally funded by property taxes or it increases the overall tax burden. I'm not saying that would be the case in Hialeah, I'm just saying that $100m in TIF revenue from a swath of land that currently sits vacant is a large commitment and would be more difficult to bond than, say, a similar proposal would be in an area near downtown that is truly ripe for such development anyway (with or without a stadium). To my question about the franchise tax... Well I haven't spent the past three years dissecting your posts. I just asked a simple and highly relevant question, so obviously I do want to know. You don't have to be an ass about it. I gave you a link to the tax collector's webpage. If you're too lazy to click on the link and find the PSFT (hint look under hotel and restaurant taxes) there's nothing I can do about that. Blame your parents for your laziness, not me. As for how much tax revenue can be gathered from the site, without knowing the value of what would be proposed to be built there, and the timeline, to suggest it's not bondable (and it's the revenue stream based on both a plans of the developer, in this case one with a tremendous record, and the plans proferred that creates the underpinnings for any potential bond sales) is foolhardy. And as for my "red herring" comment it was in regard to usual, tired arguments about "we need new schools and roads before a a stadium for a gazillionaire...", not specifically about TIF (Tax Increment Financing). I believe my point though is still valid. If nothing is built there, no jobs are created, no income or sales taxes are paid by that workforce, no property taxes collected, etc. Further the idea that somehow because this property is in West Dade it's less desirable ignores it's proximity to major highway systems. While it may not be worth alot to a guy who wants to build million dollar condos to the sky, but if a Fedex or Walmart or any one of a thousand other national and international companies were looking for corporate headquarters tied to a 2,000,000 sq ft distribution facility, this is the ideal spot. Since there is not expected to be a housing component in the project there will be no impact on schools. Highway access improvements will be made in the course satisfying not primarily the stadium, which has limited use, 81 times a year, but rather the above described 300 day users. If Walmart or Lowes or Home Depot wanted to build a few million sq ft there and provide 800-1000 job, the county and FDOT would be Johnny on the spot with funds to make sure they located there instead of Marietta GA. or Columbus OH. see Burger King. As for TIF, btw, it seems to be working nicely all accross the country. I was just reading an article (for something unrelated) that had to do with a TIF program in Evanston, IL, the results of which include collecting much more in taxes than was anticipated. For every place it hasn't worked there are multiple ones which have. Painting with a broad brush isn't always the best way to get at the truth.
-
News and information about the new stadium thread
Thanks Swift. But who are they kidding about getting the park done in 27 months? It really depends on a) who supervises construction and b) what is built. Alot of the larger, more complex components will have to be engineered (as in design, wind and stress-tested because of unique weather conditions here, etc.) and fabricated. The more they can approximate an already existing structure (let's say MinuteMaid for example) the quicker it can be built. It will be interesting to see if it is in fact Miami, who get's control over construction, once a primary demand of the Marlins. The worst thing that could happen is either the city or county builds it ad you have another PAC on your hands, with mega-cost-overruns.
-
City of Miami in the mix: Good or bad news?
Residing where I do I don't care where it is built and have no preference. Wherever it is built the same bonding mechanism will be used to pay for construction. And whether it's PSF tax dollars or a special taxing district in Hialeah, ultimately it means little to the fan. If I had to lean towards one, I guess I would go towards Miami but only for reasons unrelated to baseball and more towards tourism, both convention-related and individual.
-
City of Miami in the mix: Good or bad news?
Marlins2003 - Great post. I have a comment and a question. My comment is that I see no way that Hialeah can generate enough revenue to the special taxing district to cover the current funding gap. As I pointed out a few months ago in another thread, by my calculations they would need to generate over a billion dollars in improvements, and even then it would be at a cost of property tax dollars that might otherwise go to funding schools or essential services in the area. Given what I've heard about the immediate area, I can't see the bond community rallying around it without massive amounts of guaranteed future developments locked in place. My question has to do with the franchise tax. What is the source of this revenue? Property taxes? Sales taxes? Ticket taxes? Hotel taxes? Something else? And why would Hialeah have any less of a claim to that money compared to Miami? To the first part, it is depends on what is built on the land, it's density, height and ultimately it's value. If a bunch of Value-Stor mini-warehouses are built it's one thing, if the property development is towards a high-rise office park (think immediately south of MIA across 836) the value could be staggering. As for the usual red herring regarding schools and essential services in the area, if nothing is built (the site is never developed, there is zero tax revenue. 20% of something is better than 100% of nothing. To the last part. If after three years of writing about this you don't know, then you don't want to know. Here's link, do your own research. http://www.miamidade.gov/taxcollector/
-
City of Miami in the mix: Good or bad news?
The important component that Miami brings to the table, and one that Hialeah can match, is a predictable and thus bondable taxing mechanism. When the City of Miami was jettisoned as a participating partner with it went their share of the Professional Sports Franchise Tax which is collected through the Convention Development Tax. It was the loss of those $$$ that skyrocketed the deficit. Here's how this works. Let's say a project cost $100 million to build (numbers used for illustration purposes to keep it simple). The general contractor, architects, subs, suppliers all need to be paid during and immediately after the construction process yet there is no revenue coming in to pay these costs. A government, either a city or a county, will issue (sell) tax-exempt bonds in the required sum (actually a little more to cover the commission paid for selling the bonds), let's say $110 million. But before that happens the bond community needs to know there is the cashflow or a revenue stream to cover repayment of those bonds. And the repayment of these bonds includes an interest component so let's say over the term of the bonds the total cost, $100 million for construction, $10 million for sales commission and another $90 million in interest will have to be paid so the total cost of financing the stadium is actually $200 million. In the case of the Marlins' new stadium both the city and the county's share will come from their respective shares of the Professional Sports Franchise Tax, which has been in existence for a number of years and already taxpayer approved. In fact there is a huge pot of money already collected but unspent but let's ignore that for this explanation. Analysts for the city and county, looking at prior years collections of this tax and conservatively calculating future collection based on tourist and convention trends might extimate that a minimum of say $3 million a year in the first year and $8 million in the twentieth year will be available. They can't just pick numbers out of a hat because the bond community has their own number-crunchers and will be looking at every facet of the deal to make sure the people they sell these bonds to will in fact be paid. So in the end the city and county can peg their collection share of the over twenty years at $90 million. That leaves $110 million unaccounted for. This is where the Marlins component comes in. First they put $30 million in, reducing the bonds necessary from $110 million to $80 million, and the overall cost down to $160 million (less borrowed, less interest due over the term). The city and county have already committed $90 million, bringing the rent the Fish have to pay down to $70 million over the twenty years which they agree to pay, pledging a) not to move for the life of the bonds and b) pledging the team as collateral to the city and county (who are ultimately responsible for the bond repayment) so as to the the local governments comfort in getting involved in the first place. Okay, so now Miami pulls out, leaving a big shortfall because the PSF taxes that flow to the city are no longer part of the deal. Enter Hialeah. Hialeah doesn't get as much if any of the PSF tax as Miami so they must find a different way to make up the missing piece. In this case, what they have is a dump that is spinning off zero property taxes (collected on the "improvements", buildings, etc. on the property of which there are none). By "improving" the property, any improvments are now taxable like any other building. What Hialeah does, with the county's encouragement and permission is create a "special taxing district". Keep in mind all property taxes are collected by the county and distributed county-wide, with a only a portion collected in each community coming back to that community. But in the case of a "special taxing district", let's say if Hialeah would normally get back 20% (again all this is all illustrative, for you accountants or government bureaucrats bear with me I know it's much more complicated but basically it works as a demo), in this "special taxing district", the city of Hialeah will be allowed, for the same twenty year period as the bonds, to keep 80% of the taxes collected, and use that $$$ to make their contribution to the new stadium, in effect replacing the City of Miami's Professional Sports Franchise Tax component with their "special taxing district" revenue component. All this happens under the understanding that were it not for the creation of the special taxing district, which funds the creation and improvement of a dump into a useful piece of taxable property, no taxes would be collected in the first place. The county comes out ahead, collecting 20% instead of nothing, people are employed in all those new businesses, money is coming in to help pay off a stadium - in short everyone wins. So while Hialeah has a tougher road to hoe, it isn't out of the running by any means. And beyond that, one other thing. If the Marlins move to Miami, the team changes names as a prerequiste of the deal, if they wind up in Hialeah they continue to be a "regional" team still called the Florida Marlins. So let's not pronounce Hialeah dead quite yet, in fact they may have a leg up on Miami for any number of reasons. Right now MLB and Miami "want" the Marlins but Hialeah, with the county's help has the land and resources (not mention location for all three counties) to actually make it happen quickly enough to be out of hell on earth, er Dolphin Stadium by opening day of the 2011 season.
-
Next years Attendance
When I was down there I heard tons of season ticket holders say they won't renew. :thumbdown Dumb fans. You did? That's surprising because everyone I talk with is pretty happy with this season and plan in many cases going back to their pre-2006 ticket plans. I've heard more good things about this team from people in attendance over the last couple of months than I heard the whole last half of last season where most fans in the stands took the team as dogging it through August and September.
-
Conspicuously Absent...
Anyone else notice that Loria has yet to sit by the dugout this entire home-stand, which is also the first homestand since he allegedly fired Girardi? Loria not being there speaks volumes about the rift, at least to me. :mischief2 Or in the alternative, while yes it speaks volumes about what may have transpired that Sunday, Loria's absence from his usual seat, may in fact have been a token gesture by him that he recognizes Joe's authority on the field and in the clubhouse, and that in the heat of the moment, things were said, that intelligent men may think, but don't say. I doubt it's Loria pouting somewhere off in the corner, fuming, if anything it may be an attempt at rapprochement. But who's to say. None of us really know what went on or what is going on as we speak. Tick...tick...tick. Time will tell.
-
Girardi Rumors
I am counting down until we see the "who will replace Giradi as manager in 2007" thread... I would assume, if the Marlins are going to sever their relationship with Joe, they already know. Here's hoping for Fredi Gonzalez. Considering how many times he's been (pardon my phrasing) the bridesmaid and never the bride, one has to suspect there is some fatal flaw there that has led at least four teams I can think of from hiring him.
-
Girardi Rumors
I am counting down until we see the "who will replace Giradi as manager in 2007" thread... I would assume, if the Marlins are going to sever their relationship with Joe, they already know.
-
Girardi Rumors
Just in the hypothetical, one has to wonder, assuming Ramp is correct about Girardi's tenure, he very well may have seized an opportunity to instigate an argument to get himself fired, and thusly place himself (and with him the entire coaching staff) squarely at the front of the line for Dusty's job. Perhaps the real reason cooler heads prevailed was to protect the Marlins negotiating position. Since the Marlins hold all the cards (they are paying him relatively little and can keep him from working for the next couple of years if is their pleasure). If history is any indicator, and Chicago is indeed interested, there's a price to be paid, and not an insignificant one. Were it me, I'd be looking at Murton and at least one prospect as compensation for the manager, and one more every coach who departs along with him. Stripping the Cubs of every piece of low-cost/high value prospect talent would be the name of the game. Otherwise Joe can sulk around the dugout for another two years, or if is his preference, at home on the couch without a paycheck or a job. But, be clear, he won't be even talking to Chicago unless the Marlins are guaranteed their compensation first. The last time this happened the pricetag was Randy Winn, at the time an all-star for TB, and that was just for the manager. No reason not to ask for the sun and moon. After all, you have to assume you are handing over an entire coaching staff as well. There is almost no amount of compensation to offset the loss, but not doubt Admin Beinfest will pick the Cubbies clean. When he gets done it will take the Cubs years to recover. Which in itself is fine with me.
-
Saturday night's lineups: Cody and Reggie roam the OF
:sigh: If Reggie is a good player he needs to show it now or I am going to totally give up on him. We have given him time to shine. play him for a week straight... if he looks like crap, bench him... ...but Im going to bet he isnt playing tomorrow, and now wont play again till next week and thats not fair to him or the team... It's only unfair to him if he is unaware of why he's playing infrequently and doesn't realize the team has the confidence (misplaced or not) in him that they are prepared to keep him on the active roster even though his performance so far this season would suggest otherwise. I would guess Reggie understands completely what's going on and how lucky he is to be not riding a bus between Albuquerque and Fresno or Zebulon and Birmingham as we speak. As for it being unfair to the team, this is after all an audition for the rest of the decade and every player is being given their chance to show off, and playing time commensurate with performance, including him.