Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Jake Peavy; Cheater?

Featured Replies

Look

 

It was discovered that Jake Peavy had something on his hand during his impressive complete game gem on Saturday vs. the L.A. Dodgers.

 

The following day, Peavy made the following comments to The San Diego Union Tribune:

 

Anybody that wants to check me, feel free. There's nothing on my hands that's not supposed to be. I thought it was funny that it was such a big deal. I've got no problems with anytime anybody needs to check me."I can't imagine my hands being that dirty. That being said, you're hand doesn't look clean when you're out there. Obviously I pick up rosin, pick up dirt, I do hit."

 

The photo can be seen by clicking the link above.

 

 

 

Thoughts?

if peavy is a cheater...then im an astronaut...and i dont like heights

 

I don't agree with this line of thinking, but I also don't think he was cheating. But I wouldn't put it past anyone at this level. I don't blame anyone for trying to get any small advantage.

if peavy is a cheater...then im an astronaut...and i dont like heights

 

I don't agree with this line of thinking, but I also don't think he was cheating. But I wouldn't put it past anyone at this level. I don't blame anyone for trying to get any small advantage.

maybe...maybe if it was an american league pitcher pitching in say the rogers centre...i would take further look at this...

 

but its san diego, where there is A. no DH and B. beautiful weather and it doesnt rain all that much...which leads me to believe that C. peavy has filthy ridiculous stuff and i pray when we play the padres, his number isnt due to pitch

maybe...maybe if it was an american league pitcher pitching in say the rogers centre...i would take further look at this...

 

but its san diego, where there is A. no DH and B. beautiful weather and it doesnt rain all that much...

 

What the hell are you talking about?

maybe...maybe if it was an american league pitcher pitching in say the rogers centre...i would take further look at this...

 

but its san diego, where there is A. no DH and B. beautiful weather and it doesnt rain all that much...

 

What the hell are you talking about?

my point is that because of those reasons...he has plenty of reasons to have dirt on his fingers...which is exactly what i think it is

Ok. But the difference between a mediocre ML pitcher and Peavy is about 10 mil a year. That's a pretty good reason to do anything you can to gain an advantage.

Ok. But the difference between a mediocre ML pitcher and Peavy is about 10 mil a year. That's a pretty good reason to do anything you can to gain an advantage.

i agree...but it looks like dirt to me...and when considering that he has to handle a bat, pitched a complete game and wasnt playing indoors or in a place where it rained earlier that day...dirt seems very reasonable to me

I'm also on the thinking of dirt for this 1.

They gotta think how much these guys sweat too, so that in a mixture with the dirt would create that most likely.

It was probably dirt, but not for any of the reasons you said.

 

This

 

My only logical reasoning is that, being right handed, he picked up a bat that had gotten some dirt on the pine tar, and if you grip a bat and imagine where the pine tar would be, you'd see his grip is consistent with where the dirt on his hand is.

There's no doubt that whatever is on his fingers was done on purpose. The "dirt" is only on his index/middle and thumb.

 

But it doesnt necessarily mean he's cheating though. And well batters get so much stuff to help themselves against pitchers that I really dont even care if he was.

It was probably dirt, but not for any of the reasons you said.

 

This

 

My only logical reasoning is that, being right handed, he picked up a bat that had gotten some dirt on the pine tar, and if you grip a bat and imagine where the pine tar would be, you'd see his grip is consistent with where the dirt on his hand is.

 

 

There's no doubt that whatever is on his fingers was done on purpose. The "dirt" is only on his index/middle and thumb.

 

But it doesnt necessarily mean he's cheating though. And well batters get so much stuff to help themselves against pitchers that I really dont even care if he was.

 

Pretend to hold a bat in your hands, right handed... which two fingers are closest to the barrel of the bat... which two fingers would be closer to where the pine tar is?

 

THE INDEX AND MIDDLE OF THE RIGHT HAND... and the index and middle FREQUENTLY touch the thumb... e.g. He got pine tar/dirt on those fingers, and as a natural habit (especially for pitchers), rubbed it on his thumb... this is getting ridiculous... :banghead

 

Edit: And for those saying that it should be on his palm too, the palm comes into contact with the rosin bag/ball/uniform pants often which would lead to it being wiped off which is why the dirt kind of fades as it makes its way to the palm

 

PS Edit: Also, I'm not saying that this may not have effected his performance, but I AM saying it was hardly intentional

Have you ever grabbed a wood bat with pine tar before?

 

There is no way that your hands can become that dark unintentionally just from holding a bat. Sorry. And theres no reason that it would only be located on the 3 fingers that touches the ball.

 

And also in what part of holding a bat does your index finger and middle finger contact the thumb? :lol Your thumb is placed on TOP of your middle and index finger. Not on the bat itself.

Well, here are 3 examples of thumb placement that is "wrong" by your standards... oh, and on a wood bat no less. Weird. Also, considering Peavy is a pitcher, if he were trying to get a hit, he would feasibly choke up on the bat... e.g. feasibly to the portion with more pine tar. And in the case of Howard, his bottom hand (left hand) is similar to the placement of his top hand.

 

Edit: And in response to that "what part of holding a bat does your index finger and middle finger contact the thumb?" statement, READ MY POST... then make a comment, otherwise you're ignorant for not reading the whole thing. But I'll clarify, he didn't have to contact his thumb and fingers to each other, but to the bat, as depicted below, OR as he's in the dugout, he could rub his middle/index fingers to his thumb.

 

 

 

 

 

 

If you're not cheating you're not trying to win :rolleyes: or its only cheating if you get caught :thumbup These are the accepted non-rules of most sports

Actually I think it was from his bat, but either way he pitched great.

All this batting grip talk is nonsense if he uses batting gloves -- and the fact that he ring and pinky fingers are immaculate is weird, but until he's actually caught in game I think this is pretty much a waste of time.

  • Author

The only cheating Peavy is doing is using a booster seat so he can reach the dinner table.

 

He's 6'1"

 

:blink:

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.