April 9, 200818 yr Hermida has the minor league track record to demonstrate his major league achievements This makes no sense. Are you sure you understand the word achievement? I never said Jake was a bust, I was saying that he came over with HIGH expectations though Penguino said he was a bust. My original comment was in response to that. People picked Hermida ahead of Hanley based on ML service time, and the fact that Hanley had "regressed" when in all actuality, he was bored in the minors Whatever the case people were wrong. Not only wrong, but by the end of 2006, there were 4 Marlins in the ROTY picture and not one named Jeremy Hermida. His injuries are flukey, once he shakes the bad luck, he will prove everyone wrong, and everyone will be a Hermida fan Only time can tell such a thing. No one can assert that, and no one can say if or when he shakes his "bad luck". And he'd be more proving people right than proving people wrong. We've heard forever about the talent and potential and it hasn't materialized. All the while people criticize Uggla who made it to the All-Star game as a rookie and has been one of our top 3 or 4 run producers the last two years, and we hear things like on this thread, about how great the disparity is in talent between the two. I'll be happy if Hermida comes through, and I'd like to see him actually play the entire rest of the season.
April 9, 200818 yr Hermida sucks.........can't wait to hear all the excuses about his slow start......"he was hurt during ST" "Hes a slow starter" "This is his ST" Hopefully he returns to the player he was the 2nd half of last year but I dont trust him......Not to mention he is the defensive equivalent of Junior Felix in RF :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead
April 9, 200818 yr Hermida sucks.........can't wait to hear all the excuses about his slow start......"he was hurt during ST" "Hes a slow starter" "This is his ST" Hopefully he returns to the player he was the 2nd half of last year but I dont trust him......Not to mention he is the defensive equivalent of Junior Felix in RF :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead They closed your thread so you come to say it here huh? Give it a rest, and lets just wait and see.
April 9, 200818 yr Yes, I understand the word achievement quite clearly... stuff like plate discipline translates well between minor and major leagues, and Hermida has always had the plate discipline that makes his game work.. Some people are suggesting that what Hermida did last year was an anomaly, and I'm saying it was anything but... An achievement, however big or small is an achievement, what you may be seeing now is an ice cube, but I'm seeing the tip of an ice berg here. You can not hold not being a ROTY candidate against Hermida for only so long, who gives a ^$ that Hermida didn't win it, only one person can anyways. The fact is, he keeps playing on these injuries and making them worse trying to be in the lineup for all 162 games. Let him get to 100% and we'll take it from there.
April 9, 200818 yr Hermida sucks.........can't wait to hear all the excuses about his slow start......"he was hurt during ST" "Hes a slow starter" "This is his ST" Hopefully he returns to the player he was the 2nd half of last year but I dont trust him......Not to mention he is the defensive equivalent of Junior Felix in RF :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead :banghead They closed your thread so you come to say it here huh? Give it a rest, and lets just wait and see. At least we can agree here though :thumbup
April 9, 200818 yr Hermida has the minor league track record to demonstrate his major league achievements This makes no sense. Are you sure you understand the word achievement? I never said Jake was a bust, I was saying that he came over with HIGH expectations though Penguino said he was a bust. My original comment was in response to that. People picked Hermida ahead of Hanley based on ML service time, and the fact that Hanley had "regressed" when in all actuality, he was bored in the minors Whatever the case people were wrong. Not only wrong, but by the end of 2006, there were 4 Marlins in the ROTY picture and not one named Jeremy Hermida. His injuries are flukey, once he shakes the bad luck, he will prove everyone wrong, and everyone will be a Hermida fan Only time can tell such a thing. No one can assert that, and no one can say if or when he shakes his "bad luck". And he'd be more proving people right than proving people wrong. We've heard forever about the talent and potential and it hasn't materialized. All the while people criticize Uggla who made it to the All-Star game as a rookie and has been one of our top 3 or 4 run producers the last two years, and we hear things like on this thread, about how great the disparity is in talent between the two. I'll be happy if Hermida comes through, and I'd like to see him actually play the entire rest of the season. His talent hasn't materialized? He had a better year statistically than Uggla. His OPS was third on the team. He hit 18 HR in 200 fewer ABs than Uggla. He hits with runners on. He takes walks and he makes contact. What more do people want from him other than improving his defense like everyone else on this team.
April 9, 200818 yr You can not hold not being a ROTY candidate against Hermida for only so long, who gives a ^$ that Hermida didn't win it, only one person can anyways. The fact is, he keeps playing on these injuries and making them worse trying to be in the lineup for all 162 games. I'm not holding it against him, just making the point that there have always been huge expectations for Hermida to which he has not lived up. Let him get to 100% and we'll take it from there. Sure, and I bet the team has been trying to do this for the last 2 seasons. How long should it take you think?
April 9, 200818 yr You DON'T cut ties with talented 24 year olds... unless they have a career ENDING injury it's just something you DON'T do.... stop suggesting we "cut ties" with Hermida, it's ridiculous that you'd suggest a 24 year old with uber talent be "washed up" almost to the point of genuinely being irritating Case in point: Josh Hamilton I agree 100%. The Marlins don't however. They got rid of Miguel Cabrera. He was pretty good and about 24.
April 9, 200818 yr You can not hold not being a ROTY candidate against Hermida for only so long, who gives a ^$ that Hermida didn't win it, only one person can anyways. The fact is, he keeps playing on these injuries and making them worse trying to be in the lineup for all 162 games. I'm not holding it against him, just making the point that there have always been huge expectations for Hermida to which he has not lived up. Let him get to 100% and we'll take it from there. Sure, and I bet the team has been trying to do this for the last 2 seasons. How long should it take you think? He was healthy last season down the stretch and his G total has increased every year for 3 years... this should be about it :thumbup
April 9, 200818 yr WTF? Are people seriously still doubting Hermida? He is one of our cornerstones along with Hanley and Maybin. Not only does he ooze with a ton of potential, but he put up very good numbers as a 23 year old last year. I've only read this last page so I am sure I am just reiterating what the few fans with common sense left on this board are saying, but Hermida is not a bust and to say anything even close to that is laughable.
April 9, 200818 yr You DON'T cut ties with talented 24 year olds... unless they have a career ENDING injury it's just something you DON'T do.... stop suggesting we "cut ties" with Hermida, it's ridiculous that you'd suggest a 24 year old with uber talent be "washed up" almost to the point of genuinely being irritating Case in point: Josh Hamilton I agree 100%. The Marlins don't however. They got rid of Miguel Cabrera. He was pretty good and about 24. THAT was a factor of money (whatever your take on the situation is)... THIS is NOT a factor of money
April 9, 200818 yr You DON'T cut ties with talented 24 year olds... unless they have a career ENDING injury it's just something you DON'T do.... stop suggesting we "cut ties" with Hermida, it's ridiculous that you'd suggest a 24 year old with uber talent be "washed up" almost to the point of genuinely being irritating Case in point: Josh Hamilton I agree 100%. The Marlins don't however. They got rid of Miguel Cabrera. He was pretty good and about 24. THAT was a factor of money (whatever your take on the situation is)... THIS is NOT a factor of money I know. I just couldn't resist. And I agree they should have traded him because Loria's cheap a** had no intention of signing him as a FA.
April 9, 200818 yr You DON'T cut ties with talented 24 year olds... unless they have a career ENDING injury it's just something you DON'T do.... stop suggesting we "cut ties" with Hermida, it's ridiculous that you'd suggest a 24 year old with uber talent be "washed up" almost to the point of genuinely being irritating Case in point: Josh Hamilton I agree 100%. The Marlins don't however. They got rid of Miguel Cabrera. He was pretty good and about 24. THAT was a factor of money (whatever your take on the situation is)... THIS is NOT a factor of money I know. I just couldn't resist. And I agree they should have traded him because Loria's cheap a** had no intention of signing him as a FA. Fair enough :lol
April 9, 200818 yr Take a chill pill. Calling a 24 year old a bust is ridiculous. Listen, I don't like the way Hermida plays baseball, but fact is...he already showed what he's capable of the 2nd half of last year. And the reason why you'll see complaints on him instead of a guy like Jacobs is because Hermida was touted as THE man. #1 prospect (not for the Marlins, only), but all of baseball, according to Baseball America, when he was eligible. The kid has a sweet swing. With that said, Brett Carroll could show him a few things on how to play defense in RF, and how to play the game with passion, in general. But, please, don't call Jeremy Hermida a bust. It's as ridiculously stupid as giving up on VandenHurk and/or Andrew Miller already. Be patient.
April 9, 200818 yr Take a chill pill. Calling a 24 year old a bust is ridiculous. Listen, I don't like the way Hermida plays baseball, but fact is...he already showed what he's capable of the 2nd half of last year. And the reason why you'll see complaints on him instead of a guy like Jacobs is because Hermida was touted as THE man. #1 prospect (not for the Marlins, only), but all of baseball, according to Baseball America, when he was eligible. The kid has a sweet swing. With that said, Brett Carroll could show him a few things on how to play defense in RF, and how to play the game with passion, in general. But, please, don't call Jeremy Hermida a bust. It's as ridiculously stupid as giving up on VandenHurk and/or Andrew Miller already. Be patient. That's not fair and you know it... You don't make it to the majors without passion for the game unless you have ungodly talent and ability... Hermida isn't THAT good, he plays the game with passion just as everyone on the Marlins does
April 9, 200818 yr I don't understand the be patient talk either. This isn't Vanden Hurk with his plus 6.00 ERA that we need to be preaching patience with. Hermida has already shown he will get on base, hit for power and put up good numbers at the major league level at a very young age. Has he been injured and made some mental errors in the outfield? Yes, but his range is fine and injuries happen. Hermida is a stud, future all star and a core piece we need/will build the next championship run around. Just compare his ML numbers to the guy he is most often compared to: Paul O'Neill. At age 23 in 123 (in a pitchers park) games Hermida already has put up better numbers than O'Neill ever did in his entire twenties. In my book if you talk down Hermida you instantly lose all credibility.
April 9, 200818 yr Lets not forget Hermida could be THE WORST defensive player in the majors. Now if anybody scrutinizes this comment they have a very short memory. Dont forget how awful he was in RF last year. I was utterly shocked to read that he made two errors in a single A game the other night. If you did forget im sure Jeremy will remind you soon.
April 9, 200818 yr You DON'T cut ties with talented 24 year olds... unless they have a career ENDING injury it's just something you DON'T do.... stop suggesting we "cut ties" with Hermida, it's ridiculous that you'd suggest a 24 year old with uber talent be "washed up" almost to the point of genuinely being irritating Case in point: Josh Hamilton Josh may or may not turn out to be an answer for the Rangers, but both Tampa Bay and Cinicinnati didn't see enough to keep him. I find it ridiculous we still have (or had during spring training) Jeff Allison in our organization. Talk about a worst bust than Hermida, Allison is right above Josh Booty in that catagory. All in all the Marlins have only a mediocre at best drafting history. Certainly they hit on Josh Beckett, Charles Johnson and Adrian Gonzalez, but other than that its all been FA signings or trades. Its a good thing Beinfest has hit on some trades or this franchise would really be in trouble. Cincinnatti needed pitching more than they needed hitting, that's the only reason they traded Hamilton... And I never get that Rangers organization. As if they are loaded with pitching.....I guess they are gonna try to outbomb everyone.
April 9, 200818 yr Ughh, I'm done, I've made all the points I've needed to to prove that Hermida shouldn't catch all this flak... This is just getting lame now
April 9, 200818 yr Take a chill pill. Calling a 24 year old a bust is ridiculous. Listen, I don't like the way Hermida plays baseball, but fact is...he already showed what he's capable of the 2nd half of last year. And the reason why you'll see complaints on him instead of a guy like Jacobs is because Hermida was touted as THE man. #1 prospect (not for the Marlins, only), but all of baseball, according to Baseball America, when he was eligible. The kid has a sweet swing. With that said, Brett Carroll could show him a few things on how to play defense in RF, and how to play the game with passion, in general. But, please, don't call Jeremy Hermida a bust. It's as ridiculously stupid as giving up on VandenHurk and/or Andrew Miller already. Be patient. That's not fair and you know it... You don't make it to the majors without passion for the game unless you have ungodly talent and ability... Hermida isn't THAT good, he plays the game with passion just as everyone on the Marlins does Actually, I think it is fair. There are balls in the outfield, where it just looks to me, as if he's not hustling, often times. He's an easy-going player. Not intense, at all. Of course, he can hit 25-30 HR's, and get 90-100 RBI's if healthy a full season, so it really balances out. He'll be a good ballplayer.
April 9, 200818 yr Take a chill pill. Calling a 24 year old a bust is ridiculous. Listen, I don't like the way Hermida plays baseball, but fact is...he already showed what he's capable of the 2nd half of last year. And the reason why you'll see complaints on him instead of a guy like Jacobs is because Hermida was touted as THE man. #1 prospect (not for the Marlins, only), but all of baseball, according to Baseball America, when he was eligible. The kid has a sweet swing. With that said, Brett Carroll could show him a few things on how to play defense in RF, and how to play the game with passion, in general. But, please, don't call Jeremy Hermida a bust. It's as ridiculously stupid as giving up on VandenHurk and/or Andrew Miller already. Be patient. That's not fair and you know it... You don't make it to the majors without passion for the game unless you have ungodly talent and ability... Hermida isn't THAT good, he plays the game with passion just as everyone on the Marlins does Actually, I think it is fair. There are balls in the outfield, where it just looks to me, as if he's not hustling, often times. He's an easy-going player. Not intense, at all. Of course, he can hit 25-30 HR's, and get 90-100 RBI's if healthy a full season, so it really balances out. He'll be a good ballplayer. Since we're on good terms, I'll respond to you I think that's more a function of him not overrunning plays he can't otherwise make, he's no Andruw Jones in the OF, and he knows it, sure he has mental lapses... but c'mon, he's 24 :whistle
April 9, 200818 yr Hermida out performed Uggla in every offensive category but HR last year including OPS (.870 to .805) and BA/RISP (.287 to .199!). If you look at home runs per AB Hermida was .042 and Uggla .049, not a huge difference. So who has more value? How many games did Uggla play in and how many did Hermida miss in 2007 ? I'd say the guy who was in more games is of better value. Also again, this was for ? a season. What about Hermida's 2006 season stats ? Are they better than Uggla's 2006 ? So far its not close as far as power hitting goes, that much I am pretty sure I am right about.
April 9, 200818 yr Take a chill pill. Calling a 24 year old a bust is ridiculous. Listen, I don't like the way Hermida plays baseball, but fact is...he already showed what he's capable of the 2nd half of last year. And the reason why you'll see complaints on him instead of a guy like Jacobs is because Hermida was touted as THE man. #1 prospect (not for the Marlins, only), but all of baseball, according to Baseball America, when he was eligible. The kid has a sweet swing. With that said, Brett Carroll could show him a few things on how to play defense in RF, and how to play the game with passion, in general. But, please, don't call Jeremy Hermida a bust. It's as ridiculously stupid as giving up on VandenHurk and/or Andrew Miller already. Be patient. That's not fair and you know it... You don't make it to the majors without passion for the game unless you have ungodly talent and ability... Hermida isn't THAT good, he plays the game with passion just as everyone on the Marlins does Actually, I think it is fair. There are balls in the outfield, where it just looks to me, as if he's not hustling, often times. He's an easy-going player. Not intense, at all. Of course, he can hit 25-30 HR's, and get 90-100 RBI's if healthy a full season, so it really balances out. He'll be a good ballplayer. Since we're on good terms, I'll respond to you I think that's more a function of him not overrunning plays he can't otherwise make, he's no Andruw Jones in the OF, and he knows it, sure he has mental lapses... but c'mon, he's 24 :whistle It could be that. Whatever it is, I hope he improves out there, first and foremost. I'm not worried about his production at the plate, and I personally don't see why people are so critical of him, as a hitter. He can hit. As a matter of fact, I think he's the type that will get better at the plate, and once we leave the football stadium in a couple years, I say he'll really thrive. Have you seen his home / road splits from last year?
April 9, 200818 yr Hermida has the minor league track record to demonstrate his major league achievements Then what has been his problem turning that minor league success into major league glory ? He has had ? season of good in parts of 3 seasons.
April 9, 200818 yr Hermida out performed Uggla in every offensive category but HR last year including OPS (.870 to .805) and BA/RISP (.287 to .199!). If you look at home runs per AB Hermida was .042 and Uggla .049, not a huge difference. So who has more value? How many games did Uggla play in and how many did Hermida miss in 2007 ? I'd say the guy who was in more games is of better value. Also again, this was for ? a season. What about Hermida's 2006 season stats ? Are they better than Uggla's 2006 ? So far its not close as far as power hitting goes, that much I am pretty sure I am right about. HE PLAYED IN 3/4 OF THE FRICKIN SEASON AFTER SUFFERING A FLUKE INJURY... HOME RUNS ARE NOT THE BEST MEASURE OF POWER HITTING, STOP COMPARING UGGLA TO HERMIDA, IT'S APPLES TO ORANGES!!!! :banghead :banghead :banghead WE ARE SHOWING YOU STATISTICS THAT SAY HERMIDA IS A BETTER BASEBALL PLAYER THAN UGGLA BUT YOU JUST IGNORE THEM... WHY? WHY DO YOU DO THIS TO ME?!?!?!? :crying :crying :crying
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.