Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Comeback Player of the Year

Featured Replies

Remember, to win this awrad the player must have had a good year once or more than once before so a rookie or a bench player who finally gets to play dont qualify.

Tatis will probably get it but if Cantu hits some more jacks and gets his average back over .300, he could snag it.

I would've said Kerry Wood before the injury, but now i have to say Fernando Tatis, without him the mets are still 6 games back in the division.

The NL Comeback Player of the Year isn't even listed on the poll.

The NL Comeback Player of the Year isn't even listed on the poll.

Who would that be, oh cryptic one?

we all know AL Comeback player of the year and Cy Young Award winner should be Cliff Lee

The NL Comeback Player of the Year isn't even listed on the poll.

Who would that be, oh cryptic one?

 

 

Well, he might not exactly be THE GUY, but he's definitely worthy of being on the poll...he's a better choice than some of the guys on it.

 

Brad Lidge.

The NL Comeback Player of the Year isn't even listed on the poll.

Who would that be, oh cryptic one?

 

 

Well, he might not exactly be THE GUY, but he's definitely worthy of being on the poll...he's a better choice than some of the guys on it.

 

Brad Lidge.

 

Lidge would be a better choice than Backe, but still players like Cantu and Tatis have made more drastic changes over last year than Lidge. The one thing Lidge has done is lower the amount of HR's he's given, last year he gave up 9, this year so far 2.

The NL Comeback Player of the Year isn't even listed on the poll.

Who would that be, oh cryptic one?

 

 

Well, he might not exactly be THE GUY, but he's definitely worthy of being on the poll...he's a better choice than some of the guys on it.

 

Brad Lidge.

He wasn't nearly as bad last year as some of these guys. In 2006, yeah, but he was an average closer last year. 3.36 ERA, 1.254 WHIP. His low wasn't as low as a ton of these guys.

 

That said, here is a video I recorded of Lidge last year. Please excuse my crappy camera work.

 

I'll even set it up...

 

Brad Lidge in for the save. Astros up 4-3, 2 outs, 2 men on, 1-2 count on Ryan Braun.

The NL Comeback Player of the Year isn't even listed on the poll.

Who would that be, oh cryptic one?

 

 

Well, he might not exactly be THE GUY, but he's definitely worthy of being on the poll...he's a better choice than some of the guys on it.

 

Brad Lidge.

He wasn't nearly as bad last year as some of these guys. In 2006, yeah, but he was an average closer last year. 3.36 ERA, 1.254 WHIP. His low wasn't as low as a ton of these guys.

 

That said, here is a video I recorded of Lidge last year. Please excuse my crappy camera work.

 

I'll even set it up...

 

Brad Lidge in for the save. Astros up 4-3, 2 outs, 2 men on, 1-2 count on Ryan Braun.

 

 

 

 

The thing with Lidge is...he's so due for a blown save. He's been allowing baserunners; just hasn't completely blown a save yet. He's 28/28, and to his credit, has a 1.29 ERA in save situations.

 

But...I have a feeling he's overdue for a bad appearance in a save situation.

Tatis currently has less than 200 AB and he's not gonna break 300 AB

 

Cantu's over 450 AB and is gonna break 500 AB

 

so if it goes to tatis over cantu, that's bull

Tatis currently has less than 200 AB and he's not gonna break 300 AB

 

Cantu's over 450 AB and is gonna break 500 AB

 

so if it goes to tatis over cantu, that's bull

 

 

I dont think they take that into consideration.

how much a player plays should matter.

 

if tatis plays has double the playing time to put him on Cantu's time, there's no guarentee that his numbers would still be that good.

 

tatis is gonna have laround half a seasons AB. Getting come back player of the YEAR for HALF a year is bulls***.

how much a player plays should matter.

 

if tatis plays has double the playing time to put him on Cantu's time, there's no guarentee that his numbers would still be that good.

 

tatis is gonna have laround half a seasons AB. Getting come back player of the YEAR for HALF a year is bulls***.

 

 

If he only had 50 at bats that would be one thing, but I think 200 is enough.

Look who cantu had to replace and where he came from. remember, he wasnt even supposed to make the team. he was a non roster invitee. It has to go to Cantu

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.