March 31, 200719 yr And for the record, what is wrong with not liking this deal? Since when do we have to "trust" Beinfest on every single move he makes. Now before some of you say, "you never like any deal and you are always wrong blah blah blah", that is not true at all. I loved the Hanley deal. I loved the Owens deal. I loved the Urbina deal. I'm sure there were many others but I hate the fact that if you disagree with the deal you are A)just trying to be difficult B)not as smart as Beinfest anyway so your opinion doesn't matter or C)OMG liek in BeINfest we trust, why are you the GM?. That's what a message board is for. I'm allowed to hate a deal. I'm allowed to think it "blows". The beauty of the board is that many of the real solid baseball minds, who agree on alot of things can actually disagree so heavily on a trade (i.e. Lou and Sham liking the Julio deal). So I don't think Beinfest is perfect, or even close to it. And yea, I have absolutely hated a few of his deals, while loved other ones. It's going to happen. It's a message board. Just because I didn't like the Stokes deal, doesn't mean I need a better education, 03. You can do better than calling me out like that. I never said you don't have to agree with a deal. But saying Baker is not as good as JD Closser is purely ignorant and that is what you said. You always call me names but I use facts. For your info.... 1) Borchard is a career .209 hitter and a horrible defender. 2) Stokes is always injured and K's 43% vs. MLB pitching. 3) Closser is not as good offensively or defensively as Baker. Many people will agree that you always think you are right.....and you do that by calling people names. You have a lot of posts....big deal! John Baker info.....from the Kane County website in 2003.....(he was on the same team as pitchers Joe Blanton (A's) and Bill Murphy (former Fish prospect). 2003 scouting reports are absolutely irrelevant. :banghead Fine, read the 2007 article and Q and A with John Baker....when he was an all star last year and picked Frank Thomas and Mike Piazza's brain. He learned a lot from Jason Kendall. Some people are just stubborn. The point is that Baker has succeeded everywhere he has been and Jason Stokes has not.
March 31, 200719 yr For your info.... 1) Borchard is a career .209 hitter and a horrible defender. 2) Stokes is always injured and K's 43% vs. MLB pitching. 3) Closser is not as good offensively or defensively as Baker. 1) Ok? No one can deny that Borchard is a .209 career hitter. Calling him a horrible defender is laughable. He is more than adequate at the corners and can play some CF, albeit not everyday. 2) Stokes is always injured. Correct. Again who is arguing that? He also k's alot too. Again I have never disputed that. 3) Closser is better offensively. Baker is better defensively. Stokes has "succeeded" at every level too. He has just been hurt alot.
March 31, 200719 yr After some re-thinking, I can accept this trade as long as it means an upgrade in our backup catcher. Stokes wasn't ever likely to help our ML team because we have Gaby coming through the ranks and Sanchez already there. But still, upside is upside and I think that Stokes has Baker on this one.
March 31, 200719 yr For your info.... 1) Borchard is a career .209 hitter and a horrible defender. 2) Stokes is always injured and K's 43% vs. MLB pitching. 3) Closser is not as good offensively or defensively as Baker. Many people will agree that you always think you are right.....and you do that by calling people names. You have a lot of posts....big deal! 1. Borchard hit .258/.353/.449 (.803) vs RHP last year. No one thinks Borchard is the answer, but when he bats lefty, he can hit a little bit. Seemingly that the Marlins will play 120+ games vs RHP this year, this is a much better idea then De Aza, A. Sanchez, E. Reed, etc, just because he will out OBP and mash them with ease. His offensive gains over those guys drastically outweigh the defensive short comings. You can always remove him for defense in the later innings as well when you're up. 2. Jason Stokes has never played in the major leagues, but if you have a statistical resource that will pull out every AB he has ever faced by a pitcher who has reached the big leagues, by all means share this wealth of knowledge. Stokes strikes out a lot, like 31% of his plate appearances in AAA last year, but this is a poor use of statistics from whatever split you are attempting to look at even if you're "right." 3. Closser hit .298/.384/.480 in AAA last year. Baker hit .273/.361/.386. if you want to look at 2005, Closser had a higher OPS playing in the bigs the Baker did in AAA. Feel free to hate on the defense, but offensively there is no way in hell. He hits for more average, power, walks more, and strikes out less. John Baker info.....from the Kane County website in 2003.....(he was on the same team as pitchers Joe Blanton (A's) and Bill Murphy (former Fish prospect). 2003 scouting reports are absolutely irrelevant. :banghead Fine, read the 2007 article and Q and A with John Baker....when he was an all star last year and picked Frank Thomas and Mike Piazza's brain. He learned a lot from Jason Kendall. Some people are just stubborn. The point is that Baker has succeeded everywhere he has been and Jason Stokes has not. So I'm supposed to like John Baker because he's talked to Thomas, Piazza, and Kendall?
March 31, 200719 yr Some more about John Baker.....real facts without hating on people..... 1) Graduated from FAMOUS De La Salle HS (Concord, CA) 2) Attended University of California where he hit .383 his senior season and was a PAC 10 ALL STAR C. 3) Selected in the fourth round by the A's in the June 2002 draft. 4) 2003 Kane County A....named best hitter on team at .309 5) 2004 Midland AA....Had an excellent season in Midland (AA), hitting .280 with 15 homeruns and 32 doubles. 6) 2004- Joined Sacramento (AAA) in the final month and helped the RiverCats win the PCL Championship. * Hit .347 with 10 RBI in 14 games for the RiverCats. 7) 2004- Arizona Fall League, he hit .318 playing with major leaguers. 8) Plays a little first base in addition to catching. 9) 2006- ALL STAR C in AAA Sacramento (Pacific Coast League All-Star). 10) 2006 Spring Training VOTED STAR OF CAMP BY SPORTS ILLUSTRATED- made waves by hitting 10-20 with a double and a homer for the A's 11) Was voted AAA Sacramento FAN FAVORITE! Sports Illustrated quote....Fourth round -- John Baker, C, California: "Unlike Jeremy Brown, Baker is posting a good OBP and shows good slugging ability and doubles power. He could have interesting power potential." Sorry Ramp, but I just don't see how this is a bad trade. Stokes will never amount to anything. Gabe Sanchez is better than Stokes. Baker is better than Treanor. I don't care what anyone says. I trust Beinfest 100% and you're right, in my eyes HE CAN DO ZERO WRONG! Willis off the scrap heaps? Hanley? Anibal? Owens and Lindstrom? Benitez? Todd Jones? Need I say more.....he is one of the best I've ever seen.....PERIOD. I trust Beinfest.
March 31, 200719 yr With all due respect to Gaby Sanchez, he has never done anything outside of low-A ball. Seriously though, you are a homer. At best, BEST, Baker becomes our backup catcher next year (possibly starter but with 2008 supposed to be our year, that won't happen... I hope) and Jason Stokes never does anything of note. That's the absolute best case scenario here. On a random note, has Beinfest ever made a bad trade in your eyes? how about Choi, Holandsworth, Bowyer, Leiter, Oliver?... anyway, if you seriously don't believe that Beinfest can do any wrong, we can no longer have an intelligent conversation regarding player personnel. And did you seriously say "Willis off the scrap heaps"? Just because you had never heard of him, doesn't mean he wasn't known around baseball.
March 31, 200719 yr If you read my entire closing comment Ramp I said I knew you were smarter than the language and comments you were throwing around in this thread about this (let's face it, it's a minor) trade. And you know I do. I've always encouraged you to do better. And that was my point. You're more articulate than this and I don't know why, but lately it isn't just this trade, it seems to be every trade or every potential missed opportunity seems to bring out in you a negativity and scorn for Beinfest we haven't seen here before. Disagreeing is one thing, calling people stupid or a moron just incites conflict, saying "the trade still blows...", "terrible", suggesting Beinfest was "ripped off", you can't deny you're fanning the flames, so don't. And the Closser this is just ridiculous. After all, to repeat myself, trading Jason Stokes at this point in his career was probably the best thing for him. I think RFerry may have been close to the truth when he suggested for both players, they may have a window (albeit small) to the bigs that they didn't have before. As for Stokes "succeeding" at every level maybe I'm missing something but looking at his career minor league numbers, there really isn't much there to blow your horn about. He could of been, should have been, might have been, but he hasn't. That's the bottom line. Jason Stokes career courtesy of thebaseballcube.com ~~~> http://www.thebaseballcube.com/players/S/Jason-Stokes.shtml
March 31, 200719 yr With all due respect to Gaby Sanchez, he has never done anything outside of low-A ball. Seriously though, you are a homer. At best, BEST, Baker becomes our backup catcher next year (possibly starter but with 2008 supposed to be our year, that won't happen... I hope) and Jason Stokes never does anything of note. That's the absolute best case scenario here. On a random note, has Beinfest ever made a bad trade in your eyes? how about Choi, Holandsworth, Bowyer, Leiter, Oliver?... anyway, if you seriously don't believe that Beinfest can do any wrong, we can no longer have an intelligent conversation regarding player personnel. And did you seriously say "Willis off the scrap heaps"? Just because you had never heard of him, doesn't mean he wasn't known around baseball. A player to be named later turning into a Cy Young, All Star #1 pitcher is considered scrap heaps.....your baseball knowledge is suspect at best. RAMP in the minor league forum...... "absolutely terrible trade for Florida at best, Baker becomes a backup catcher... what is the point of giving up on Jason Stokes for this non prospect? boggles the mind sometimes" Based on what? Stokes sucks and Baker is more of a prospect than him at this point! haha
March 31, 200719 yr With all due respect to Gaby Sanchez, he has never done anything outside of low-A ball. Seriously though, you are a homer. At best, BEST, Baker becomes our backup catcher next year (possibly starter but with 2008 supposed to be our year, that won't happen... I hope) and Jason Stokes never does anything of note. That's the absolute best case scenario here. On a random note, has Beinfest ever made a bad trade in your eyes? how about Choi, Holandsworth, Bowyer, Leiter, Oliver?... anyway, if you seriously don't believe that Beinfest can do any wrong, we can no longer have an intelligent conversation regarding player personnel. And did you seriously say "Willis off the scrap heaps"? Just because you had never heard of him, doesn't mean he wasn't known around baseball. A player to be named later turning into a Cy Young, All Star #1 pitcher is considered scrap heaps.....your baseball knowledge is suspect at best. RAMP in the minor league forum...... "absolutely terrible trade for Florida at best, Baker becomes a backup catcher... what is the point of giving up on Jason Stokes for this non prospect? boggles the mind sometimes" Based on what? Stokes sucks and Baker is more of a prospect than him at this point! haha Was Willis a PTBNL? I don't think he was, I could be wrong there though. And just because someone is a PTBNL doesn't mean they are on the scrap heap, that is ridiculous. And if Baker is more of a prospect, why isn't he on the top 30 A's prospects and Stokes is with the Marlins? Is it because Stokes actually has some upside to him? You're right, my baseball knowledge is suspect at best. You're adorable.
March 31, 200719 yr With all due respect to Gaby Sanchez, he has never done anything outside of low-A ball. Seriously though, you are a homer. At best, BEST, Baker becomes our backup catcher next year (possibly starter but with 2008 supposed to be our year, that won't happen... I hope) and Jason Stokes never does anything of note. That's the absolute best case scenario here. On a random note, has Beinfest ever made a bad trade in your eyes? how about Choi, Holandsworth, Bowyer, Leiter, Oliver?... anyway, if you seriously don't believe that Beinfest can do any wrong, we can no longer have an intelligent conversation regarding player personnel. And did you seriously say "Willis off the scrap heaps"? Just because you had never heard of him, doesn't mean he wasn't known around baseball. A player to be named later turning into a Cy Young, All Star #1 pitcher is considered scrap heaps.....your baseball knowledge is suspect at best. RAMP in the minor league forum...... "absolutely terrible trade for Florida at best, Baker becomes a backup catcher... what is the point of giving up on Jason Stokes for this non prospect? boggles the mind sometimes" Based on what? Stokes sucks and Baker is more of a prospect than him at this point! haha Was Willis a PTBNL? I don't think he was, I could be wrong there though. And just because someone is a PTBNL doesn't mean they are on the scrap heap, that is ridiculous. And if Baker is more of a prospect, why isn't he on the top 30 A's prospects and Stokes is with the Marlins? Is it because Stokes actually has some upside to him? You're right, my baseball knowledge is suspect at best. You're adorable. You don't understand. You never will understand. It's like talking to the wall. Stokes was good in high school and single A. Stokes value CONTINUES to decline. Stokes can not hit major league pitching. Stokes is injured EVERY year. Stokes is damaged goods. Baker continues to get BETTER. Baker is healthy every year. What do you not understand kid?
March 31, 200719 yr With all due respect to Gaby Sanchez, he has never done anything outside of low-A ball. Seriously though, you are a homer. At best, BEST, Baker becomes our backup catcher next year (possibly starter but with 2008 supposed to be our year, that won't happen... I hope) and Jason Stokes never does anything of note. That's the absolute best case scenario here. On a random note, has Beinfest ever made a bad trade in your eyes? how about Choi, Holandsworth, Bowyer, Leiter, Oliver?... anyway, if you seriously don't believe that Beinfest can do any wrong, we can no longer have an intelligent conversation regarding player personnel. And did you seriously say "Willis off the scrap heaps"? Just because you had never heard of him, doesn't mean he wasn't known around baseball. A player to be named later turning into a Cy Young, All Star #1 pitcher is considered scrap heaps.....your baseball knowledge is suspect at best. RAMP in the minor league forum...... "absolutely terrible trade for Florida at best, Baker becomes a backup catcher... what is the point of giving up on Jason Stokes for this non prospect? boggles the mind sometimes" Based on what? Stokes sucks and Baker is more of a prospect than him at this point! haha Was Willis a PTBNL? I don't think he was, I could be wrong there though. And just because someone is a PTBNL doesn't mean they are on the scrap heap, that is ridiculous. And if Baker is more of a prospect, why isn't he on the top 30 A's prospects and Stokes is with the Marlins? Is it because Stokes actually has some upside to him? You're right, my baseball knowledge is suspect at best. You're adorable. You don't understand. You never will understand. It's like talking to the wall. Stokes was good in high school and single A. Stokes value CONTINUES to decline. Stokes can not hit major league pitching. Stokes is injured EVERY year. Stokes is damaged goods. Baker continues to get BETTER. Baker is healthy every year. What do you not understand kid? Baker does not continue to get better, check some stats. He is heading into his fourth season of AAA ball. yay! and an injured Jason Stokes had a higher OPS than him in AAA last year. That's cool! And don't call me kid, kid. BEINFEST4LIFE!
March 31, 200719 yr With all due respect to Gaby Sanchez, he has never done anything outside of low-A ball. Seriously though, you are a homer. At best, BEST, Baker becomes our backup catcher next year (possibly starter but with 2008 supposed to be our year, that won't happen... I hope) and Jason Stokes never does anything of note. That's the absolute best case scenario here. On a random note, has Beinfest ever made a bad trade in your eyes? how about Choi, Holandsworth, Bowyer, Leiter, Oliver?... anyway, if you seriously don't believe that Beinfest can do any wrong, we can no longer have an intelligent conversation regarding player personnel. And did you seriously say "Willis off the scrap heaps"? Just because you had never heard of him, doesn't mean he wasn't known around baseball. A player to be named later turning into a Cy Young, All Star #1 pitcher is considered scrap heaps.....your baseball knowledge is suspect at best. RAMP in the minor league forum...... "absolutely terrible trade for Florida at best, Baker becomes a backup catcher... what is the point of giving up on Jason Stokes for this non prospect? boggles the mind sometimes" Based on what? Stokes sucks and Baker is more of a prospect than him at this point! haha Was Willis a PTBNL? I don't think he was, I could be wrong there though. And just because someone is a PTBNL doesn't mean they are on the scrap heap, that is ridiculous. And if Baker is more of a prospect, why isn't he on the top 30 A's prospects and Stokes is with the Marlins? Is it because Stokes actually has some upside to him? You're right, my baseball knowledge is suspect at best. You're adorable. You don't understand. You never will understand. It's like talking to the wall. Stokes was good in high school and single A. Stokes value CONTINUES to decline. Stokes can not hit major league pitching. Stokes is injured EVERY year. Stokes is damaged goods. Baker continues to get BETTER. Baker is healthy every year. What do you not understand kid? Baker does not continue to get better, check some stats. He is heading into his fourth season of AAA ball. yay! and an injured Jason Stokes had a higher OPS than him in AAA last year. That's cool! And don't call me kid, kid. BEINFEST4LIFE! I hope he has a higher OPS hahaha HE IS A FIRST BASEMAN AND BAKER IS A CATCHER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I'm done talking to someone who knows as little about baseball as you. Stokes is injured goods and continues to digress and Baker is getting better. Try reading about him instead of your uneducated guesses about players you don't know about. Please find me one current POSITIVE artcle about Jason Stokes in 2007 because I have found 4 about John Baker. Jason Stokes had what 13 ABs this spring and 10 K's? He's awful man. Please watch a little baseball and get back to me. Baker is a fan favorite and great in the clubhouse. Baker is a 3 time all star. What is Stokes an all star of the 60 day DL team? Get a clue....
March 31, 200719 yr BTW Closser threw out 47% potential base stealers last year. Try getting your facts straight. I know it's getting more and more difficult around here for people to actually spend two minutes checking something out before they post, but it would be helpful. Closser's CS% was 32% . His MLB career average is 24%. http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/players/stat...ontext=fielding Treanor's CS% numbers was 47.1%, perhaps you were looking at the wrong guy. But as usual why let the facts get in the way of a good bashing... Your right for some reason I got confused and was looking at Treanors stats... oops :banghead
March 31, 200719 yr With all due respect to Gaby Sanchez, he has never done anything outside of low-A ball. Seriously though, you are a homer. At best, BEST, Baker becomes our backup catcher next year (possibly starter but with 2008 supposed to be our year, that won't happen... I hope) and Jason Stokes never does anything of note. That's the absolute best case scenario here. On a random note, has Beinfest ever made a bad trade in your eyes? how about Choi, Holandsworth, Bowyer, Leiter, Oliver?... anyway, if you seriously don't believe that Beinfest can do any wrong, we can no longer have an intelligent conversation regarding player personnel. And did you seriously say "Willis off the scrap heaps"? Just because you had never heard of him, doesn't mean he wasn't known around baseball. A player to be named later turning into a Cy Young, All Star #1 pitcher is considered scrap heaps.....your baseball knowledge is suspect at best. RAMP in the minor league forum...... "absolutely terrible trade for Florida at best, Baker becomes a backup catcher... what is the point of giving up on Jason Stokes for this non prospect? boggles the mind sometimes" Based on what? Stokes sucks and Baker is more of a prospect than him at this point! haha When healthy, Stokes is ten times the prospect Baker is.
March 31, 200719 yr Does everyone here forget that Stokes was a star of spring training last year and very nearly made the team?
March 31, 200719 yr With all due respect to Gaby Sanchez, he has never done anything outside of low-A ball. Seriously though, you are a homer. At best, BEST, Baker becomes our backup catcher next year (possibly starter but with 2008 supposed to be our year, that won't happen... I hope) and Jason Stokes never does anything of note. That's the absolute best case scenario here. On a random note, has Beinfest ever made a bad trade in your eyes? how about Choi, Holandsworth, Bowyer, Leiter, Oliver?... anyway, if you seriously don't believe that Beinfest can do any wrong, we can no longer have an intelligent conversation regarding player personnel. And did you seriously say "Willis off the scrap heaps"? Just because you had never heard of him, doesn't mean he wasn't known around baseball. A player to be named later turning into a Cy Young, All Star #1 pitcher is considered scrap heaps.....your baseball knowledge is suspect at best. RAMP in the minor league forum...... "absolutely terrible trade for Florida at best, Baker becomes a backup catcher... what is the point of giving up on Jason Stokes for this non prospect? boggles the mind sometimes" Based on what? Stokes sucks and Baker is more of a prospect than him at this point! haha When healthy, Stokes is ten times the prospect Baker is. No he isn't. Stokes CAN NOT HIT MLB PITCHING!!!!!!!!!!!!!! What do you not understand? He is an injured version of Russell Branyan. Baker has heart, his teammates like him, fans loved him in Sacramento, and he has steadily gotten better over time. He had only 1 bad year and then last year replaced it with an all star level season. I'm not saying Baker is the savior but we have an all star level AAA catcher now and that is better than having a 60-day DL'ed 1st baseman who can't hit major leaguers. Does everyone here forget that Stokes was a star of spring training last year and very nearly made the team? So was Baker......in 2006. But then let's see....Stokes went down to AAA, K'd 1/4th of his ABs and landed on the DL again! However, Baker had an all star year. I don't even know why I try to sell some of you guys on this trade....
March 31, 200719 yr With all due respect to Gaby Sanchez, he has never done anything outside of low-A ball. Seriously though, you are a homer. At best, BEST, Baker becomes our backup catcher next year (possibly starter but with 2008 supposed to be our year, that won't happen... I hope) and Jason Stokes never does anything of note. That's the absolute best case scenario here. On a random note, has Beinfest ever made a bad trade in your eyes? how about Choi, Holandsworth, Bowyer, Leiter, Oliver?... anyway, if you seriously don't believe that Beinfest can do any wrong, we can no longer have an intelligent conversation regarding player personnel. And did you seriously say "Willis off the scrap heaps"? Just because you had never heard of him, doesn't mean he wasn't known around baseball. A player to be named later turning into a Cy Young, All Star #1 pitcher is considered scrap heaps.....your baseball knowledge is suspect at best. RAMP in the minor league forum...... "absolutely terrible trade for Florida at best, Baker becomes a backup catcher... what is the point of giving up on Jason Stokes for this non prospect? boggles the mind sometimes" Based on what? Stokes sucks and Baker is more of a prospect than him at this point! haha When healthy, Stokes is ten times the prospect Baker is. No he isn't. Stokes CAN NOT HIT MLB PITCHING!!!!!!!!!!!!!! What do you not understand? He is an injured version of Russell Branyan. Baker has heart, his teammates like him, fans loved him in Sacramento, and he has steadily gotten better over time. He had only 1 bad year and then last year replaced it with an all star level season. I'm not saying Baker is the savior but we have an all star level AAA catcher now and that is better than having a 60-day DL'ed 1st baseman who can't hit major leaguers. Does everyone here forget that Stokes was a star of spring training last year and very nearly made the team? So was Baker......in 2006. But then let's see....Stokes went down to AAA, K'd 1/4th of his ABs and landed on the DL again! I don't even know why I try to sell some of you guys on this trade.... Stokes has played 9 games, I repeat 9 GAMES at the Major League level. How in God's name can you make the judgment that he can't hit MLB pitching after 11 MLB at-bats? Even if he played a thousand games, your argument has no base because Baker hasn't proved he can hit MLB pitching yet. You're arguing that because he has a good attitude and he's respected by his teammates that he's a better MLB hitter than Stokes. If you want to get down to literal facts, Stokes is the better MLB hitter because he actually has recorded MLB at-bats and a MLB average. Wanna take a look at minor league stats? Stokes's career MILB line: .279/.351/.509/860 Baker's career MILB line: .270/.358/.404/762 The stats prove it. Stokes is a better career hitter than Baker is at both levels. I rest my case.
March 31, 200719 yr With all due respect to Gaby Sanchez, he has never done anything outside of low-A ball. Seriously though, you are a homer. At best, BEST, Baker becomes our backup catcher next year (possibly starter but with 2008 supposed to be our year, that won't happen... I hope) and Jason Stokes never does anything of note. That's the absolute best case scenario here. On a random note, has Beinfest ever made a bad trade in your eyes? how about Choi, Holandsworth, Bowyer, Leiter, Oliver?... anyway, if you seriously don't believe that Beinfest can do any wrong, we can no longer have an intelligent conversation regarding player personnel. And did you seriously say "Willis off the scrap heaps"? Just because you had never heard of him, doesn't mean he wasn't known around baseball. A player to be named later turning into a Cy Young, All Star #1 pitcher is considered scrap heaps.....your baseball knowledge is suspect at best. RAMP in the minor league forum...... "absolutely terrible trade for Florida at best, Baker becomes a backup catcher... what is the point of giving up on Jason Stokes for this non prospect? boggles the mind sometimes" Based on what? Stokes sucks and Baker is more of a prospect than him at this point! haha When healthy, Stokes is ten times the prospect Baker is. No he isn't. Stokes CAN NOT HIT MLB PITCHING!!!!!!!!!!!!!! What do you not understand? He is an injured version of Russell Branyan. Baker has heart, his teammates like him, fans loved him in Sacramento, and he has steadily gotten better over time. He had only 1 bad year and then last year replaced it with an all star level season. I'm not saying Baker is the savior but we have an all star level AAA catcher now and that is better than having a 60-day DL'ed 1st baseman who can't hit major leaguers. Does everyone here forget that Stokes was a star of spring training last year and very nearly made the team? So was Baker......in 2006. But then let's see....Stokes went down to AAA, K'd 1/4th of his ABs and landed on the DL again! I don't even know why I try to sell some of you guys on this trade.... Stokes has played 9 games, I repeat 9 GAMES at the Major League level. How in God's name can you make the judgment that he can't hit MLB pitching after 11 MLB at-bats? Not to mention that even if he played a thousand games, your argument has no base because Baker hasn't proved he can hit MLB pitching either. You're arguing that because he has a good attitude and he's respected by his teammates that he's a better MLB hitter than Stokes. If you want to get down to literal facts, Stokes is the better MLB hitter because he actually has recorded MLB at-bats and a MLB average. Wanna take a look at minor league stats? Stokes's career MILB line: .279/.351/.509/860 Baker's career MILB line: .270/.358/.404/762The stats prove it. Stokes is a better career hitter than Baker is at both levels. I rest my case. Benched, I will not argue with you long because Ramp is more knowlegable than you and I don't want to waste my time with you. But OBVIOUSLY Stokes has better offensive numbers!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! HE IS A FIRST BASEMAN. HE IS SUPPOSED TO HAVE BETTER NUMBERS!!!! Stokes can not hit MLB pitching because in spring training games, he K'd about 50% of the time and 25% vs. minor leaguers. The writing is on the wall.
March 31, 200719 yr With all due respect to Gaby Sanchez, he has never done anything outside of low-A ball. Seriously though, you are a homer. At best, BEST, Baker becomes our backup catcher next year (possibly starter but with 2008 supposed to be our year, that won't happen... I hope) and Jason Stokes never does anything of note. That's the absolute best case scenario here. On a random note, has Beinfest ever made a bad trade in your eyes? how about Choi, Holandsworth, Bowyer, Leiter, Oliver?... anyway, if you seriously don't believe that Beinfest can do any wrong, we can no longer have an intelligent conversation regarding player personnel. And did you seriously say "Willis off the scrap heaps"? Just because you had never heard of him, doesn't mean he wasn't known around baseball. A player to be named later turning into a Cy Young, All Star #1 pitcher is considered scrap heaps.....your baseball knowledge is suspect at best. RAMP in the minor league forum...... "absolutely terrible trade for Florida at best, Baker becomes a backup catcher... what is the point of giving up on Jason Stokes for this non prospect? boggles the mind sometimes" Based on what? Stokes sucks and Baker is more of a prospect than him at this point! haha When healthy, Stokes is ten times the prospect Baker is. No he isn't. Stokes CAN NOT HIT MLB PITCHING!!!!!!!!!!!!!! What do you not understand? He is an injured version of Russell Branyan. Baker has heart, his teammates like him, fans loved him in Sacramento, and he has steadily gotten better over time. He had only 1 bad year and then last year replaced it with an all star level season. I'm not saying Baker is the savior but we have an all star level AAA catcher now and that is better than having a 60-day DL'ed 1st baseman who can't hit major leaguers. Does everyone here forget that Stokes was a star of spring training last year and very nearly made the team? So was Baker......in 2006. But then let's see....Stokes went down to AAA, K'd 1/4th of his ABs and landed on the DL again! I don't even know why I try to sell some of you guys on this trade.... Stokes has played 9 games, I repeat 9 GAMES at the Major League level. How in God's name can you make the judgment that he can't hit MLB pitching after 11 MLB at-bats? Not to mention that even if he played a thousand games, your argument has no base because Baker hasn't proved he can hit MLB pitching either. You're arguing that because he has a good attitude and he's respected by his teammates that he's a better MLB hitter than Stokes. If you want to get down to literal facts, Stokes is the better MLB hitter because he actually has recorded MLB at-bats and a MLB average. Wanna take a look at minor league stats? Stokes's career MILB line: .279/.351/.509/860 Baker's career MILB line: .270/.358/.404/762The stats prove it. Stokes is a better career hitter than Baker is at both levels. I rest my case. Benched, I will not argue with you long because Ramp is more knowlegable than you and I don't want to waste my time with you. But OBVIOUSLY Stokes has better offensive numbers!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! HE IS A FIRST BASEMAN. HE IS SUPPOSED TO HAVE BETTER NUMBERS!!!! Stokes can not hit MLB pitching because in spring training games, he K'd about 50% of the time and 25% vs. minor leaguers. The writing is on the wall. You argued that Baker is a better hitter. I proved you wrong. Now you agree with me. :lol I'd like to see where you're getting your stats from.
March 31, 200719 yr With all due respect to Gaby Sanchez, he has never done anything outside of low-A ball. Seriously though, you are a homer. At best, BEST, Baker becomes our backup catcher next year (possibly starter but with 2008 supposed to be our year, that won't happen... I hope) and Jason Stokes never does anything of note. That's the absolute best case scenario here. On a random note, has Beinfest ever made a bad trade in your eyes? how about Choi, Holandsworth, Bowyer, Leiter, Oliver?... anyway, if you seriously don't believe that Beinfest can do any wrong, we can no longer have an intelligent conversation regarding player personnel. And did you seriously say "Willis off the scrap heaps"? Just because you had never heard of him, doesn't mean he wasn't known around baseball. A player to be named later turning into a Cy Young, All Star #1 pitcher is considered scrap heaps.....your baseball knowledge is suspect at best. RAMP in the minor league forum...... "absolutely terrible trade for Florida at best, Baker becomes a backup catcher... what is the point of giving up on Jason Stokes for this non prospect? boggles the mind sometimes" Based on what? Stokes sucks and Baker is more of a prospect than him at this point! haha When healthy, Stokes is ten times the prospect Baker is. No he isn't. Stokes CAN NOT HIT MLB PITCHING!!!!!!!!!!!!!! What do you not understand? He is an injured version of Russell Branyan. Baker has heart, his teammates like him, fans loved him in Sacramento, and he has steadily gotten better over time. He had only 1 bad year and then last year replaced it with an all star level season. I'm not saying Baker is the savior but we have an all star level AAA catcher now and that is better than having a 60-day DL'ed 1st baseman who can't hit major leaguers. Does everyone here forget that Stokes was a star of spring training last year and very nearly made the team? So was Baker......in 2006. But then let's see....Stokes went down to AAA, K'd 1/4th of his ABs and landed on the DL again! I don't even know why I try to sell some of you guys on this trade.... Stokes has played 9 games, I repeat 9 GAMES at the Major League level. How in God's name can you make the judgment that he can't hit MLB pitching after 11 MLB at-bats? Not to mention that even if he played a thousand games, your argument has no base because Baker hasn't proved he can hit MLB pitching either. You're arguing that because he has a good attitude and he's respected by his teammates that he's a better MLB hitter than Stokes. If you want to get down to literal facts, Stokes is the better MLB hitter because he actually has recorded MLB at-bats and a MLB average. Wanna take a look at minor league stats? Stokes's career MILB line: .279/.351/.509/860 Baker's career MILB line: .270/.358/.404/762The stats prove it. Stokes is a better career hitter than Baker is at both levels. I rest my case. Benched, I will not argue with you long because Ramp is more knowlegable than you and I don't want to waste my time with you. But OBVIOUSLY Stokes has better offensive numbers!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! HE IS A FIRST BASEMAN. HE IS SUPPOSED TO HAVE BETTER NUMBERS!!!! Stokes can not hit MLB pitching because in spring training games, he K'd about 50% of the time and 25% vs. minor leaguers. The writing is on the wall. Can you show us these stats? I know I didn't just read three pages of bickering for nothing...
March 31, 200719 yr Ahhh..."bickering"...good word. :thumbup Enough is enough already. no one is changing anyone's mind. Maybe, I don't know, maybe we could talk about baseball for a change. Rumor has it the Marlins won today... :brigginbounce
March 31, 200719 yr just wanna look at what's in your sig for a moment, Wild... since you can't seem to get off my jock for 2 seconds 1) Regarding Jason Wood....."wonder why he didn't retire" Wrong, he made the team proving doubters like you wrong. I legitimately wondered out loud on why he didn't retire. That isn't even an opinion. 2) Regarding our CF situation....."Joe Borchard should be our starting CFer." Wrong, he sucks and I'll update his season stats later to prove you wrong even more. That's an opinion, how is that wrong? Oh well, I look forward to you bringing up every Joe Borchard out at the plate all season long. 3) Regarding Borchard and Ross not given a chance at CF......"yep... it's unfortunate they won't be given a legit chance..that being said, I hope Reggie wins the job." Wrong, Reggie is not a MLB talent. Again, I said I HOPE HE WINS THE JOB. How is that wrong to hope someone wins a job? 4) Regarding the Julio trade.... "so we made a knee jerk trade when we didnt have to? come on!" Wrong, knee jerk trade? Petit is not a MLB talent according to the scouts. His stuff is average. I'll update Julio's stats later to prove you wrong again. I look forward to this one all season long 5) Regarding the Jason Stokes trade...."absolutely terrible trade for Florida at best, Baker becomes a backup catcher... what is the point of giving up on Jason Stokes for this non prospect? boggles the mind sometimes" Wrong, bad trade how? Stokes K's 45% of his ABs vs. MLB pitchers. Baker is a 3 time all star who was voted fan favorite and MVP of the A's spring camp last year. I'll update stats to prove you wrong again. 45% vs MLB pitchers? Where do you come up with this stuff. And as much as you wish to believe, strikeouts and average are NOT the be-all, end-all of stats. And who gives a flying f*** if Baker was a fan favorite? That means nothing at all. We have shown that Stokes has put up better minor league numbers than Baker, yet you say he is supposed to because he is a 1B. So what? He is still more of a prospect, or atleast he has a chance to regain your prospect status. You routinely mock my baseball knowledge because I do not think Beinfest is the best GM of all time. I'm sorry, I don't. Sue me. So keep mocking me for whatever reasons you want, it just makes me feel that much smarter. For when you and I disagree, I know I am right. If we ever agree on something, I am going to be worried.
March 31, 200719 yr I was just going to say. What the living hell does it matter if Baker was a fan favorite? I think its a trade the Marlins had to make for the better of Stokes' career if nothing else. A change of scenery can often help a player out. Oakland liked him, we had a need for a AAA catcher, provides some depth, the other catchers arent anywhere close to really being ready this year, you know the ones that could actually be good, aka Hayes. Its a minor deal. It may turn out to be a horrible deal in the end for us, but Stokes was never going to do it in this organization. Like I said, a change of scenery may help him tremendously. Baker is an all star AAA player, but he will never amount to anything in the majors, a perfect example of the AAAA player. Hopefully he can stick at some point with some organization in the bigs. I just hope its not with us.
March 31, 200719 yr I was just going to say. What the living hell does it matter if Baker was a fan favorite? I think its a trade the Marlins had to make for the better of Stokes' career if nothing else. A change of scenery can often help a player out. Oakland liked him, we had a need for a AAA catcher, provides some depth, the other catchers arent anywhere close to really being ready this year, you know the ones that could actually be good, aka Hayes. Its a minor deal. It may turn out to be a horrible deal in the end for us, but Stokes was never going to do it in this organization. Like I said, a change of scenery may help him tremendously. Baker is an all star AAA player, but he will never amount to anything in the majors, a perfect example of the AAAA player. Hopefully he can stick at some point with some organization in the bigs. I just hope its not with us. I actually think Baker can be solid in the majors- a borderline starter (most likely backup). He is better than Treanor is now. To say he will never amount to anything is a bit wrong.....nobody knows. No one thought Willis even had major league stuff to be a starter- scouts thought he was a bullpen guy.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.