Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

dim

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by dim

  1. Am I able to post in any area on this forum without you right wing douchebags following me around anymore?
  2. I'm not even going to go along in this thread. It feels like making fun of the mentally handicap kid who doesn't realize he's not in on the joke.
  3. I'm not sure what the market value for somebody like Dunn will be though. He avoided arbitration with a $3 million a year deal in 2015 after a 3.16 ERA season, but again that was arbitration and I don't know what teams will pay for him. I do know the Marlins would love him back.
  4. Well Rodney's apparently on the way out (didn't realize his salary more than doubled due to him achieving incentives). Now I'm pretty annoyed we gave up Paddack for somebody who gave us a 6 ERA in two months. Expected him to get at least another month next year to prove himself since Rodney's success is always predicated on confidence. Mike Dunn isn't going though. Lefty veteran who has been pretty consistent and was solid out of the 'pen last season. Don't see why he shouldn't be there.
  5. The funny thing about Doug Fister is he raised his ERA by a full run in the final month of the season. Went from 3.60 to 4.60 in a span of 6 starts, losing all of them. Before that he had gone at least 5 2/3 IP in 20 of his first 26 starts. He gave 3 ER or less in 22 of his 32 starts. He had a 2 month stretch in May/June when he had a 2.66 ERA. He signed a 1 year, $7 million deal with the Astros to play this year, and after sh*tting the bed to end the season he's set to get about the same thing. He'd either be Mat Latos 2.0 or Mark Buerhle 2.0 for us. At that price tag it would be dumb not to see which one he'll be.
  6. I am still completely against spending anything big for closers. I know the market over the past year has started to once again value closers incredibly high due to the emergence of guys like Andrew Miller and Aroldis Chapman, but I'm still of the mindset that our current squad could be a top tier bullpen with a top tier closer (which was apparent by Ramos making the All Star team). Look, I know the trend is towards closers. I looked at every division winner this year and they all have the best closers in the league (Aroldis Chapman, Kenley Jansen, Mark Melancon, Craig Kimbrel, Andrew Miller, and Sam Dyson). Maybe I'm by myself in this belief, but I think not only can Ramos handle the closer spot, but I think David Phelps, Kyle Barraclough, and maybe even Nick Wittgren or Brian Ellington could be successful closers in this league. If this team stopped putting its faith in Fernando Rodney, I think the Marlins could have their own top tier closer without having to acquire from outside.
  7. I've said I want to go after Gio Gonzalez, and yes I know it is incredibly unrealistic to see the Nationals not picking up his option. But that would be my first go-to player if things fall through. I believe the way to winning is through the rotation. It needs to be fixed, and the biggest trade pieces this team has are Marcell Ozuna, AJ Ramos, Derek Dietrich, Tomas Telis, Tom Koehler, and maybe Hech. The Marlins needed at least a #2 starter with Jose. Without Jose they need a rotation that cannot be fixed in a years time. It's going to take time to rebuild it now. I don't know who that guy will be, but giving up AJ Ramos for him would be the ideal situation (and I'd be willing to throw in Ozuna for the right person). The team next year going in should look like... C Realmuto 1B Bour 2B Gordon SS Rojas (I'm open to giving him a full season try despite his own shortcomings) 3B Prado LF Yelich CF Ozuna (barring a trade) RF Stanton Rotation (this is with trading Koehler) Wei-Yin Chen Adam Conley Doug Fister David Phelps ??? (Guys I've seen that could be interesting matches include Jake Peavy, R.A. Dickey, and Jorge De La Rosa. In house options here will be Austin Brice, Justin Nicolino, and Jose Urena). Bullpen (this would be without Ramos, who should be a prime trade target) Closer: Kyle Barraclough Setup: Nick Wittgren RP: Fernando Rodney RP: Brian Ellington RP: Mike Dunn RP: Austin Brice RP: Jose Urena RP: Chris Reed Rest of RP are random free agent signings. That's how I would like to see the team constructed next season. In the event of an Ozuna trade, I'd like to see the team target either Austin Jackson or try and go big to get Josh Reddick in free agency. I think the rotation is going to be poor regardless of what you do. However, I do think there are some underrated value players that could help fix things. David Phelps was spectacular last season in the role and while he's obviously due to regress it would be a mistake not to give him a job to open the year. I also believe Austin Brice is an excellent sleeper candidate to become a respectable starter in 2017, similar to what Adam Conley did for us this year. Brice was our best starting pitching prospect who the team inexplicably moved to the bullpen with successful results. While the numbers have been good in relief, it would be a mistake to not see what you have in him as a starter. Other than that my plan is about getting veteran pitchers on their last run. Guys like Peavy, Dickey, and De La Rosa would make for great clubhouse guys and can have good seasons at a cheap cost with no long term investment. Instead of splurging in the market, those are the kind of moves that are needed to push the needle without a farm system.
  8. I only started the article, but I call BS on Luis Castillo being a top 100 prospect. I like the guy as a pitcher and he made great strides in 2016, but he's not even a top 150 prospect. Braxton Garrett is our only top 100 guy and that is just out of principle of being a top 10 draft pick. I am highly skeptical of the Rays trade you offer forward. While I'm always ok with upgrading at shortstop, that trade does the exact opposite that needs to be done to improve. The Marlins were league average when it came to getting on base and far above average at hitting the ball, but were one of the worst in the league in power statistics leading to low end run support. Ozuna is one of the only guys left on the roster that has legitimate 30 home run power. Take that away and we have even less runs next season. I'm going to point out that Hechavarria carries a negative value currently, and Flores is a pointless value at the moment given his poor AAA production this season. So when I look at a straight up Ozuna for Adames trade, it basically becomes giving away consistent MLB performance at a loaded position versus unknown potential at a premium position. Good shortstops are hard to find in the league today. Adames is a 21 year old who has only reached AA who has never shown an ability to hit for contact or power in the minors. He's a top 50 prospect for a reason, and it's all about potential and his discipline at the plate. Long term, Adames could very easily become the better player and better value in the trade, but that won't happen for another four or five years while he finds his bearings in the majors. If your plan involves the Marlins going full rebuild mode, then that is an acceptable trade to consider. But if you want them to look towards competing soon, it isn't. Chih-Wei Yu has incredible minor league numbers and it would be amazing to get him. Again, the issue with a Hu trade would be he'll need three or four years to truly develop. I believe value wise his potential is equal to the value Ozuna provides right now, but that would mean going into rebuild mode. As for Blanco, I'd rather just stick with Hech for another year as terrible as that sounds. The value Hech adds defensively makes him pretty much the same value of a player as Blanco. The shortstop market in free agency is awful and it will likely be awful for a while so I don't see the Marlins moving on from Hech anytime soon. Doug Fister is a perfectly fine signing and the kind of moves the Marlins should always try to make. Getting a pitcher who was once a star and after a couple bad seasons is of incredibly low value on the market. Won't cost much to see whether Fister still has anything left in the tank or if he is truly on the downturn of his career. I actually expect Fister to be one of the Marlins signings this offseason. Ivan Nova is the other side of the coin. Historically inconsistent pitcher who had a career year in a short amount of time (11 starts) and is likely to get a relatively big money, long term-ish deal where he's bound to regress. I'd stay far away from a bidding war that takes place for Nova. As for Tim Lincecum, I think it's safe to say he's done barring some minor miracle. He was absolutely awful with the Angels this year and his career is just DOA. I have no problems signing him to a minor league contract since the rule of thumb is that there really is no such bad thing as a minor league deal, but I don't think we'll ever seen Big Time Timmy Jim pitching in the big leagues again.
  9. You're basically telling me Miguel Cabrera should've taken something like $30 million from the Marlins back in 2005 instead of waiting a few years and getting $210 million because of the chance of a freak accident killing him instantly. In a business sense Jose Fernandez would've been leaving $210 million on a the table by taking that offer. It would've been dumb for him to push his future big free agent contract even further with any potential arm injuries hurting his value. There's a reason Boras knows exactly what he's doing. He was getting every penny he could for Fernandez and was doing his job excellently.
  10. Ok I worded that poorly. They were listening to offers. They weren't trying to trade him but they weren't hanging up the phone on teams.
  11. It wasn't even bad advice not to take the money. Jose would've made that money and more in arbitration. There's no way he should've been banking on some freak accident happening when just a few more healthy seasons was going to net him an extra $210 million at least. I also call BS on Jose staying here. Sure, he loved Miami and based on the city he would've loved to stay long term. The reality of the situation was he was going to go where the money was, and the Marlins weren't going to offer him $250 million in a few years. Jose Fernandez would've ended up a Dodger, Yankee, Cub, or with the Red Sox. I know the tragedy makes people want to say Jose was going to be a Marlin lifer, but the truth is he was being shopped and was likely to be traded in the 2017 offseason.
  12. dim replied to Admin's topic in Sports
    Pretty sure Brad Hand would be a better comparison, aka failed starter who made it elsewhere as a reliever.
  13. Jeffery Loria walks into a front office meeting... "Guys, I know we've spent a ton in free agency and the draft the last few years. I know we've traded for veterans and replaced a ton of coaches. There's just something that's missing, and I can't figure it out..." Everybody looks around the room, contemplating just that thing that the Marlins need. As David Samson continues to think about that time he finished last in Survivor, Michael Hill comes to a sudden realization. He gets up out of his chair and walks over to the whiteboard. Hill draws something on the board as everybody looks to see what it is. A perfectly shaped heart is visible, colored in that horrible green color at Marlins Stadium. "It's love. Love is what's missing." Loria stands up from his throne and begins to slow clap. The entire office is now applauding as Hill smiles, knowing that he has solved the mystery that has plagued this franchise for thirteen years. The Marlins go 162-0 and win 40 straight World Series with Jeffery Loria as owner, celebrating his final win at the age of 115.
  14. I have no idea what you said here, but I'm going to accept that it's all wrong. The Marlins need to draft better. They need to hold onto the prospects that have promise rather than trading them for bad veterans. They need to make smarter choices in free agency and possibly even take more than just 1 "chance free agent" an offseason. If the Cubs had Jose Fernandez instead of, say, Kyle Hendricks this season they still would've made the playoffs. Multiple teams have built stability where the loss of a single player can be overcome. The Marlins did not successfully build around Stanton and Fernandez. While the loss of Fernandez would suck regardless, the poor front office management for at least the last three years makes it even worse.
  15. He did that in A ball too though. It's one of those situations that you accept it as a flaw and work on improving in areas that you can. He excels so much in so many things that I'll overlook the inconsistency.
  16. In terms of trades, the obvious has been stated with the no trade clause. However, as I said with Jose before the tragedy, I would only be willing to part with them if we were able to loot a team's farm system. Back at the start of this season that would've been the Dodgers and Corey Seager, Julio Urias, Jose De Leon, and possibly two more lower ranked players. That kind of deal would've needed to be the return for either Stanton or Fernandez. The other teams with farm systems that would enable a trade like that to happen and would make sense to trade for Stanton or Fernandez would've been the Yankees (Judge, Sanchez, Austin, etc...) and maybe the Astros (Bregman, Fisher, Reed). Unfortunately, many of these players have made the majors and done great things, making their value far higher than they were back then. If the team is to look towards trading Stanton, it'll need to wait and see how other team's prospects develop as well as how Stanton bounces back from a turbulent 2016. This offseason easily is not the right time.
  17. It's all ok, no need to apologize, I am not offended so don't worry. My goal is always to work on just thinking before writing and always keeping yourself informed and becoming better as a fan. You didn't do anything off, and my point was directed more at the year of the fanbase souring on Stanton and creating false narratives about him.
  18. Apologies for the big wall of text, but some information needed to be brought to this discussion. There's been a ton of false opinions thrown around so long in 2016 that they've been reinterpreted as fact. Oh, and I laughed at "his value will never be higher". Bull...shit. I don't care if he's making $30 million a year. The season Stanton stays healthy and hits 50 home runs (which with 80 grade power it's only a matter of when) somebody will throw their entire farm to acquire him costs notwithstanding. Stanton's value only tanks if he either remains injury prone or puts up continuous poor seasons while getting paid high. Right now he's on 1 poor season in a row.
  19. Lets even pretend for a second that Stanton wants out of Miami and will waive his no-trade clause. 1) Stanton is going to make $14.5 million next season, so he's not making "break the bank" money yet. Trading him now would be both trading him at a low value and giving up a year of reasonable money. 2) While it has been said before, a large portion of Stanton's injuries in his career have been to different body parts or freak injuries. He couldn't finish 2014 because he was hit in the face with a baseball. In 2015 he was hit by a pitch in the hand and broke it. This year he had that groin injury when running. The issues prior to 2014 were to his hamstring, shoulder, knee, and quad. If you want to call him a complete mess who'll injure anything then its fine. But I'd be far more worried long-term if it was a singular injury that was recurring constantly. Many of the injuries have just been a product of terrible luck. 3) In regards to Stanton's defense, you would be correct when accounting for the 2016 season. When ranking players by specific defensive metrics, Stanton ranked the 104th best defensive outfielder among players with a certain amount of innings (he did not finish the season as a qualified player). But in 2015 Stanton was ranked 19th in UZR (which factors things such as arm strength, range, errors, etc...) among all outfielders in baseball. That means that while Stanton failed the eye test, he was able to make a great deal of plays look easy and effortless that lesser players wouldn't have made, saving us double digit runs over the course of the season. Stanton has been inconsistent defensively in his career, playing like a top 20 defensive outfielder in 2010, 2012, and 2015, average in 2011/2014, and poor in 2013/2016. There isn't enough consistency to definitively say what kind of defender Stanton is, but when accounting for everything it is safe to say he is average to very slightly above average. 4) Stanton is not a poor hitter. He is a streaky hitter and fans who don't bother to look into the team tend to mistake the two. Stanton has consistently led the majors in isolated power and has a career OBP that mirrors that of Christian Yelich, a player that everybody universally agrees is a fantastic hitter. Before 2016, Stanton had OPS' of .950 and .952, which would put him alongside Miguel Cabrera and Josh Donaldson this season as one of the top 7 hitters in baseball. Stanton is the same hitter he was in the minors (if not vastly improved in many areas). He's inconsistent and will go through spouts where he strikes out a ton and hits no home runs over the course of a month. And then there'll be moments where he looks like the greatest hitter alive. This season saw more of the former than the latter. He's still a 26 year old player with multiple .900+ OPS seasons and 208 home runs already in the bank. There isn't a single player in the league that can provide the peaks that Stanton's potential offers (and highs that we've seen previously). You are completely wrong in your entire assessment of Stanton as a player. I've followed Stanton's career since he was in Greensboro and I believe I have a fair grasp on the player he is. He's improved his patience, he's maintained the power, and he has the respect of the entire league with his presence alone. He showed in the wake of tragedy that he is a team leader and is still two years shy of when most players even hit their peak. Is he going to be overpaid when his contract kicks up to $25 million in 2018? Possibly. Is there a chance that Jeffery Loria or whoever the owner is trades him in a few years to Los Angeles or New York to rid themselves of his contract and rebuild a dead farm? Again, possibly. But Stanton is a generational player. And your sentiment is one that many in the Marlins fanbase has grown to have, and it is 100% false. Frankly, I'm tired of seeing people throwing shade at players whenever anything goes the slightest bit wrong. The smart thing to do, and one I personally believe Miami is going to do, is build around Stanton and play around both his strengths and weaknesses rather than harping on them.
  20. dim replied to pollythewog's topic in Off-Topic
    Fun fact: JJ Abrams is a producer for Westworld, so it isn't coincidental the similarities.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.