Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Featured Replies

The greatest thing about 300 is that it didn't focus too much on the romance or politics. The movie is about 300 men who stood up to fight an army of unimaginable numbers, and nearly won. It's about how can we re-invent action sequences in a way that we as viewers can go, "God Damn that was like nothing I've seen before in a movie!"

 

End.

Unless someone attacks a point I've made thus far, I'll do just that (wait until I've seen the movie before writing more).

 

However, Zodiac and the next Ingmar Bergman revival take preference right now.

 

I thought Fox did a good job of attacking your point.

None better. He was attacking my point all night.

I think you won too.

The movie is about 300 men who stood up to fight an army of unimaginable numbers, and nearly won.

Well, they did accomplish their mission. Though the movie doesn't go into that storyline.

Well, they did accomplish their mission. Though the movie doesn't go into that storyline.

Agreed. I think the point was that they were still completely annihilated, but they went willingly to slaughter in order to set an example. Their "victory" was that tales of their heroism rallied and united the Greeks and rattled Xerxes' confidence. Ultimately, their two day stand also gave the Greek states enough time to prepare for the coming invasion and forced Xerxes to use his navy ? a decision that would prove to be the undoing of the Persian invasion at the Battle of Salamis [which is still studied at the Naval Academy and considered by many to be the single most important naval battle in world history].

 

The Battle of Thermopylae is merely a footnote in anglicized history, stating that the entire Spartan contingent was butchered but at ?great cost? to the Persians. The reason Leonidas is such an icon in Greece is because of his self-sacrifice. He was, basically, a military version of Jesus Christ in the minds of the Spartans!

Yup. If the Spartans hadn't held down the Gates of Fire, Athens would have burned to the ground with everyone in it. Instead, the Athenians fled and were able to battle Xerxes where they could take him best (now that the Spartans had sacrificed himself). That to me is what makes the Battle of Thermopylae my favorite of all time - the fact that the Spartans laid down their lives to allow their mortal enemies (Athens) to escape with enough time to save Greece later on. People that haven't learned about the time forget it, but Greek was a fractured land where there were rival factions - the Delian League (run by Sparta) and the Athenian League (duh).

Has anyone seen this in the IMAX yet? I am thinking about going friday, but I wanted to see what someone's IMAX opinion was.

WTF was with that fat Jabba the Hutt executioner Xerxes had? Sliced off one of his generals' head with his sawblade arms!!!?

 

:o

Yeah - that was a little weird. The cool thing about it, though, is that I can imagine some old guy sitting around the campfire telling the "true" story of Brave King Leonidas and his 300 Men with some "minor" embellishments. Keep that image in the back of your mind the next time you watch the movie and some of the odder elements will make a lot more sense.

I just got back from a 12:40 AM showing, which is undoubtedly the latest movie I have ever gone to.

 

Anyway, I thought it was okay. Visually appealing, no doubt. I just had a problem understanding why I was supposed to be cheering for the Spartans. I know it was more or less by design, but they basically had no personality whatsoever. The word "spartan" can be used to describe people who bottle everything up inside, who are inexpressive, and even cold. And the Spartans in this movie took that to its extreme. Frankly, I couldn't help but think how dull it might've been to live in Sparta. The only character in this movie with a personality was Xerxes, who, by the way, looked pretty much like a drag queen.

 

Also, I found pretty difficult to reconcile the first 10 minutes or so of the movie, where they show the kid being removed from his home against his will, and basically being thrown to the wolves...I found it hard to reconcile that with all the later talk of how they were fighting for freedom. Whatever. If that's what freedom is, you can keep it.

Well, they were fighting for Greece's freedom, but the movie doesn't really do a great job of telling you that.

I haven't read the graphic novel, but I did like this movie.

 

My only complaint was, what the hell was the point of that weird hunchback guy? He doesn't really add anything to the story that I could tell.

 

It appears that minus the weird Persian creatures, the film was mostly accurate on a historical level. The only thing the movie left out was the naval battle, which was important as well.

 

A documentary on this battle on the History Channel actually says that Athens DID burn, but almost no one died because the city was evacuated. The Persians were also forced out of Greece rather quickly by a united Greek army, which we see at the end of the film. The show credits this battle with essentially saving democracy, because the Persians would have been able to annihilate Sparta very fast if it wasn't for Leonidas' forces holding off the Persians for several days. The historians on the show say that if he hadn't made that sacrifice, it is likely that democracy as an idea would have ceased to exist after the destruction of Athens.

The thing about 300 is this, its an awesome movie, but you have to look at it for what it is.

 

Lets compare 300 to another movie set in the time of the Romans, The Gladiator. The Gladiator was a fantastic film, it won 5 Oscars including Best Film and Best Actor, many will tell the that you cannot compare 300 and The Gladiator, and this is my point exactly.

 

The Gladiator was mostly a drama, 300 is just an action packed epic.

 

People complain about its lack of depth and how it ignores the storyline. I for one think it was pretty obvious from the previews that 75% of the movie would be battle scenes.

 

When grading The 300 you have to look at it as a film that is not story driven, but rather as a pulse-pounding, 2-hour long fight scene.

 

In my opinion, The 300 is one of the best ACTION movies of all time. IMDB has The 300 with a viewer rating (only rating that really counts) of 8.3/10, in contrast, The Gladiator has an 8.1/10. Though The 300's rating will probably go down a little once the initial excitement burns out.

I haven't read the graphic novel, but I did like this movie.

 

My only complaint was, what the hell was the point of that weird hunchback guy? He doesn't really add anything to the story that I could tell.

 

It appears that minus the weird Persian creatures, the film was mostly accurate on a historical level. The only thing the movie left out was the naval battle, which was important as well.

 

A documentary on this battle on the History Channel actually says that Athens DID burn, but almost no one died because the city was evacuated. The Persians were also forced out of Greece rather quickly by a united Greek army, which we see at the end of the film. The show credits this battle with essentially saving democracy, because the Persians would have been able to annihilate Sparta very fast if it wasn't for Leonidas' forces holding off the Persians for several days. The historians on the show say that if he hadn't made that sacrifice, it is likely that democracy as an idea would have ceased to exist after the destruction of Athens.

The hunchback guy represents the spy that sold out the Spartans in the real battle, and there was no naval battle at Thermopylae.

Well, I'm no huge fan of Gladiator, but it's definitely more fun and more interesting than 300.

 

And actually I went in expecting about 75% battle scenes, but I found that it was probably more like 25% battle scenes. I'd guess the first fight scene happened like 40 minutes into the movie, and then the rest of the movie had fights in about a 50/50 proportion with other stuff.

My only complaint was, what the hell was the point of that weird hunchback guy? He doesn't really add anything to the story that I could tell.

Wow. He was a PIVITOL character in the story! Ephialtes was the "monster" that showed the Persians the goat path around the Gates of Hell and allowed them to circle the Spartan army. He was the original Benedict Arnold.

 

The filmmakers used deformed and distorted characters [Ephialtes, the saw arm guy, the Immortals, larger-than-life Xerxes, etc.] to represent evil and/or the enemy in contrast to the beauty and perfection of the Spartans [the 300 and the Queen].

It was a great action movie, but when my friends and I went to see it a 2nd time, I felt a little underwhelmed.

I'm a comic guy. I read 300, didn't really consider it among Miller's best, and I was luke-warm to seeing this movie.

 

My friend and I saw it this afternoon and I loved it. I didn't think it was a great movie, but it was a really cool movie. The way they tried to copy the blurred background (to be faithful to the comic) bothered me (as it did in the comic) but whatever, that was my main gripe.

 

I'd recommend it to just about anyone that can deal with gore.

  • 3 weeks later...

Nothing says date movie like 300 half-naked, well-chiseled, sweaty men tearing an army of freaks to bloody shreds.

 

gotta remember its Dodge :lol

 

i went with a girl and a couple of guys and the girl was drooling over those guys and got all excited during the sex scene yelling "they had the backshot position back then!?" ive never laughed so hard during a sex scene.

 

i normally dont like a lot of blood and all that stuff but i absolutely loved the movie. yeah the story wasnt perfect but you gotta take it for what it is... a movie that delivered on the entertainment.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.