Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

EricWiener

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by EricWiener

  1. Now I am very happy we signed Gonzalez. Though Bonds probably wouldn't be forced to stand trial until after Josh gets back
  2. I just want to go off on another winning streak, I don't care who it is against.
  3. The Marlins will spend more. Will they be waving cash around like Boston and NY? I'd think no.
  4. Anyone see Edmonds catch last night in CF. He is just sick! That is what a good defensive CF looks like, smooth as silk. While I like Edmonds... he makes a lot of stuff harder than it should be, I haven't seen the play in question, but I'm willing to assume it would meet my criteria there... I happen to agree that Edmonds is overrated but that catch was a good play, he got a perfect jump and took the best angle to the ball and robbed a hit.
  5. Era's considered, I think the general consensus still has Piazza over Bench, and Bench over Fisk... IMO Bench is definitely better than Fisk I happen to think that Piazza may very well be the best, the only real doubts are guys that managed .750 OPS seasons in eras where the leader in SLG had a .475 or so, and it is hard to prove the apples and oranges case.
  6. Why is there a question mark after "Best Hitting Catcher Ever"? Because Bench and Pudge Rodriguez are good as well, and Pudge's career isn't over. I love Pudge, he isn't on the same planet as Piazza as a hitter. Looking at era, one can make a pretty good argument for Bench and Fisk.
  7. Cantu is not a big suprise with his bat. He is exactly what one could expect based upon earlier performance. Personally I think the Marlins won't call Dallas up until after we can safely put Amezega on the bench and Andino in the minors.
  8. I wasn't comparing him to Utley...someone else was; I just proved Utley was better (with stats). Despite parks, Utley's career .OPS+ (which factors parks) is 128; Uggla's is 117. OPS+ does not acount for park effects as regards handedness, only park effects overall. CBP overwhelmingly favors left handers, right handers not so much.
  9. And why do you keep comparing him to Chase Utley??? Chase Utley is one of the best all around second basemen the game has EVER seen. So what if he isn't as good as Utley? Nobody is!!! The Utley thing is from me. Dan's first 2 seasons are better than Utley's first 2 seasons. I brought that up and we got into a large, wide-ranging discussion about how Utley benefits from CBP (in addition to being awesome) and that Dan is harmed by DS (and is still awesome). Not even I am saying that Dan is better than Utley, or even as good, though I think Dan can get close. I see Dan becoming an even better Jeff Kent.
  10. Bullpen roles are overrated.
  11. Cantu is a pleasant suprise, but lets not pretend he's anything other than a band-aid. McPherson, might be better, and we can call him up and keep Cantu on the roster to avoid having to waive him by sending Andino down. I would not be inclined to do this until we get Jacque Jones on the team, so that we will have 'fredo as a backup SS option
  12. Btw, guys...I think it's really cool how we've debated this, and we haven't really gotten into huge arguments. Just sharing opinions & thoughts. Jerk.... :whistle But back to the topic at hand. The team should sign Hermida as soon as he completes a season without more than 15 days on the DL. Hopefully that is this season. The only guy that I think the team should stay year-to-year on is Willingham, because his back problem is not going to go away, at least without major surgery. This is a team that could have one of the best lineups 1-6 in baseball, without going outside the organization, within 2 years. If Coughlin pans out, make that 1-7 in the new ballpark.
  13. I'm not saying Uggla sucks. I'm just saying he's not as special, as some of you guys are making him out to be (stats prove this). And at the age of 28, how MUCH BETTER (Key word: "better") can he really get? Actually, stats prove he special. He's on an upward trend and he is going to be better and he is a guy we are going to want for 2011-2014 at least. That is a 6 year buy out.
  14. Uggla is ahead of Utley's development. He will have his 3rd .800 OPS + season this year. And Utley had 3 .900+ seasons in the same time frame. I really don't understand how you can say there's a difference in their "development". Both entered pro-ball at 21. Uggla had two strait .800 OPS seasons from 26-27. Utley had two strait .900 OPS seasons from 26-27. At 28, Utley had another .900 OPS season. At 28, so far Uggla is putting up great numbers but still 4 months to play. And again 82 games at CBP isn't going to add 100 points to OPS. Maybe .040-.050, which is still greater than Uggla's numbers. Except CBP has added massively to Utley's OPS, each of the last 2 seasons. Last season his home OPS was 180 points higher than on the road. In 2006 it was 122 points higher. The inflator for CPB is that absurd. Combine that with the deflator of Dolphin stadium and it is out of control... CPB vs. LHP and DS vs. RHP Singles: favor DS by 2% Doubles: favor CBP by 9% Triples: favor CBP by 10% Homers: favor CBP by 44% A LH power hitter that is identical to a RH hitter in all other ways would OPS far higher with 81 games in CBP rather than 81 in DS. Utley's CAREER OPS+ is 128...and this includes his 1st 2 years, where he was mediocre; if I were to include his stats from his 3rd year on (since Utley began his career at a younger age than Uggla), it wouldn't even be close. Erick, Utley is the best 2B in the NL right now, but time played in MLB is a significant factor. The incompetance of the Arizona Diamond backs as regards Dan Uggla should not be a knock on Dan. The more MLB pitching he sees, the more walks he draws and the more extra base hits he generates. Doubles and walks are clear indicators of improvement, and Dan is getting both at a pretty good rate. Not signing Dan is a foolish move. Period. The only thing that age indicates moving forward is that, barring injury, Utley may have a longer career than Dan.
  15. No doubt about Dan.
  16. I would split lefties to screw with other bullpens, but frankly it is an overrated practice. I just happen to think that we have a pretty good potential lineup that splits the lefties anyhow.
  17. Stop talking about sending Miller down. It makes me wonder if you guys even watch the team play. Miller's first 2 starts were really, really bad. His 3rd start was tough, but unlucky to a cerain extent. 5 of his last 6 starts were good. He's putting it together.
  18. You said a variance in birthdays, not pro-ball. Also both entered proball at the same age (21). And I don't see what pro-ball that has to do with anything. That means that Utley's 28 season was last year, and Uggla's 28 season is this year....which is exactly what I was saying. Whatever. Uggla is ahead of Utley's development. He will have his 3rd .800 OPS + season this year. I will expect that he will have his 1st .900 OPS season as well. He will do it without Citizen's Bank Park, which is 2nd only to Fenway in its left-handed hitter bias. And therefore have three .800+ OPS season with less experience than Utley. He is a line drive machine. He is going to crank 50 doubles, 30 homers, and draw 80 walks through his prime, and will very quickly become a guy that will cost us many millions in arbitration, and thus is not likely to be a Marlin in 2011 without a deal that buys him out.
  19. Right But being born in Decemeber doesn't make his previous baseball season a year older. When Utley was 28, his season was last year, 2007, not 2006. This baseball season, Utley is 29, not 30. He won't turn 30 until several months into the offseason. By Eric's assessment, this season counts as Utley being "30". Utley entered proball "younger" than Uggla. Utley entered in 2000, Uggla in 2001, there is a 1 season difference in their experience, despite the "2" years in age.
  20. and he's a little ahead of Utley's development. Utley was having his third strating .900+ OPS season when he was 28. Due to a variance in birthdays, Ultey's 27 is Uggla's 28. I expect Uggla to manage a .900+ OPS this season and thus have three .800+ OPS season sat the same point Utley had managed two. Not to mention the tremendous home-field bias Utley operates on.
  21. Most similar 2b hitter at age 27 is Jeff Kent, and he's a little ahead of Utley's development. Letting Uggla go would be an error.
  22. Does anyone know the date of the super two deadline? Depends on the team, but once we play 75 games or so we should be clear.
  23. And lets not sugarcoat it...Uggla's been as inconsistent as anyone, as a hitter. I remember him K'ing a lot last year, and having a horrible .OBP, and he's HORRIBLE with men on base (unless if he's really HOT, as he is now). His OBP is not horrible, his ability to draw walks has consitently improved, and he is an extra base machine. .800+ (and improving) OPS at 2B is a rare commodity. Uggla has all the makings of a player that is improving his OBP, and is the kind of guy that the Marlins would be foolish to part with. As for being "HORRIBLE" with men on base, that is also not true. His career OPS with runners on is higher than his career OPS.
  24. Maybe, with Josh back, we can do either: Hermida, Willingham, Ramirez, Jacobs, Uggla, Cantu, Jones/Ross, Catcher, Pitcher or Ramirez, Hermida, Willingham, Jacobs, Uggla, Cantu, Jones/Ross, Catcher, Pitcher
  25. Lock up Uggla. He is already great, and he is getting better. Late in the year if Hermida avoids injury, I'd get him also. Sometimes next season, if Jacobs is healthy, we lock him up as well. ...and then we'll have no pitching. :thumbdown That is the most absurd thing I've heard this week... and I work in a call center. Volstad + Olsen + Miller does not equal no pitching. That doesn't count the other 10 guys in our system that can pan out or... GASP.... a free agent acquisition to round out the rotation.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.