Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins will seek lower-cost free agents

Featured Replies

Marlins will seek lower cost free agents... SARCASM no sh*t. SARCASM

The Marlins struck out on the bidding for one of their top free-agent targets Thursday when catcher Yorvit Torrealba agreed to a reported three-year, $14.4 million contract with the New York Mets.

 

Now, Florida will focus on free agent Michael Barrett but will have to compete with offers from the San Diego Padres and Colorado Rockies, among other teams.

 

The Marlins also could turn their attention to Paul Lo Duca, Rod Barajas and Damian Miller, but all three veterans will attract interest from teams with higher payrolls in a thin market for starting catchers.

 

---

 

And during the general managers' meetings last week, baseball operations President Admin Beinfest indicated the Marlins like Treanor as the backup.

 

"He has done a good job in that role. Whether he steps up into a different role obviously depends on our catching situation,'' Beinfest said.

 

Treanor, 31, who has been in the organization since 1997, said he hopes to at least have more playing time next year, if not a shot at the starting job. "I definitely want to play as much as possible. I hope to get a little more chance than I did last year,'' said Treanor, who hit .269 with four homers and 19 RBI in 55 games last year.

Palm Beach Post

 

I have no issues with Barrett. I realize his defense stinks, but besides 130 at bats in San Diego last year, he is pretty solid offensively. I, like many here, would rather go with Baker and Treanor but it appears Baker won't even be sniffing the 25 man roster this year based on quotes about liking Treanor as a backup. It makes no sense, but every now and then this team's management gets stuck on a position (last year being vet closer) and just goes all out for it.

 

I won't complain if we sign Barrett, or even Lo Duca. I don't like Paulie but things could be much worse in the 8 hole (like Olivo or Torrealba). Rod Barajas is absolutely terrible, even with such a cool first name. He is going to be 32, and is coming off a .230/.352/.393 line in Philly. Those walks were an aberration has he had 21 in 122 at bats. His high is 26 in 410. Damian Miller? More crap and he's going to be 38!

 

Matt Treanor hit .269/.357/.392 in 171 at bats. This was the third year in a row his avg/obp/slg have all gone up from the year before. A .749OPS is pretty damn respectable for a catcher, especially one as good defensively as he is.

 

Backing him up should be John Baker, especially against righties where he hit .294/.361/.460 in 211 at bats vs them last year.

 

If we want to drop a few mil on Barrett or Lo Duca, that's fine. But those are guys are absolutely terrible.

If I could, I'd piss in Beinfest's coffee over this.

I will put in my two cents on the catcher position. I think Barrett or LoDuca are light years better than Matt Treanor. Barrett (.266 avg, .748 OPS) has solid numbers over his career and LoDuca's are even better (.288 avg, .752 OPS). Treanor had a decent year playing once a week but his career numbers (.236 avg, .652 OPS) show his real colors. I also think he would wear down during the season and pitchers would expose his weaknesses with the bat which would offset his defense and make him a liability in the lineup.

I will put in my two cents on the catcher position. I think Barrett or LoDuca are light years better than Matt Treanor. Barrett (.266 avg, .748 OPS) has solid numbers over his career and LoDuca's are even better (.288 avg, .752 OPS). Treanor had a decent year playing once a week but his career numbers (.236 avg, .652 OPS) show his real colors. I also think he would wear down during the season and pitchers would expose his weaknesses with the bat which would offset his defense and make him a liability in the lineup.

Treanor's numbers are on the rise, while Lo Duca is on the decline

 

not sure how to look at those at bats in San Diego with Barrett, and I for one would love to have him

I will put in my two cents on the catcher position. I think Barrett or LoDuca are light years better than Matt Treanor. Barrett (.266 avg, .748 OPS) has solid numbers over his career and LoDuca's are even better (.288 avg, .752 OPS). Treanor had a decent year playing once a week but his career numbers (.236 avg, .652 OPS) show his real colors. I also think he would wear down during the season and pitchers would expose his weaknesses with the bat which would offset his defense and make him a liability in the lineup.

Treanor's numbers are on the rise, while Lo Duca is on the decline

 

not sure how to look at those at bats in San Diego with Barrett, and I for one would love to have him

 

Treanor's numbers couldn't help but rise as he hit like a pitcher until last season.

I will put in my two cents on the catcher position. I think Barrett or LoDuca are light years better than Matt Treanor. Barrett (.266 avg, .748 OPS) has solid numbers over his career and LoDuca's are even better (.288 avg, .752 OPS). Treanor had a decent year playing once a week but his career numbers (.236 avg, .652 OPS) show his real colors. I also think he would wear down during the season and pitchers would expose his weaknesses with the bat which would offset his defense and make him a liability in the lineup.

The key here is money. The Marlins don't have a lot of it. Barret or Lo Duca are not cost effective options because their likely productivity over Treanor is not going to equal their cost.

 

Instead of spending money on Beinfest Players the Marlins should solidify their pitching for next season.

 

I think the Marlins will get a catcher in a trade that's better than Treanor or Olivo. I would be upset if the Marlins spent money on Barrett or LoDuca after trading Cabrera/Willis to save money.

I will put in my two cents on the catcher position. I think Barrett or LoDuca are light years better than Matt Treanor. Barrett (.266 avg, .748 OPS) has solid numbers over his career and LoDuca's are even better (.288 avg, .752 OPS). Treanor had a decent year playing once a week but his career numbers (.236 avg, .652 OPS) show his real colors. I also think he would wear down during the season and pitchers would expose his weaknesses with the bat which would offset his defense and make him a liability in the lineup.

Treanor's numbers are on the rise, while Lo Duca is on the decline

 

not sure how to look at those at bats in San Diego with Barrett, and I for one would love to have him

 

Treanor's numbers couldn't help but rise as he hit like a pitcher until last season.

I know that's tongue-in-cheek but Treanor actually looked like a ballplayer at the plate last season

i like the idea of the baker/treanor platoon, but the only problem with that is the way pitchers would react to that. do you platoon them vs right/left, or do you stick certain pitchers with their own specific catcher?

 

also, unrelated to the catcher, i think the marlins should take a chance on Jody Gerut...looowww risk and potentially decent reward, he's been hitting well in the fall league, and will come for cheap since he hasn't stepped on a big league field since (i think) 2005

 

thoughts?

Gerut has no place on this team

he's played a little (very little) center field, and he can definitely be had for cheap.

i don't think it would be the best idea, but we could do worse.

Gerut has no place on this team

he's played a little (very little) center field, and he can definitely be had for cheap.

i don't think it would be the best idea, but we could do worse.

He had one good year, and that was in 2003. And he hasn't played baseball in either of the last 2 seasons before being in winter ball right now

I'd rather go with EP's plan of platooning Baker and Treanor.

 

:| Lets not kill our team next season.I'd much rather prefer we sign Barrett or LoDuca.

 

 

 

 

Why because Barrett and LoPuka are bigger names?

The Mets' deal with Yorvit Torrealba has fallen apart for an undisclosed reason, and no further negotiations are scheduled.

Odd. Reports Friday indicated that only a physical stood in the way of a three-year, $14.4 million, and MLB.com went so far as to post it as an official transaction yesterday. If Torrealba failed the physical, it's likely that the Mets would have disclosed it. Instead, their spokesman said simply that "the Mets did not reach an agreement" with the catcher. Torrealba could re-sign with the Rockies now, though it'd probably be a two-year deal. The Marlins were also interested. After their comments the last few days, it sounds as though the Mets don't want to go back to Paul Lo Duca. Michael Barrett, Jason Kendall and Rod Barajas are still out there, while Ramon Hernandez, Johnny Estrada, Ronny Paulino and Gerald Laird are trade possibilites. Nov. 17 - 5:22 pm et

 

 

Sh*t.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.