Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Stokes traded

Featured Replies

If Beinfest really liked Baker he would have kept him when we had him last offseason.

 

 

There wasn't enough room on the roster at the time. Obviously, Stokes is used goods and something is wrong with him and I'm not talking about him K'ing 50% of the time either.

 

Loria has learned to trust Beinfest especially after he picked Girardi and Beinfest picked Fredi Gonzalez the 1st time around. Beinfest likes certain guys...Gonzalez, Baker, Jorge Julio, Benitez....you have to trust him.

lol... terrible

 

 

 

Offseason report card grade goes to a G?

 

:lol

well this certainly didn't help

 

most likely this trade becomes a nothing trade, but why even make the trade to begin with?

 

I don't get it

catching depth

so why didn't we pluck JD Closser off waivers last week?

 

 

Because Baker was an actual prospect and Beinfest likes the guy. How come you aren't the GM since you always hate EVERY trade and always end up wrong?

 

 

free a spot on the 40?

 

 

Baker will be with the Marlins next year instead of Treanor. Baker can hit and has a good eye at the plate. Don't listen to many of these fans who never know anything about new players. Baker is a former PAC-10 all star C and was drafted in the 4th round, showing he has good potential. Baker has very good gap power as I've read- in 2004 he had 35 doubles and 15 HR, 24 doubles in 2005 and 19 doubles last year to go along with a steady .270 BA for a catcher. He is quick from what I've read as well and stretches some singles into doubles. Last season he went 10-20 in spring training with a double and a homer with the A's.

 

I hate it when people think change is bad. This is the classic case of Beinfest ripping off one of the best in the business, Beane. Beane doesn't know that Stokes is USED GOODS and Beinfest does.....

Jesus H Christ, you are a moron. Has Beinfest ever done anything wrong in your eyes? How in G-d's name is Baker a prospect? You want to talk about hitting. JD Closser killed him in the minors and wouldnt have cost us a f***ing thing. .283/.383/.461. That is Closser's career line in the minors and he is all of 27 years old. John Baker is as much a prospect as Jason Wood is. I love how you say "how come you aren't the GM". Thats a real mature comeback. How about you take your head out of Beinfest's ass and smell the coffee. He ain't perfect, man. Not everything he touches turns to gold. In fact, he's been finding out some sh*t recently. The only one who possibly got ripped off here was Beinfest. There is no possibly way Beane got ripped here. Sorry. You are wrong, as YOU ALWAYS ARE.

 

And why do you keep calling me out saying I'm always wrong? Where have I been wrong recently? Or in the past few seasons? Sure we all make mistakes but I happen to think I have a pretty good grasp of what is going on.

Wow Ramp are you ok? :lol

Haven't ever seen a meltdown like that from you Dude, easy man we still love you :cool

Yea, I'm fine. I just hate incoherent morons.

Wow, this is like a slap in the face. What on Earth are we doing trading a prospect for spare parts to fill out our triple A roster? For some reason this trade makes me incredibly mad like none other before.

Rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic.

 

I don't mean that to sound as pessimistic as it does, but really... Really...

This was a great minor move for the Marlins when you consider how difficult it is for teams to acquire young catchers from other teams and the fact we rid ourselves of an injury-prone prospect in Jason Stokes. I really like Baker's talent and potential to become a major league catcher either this season or next season for the Marlins who were in dire need of a young catcher. Another small, yet steally move by Beinfest.

Signing a minor league free agent like Quiroz, or picking up a guy like Closser, would have been similar moves in identifying a young catcher with some potential that would not have cost us a "Stokes." I don't mind acquiring Baker in a deal like this as I don't think it's a horrible idea, but other options were available to upgrade the organizational depth chart while maintaining what we had. And that is why this is not a "steally" move by Beinfest, even if I don't necessarily disagree with it. It's more of the overall philosophy of how he operates. He routinely misses opportunities to bring players into the organization that COULD help us where there is relatively no cost involved, and then at some point, he'll address that problem and have to trade away whatever to get it. Julio and Baker are two examples of this. It's probably not a huge deal cause all of the players involved are not going to turn into stars and probably not even starting caliber players, but we're just not the most efficient franchise in acquiring talent off waivers and minor trades. I think we could do just a solid job in this area, while keeping the Petits, Resops, and Stokes of our organization, in our organization.

 

Regardless, I just really hope Baker can hit .240 in the bigs, cause that means Treanor is goodbye.

I agree whole heartedly. only thing about this is I dont think Baker has to be on the 40-man so it's convenient in that sense. In the end, I tihnk this trade actually turns out OK with Baker providing depth at a position of extreme need (like we talked about earlier)....and, someone who is better than Treanor RIGHT now. As it stands we have one of the worst backup C in the league with garbage behind him (Hoover/Treszniak stink).

It's too bad we didn't move him years ago (or have put him in the Urbina trade instead of Adrian Gonzalez). His value has faded pretty low now, as he continues to age (just turned 25) and has at least Mike Jacobs and Gaby Sanchez ahead of him. It's not like he had a potential role on this team. Baker will.

 

At least Beinfest filled a need where we have zero depth, catching. I'm almost positive that Baker can outperform Treanor in the bigs. You can't get a much weaker bat than Matt has.

 

As for Closser, my guess is money? Otherwise that would have been a nice pickup.

 

I don't consider Stokes or Baker much of a prospect at this point, not when they are 25 and 27 years old respectively.

Stokes was never gonna make the big league club, so who cares? He coulda got traded for some donuts and a parking pass. This impacts nothing.

lol... terrible

 

 

 

Offseason report card grade goes to a G?

 

:lol

well this certainly didn't help

 

most likely this trade becomes a nothing trade, but why even make the trade to begin with?

 

I don't get it

catching depth

so why didn't we pluck JD Closser off waivers last week?

 

 

Because Baker was an actual prospect and Beinfest likes the guy. How come you aren't the GM since you always hate EVERY trade and always end up wrong?

 

 

free a spot on the 40?

 

 

Baker will be with the Marlins next year instead of Treanor. Baker can hit and has a good eye at the plate. Don't listen to many of these fans who never know anything about new players. Baker is a former PAC-10 all star C and was drafted in the 4th round, showing he has good potential. Baker has very good gap power as I've read- in 2004 he had 35 doubles and 15 HR, 24 doubles in 2005 and 19 doubles last year to go along with a steady .270 BA for a catcher. He is quick from what I've read as well and stretches some singles into doubles. Last season he went 10-20 in spring training with a double and a homer with the A's.

 

I hate it when people think change is bad. This is the classic case of Beinfest ripping off one of the best in the business, Beane. Beane doesn't know that Stokes is USED GOODS and Beinfest does.....

Jesus H Christ, you are a moron. Has Beinfest ever done anything wrong in your eyes? How in G-d's name is Baker a prospect? You want to talk about hitting. JD Closser killed him in the minors and wouldnt have cost us a f***ing thing. .283/.383/.461. That is Closser's career line in the minors and he is all of 27 years old. John Baker is as much a prospect as Jason Wood is. I love how you say "how come you aren't the GM". Thats a real mature comeback. How about you take your head out of Beinfest's ass and smell the coffee. He ain't perfect, man. Not everything he touches turns to gold. In fact, he's been finding out some sh*t recently. The only one who possibly got ripped off here was Beinfest. There is no possibly way Beane got ripped here. Sorry. You are wrong, as YOU ALWAYS ARE.

 

And why do you keep calling me out saying I'm always wrong? Where have I been wrong recently? Or in the past few seasons? Sure we all make mistakes but I happen to think I have a pretty good grasp of what is going on.

 

 

JD Closser is probably the worst defensive catcher in the history of baseball, yes worse than Piazza. Closser should be a 1st baseman. Quit acting like you know everything. Baker is sound defensively and offensively. There is a reason Closser is NOT picked up by anyone. Think for once.

he wasn't picked up because most teams have a competent backup already

 

and Closser is not that bad of a defensive catcher... sure he was about 4 years ago but he is much improved

 

oh well, this trade still blows

he wasn't picked up because most teams have a competent backup already

 

and Closser is not that bad of a defensive catcher... sure he was about 4 years ago but he is much improved

 

oh well, this trade still blows

 

Closser couldn't throw out a runner if the guy was on crutches. And on a good day last season he hoped maybe he'd be able to see the Mendoza line, which he failed to reach.

 

There's a reason twenty-eight other GMs passed on Closser and not a word was said about their competence. Only here, where whatever Beinfest does is wrong, and whatever he doesn't do is wrong too, would he be called to task for not picking up Closser and instead picking up the guy who was selected the 2006 PCL all-star catcher. But then again some people here think they know more about evaluating talent than the coaches and managers who, a continent away, watched games being played every night and in the end selected Baker as the best in the league.

 

We trade a chronically injured, bad luck, no longer a prospect underachiever who has so many guys ahead of him and coming up about to pass him he was never going to see ML playing time unless an airplane went down, for a good insurance catcher who happens to be five years younger than two-thirds of the catchers on the Isotopes' roster, and the comment is Beinfest got hosed in the deal. Or as Ramp says, "the deal blows".

 

Gimme a freakin' break. :banghead

 

Get a good education kid because your career sure isn't going to be in baseball if you really think that. In fact I don't think you really believe it, you're smarter than that.

lol... terrible

 

 

 

Offseason report card grade goes to a G?

 

:lol

well this certainly didn't help

 

most likely this trade becomes a nothing trade, but why even make the trade to begin with?

 

I don't get it

Because it serves the players well.

Sometimes it's good for a team to let something go to show the league, its players and future players that it won't hold onto talent that might have a better chance elsewhere.

 

See not offering Jones arbitration when it was learned that his hand shake deal with the Tigers was conditional on the Marlins' not doing so to get compensatory draft picks.

BTW Closser threw out 47% potential base stealers last year.

they must have all been in wheel chairs or something

 

edit: I knew it looked a bit high from when I checked up on him 2 weeks ago

BTW Closser threw out 47% potential base stealers last year.

 

probably because he was so bad that guys like Jason Stokes would try to steal on him.

he wasn't picked up because most teams have a competent backup already

 

and Closser is not that bad of a defensive catcher... sure he was about 4 years ago but he is much improved

 

oh well, this trade still blows

 

Closser couldn't throw out a runner if the guy was on crutches. And on a good day last season he hoped maybe he'd be able to see the Mendoza line, which he failed to reach.

 

There's a reason twenty-eight other GMs passed on Closser and not a word was said about their competence. Only here, where whatever Beinfest does is wrong, and whatever he doesn't do is wrong too, would he be called to task for not picking up Closser and instead picking up the guy who was selected the 2006 PCL all-star catcher. But then again some people here think they know more about evaluating talent than the coaches and managers who, a continent away, watched games being played every night and in the end selected Baker as the best in the league.

 

We trade a chronically injured, bad luck, no longer a prospect underachiever who has so many guys ahead of him and coming up about to pass him he was never going to see ML playing time unless an airplane went down, for a good insurance catcher who happens to be five years younger than two-thirds of the catchers on the Isotopes' roster, and the comment is Beinfest got hosed in the deal. Or as Ramp says, "the deal blows".

 

Gimme a freakin' break. :banghead

 

Get a good education kid because your career sure isn't going to be in baseball if you really think that. In fact I don't think you really believe it, you're smarter than that.

 

 

Well said.

 

BTW Closser threw out 47% potential base stealers last year.

 

 

You are such a liar! haha.....

 

 

2004- 32% (19 SB/ 9 CS)

 

2005- 17% (53 SB/ 11 CS)

 

2006- 32% (17 SB/ 8 CS)

 

 

Nice try though.....his career average is (89 SB/28 CS) 23.9%.......PEW!

BTW Closser threw out 47% potential base stealers last year.

 

Try getting your facts straight. I know it's getting more and more difficult around here for people to actually spend two minutes checking something out before they post, but it would be helpful.

 

Closser's CS% was 32% . His MLB career average is 24%.

 

http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/players/stat...ontext=fielding

 

Treanor's CS% numbers was 47.1%, perhaps you were looking at the wrong guy.

 

But as usual why let the facts get in the way of a good bashing...

Some people will do anything around here to act like they are right. They will do anything but give straight COLD facts.

So now you guys are going to start bashing Ralph, who is a very knowledgeable poster around here because he probably got Treanor's and Closser's numbers mixed up?

 

Come on, thats not right. He made a mistake, we all do it.

John Baker info.....from the Kane County website in 2003.....(he was on the same team as pitchers Joe Blanton (A's) and Bill Murphy (former Fish prospect).

 

 

The Cougars were the MWL's best team in 2003, even though their championship bid failed. Catcher John Baker, who was promoted in mid-season, was easily the team's most productive player.

 

Best Player on the Team: Catcher John Baker

Best Hitter: John Baker (.309, 6 HR, 49 RBI [82 games])

High Batting Average: John Baker (.309)

High On Base Percentage: John Baker (.414)

High Slugging Percentage: John Baker (.457)

If catcher John Baker can develop some power, he'll be a very valuable player; he does many things very very well. Catcher John Baker's a very fine hitter with an impressive range of skills.

 

 

Oakland A's Spring Q&A: John Baker, C

 

John Baker was a PCL All-Star in 2006. By Melissa Lockard

Senior Editor

Posted Mar 2, 2007

 

Coming off of an All-Star season for the Triple-A Sacramento River Cats, catcher John Baker is attending his third Oakland As major league camp with hopes of making a strong enough impression to get a crack at the big leagues sometime this season. We caught up with the talented back-stop after the first spring training game of the season.

 

John Baker hasnt made his major league debut yet, but he is a relative veteran in Phoenix this spring. The Cal alum has been a fixture at major league spring training camp with the Oakland As since 2005. Last season, Baker was one of the stars of camp, as he had 10 hits in 20 at-bats, including a homerun. He also drove-in 13 runs in 15 games.

Baker parlayed that spring performance into a solid rebound season for Triple-A Sacramento. After struggling in 2005 with the River Cats to the tune of a .234 batting average, Baker recovered to hit .273 for Sacramento in 2006. He was a Pacific Coast League All-Star, as well.

 

Baker has spent the last two and a quarter seasons in Sacramento, during which time he has become a fan favorite in the Capitol City. We spoke to the East Bay native after the As first spring training game on Thursday.

 

 

OaklandClubhouse: I was following the game on-line today and saw you had an at-bat. It must be nice to not be just practicing any more right?

 

John Baker: Yeah, it was about time to see some other faces on the field. Weve been here for a couple of weeks and the days were nice and short. Bob [Geren] did a great job keeping the camps short early so people could go out and play golf and do whatever they had to do and we were playing games, but yeah, its always nice to get out there and play. Thats what we love to do. You do all of the practicing and training so that you can go out there and play games so it was good to get out there and see a different team.

 

OC: How would you compare the pace and the mood around this camp compared to the last two with pretty much an entirely new coaching staff, save Curt Young and Rene Lachemann?

 

JB: Its a little bit different. I think that the people who benefit most from having Bob as the manager are the catchers because being a major league catcher himself, he really tries to make everything easy for us. A lot of times early in spring training, the catchers really have a large work load, doing bullpens and early work, but he is really good about letting us know here is what you are going to do, you are going to do this, you are going to do that. There is no questions about are we doing this, or are we doing that or whats going on. He lets you know ahead of time that this person is probably going to play. We didnt have that in the past, and it is nice to know when you are going to the game. Like today, with Kurt [suzuki], he knew that he was likely going to catch so he could get ready, and we were told, look, you guys are probably going to get an at-bat, so its nice to know that.

 

All in all, I wouldnt say it is too big of a change. Its a little different without Ron Washington, but I think everybody really wishes him well with Texas unless Oakland is playing Texas. But Schaef [bob Schaeffer, the As new bench coach] is a good guy and he is very knowledgeable, and Ty Waller, we really have a lot of experience coming into the organization, so that is positive for everybody. I think Bob is going to do a great job as the manager and, obviously, we have Rene Lachemann, who is kind of the clown of spring training. He keeps it fresh, he keeps it fun. Hes got such a positive attitude and he is great to have around.

 

OC: I read that Mike Piazza had been sitting in on a lot of your catching meetings, even though he wasnt taking bullpens and that sort of thing. Have you had a chance to pick his brain about his experiences behind the plate all those years?

 

JB: Yeah, he is in my defense group. Its me, him, [Adam] Melhuse and Suzuki and he has also been down with us for all of the catching stuff that weve done, whether it be throwing, footwork or blocking, he makes it a point to go down there. Hes with us, he plays catch with us and he talks about things that work for him. The two guys I have had a chance to play with now, Frank Thomas and Mike Piazza both Hall of Fame guys its just amazing how open they are and how much they want to help out younger players.

 

Its really cool for me to hear him tell stories about when he came up in the eighties and stuff that happened to him and weve been able to ask him all sorts of questions like tell us what happened when Clemens threw the bat and all of those things that Ive seen growing up, watching him on TV. Its just amazing to hear him talk about it first-hand. Hes really interactive with everybody. He doesnt really seem to have any ego when it comes to who he is going to talk to and hell just talk to whomever is around him. Hes just a really nice guy.

 

Its great having him and we have such a wealth of catching experience for us to learn from. Between him and Jason [Kendall] and Adam, as well, youve got three established major league players, one in the Hall of Fame and one maybe on the way, and to be able to learn from those guys is such a positive experience.

 

OC: How do you feel like you have progressed, now that this is your third major league camp? Do you feel like there has been a learning curve for you over the last two-and-a-half years?

 

JB: Yeah, definitely. I think that every year that comes I improve a little bit and I think that is what every player tries to do. I have also realized, too, that the first year [in major league camp] is really about getting over the shock of the whole thing, that you are sitting in the lockerroom and there is Eric Chavez and theres Barry Zito, when he was with us, and there is Mike Piazza.

 

I got over the shock of that the first year, and then last year having some success and getting to play a lot, then you start to feel like maybe you belong here. Now coming back here a third time, I know everyone really well and it is a really comfortable atmosphere. The guys that we have in the major leagues really try to accommodate younger players and try to bring them in and really make them feel like part of the team. Its really great for guys who are new to the organization, like Ryan Goleski and Donnie Murphy. You hear them talk about our major league players and how relaxed everyone is and they are shocked.

 

You know Goleski came from Cleveland where there are rules and everything is very strict and in Oakland everything is just so much more laid back and contusive to relaxing. You realize that you can become a better player when you can calm down and relax. I think I have taken that personally, too. Being out there now, I dont have the same amount of butterflies that I used to because it is more of a routine now and I think that is a positive thing.

 

OC: You had a much better year offensively for Triple-A Sacramento last season as opposed to the year before. Was there anything that you worked on in the off-season to make those improvements?

 

JB: Last year, during the off-season and in spring training and during the season, I really give a lot of credit to Brian McArn, our hitting coach. When I was struggling a couple of years ago it was the first time in my life that I had really struggled, and you try to change things. Im going to stand up taller or get down lower or Im going to try put my hands there. He really did a good job last year keeping me using one swing, one stance, one set-up the entire season. I think that is a big part of it. A lot of people can be quick to try to adjust and they say that baseball is a game of adjustments. Well, you can kind of over-adjust yourself. I think that is what happened the year before. I learned last year to be patient and to try to stick with the same approach and the same swing and the same routine day-in and day-out and that is going to help me have success over long periods of time.

 

OC: I know you have had a chance to share time with Jeremy Brown over the course of both of your careers. Was it comfortable to have him on the same team last year since you have played so much together, or do you guys feel like it is going to be hard to distinguish between the two of you because you have traveled up the system at relatively the same pace?

 

JB: Jeremy and I are really close friends. Id say that he is if not the best, he is one of my best friends in baseball. We always talk about how we want to be together. The whole time we were coming up, especially when we were in the low levels of the minor leagues, we would both get a lot of questions like you guys are competing against each other and what do you feel about each other. I told [Oakland As announcer] Robert Buan last year that when Jeremy got called up [to Oakland] that we have the kind of relationship where, yeah, everyone wants to get to the big leagues, and I wanted to get called up last year, but if there was one guy that I could say, if not me, him, it would definitely be Jeremy.

 

We have such a good relationship. We help each other out offensively, we are always hitting together early, and we always do our defensive stuff together and it great for me and him to be together, I think. And then you get a little bit of that competition with each other of who did this yesterday and who did this today, but it is all positive and it is all fun. Weve never had any negative thoughts towards each other. We spent a lot of time together.

 

Yesterday, for example, after the day, we went and got haircuts and went to the mall. We hang out a lot, eat dinner a lot together, so it was comfortable for me to have him back on the team with me last year, somebody who has seen me have success and who is a positive influence around me.

 

OC: Have you been taking any groundballs at first base? I know that earlier in your career, you saw a little time over there.

 

JB: No, but Ill always have that [ability to play at first]. I played first base in high school and then I played about 30 games at Double-A Midland at first. I remember the first game of the season in 2004, I got to the field and looked at the line-up and I was playing first base. I didnt even have a first basemans glove [laughs]. I hadnt taken a groundball in awhile either.

 

I havent taken too many groundballs [recently]. Although right now we are doing bullpen work during batting practice so there hasnt really been time to take groundballs. Last year, I went out early with Wash and did some first base stuff. I think that once we get into the routine of games, Ill get out there and take some groundballs.

 

OC: Has there been anyone who has stood out so far in the bullpen sessions, like maybe some of the young guys?

 

JB: Mike Mitchell, hes got some phenomenal stuff. If he can harness it and throw strikes, hes a guy who I think has a chance to be in the big leagues by the end of the year. Hes got a power arm and a lot of sink and a good attitude. I really see him being a major leaguer. Another guy who has really impressed me, and hes been around for about 15 years, is Alan Embree. Just another guy who is willing to share with other players and is just a good guy all the way around. Also, just watching him throw I got to catch him in a pitchers batting practice session where he threw and just watching him throw, it was just incredible. How relaxed and easy he is and how hard he throws, its surprising the first time you see it.

 

OC: With him and Lou Merloni and Lenny DiNardo in camp, is it like a little Red Sox cabal in camp?

 

JB:[laughing] A little bit. Alan Embree was showing us his Red Sox World Series ring around the other day in spring training. Its pretty fun to have Lou Merloni around. Hes another guy who has been around the block and he knows what he is doing. A funny story about Lou is that when I was in the Cape Cod League in college I made the All-Star team and we went down to Fenway Park. They had players who had played in the Cape League handing us plaques and we shook their hands. The guy who gave me mine was Lou Merloni. Seven years later, getting to talk to him, he and I had a laugh about that story. Hes another great guy to have around. We do have a little bit of that Red Sox lore floating around.

 

OC: Has it been different for the pitchers without Barry Zito there to kind of set the tone?

 

JB: I havent really noticed a big difference. The staff that we have is so strong and to lose someone like Barry, a former Cy Young winner who is a superstar basically, I think for a lot of teams would be devastating, but with this team, just with the young talent that Oakland has Dan Haren, Joe Blanton those guys are still young, and to have them Rich Harden, as well I think theyll miss Zito a little bit with some of the stuff that he brought to the clubhouse, but I think those guys are all very capable of filling those shoes.

 

OC: What is your mindset coming into this season? Youve been in Triple-A for the last couple of years now. Are you starting to get antsy at this point, or are you still on the path that you were hoping to be?

 

JB: I try to think short-term in baseball. The more I start thinking about where I am going to be and what is going to happen, those thoughts can kind of bring you down a little bit. You really have to think day-to-day because if you start looking at the big picture too much, it can be overwhelming. One of the main things that I try to remember is that when you are out there, you are playing for every other major league team.

 

I just want to go out and have a good showing in spring training and if I go to Sacramento, I go to Sacramento. And if something happens and I have to go to another organization, then that is the path that is supposed to be. When I start to worry about I should be here, and this person should be there it is an overwhelming feeling and that stuff is out of my control. What is out of my control, I really, really try not to even think about it.

 

OC: I know you have been very popular in Sacramento on the sports radio programs and that sort of thing. How has it been to play in Sacramento the last few years?

 

JB: I tell you what, for me, if not Oakland, then Sacramento is [a good situation]. My grandfather lives in Sacramento and my family is 70 miles away and my wife, Megan, can drive up on the weekends she teaches first grade and stay up for the whole time when we are there. It is a very comfortable feeling. Having been there for a couple of years, the way that organization is run is just incredible. It is so fan friendly, but it is also player friendly at the same time. It has been just an incredibly positive experience being in Sacramento and there is a real comfort level there.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Some people will do anything around here to act like they are right. They will do anything but give straight COLD facts.

So now you guys are going to start bashing Ralph, who is a very knowledgeable poster around here because he probably got Treanor's and Closser's numbers mixed up?

 

Come on, thats not right. He made a mistake, we all do it.

 

 

You do it the most around here....just throw around facts like you know everything. Read about Baker below and you will learn that he is a good player- better than Stokes and his 50% strikeout rate will be.

And for the record, what is wrong with not liking this deal? Since when do we have to "trust" Beinfest on every single move he makes. Now before some of you say, "you never like any deal and you are always wrong blah blah blah", that is not true at all. I loved the Hanley deal. I loved the Owens deal. I loved the Urbina deal. I'm sure there were many others but I hate the fact that if you disagree with the deal you are A)just trying to be difficult B)not as smart as Beinfest anyway so your opinion doesn't matter or C)OMG liek in BeINfest we trust, why are you the GM?.

 

That's what a message board is for. I'm allowed to hate a deal. I'm allowed to think it "blows". The beauty of the board is that many of the real solid baseball minds, who agree on alot of things can actually disagree so heavily on a trade (i.e. Lou and Sham liking the Julio deal).

 

So I don't think Beinfest is perfect, or even close to it. And yea, I have absolutely hated a few of his deals, while loved other ones. It's going to happen. It's a message board. Just because I didn't like the Stokes deal, doesn't mean I need a better education, 03. You can do better than calling me out like that.

 

You do it the most around here....just throw around facts like you know everything. Read about Baker below and you will learn that he is a good player- better than Stokes and his 50% strikeout rate will be.

Sorry, I will never ever ever be on the Baker bandwagon. I will eat all the crow in the world if he ever does anything worthwhile in the major leagues.

 

For the record, I believe I am more well read on baseball than most here. There are a few fantastic posters that I still learn from. If that sounds like I am being conceited or cocky or being a straight up douche bag, I don't care. There are reasons why people outside of this forum think highly of me, and it's not just because of my smashing good looks. This is the way I am. Love it or ignore it.

John Baker info.....from the Kane County website in 2003.....(he was on the same team as pitchers Joe Blanton (A's) and Bill Murphy (former Fish prospect).

2003 scouting reports are absolutely irrelevant. :banghead

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.