Everything posted by Marlins2003
-
Rosenthal reports Cantu & Ross on the market
Logan Morrison is in the same boat Mike Stanton was in while in AA. Logan Morrison is only going to be called up if he is going to play everyday. Once one of Ross/Cantu/Uggla is traded at the all star break, that will open up room in LF to get Morrison starts. This team isn't and shouldn't be interested in having a guy like Morrison come off the bench, especially with the high OBP he is expected to bring each and every game. While admittedly 100% conjecture on my part, a product of my vivid imagination and with no basis in fact, I was suggesting at the worst Morrison would spend no more than sixteen days (it is after all July 14th today already, play resumes Jul 16th) at the major league level getting acclimated by coming off the bench as a temporary replacement for the failed left-handed bat we have now or by platooning or getting a spot start, until one opens on or before the trade deadline and he begins his full-time major league career.
-
Braves interested in Cody
Not sure how this would play in, but the Braves just got Sea Bass in a trade.
-
Braves interested in Cody
And yet, if the Braves give you the best offer, you take it. Cody Ross is not really the type of player you worry about trading within division. Cody isn't worth enough to compensate the Marlins for the problems making that move brings with it. You aren't getting anything approaching a phenom, you aren't getting any everyday majorleauger that can improve the team now which is the avowed goal of the FO according to Admin Beinfest (this team as configured isn't doing it + no salary dump), you aren't getting an almost ready prospect that slotted into next season's roster, all you do is give naysayers something to point fingers at and alienate the loyal fanbase who by and large adore Cody. You can trade him to 20+ other clubs and not cause yourself the aggravation you will by trading him within the division and to the Braves especially, not to mention the Braves are not about to offer their divisional competitor anything ****that might cost**** their own team a shot at the division their leading. It's a loser move and it won't happen. (I hate typos)
-
Braves interested in Cody
Any trade of Cody to the Braves is a season-quitting move. We would be doing it for next season and beyond. It does send a message to the team (not to mention fans) that "you're playing for nothing so try to be to the park on time but if you aren't no big deal" since you'll be facing those same Atlanta Braves 12 more times this season including three games the last week of September. It isn't about Ross as much as it's about the perception it fosters.
-
Rosenthal reports Cantu & Ross on the market
Just pure idle speculation and I could be completely wrong - lol and a number of people will be glad to confirm that lol - anyways I noticed that the Marlins just moved a weak-hitting outfielder from Jupiter to NOLA and the first thing that crossed my mind was Morrison is coming up now, to start the second half, perhaps as a short term replacement for Lamb as a way of integrating him into major league ball. Forget all the rational thinking that Morrison is better off playing everyday in NOLA and ask yourself one thing, would you rather have Morrison coming in off the bench when you need a lefty bat than Mike Lamb if you (being Admin Beinfest and reciting his recent confessionals about "this" team as it is currently configured not going anywhere) expect he's going to be up by the end of the month anyways and you want him to dip his toe in the water and at the same time get a look for yourself (Beinfest and his talent evaluators) at how ready he really is. Call me crazy and I may not have it exactly right but we'll see. The underlieing thought is Morrison is with the club when they open the second half.
-
Braves interested in Cody
Isn't it a cardinal rule not to trade within your division? Or is that just other sports? The Marlins front office has done it several times before. Specifically with the Mets. The only instances I can think of (and I could just be drawing a blank on something) were in the off-season involving an external (non-baseball) event. There may have been some minor move(s), or what was a minor move at the time, but I can't remember since this became a competitive team (2003 on) that we traded anyone of importance to the Mets or anyone else in our division mid-season.
-
Tim Wood optioned down
What was missed was over the his last two appearances, besides the walks he gave up, THREE inherited runners scored. Nashville Top 4th - July 9th * Ray Olmedo singles on a line drive to left fielder Aaron Luna. * Anderson De La Rosa flies out to right fielder Mark Shorey. * Tim Dillard singles on a line drive to right fielder Mark Shorey. Ray Olmedo to 3rd. * Pitcher Change: Renyel Pinto replaces Oneli Perez, batting 9th. * Norris Hopper out on a sacrifice fly to left fielder Aaron Luna. Ray Olmedo scores. * Lorenzo Cain walks. Tim Dillard to 2nd. * With Mat Gamel batting, wild pitch by Renyel Pinto, Tim Dillard to 3rd. Lorenzo Cain to 2nd. * Mat Gamel walks. * Brendan Katin lines out to shortstop Mike Folli. ------------------ Nashville Top 7th - July 10th * Brendan Katin pops out to shortstop Donovan Solano. * Luis Cruz doubles (19) on a line drive to left fielder Aaron Luna. * With Johnny Raburn batting, passed ball by Matt Pagnozzi, Luis Cruz to 3rd. * Johnny Raburn walks. * Pitcher Change: Renyel Pinto replaces David Kopp, batting 5th. * Defensive Substitution: Mike Folli replaces pitcher David Kopp, batting 9th, playing shortstop. * Ben Johnson singles on a line drive to left fielder Aaron Luna. Luis Cruz scores. Johnny Raburn to 3rd. * Sam Narron walks. Ben Johnson to 2nd. * Adam Stern called out on strikes. * Lorenzo Cain walks. Johnny Raburn scores. Ben Johnson to 3rd. Sam Narron to 2nd. * Coaching visit to mound. * Erick Almonte strikes out swinging. I guess those runs don't matter 'cause they're on someone else's line huh. More walks and a wild pitch. Same old, same old Renyel Pinto. The more things change, the more things stay the same.
-
Sean West
I really like West and found amusing his youthful indiscretions last year, and I expect we will see him sooner rather than later, maybe even by the end of this month although August might be more realistic. But right now he's only thrown a total of 40 innings so far this season - compared to Brian Lawrence for example who has 100 innings under his belt - and just went seven innings in a game for the first time since he returned from the DL. It was a very good performance by the way. I would guess he's more in mid to late-spring training shape than fully stretched out and how strong his arm is and what kind of velocity he's showing are questions yet (at least for us fans) unanswered. His due date is probably as much a function of how well Robertson and Meyer do as his own, if either or both fail, or if Robertson is traded which I think is a distinct possibility, he'll probably be on the next plane out, but that of course also is dependent on whether Beinfest and company get starting pitching back in any trade that might happen.
-
Rosenthal reports Cantu & Ross on the market
HAHAHA! Next thing you're going to tell me is that your mouse uses RF for its wireless! Hahaha! You're a riot my friend. I did so much _________ in the sixties if I don't have these things tethered I'd lose one a day. :hat
-
Rosenthal reports Cantu & Ross on the market
(***Thanks to whichever mod fixed my original message and posted this in its place. Darn keyboard cable came loose.***) What the hell is a keyboard cable? lololololololol :thumbup
-
Rosenthal reports Cantu & Ross on the market
After Maybin's injury problem, and I'm not sure how serious it is or not, I can't see the front office risking the rest of the season on him being our everyday centerfielder, purely from a health perspective. I'll leave to others to decide if he can find his way with a bat or play a ML centerfield for a winning team, I'd not risk next season when I'm confident we can find an adequate CFer before the end of the month (assuming Cody is gone).
-
Rosenthal reports Cantu & Ross on the market
Depending on how they go about filling whatever need arises from one or both of these moves, one thing has become clear to me this season - and that is there is so much talent out there from around the world flooding major league baseball right now, that if our scouts and talent evaluators do their jobs, it's like shooting fish in a barrel. Not just among prospects but good everyday major leaguers who are being pushed out because of their salaries by quality kids coming up and the fear of being stuck with salaries they can't handle in a worsening economy. I'm, for what it's worth, very happy to get "rent a players" (vs. prospects) in return for the above-mentioned guys if the net effect is an improved ballclub 2010. I know I'm in a minority on this but such is life. I also think Robertson will go before the end of July if West can throw two or three competitive starts in AAA. We have zero investment in Nate thanks to the Tigers and while a lot of people don't like him, I suspect a number of GMs would be happy to have an experienced lefty either as their fifth starter or in their pen.
-
Rosenthal reports Cantu & Ross on the market
I have no problem trading Ross and/or Cantu so long as the end result is a (combined) better OBP, a higher RISP and better defense at least at one of the positions.
-
Rosenthal reports Cantu & Ross on the market
The Marlins have made infielder Jorge Cantu and outfielder Cody Ross available, major-league sources say, but are holding off — for now — on second baseman Dan Uggla and right-hander Ricky Nolasco. Cantu, a potential free agent, would be ideal for the Rockies, an even better fit than Uggla, who likely will earn $10 million in arbitration next season. The Rockies want a right-handed, run-producing corner bat, and are unsettled at first without Todd Helton, who is on the disabled list with lower back stiffness. The Rockies discussed trading infielder Clint Barmes and a prospect for Uggla last offseason. But if they added Cantu, they could use Barmes and Jonathan Herrera at second after Troy Tulowitzki returns from the DL in August. The downside of adding Cantu is that it might force the team to part with Melvin Mora, who is well-regarded by his teammates and has a .359 on-base percentage since May 28. For now, the Rockies will ride the Brad Eldred/Jason Giambi platoon at first and wait for Helton to return, knowing his defense, at least, is an asset. The team also might need bullpen help; right-hander Taylor Buchholz is struggling in his rehabilitation assignment at Triple-A. FoxSports.com (***Thanks to whichever mod fixed my original message and posted this in its place. Darn keyboard cable came loose.***)
-
Deals May be Coming
Adrian Gonzalez
-
Tim Wood optioned down
Yes the 16 was a typo. I hate typos. The 12.27 ERA is not a typo. But also that ERA represents his recent minor league work with the St. Louis minor league team - games pitched, July 2, 5, 7, 9. I ignored his rehab earlier in the year in the FSL
-
Tim Wood optioned down
For those really Jonesing for a quick return of Reynel Pinto so you can say "See how wrong the Marlins were..." Pinto's AAA line so far is four (4) appearances, 3.2 innings, 16 hits, 5 earned runs, 3 walks and zero strikeouts for a 12.27 ERA that almost makes the D-Train look like the Comeback Pitcher of the Year. Great to see Pinto is really committed to getting back to the MLs to show the world what he's really made of. Good get there St. Louis. :thumbup
-
Gaby or Morrison
I've never liked the argument that others have to be portrayed as inferior in order to make a usually faulty argument that the player being lionized is superior. Stats are so so notoriously corrupted by the lack of existence of factors they purposely leave out and the faulty thought rationalizations behind their formula construction, that's why those etched in stone just a few years ago as definitive are so often now considered feeble failures those obsessed with these things would like to forget ever existed because they proved to be so embarrassing. Stats have their place, one of them is not on the field. And there is no definitive correlation between an infielder being moved to the outfield (or vice versa) undermining or affecting his play out there, these are individual, player by player determinations that can't all be painted by the same broad brush. Brett Carroll......the point is throughout baseball, if you want to go back and go through the hundred or so outfielders playing at the major league level at any given time, I would guess a large percentage of them began their professional careers or played much of their college days at a position other than where they wound up. It isn't be accident that Sanchez has routinely been replaced at first late in games even as his hitting prowess became evident. He's a rookie major leaguer getting better every day at his craft but he is not at this point the best first baseman on the team in the minds of those professional talent evaluators in the dugout or in the front office, so accept it. Maybe, and I have no doubt he will become a fine first baseman, as good as 95% of the guys in the game, but he isn't there yet and to complain about others ringing up errors at least partially of his doing doesn't further the debate or make it true now. Care to give examples? Statisticians are constantly qualifying their statistics. The guys on Fangraphs never quit analyzing and criticizing the merits of their in-house WAR. Sorry, but I find those assertions to be baloney. What you said may be 100% true, but Coghlan was an IF so late in the game and moved to LF so there was space for his bat. He may end up fine in LF, but I have to think he's better off at 2B, mainly because I have to trust the assessment of the Marlins (Minor League) staff over my own. One point about CC's fielding splits: He has a positive UZR on the road but is getting crushed at home. I'm not UZR expert, but I wonder if he's being unfairly "penalized" because of how difficult it is to play LF in Dolphins Stadium? TOMMY SAID THIS WAS TO KEEP CANTU'S BAT IN THE LINEUP. And this is no longer even the case. Last night, Cantu was pulled for Helms and Gaby was left in at 1B. So this argument needs to stop. I appreciate more than most realize the improvements being made in baseball stats I'm merely pointing out that they are nowhere near definitive yet and as you point out there's always room for adjustment and improvement. What I'm saying is using them to be definitive - it's either this view of baseball and nothing else matters - is at this point not valid. Better, more sophisticated modeling will come along and make today's work obsolete. It happens in almost every facet of mathematical analysis, baseball isn't immune to change. As for the "front office as a group" and their assessment of Coghlan as an infielder vs outfielder, I like to think I keep up on my reading as well as the next guy, I can't remember anyone saying even relatively recently that the front office prefers Coghlan playing the infield over to where he's playing now. What I've heard most is them heaping accolades on him for his improved play in left. Yes, I noticed they did not replace Gaby last night, but just like stats cannot include all the factors affecting play, let's face it there's been a hundred posts here recently and Tommy and Rich have mentioned how beat down Cantu appears. And as I said Gaby is getting much better at his job and needs less defensive replacement, I thought i made that clear. I even have gone so far here to suggest one of the ways to get Morrison into the lineup would be at least for a while to relegate Cantu to the bench so both LoMo and Gaby could get the majority of playing time.
-
Gaby or Morrison
"Gaby is more than acceptable at 1B. It's the rest of the team that sucks so bad to have us next to last in defense." Sorry, not buying into it. Wait a minute. Even using the very rough and highly inexact criteria of "errors," we have, season-to-date: 7 Sanchez 9 Uggla 11 Cantu 12 Ramirez Which works out to fielding %s of: .989 Sanchez .978 Uggla .957 Cantu .963 Ramirez Ignoring all of the other supposedly (and undoubtably) better defensive stats, relatively, the rest of the infield DOES, in fact, suck, and that's half a year's sample. There may be no Golden Gloves in the bunch, but Sanchez is the best of them, by a fair margin. Except that you're missing one important factor. Scoring rules dictate that if a first baseman cannot handle anything but a perfect throw from an infielder, regardless of whether 90% of the other first basemen at the major league level could have made the play or not, the error is charged to the infielder not to the first baseman, so by definition Sanchez' fielding percentage is "protected" and thus meaningless. You can't even compare him to other first baseman because in the same way, their numbers are affected by those playing in the infield with them. You won't find one negative comment on this site about Sanchez from me, I'm no hater. I love the guy as a Miami native made good, a guy who has brought the ultimate joy to his parents who can sit in the stands every night and watch their collective lifelong dreams come true, to the accolades he's rightfully receiving and consideration for ROY deserved, and I also embrace the level of play he's exhibiting and the contributions he's making to this team. In short he's been great! But that said, I know Jeremy Hermida's pedestal is probably in storage somewhere covered in cobwebs and gathering dust but it's not quite time to drag it out and spruce it up for Gaby because there are still holes in his game, especially his defensive game and while I see him continuing to work hard to improve, he has a long way to go. But again, he's making himself into a cornerstone of the next generation of Marlins' teams. I've never liked the argument that others have to be portrayed as inferior in order to make a usually faulty argument that the player being lionized is superior. Stats are so so notoriously corrupted by the lack of existence of factors they purposely leave out and the faulty thought rationalizations behind their formula construction, that's why those etched in stone just a few years ago as definitive are so often now considered feeble failures those obsessed with these things would like to forget ever existed because they proved to be so embarrassing. Stats have their place, one of them is not on the field. It's like trying to build an argument on the notion that Chris Coghlan is a terrible left fielder which is pure, to quote Hanley Ramirez, horsesh*t. You want to say that when he came into the league he was a terrible LFer, there's no argument there. If you want to say his entire 2009 season out there was sub-par no one with an objective point of view is going to argue the point, but to use stats from a period when his learning curve was nearly on flat line to weigh down the substantially improved work he is doing in LF in July 2010, it's corrupt and unfair and just plain paints an inaccurate picture of how far he's come and the improvements he's shown, month by month this season. Chris Coghlan could play left field for the rest of his career for this or many other teams and I doubt you'd find an objective scout or general manager who would be disappointed he was out there for that team. And there is no definitive correlation between an infielder being moved to the outfield (or vice versa) undermining or affecting his play out there, these are individual, player by player determinations that can't all be painted by the same broad brush. Brett Carroll, often considered one of the best and unselfish overall defensive outfielders in the Marlins system, and certainly the guy with the strongest, most accurate arm, started out as a third baseman who also played some 2nd base along the way, yet made the conversion. But this isn't about Brett Carroll nor should the argument be deflected by his inclusion here, the point is throughout baseball, if you want to go back and go through the hundred or so outfielders playing at the major league level at any given time, I would guess a large percentage of them began their professional careers or played much of their college days at a position other than where they wound up. It isn't be accident that Sanchez has routinely been replaced at first late in games even as his hitting prowess became evident. He's a rookie major leaguer getting better every day at his craft but he is not at this point the best first baseman on the team in the minds of those professional talent evaluators in the dugout or in the front office, so accept it. Maybe, and I have no doubt he will become a fine first baseman, as good as 95% of the guys in the game, but he isn't there yet and to complain about others ringing up errors at least partially of his doing doesn't further the debate or make it true now. I'm just damn happy he's on the team and playing at a level few (if they are being honest with themselves) ever expected. Personally I see a guy getting better everyday just like the other guy in this equation, Chris Coghlan who continues to improve defensively, as much because of their commitments to excellence as their drive to be winners and the best teammates they can be. I look at these two guys and see the future of the Marlins and it brings great comfort they are there. We're pretty lucky to have both of them.
-
Gaby or Morrison
Gload is having a bad year off the bench, as often happens, and Kiko isn't even playing in the bigs. It is possible that Kiko could have gone south without the change of scenery, but that doesn't mean we should have dropped one of our more reliable bullpen guys because he cost more than the price of a Happy Meal. Actually in the case of Calero I think the Marlins did him a favor in not going public with what they knew at the end of the season, which was Calero's shoulder was a structural mess and let him go sign somewhere else if he could, and in fact he did. They could have made a big deal out of it and defended themselves in the media when the usual group of know-it-alls called them on the carpet for not re-signing the guy making the usual cheapskate accusations, instead they kept their mouths shut and took their undeserved media tongue-lashing out of loyalty to the guy. The Marlins aren't always saints but in Calero's case I think they did the right thing by the guy.
-
Gaby or Morrison
I'm sort of saying this in a vacuum, it's neither an endorsement of anything above or an indictment either. Just simply that if Uggla thought at this point in the season with the offensive season he's having, that talk he spouted this spring about not being willing or being very reluctant to move to third was more posturing to nix a trade and/or to keep his value up as a second baseman with power, he would now move to third in a heartbeat if he thought it would get the team that much closer to the playoffs. I don't have any doubt Uggla would play third about as well as he plays second, and if you can live with that, which is another question in itself, you have to ask yourself if all the moving around is worth it.
-
Should we pursue Hank Blalock?
I know I looked at his declining numbers in Tampa Bay a few weeks ago when talk of his eventual release first surfaced and without going through it again my memory was as he played less and less his offensive numbers suffered disproportionately to his playing time. And even when picking up a full game here or there he seemed to be trending down. *This could be perception more than reality, I'd have to go back and really go through it all again*. When you combine that with his minimal playing time in the field and the fact it's been three or four years since he played third base with any regularity (given that the last place we need another glove is first base if we can't find room for LoMo already) I wonder if there's a fit there for the team? If I had a choice between Blalock and Lamb I guess I would go with Blalock just because of his history, but I'm not sure there aren't other options for the Marlins to consider, and keep in mind Morrison, if he does come up, is another everyday lefty in the lineup, something the Fish can surely use. I guess I'm saying I wouldn't be upset if he came aboard as a bench player but I'm not holding my breath waiting for it to happen.
-
Cantu
Have you guys heard if hes having the same problems as last year? he dont look the same to me. you mean the wrist injury?? nah he was taking some meds that made him dizzy and weak. cholestrol meds i think. I know a few weeks ago before a game he was dizzy. He also has some kind of muscular or skeletal injury or flair-up last season that hampered his play.
-
We need more offense from Hanley
E-Rod's stated comments on Hanley were right on. I'm glad Admin Beinfest thought to have his new spokesperson go public with the front office's view of things. Taking nothing away from Rodriguez's managerial skills because I'm liking him more and more, the front office must be comforted knowing they finally have their guy in there and willing to do as he's told. That said, the number one problem continues to be defensive miscues (errors on the scorekeeper's sheet AND just plain bone-headed play) that results in teams getting five or six outs in an inning. We didn't lose last night because Sanchez pitched badly (although he certainly contributed and was far from stellar). I can't look into a crystal ball and predict what the final tally would ultimately have been but I guarantee the score would have been a lot closer and perhaps the outcome different if the Marlins could just hold teams to three outs an inning. It's criminal how badly we play sometimes. Heart-breaking really to watch games just being thrown away.
-
Tim Wood optioned down
I'm a huge believer in gamelogs and game recaps, call it old school, maybe it's just me, but I think they can give someone a more realworld snapshot of what a player is doing and the progress he's making or not making than some extrapolated stat. That's just me and this is not an anti-stats rant or a put down of that work in any way. We all see things through a different prism. Take a look at Meyer's last ten games and if you need more go back through old box scores and game recaps and in his case it's easy to see the progression he's made since being sent down and especially over his last ten appearances why the Marlins probably made the decision they did (along with speaking with his coaches and manager in NOLA). I have no idea how that will translate back in the bigs but at least in my mind he's warranted another look (and it doesn't hurt he's a lefty either). http://web.minorleaguebaseball.com/milb/stats/stats.jsp?pos=P&sid=t588&t=p_pbp&pid=434159