April 9, 200818 yr Injuries Hermida has suffered: 1) Hamstring 2) Fluke foul ball in the knee so...... ? I'm guessing most people who call him fragile have never pulled a hamstring. Not trying to "go there" but comparing a haingnail to a pulled hamstring = lol
April 9, 200818 yr And yet he posts still reflects like 30% of peoples thoughts on hermida (Although atleast that's down from 80% from last year).
April 9, 200818 yr Uggla isn't half the player Hermida is. Uggla has done more than twice as much for this team as Hermida has. The latter will be lucky to have a season in his career as good as Uggla's rookie year. I'm not that down on Hermida but he still has only shown glimpses of his potential whereas Uggla has been an allstar caliber player. Actually, now that I think about it, very few second basemen have ever had the season that Uggla had his rookie year. And its not like his year last year was awful either- his power made up for the loss in average.
April 9, 200818 yr Uggla isn't half the player Hermida is. Uggla has done more than twice as much for this team as Hermida has. The latter will be lucky to have a season in his career as good as Uggla's rookie year. I'm not that down on Hermida but he still has only shown glimpses of his potential whereas Uggla has been an allstar caliber player. Actually, now that I think about it, very few second basemen have ever had the season that Uggla had his rookie year. And its not like his year last year was awful either- his power made up for the loss in average. Hermida last year was better than Uggla's best.
April 9, 200818 yr Hermida last year was better than Uggla's best. I would take Hermida's future over Uggla's future. With that said, in both of his season Uggla created 101 and 100 runs while Hermida created 76 last season. If Hermida hadn't missed abput 40 games he likely would have created more runs than Uggla's best year but the fact is he missed those 40 games and that cannot be ignored. How does Uggla's 06 compares to Hermida's '07 in those VoRP, WARP or whatever those stats you always use are called?
April 9, 200818 yr I really don't get how you can dislike Hermida. Yeah he got hurt last year, but he played really well the second half of the season. And he is only 24. HRs aren't everything. He is a line drive hitter, not just a straight power guy like some of the guys in our lineup. He will hit around .300, take some walks, and hit a bunch of doubles and hit a few over the fence. To me, he is the epitome of a 2 slot hitter on a good team. I just am tired of him always being "The Promise". He needs to make it happen now, this time he is here, or you have to consider him to be a bust. He's had how many chances now ? 2005, 06, 07 and now 08....if someone doesn't turn into a star by then, chances are they don't ever live up the "supposed potential". Look at Hanley, David Wright, Prince Fielder, A-Rod, Miggy, or Ken Griffey Jr. They were all stars and everyone knew it. It shone right through from the start. People around the country knew who they were, and were talking about them, and players feared them. When have you heard Hermida's name on a list of up and coming players to be watched for ? Never ! Some folks here I think just tend to be too loyal, and don't take an objective look at the reality of the situation. The stats speak for themselves. He has had parts of 4 seaons to make an impression and has less at bats then Uggla in 2 seasons + 7 games, and Uggla (a 2nd baseman) has more than twice as many HR's. Hanley has almost twice as many with 48, Willingham has 50......so what gives ? When do you look at the stats and call him a bust ? One good half of last season, doesn't make him worth the high pick we wasted on him. He should have paid off with at least 70 HR's and won us some games carrying the team on his back. He just doesn't strike me as that kind of player. Yes some here think I am trolling because I dare to critizise a player. Big deal, its my opinion.
April 9, 200818 yr Hermida last year was better than Uggla's best. In terms of what? Stats & averages? Uggla has produced a lot more. Now you can say the difference in raw numbers has to do with Hermida being injured & such, and I agree. But I don't think that's irrelevant. I mean hell, lets all not forget how Dan Uggla became our #2 hitter - he filled in to replace an injured Hermida in what? the second week of 06? Then put Uggla in perspective based on the position he plays too. Led all ML 2B in more than few offensive categories. And if we really wanted to just play averages without consideration to raw numbers and games played, then Cody was far better than Hermida last year as well, hitting 335 with a 411 OBP and 653 SLG.
April 9, 200818 yr I just am tired of him always being "The Promise". He needs to make it happen now, this time he is here, or you have to consider him to be a bust. He's had how many chances now ? 2005, 06, 07 and now 08....if someone doesn't turn into a star by then, chances are they don't ever live up the "supposed potential". So, if someone isn't a STAR by age 23-24, then... well they are not a good player. Shoot, Hermida has shown in almost every non-injury affected opportunity that he can put up good-great numbers. Look at Hanley, David Wright, Prince Fielder, A-Rod, Miggy, or Ken Griffey Jr. They were all stars and everyone knew it. It shone right through from the start. People around the country knew who they were, and were talking about them, and players feared them. When have you heard Hermida's name on a list of up and coming players to be watched for ? Never ! You just compared one player to 6 of the best ballplayers that this generation has seen. That is an unfair comparable for ANYONE. Some people pick it up at an earlier age than others. Some pick it up and have some bad luck. Some folks here I think just tend to be too loyal, and don't take an objective look at the reality of the situation. The stats speak for themselves. He has had parts of 4 seaons to make an impression and has less at bats then Uggla in 2 seasons + 7 games, and Uggla (a 2nd baseman) has more than twice as many HR's. Hanley has almost twice as many with 48, Willingham has 50......so what gives ? When do you look at the stats and call him a bust ? I think some people mistake objectivity with "what have you done for me lately" Hermida's been out, and that's tough, but it doesn't mean he isn't good. And when he comes back, and sheds this bad luck, you will jump back on the bandwagon and say stuff like "oh, well, he's just gonna get hurt again" (which is a great way to speak of ANY professional athlete ) or "I knew it all along, he just needed someone to light a fire underneath him" Secondly, and it's been said before HRs are not the end-all and be-all of stats. For someone that claims to be objective, focusing in on one stat really disproves that quickly. To begin, you made that unfair comparison to Hanley (a once-in-a-generation hitter) Uggla (one of the best power hitting second basemen of this generation, behind like only... Soriano and Kent) and Willingham (a middle of the order player). Also, do you see how ridiculous the statement that "HE HAS FEWER HRs IN LESS ABs" is??? One good half of last season, doesn't make him worth the high pick we wasted on him. He should have paid off with at least 70 HR's and won us some games carrying the team on his back. He just doesn't strike me as that kind of player. Yes some here think I am trolling because I dare to critizise a player. Big deal, its my opinion. Again, HRs are not the be-all and end-all... he's consistently put up good-great offensive numbers in the minors/majors when he's healthy... his health is a reflection of bad luck, not durability issues... And we don't think you're trolling because you criticized a player... we think you're trolling because MOST of your posts have been cynical/criticizing of ANYTHING Marlins... sans two, a dirty joke and a site that pokes fun at translations.
April 9, 200818 yr I really don't get how you can dislike Hermida. Yeah he got hurt last year, but he played really well the second half of the season. And he is only 24. HRs aren't everything. He is a line drive hitter, not just a straight power guy like some of the guys in our lineup. He will hit around .300, take some walks, and hit a bunch of doubles and hit a few over the fence. To me, he is the epitome of a 2 slot hitter on a good team. I just am tired of him always being "The Promise". He needs to make it happen now, this time he is here, or you have to consider him to be a bust. He's had how many chances now ? 2005, 06, 07 and now 08....if someone doesn't turn into a star by then, chances are they don't ever live up the "supposed potential". Look at Hanley, David Wright, Prince Fielder, A-Rod, Miggy, or Ken Griffey Jr. They were all stars and everyone knew it. It shone right through from the start. People around the country knew who they were, and were talking about them, and players feared them. When have you heard Hermida's name on a list of up and coming players to be watched for ? Never ! Some folks here I think just tend to be too loyal, and don't take an objective look at the reality of the situation. The stats speak for themselves. He has had parts of 4 seaons to make an impression and has less at bats then Uggla in 2 seasons + 7 games, and Uggla (a 2nd baseman) has more than twice as many HR's. Hanley has almost twice as many with 48, Willingham has 50......so what gives ? When do you look at the stats and call him a bust ? One good half of last season, doesn't make him worth the high pick we wasted on him. He should have paid off with at least 70 HR's and won us some games carrying the team on his back. He just doesn't strike me as that kind of player. Yes some here think I am trolling because I dare to critizise a player. Big deal, its my opinion. That's right. It's your opinion and you have every right to express it here. No one said you couldn't. It's just that you're opinion is wrong. Hermida was a rookie in 06 and was hurt for most of it. He started 07 hurt but by mid season he turned it on and had a great second half. This season just started and he missed the first week. So please, tell me again how he has played 4 seasons? I count two seasons played and now entering his third. The key word being entering which means it hasn't been played yet. Also, I'm sure you're not counting a cup of coffee call up in 05 as a season for him either. He actually tore it up at the MLB level the only time he was completely healthy. By the way. I love Uggla, but he is not even on the same field of talent as Hermida. Uggla is an over achiever while Hermida is only behind Hanley in talent. That's of course until Maybin comes up. Hermida is better than Hammer, Jacobs, and Uggla. Don't get me wrong. Hammer, Jacobs , and Uggla are solid contributors but they are not stars in the making. Hermida is a star in the making. The only thing holding him back, and that could hold him back are the injuries.
April 9, 200818 yr Hermida's 2007 stat line is excellent. If you are going to start talking about potential busts maybe you should at least devote your attention to Mike Jacobs.
April 9, 200818 yr That's right. It's your opinion and you have every right to express it here. No one said you couldn't. It's just that you're opinion is wrong. Hermida was a rookie in 06 and was hurt for most of it. He started 07 hurt but by mid season he turned it on and had a great second half. This season just started and he missed the first week. So please, tell me again how he has played 4 seasons? I count two seasons played and now entering his third. The key word being entering which means it hasn't been played yet. Also, I'm sure you're not counting a cup of coffee call up in 05 as a season for him either. He actually tore it up at the MLB level the only time he was completely healthy. By the way. I love Uggla, but he is not even on the same field of talent as Hermida. Uggla is an over achiever while Hermida is only behind Hanley in talent. That's of course until Maybin comes up. Hermida is better than Hammer, Jacobs, and Uggla. Don't get me wrong. Hammer, Jacobs , and Uggla are solid contributors but they are not stars in the making. Hermida is a star in the making. The only thing holding him back, and that could hold him back are the injuries. Maybe it's simply that we value performance - achievement if you will - over talent. I mean you may be spot on about everything here, but what does it matter? If Uggla is producing around 100 runs or so for the team, while Hermida is producing maybe 70, who is doing more for the team? Is this even a question? What good is talent not realized? Whether due to injuries or anything else? Don't get me wrong. I do want Hermida to be healthy, and to become the OBP machine everyone says he can be in the #2 spot. But the guy hasn't had a big year yet, and hasn't established himself as anything remarkable YET. I hope that he does turn it around this season, but again, starting the season on the DL is hardly promising. And it may not be fair to hold it against him, but if he's not playing, he's not contributing. Hermida's 2007 stat line is excellent. If you are going to start talking about potential busts maybe you should at least devote your attention to Mike Jacobs. Bust? Was Mike Jacobs ever a highly touted prospect/projected as a ROTY candidate/top draft pick? I was under the impression that he was regula minor leaguer in the Mets system who got called up, had Pedro campaign to keep him up, and then had a good month or two in the bigs in 05 (before we got him). I remember when 06 started Hermida was supposedly the one to watch as a possible ROTY, and when 06 was over we had plenty of candidates, but Hermida wasn't there.
April 9, 200818 yr Maybe it's simply that we value performance - achievement if you will - over talent. I mean you may be spot on about everything here, but what does it matter? If Uggla is producing around 100 runs or so for the team, while Hermida is producing maybe 70, who is doing more for the team? Is this even a question? What good is talent not realized? Whether due to injuries or anything else? Don't get me wrong. I do want Hermida to be healthy, and to become the OBP machine everyone says he can be in the #2 spot. But the guy hasn't had a big year yet, and hasn't established himself as anything remarkable YET. I hope that he does turn it around this season, but again, starting the season on the DL is hardly promising. And it may not be fair to hold it against him, but if he's not playing, he's not contributing. Grand slam in first at bat, awesome numbers last year, minor league track record to prove the awesome numbers weren't flukey. Yes performance > talent, but this guy is pretty much saying Hermida is a waste... which is pretty much crazy. Bust? Was Mike Jacobs ever a highly touted prospect/projected as a ROTY candidate/top draft pick? I was under the impression that he was regula minor leaguer in the Mets system who got called up, had Pedro campaign to keep him up, and then had a good month or two in the bigs in 05 (before we got him). I remember when 06 started Hermida was supposedly the one to watch as a possible ROTY, and when 06 was over we had plenty of candidates, but Hermida wasn't there. Mike Jacobs was having an awesome campaign that year with the Mets, albeit short, and Pedro recognized the fact that he would be way more valuable than the pitcher they wound up keeping off the roster... Pedro was right. Hermida wasn't a candidate for ROTY because ... a) you're now comparing him to Hanley, and it's safe to say, talent-wise, Hanley is on another level, and b)he was injured... it is extremely difficult to play the game well while you're injured
April 9, 200818 yr Um. Hermida has an .870 OPS as a 23 y/o even though he was basically doing his spring training on the fly the first month. Basically, the kid is going to be posting .900 OPS like, tomorrow.
April 9, 200818 yr Um. Hermida has an .870 OPS as a 23 y/o even though he was basically doing his spring training on the fly the first month. Basically, the kid is going to be posting .900 OPS like, tomorrow. The guys not looking at OPS, common man he thinks Ugglas a better hitter based on injuries and HR's alone. There are some who just appreciate HRs and RBI, and there is a group who appreciate OPS, OBP and sometimes AVE. Hes obviously not belonging to the latter. The guy has a beautiful swing, very patient, line drive hitter. A guy like Uggla will hit you some bombs, but that is virtually it.
April 9, 200818 yr Um. Hermida has an .870 OPS as a 23 y/o even though he was basically doing his spring training on the fly the first month. Basically, the kid is going to be posting .900 OPS like, tomorrow. The guys not looking at OPS, common man he thinks Ugglas a better hitter based on injuries and HR's alone. There are some who just appreciate HRs and RBI, and there is a group who appreciate OPS, OBP and sometimes AVE. Hes obviously not belonging to the latter. The guy has a beautiful swing, very patient, line drive hitter. A guy like Uggla will hit you some bombs, but that is virtually it. I think what bobbob is trying to say is, the group who likes OPS and OBP is always right, and the group who likes R, HR, and RBI, will always be wrong. The whole argument is retarded because you can't compare Uggla, batting # 2 between two of the best hitters in baseball and has appropriate spikes in R/RBI production because of it, compared to Hermida, predominantly batting # 6-7-8 around total Todd Linden, Reggie Abercrombie, and Miguel Olivo douchebags and does not have the relative R/RBI spike. This is why you have to judge players offensively with OPS (and I mean simplistically because obviously warps, eqa, vorps, etc are superior), because a players OPS is directly related to THEIR contribution of offense, versus stats that are reflected by OTHERS performance. You plop Hermida 680 PA between Hanley and Cabrera, and that is going obliterate Uggla's R/RBI production. It's that easy.
April 9, 200818 yr Hermida's 2007 stat line is excellent. If you are going to start talking about potential busts maybe you should at least devote your attention to Mike Jacobs. Oh I don't disagree with that. He has been extremely underwhelming in offensive production. But his potential was never considered as great as was Hermida's ceiling. People on the board here talk about Hermida as though he is Super Human, and as of yet, I have not seen that, or anything close to it. Just to clear the air, I am not a stat guy, or anything more than just a typical fan. And I have been a Marlins fan since the 1st pitch of a minor league game in which John Lynch threw for us as the 1st game in organization history. I love Uggla, because he is a classic overachiever, and has done more with less talent than someone like Miggy has in his pinky finger. Hermida perhaps will have the breakout year this year, and I hope he does, but I just think its silly for this team and the fans to put their faith in a guy that just continues to disappoint year after year. At some point you just need to move on, and cut the ties, and see if someone else can do the job better.
April 9, 200818 yr You DON'T cut ties with talented 24 year olds... unless they have a career ENDING injury it's just something you DON'T do.... stop suggesting we "cut ties" with Hermida, it's ridiculous that you'd suggest a 24 year old with uber talent be "washed up" almost to the point of genuinely being irritating Case in point: Josh Hamilton
April 9, 200818 yr You DON'T cut ties with talented 24 year olds... unless they have a career ENDING injury it's just something you DON'T do.... stop suggesting we "cut ties" with Hermida, it's ridiculous that you'd suggest a 24 year old with uber talent be "washed up" almost to the point of genuinely being irritating Case in point: Josh Hamilton Josh may or may not turn out to be an answer for the Rangers, but both Tampa Bay and Cinicinnati didn't see enough to keep him. I find it ridiculous we still have (or had during spring training) Jeff Allison in our organization. Talk about a worst bust than Hermida, Allison is right above Josh Booty in that catagory. All in all the Marlins have only a mediocre at best drafting history. Certainly they hit on Josh Beckett, Charles Johnson and Adrian Gonzalez, but other than that its all been FA signings or trades. Its a good thing Beinfest has hit on some trades or this franchise would really be in trouble.
April 9, 200818 yr You DON'T cut ties with talented 24 year olds... unless they have a career ENDING injury it's just something you DON'T do.... stop suggesting we "cut ties" with Hermida, it's ridiculous that you'd suggest a 24 year old with uber talent be "washed up" almost to the point of genuinely being irritating Case in point: Josh Hamilton Josh may or may not turn out to be an answer for the Rangers, but both Tampa Bay and Cinicinnati didn't see enough to keep him. I find it ridiculous we still have (or had during spring training) Jeff Allison in our organization. Talk about a worst bust than Hermida, Allison is right above Josh Booty in that catagory. All in all the Marlins have only a mediocre at best drafting history. Certainly they hit on Josh Beckett, Charles Johnson and Adrian Gonzalez, but other than that its all been FA signings or trades. Its a good thing Beinfest has hit on some trades or this franchise would really be in trouble. Cincinnatti needed pitching more than they needed hitting, that's the only reason they traded Hamilton...
April 9, 200818 yr I think drug addiction falls into a different category than "bust", I mean we have no idea how he would've turned out without the addiction. But whatever.
April 9, 200818 yr Grand slam in first at bat, awesome numbers last year, minor league track record to prove the awesome numbers weren't flukey. Yes performance > talent, but this guy is pretty much saying Hermida is a waste... which is pretty much crazy. I didn't say it was flukey, but the guy has had one good half season. A GS in his first AB? So what? Plenty of people hit HRs in their first AB, they don't all get to come on with bases loaded. He didn't say Hermida was a waste - but did say that he has yet to justify being such a high draft pick. It's not that he's no good, but that he hasn't shown that he can consistently be that good. Again, what makes his ? season explosion last year where he hit 340/405/555 truly indicative of his talent? Uggla hit 307/355/510 for half a season once, and no one seems to think that is indicative of his abilities. If people just *gasp* look at their career stats you'd see what should already be obvious - Hermida hits for a bit better average and OBP, albeit inconsistently, and Uggla is a power-hitting free-swinger. Mike Jacobs was having an awesome campaign that year with the Mets, albeit short, and Pedro recognized the fact that he would be way more valuable than the pitcher they wound up keeping off the roster... Pedro was right. Yes, Jake had an a nice month or two up with the Mets in 2005. But he was never (to my knowledge) this highly touted prospect who was to be the future of the team the way Hermida was, so I still disagree with calling him a bust. Hermida wasn't a candidate for ROTY because ... a) you're now comparing him to Hanley, and it's safe to say, talent-wise, Hanley is on another level, and Hanley was here when people when people were predicting Hermida would be ROTY before the 2006 season started, so it's not like everyone immediately recognized that Hanley was as much better than Hermida as he is. People figured it out as Hanley emerged and Hermida floundered in 06. b)he was injured... it is extremely difficult to play the game well while you're injured Yes, and this is not irrelevant. We can say "it's not his fault, he's hurt", but again, durability is not irrelevant. The Marlins will be playing 162 games every year so far as I know in the forseeable future. How many of them can we count on Hermida for? Is it not relevant when a starting position player misses 30-60 games a season?
April 9, 200818 yr Hermida has the minor league track record to demonstrate his major league achievements I never said Jake was a bust, I was saying that he came over with HIGH expectations though People picked Hermida ahead of Hanley based on ML service time, and the fact that Hanley had "regressed" when in all actuality, he was bored in the minors His injuries are flukey, once he shakes the bad luck, he will prove everyone wrong, and everyone will be a Hermida fan
April 9, 200818 yr Hermida out performed Uggla in every offensive category but HR last year including OPS (.870 to .805) and BA/RISP (.287 to .199!). If you look at home runs per AB Hermida was .042 and Uggla .049, not a huge difference. So who has more value?
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.