November 29, 200718 yr Wow! This is why the Rays will always be the Devil Rays, despite having probably the most talented organization in all of baseball. Awful move for Tampa, Young is going to be a superstar.
November 29, 200718 yr I like this deal for the Rays, and now I hear they're trying to sign Percival to a two year deal. I'm excited for the Rays next season.
November 29, 200718 yr Wow! This is why the Rays will always be the Devil Rays, despite having probably the most talented organization in all of baseball. Awful move for Tampa, Young is going to be a superstar. Young may very well end up a superstar, but so may Elijah Dukes, BJ Upton, Carl Crawford, Rocco Baldelli (if he ever stays healthy) or Jonny Gomes. These are the guys that Tampa currently still has for the outfield. I don't think they'll be lacking for production there, meanwhile they were in starting pitching which Garza should fix. This move is finally a step in the right direction for them. You don't win by having too many prospects at one position, you win by using the surpluses you have to fix the holes you have and thats what they are doing.
November 29, 200718 yr I like the deal but the Rays should have gotten a better bull pen arm than Rincon though. I love Garza though.
November 29, 200718 yr I like the deal but the Rays should have gotten a better bull pen arm than Rincon though. I love Garza though. Rays didn't get Rincon they got Eduardo Morlan instead. Eduardo Morlan Seems like a nice arm.
November 29, 200718 yr http://msn.foxsports.com/mlb/story/7501338?MSNHPHMA Young trade gives Twins some options Ken Rosenthal / FOXSports.com Posted: 2 hours ago The acquisition of Delmon Young doesn't simply give the Twins an offensive replacement for Torii Hunter. It also gives them the flexibility to either keep or trade Johan Santana. If the Twins keep Santana, they might be only a few players away from contending in the AL Central next season. But if they trade Santana for elite young talent and acquire additional prospects for closer Joe Nathan, they might be an absolute monster by the time they open their new ballpark in 2010. The latter scenario still appears more likely, but Twins GM Bill Smith was not about to reveal his intentions in a conference call following the announcement of the Young trade on Wednesday night. When asked if the Twins might contend if they simply added one or two pieces to their current roster, Smith simply repeated his mantra: "We've got a lot of work to do before Opening Day." For Smith, that could mean adding a shortstop, third baseman and center fielder to his core ? no small feat. But it's a manageable quest if his goal is to compete next season rather than deconstruct. The Twins' rotation could be strong even without Matt Garza ? a player in the Young deal ? and Carlos Silva, who is likely to depart as a free agent. Santana would be at the top, followed by some combination of Scott Baker, Kevin Slowey, Boof Bonser and ? cross your fingers ? a healthy Francisco Liriano. Young, meanwhile, will join a lineup that already includes Joe Mauer, Justin Morneau and Michael Cuddyer. Put someone like the Red Sox's Coco Crisp at the top, and things would get interesting. Smith could try internal options at short or sign free agent Cesar Izturis, a gifted defender. He could acquire Crisp to play center in a deal independent of any Santana discussions. Upgrading at third would be more of a challenge, but Smith could use his savings on Hunter to trade for a player such as Scott Rolen, Melvin Mora or Bill Hall. Or, he could acquire a younger third baseman such as the Dodgers' Andy LaRoche. What would be the worst that could happen? The Twins could flounder in the first half and trade Santana and Nathan before the July 31 non-waiver deadline. Or they could contend all season, and then collect four high draft picks for Santana and Nathan after they depart as free agents, adding to the two they will receive for Hunter. The idea of keeping the roster intact is so intriguing, one rival GM said of the Young trade, "I think it could make the Twins shift gears on Santana." Don't be so sure. The best way for the Twins to fill their holes is for Smith to continue trading. Say he could get pitcher Phil Hughes, center fielder Melky Cabrera and a third player from the Yankees for Santana, then a young third baseman and more pitching for Nathan. The nucleus of position players would then be intact through at least 2010, after which Mauer and Morneau are eligible for free agency. A rotation featuring Hughes, Liriano, Baker and Slowey could develop into one of the game's best. And the Twins would gain the financial flexibility to retain their own stars or acquire comparable replacements. It would behoove Smith to act quickly if trading Santana is his preferred option ? the A's could shrink his market by sending Dan Haren and Joe Blanton to teams interested in Santana, and the Orioles could do the same by moving Erik Bedard. Trading Santana and Nathan on top of losing Hunter and Silva might turn Smith, at least temporarily, into the most unpopular man in the Twin Cities. But if he drafted wisely and made good trades, the Twins might rebound to the point where they again are capable of winning four division titles in five seasons, just in time for the opening of their new park. Smith proved on Wednesday that he is not afraid to make a bold call, trading Garza and shortstop Jason Bartlett in a six-player deal for Young, a gifted slugger whose questionable attitude and poor plate discipline raise undeniable concerns. Smith's next decision will be even bolder, but at least now he has options. He can keep Johan Santana or trade him, and justify either call. Rays get good deal, too When judging trades, the team that acquires the best player often is the one that rates the edge. Outfielder Delmon Young probably will turn out to be the best player in Wednesday's six-player deal between the Rays and Twins. But rival executives also liked what the Rays accomplished by acquiring a potential top-of-the-rotation starter, Matt Garza, and everyday shortstop, Jason Bartlett. Garza, 24, will fit behind Scott Kazmir and James Shields in the Rays' rotation, adding to the team's burgeoning collection of young starters. Some of those pitchers could spill over to the bullpen. Others could be traded to fill other needs. Bartlett, 28, is described by one general manager as "one of the more underrated guys in the league." He will improve the Rays defense, which last season was the worst in the AL. And, like Garza, he also will increase the Rays' future options. Reid Brignac, who likely will start next season at Class AAA, is considered the Rays' shortstop of the future. The Rays eventually could move him to second base, trade him or trade Bartlett. Evan Longoria, one of the game's top prospects, is expected to take over third at some point in 2008, forcing Akinori Iwamura to second. Young a big question mark Tony Oliva, Nomar Garciaparra and Albert Pujols were the only players in the past 50 years to finish with more hits, RBIs and doubles as a rookie than Delmon Young. Equally impressive, Young's .349 batting average with runners in scoring position was the sixth best by an American League rookie since 1974. The flaw in Young's game is plate discipline. He took only 37.8 percent of the pitches he saw last season, the lowest percentage in the majors and third lowest in the last 20 years. While Young is only 22, some Rays officials believe it might take him three or four years to fully evolve as a hitter. What's more, many Rays players and executives consider Young to be difficult and immature. Young received a 50-game suspension for flipping his bat into the chest of a Class AAA umpire in 2006 and threatened to go home before the Rays' final game last season after manager Joe Maddon benched him for failing to run out a groundball. "We did a lot of homework on Delmon Young," Twins GM Bill Smith said. "He is a good person. He comes from a good family. He is a good teammate. He made a terrible mistake two years ago. But some good young people make mistakes." Outstanding Trade for both teams, That is what off-season trading is about in baseball
November 29, 200718 yr I gotta believe this would put the Red Sox ahead od the Yankees in the Santana auction. I feel Coco Crisp is a better fit in the Twins Outfield, alongside Young than Melky Cabrera especially if the Red Sox take some of his salary
November 29, 200718 yr Good trade for both sides. Rays get an upgrade in three areas where it was desperately needed. Twins get another (potentially) great bat to put alongside Morneau and Mauer.
November 29, 200718 yr Delmon Young's been pencilled in at left. He has good numbers at right, and some spectacular plays. He sucks in center. But he hasn't yet played left in the majors. This will be interesting to see.
November 29, 200718 yr This trade is essentially equal it seems, but I'd have to side with the twins on this one. Pitchers are usually riskier than hitters in getting injured (arm problems) and panning out (walks, whip). Delmon Young was a #1 pick and is going to be a great hitter for many years (hes going to be consistant). Garza, while having tremendous stuff as well, is a little further back in developing in the big league level than Young is. Garza is also a pitcher (more of an injury risk), while Young is a hitter, and Young is a better prospect. I'd give Young a great edge here. As for the SS: Harris had less errors, is a year younger and can play multiple positions. He just doesnt have experience under his belt and consistancy as Bartlett does. Bartlett had a horrendous 26 errors compared to Harris' 11. Bartlett is mediocre as a starting shortstop and thats been proved the past 3 years. Hes a bench player and so is Harris. I'd give the upperhand to Harris since he'd be more useful as a bench player, (power, avg, multipositional, decent defense, spot starter) Although Garza has a chance to be great, Minnesotta robbed Tampa here. Depending if Garza can stay healthy (arm wise), lower his whip and which SS can remain consistant in the future, time will tell who got the better hand.
November 29, 200718 yr Errors isn't a very good way to judge defense. They need to be noted but the main thing you want to look at is range. Bartlett has one of the best ranges for a SS in the majors, easily top-5, and Harris is one of the worst. It REALLY upgrades thier defense.
November 29, 200718 yr Man, i hope the twins improve that rotation... Not sure I remember that flag. Honestly, i really do enjoy you being on my nuts and following EVERY post i make....Thanks a lot for the support :thumbup
November 29, 200718 yr I dont think Id ever use this site if I couldnt filter it down to FishFanInPA posts only.
November 29, 200718 yr Anyways, in order for the twins to improve, they need more pitching....especially if they get rid of Johan. They can't count on Liriano.
November 29, 200718 yr They have an influx of starting pitching. Even if they trade Santana they can choose 5 from: Loriano Pitcher they get in return from Santana (And that's assuming only one) Scott Baker Boof Bonser Kevin Slowey Glen Perkins That's a good rotation... Even if they lose Loriano they still have 5 good starters, and if they get a Hughes/Buccholz in return from Santana, they still have a huge 1-2 punch with those two.
November 29, 200718 yr Harris will most likely move to 2B because he is more suited there and Casilla could handle SS. I do think that his offensive value as a middle infielder is underrated but I think most people aren't sold on him despite his good numbers and good minor league track record.
November 30, 200718 yr Errors isn't a very good way to judge defense. They need to be noted but the main thing you want to look at is range. Bartlett has one of the best ranges for a SS in the majors, easily top-5, and Harris is one of the worst. It REALLY upgrades thier defense. Harris is a better bat while Barlett is a better glove, Bartlet may be moved to 2nd base anyway as well
November 30, 200718 yr Errors isn't a very good way to judge defense. They need to be noted but the main thing you want to look at is range. Bartlett has one of the best ranges for a SS in the majors, easily top-5, and Harris is one of the worst. It REALLY upgrades thier defense. 26 errors is horrendous anyway you put it. That is what I was looking at. But I agree, errors is not the best tool to judge for Shortstops on defense. Although, its somewhat a factor.
November 30, 200718 yr My Hopes for Garza are as high as anyones but damn, Delmond Young. So much for the hype now.
November 30, 200718 yr We don't have anyone big league ready that's uninjured on Garza's level. You could argue Volstad but he's not proven and really not exactly coming off a great minor league year. It also looks like TB wants to solve SS in this trade. We have nothing to offer. I also wouldn't say Delmon's year was decent. He was the worst offensive qualified RFer in all of baseball last year, by far. .249 GPA...ouch. All he did was hit for average. Yes his power will come around, I know he's only 22 years old...but even then all he will do is hit for average and power. I'm not saying that's bad, but he'll probably only be OPSing in the .830's-.850's, .900+ in high BABIP years. Again that's not bad by any means and I'm not saying, he's going to be a very good ballplayer, make several allstar teams, yadda yadda yadda, that but I think you're grossly overrated his talents. The implications from the desperality in your posts makes it sound like you think he's a once in a generation talent. No, I just can't fathom Garza being anything close to equal value for him. I think we've got enough pitching of interchangeable quality for Garza. You're talking about two years nothing overwhelming, nothing dominating. Even in the minors he wasn't overly dominant. I think Im gona have to call you out on this one.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.