October 8, 200818 yr Coghlan's not that great of a prospect to bring back a "very very very good prospect" in return. You must be thinking about another Chris Coghlan. Yeah your right Chris Coughlan wouldn't give us anything.They will give us a C prospect and it would just be one big lopsided trade for the other team. Your argument is very weak. Do you even have an argument?
October 8, 200818 yr Coghlan's not that great of a prospect to bring back a "very very very good prospect" in return. You must be thinking about another Chris Coghlan. Yeah your right Chris Coughlan wouldn't give us anything.They will give us a C prospect and it would just be one big lopsided trade for the other team. Your argument is very weak. Do you even have an argument? AND WHAT DOES YOUR SIG EVEN MEAN
October 8, 200818 yr Coghlan's not that great of a prospect to bring back a "very very very good prospect" in return. You must be thinking about another Chris Coghlan. Yeah your right Chris Coughlan wouldn't give us anything.They will give us a C prospect and it would just be one big lopsided trade for the other team. Your argument is very weak. You're not very good at evaluating prospects, are you? Coghlan isn't a top-tier prospect, really. You make no sense. His trade value right now isn't as good as you think it is.
October 9, 200818 yr Coghlan's not that great of a prospect to bring back a "very very very good prospect" in return. You must be thinking about another Chris Coghlan. Yeah your right Chris Coughlan wouldn't give us anything.They will give us a C prospect and it would just be one big lopsided trade for the other team. Your argument is very weak. You're not very good at evaluating prospects, are you? Coghlan isn't a top-tier prospect, really. You make no sense. His trade value right now isn't as good as you think it is. Coghlan is a grade B.Getting a grade B in return is very realistic.Perhaps a starting pitcher.
October 9, 200818 yr Coghlan's not that great of a prospect to bring back a "very very very good prospect" in return. You must be thinking about another Chris Coghlan. Yeah your right Chris Coughlan wouldn't give us anything.They will give us a C prospect and it would just be one big lopsided trade for the other team. Your argument is very weak. You're not very good at evaluating prospects, are you? Coghlan isn't a top-tier prospect, really. You make no sense. His trade value right now isn't as good as you think it is. Coghlan is a grade B.Getting a grade B in return is very realistic.Perhaps a starting pitcher. And why would the Marlins need a Grade B starting pitcher, at this point, when its uncertain they'll keep Uggla? My main question to you is...would you rather the team keep Uggla? Or do you think their priorities should be on keeping Nolasco & JJ? Anyways...it's highly debatable whether or not Coghlan is worth a Grade B SP prospect, at this point.
October 9, 200818 yr Coghlan's not that great of a prospect to bring back a "very very very good prospect" in return. You must be thinking about another Chris Coghlan. Yeah your right Chris Coughlan wouldn't give us anything.They will give us a C prospect and it would just be one big lopsided trade for the other team. Your argument is very weak. You're not very good at evaluating prospects, are you? Coghlan isn't a top-tier prospect, really. You make no sense. His trade value right now isn't as good as you think it is. Coghlan is a grade B.Getting a grade B in return is very realistic.Perhaps a starting pitcher. And why would the Marlins need a Grade B starting pitcher, at this point, when its uncertain they'll keep Uggla? My main question to you is...would you rather the team keep Uggla? Or do you think their priorities should be on keeping Nolasco & JJ? Anyways...it's highly debatable whether or not Coghlan is worth a Grade B SP prospect, at this point. We can definitely keep all 3 of those guys. Keeping or trading Uggla wouldn't affect us keeping Noly or JJ.
October 9, 200818 yr We can definitely keep all 3 of those guys. Keeping or trading Uggla wouldn't affect us keeping Noly or JJ. Yes...but trading Uggla can also give you very good value, as well...and this team has certain needs, in other areas. Coghlan, on the other hand...there's no point in trading him, imo. What are you really going to get for Chris Coghlan, that's worth trading him? If anything...stick with Uggla this year, and keep Coghlan in the minors. That's probably the best idea, at this point, really.
October 9, 200818 yr Yes...but trading Uggla can also give you very good value, as well...and this team has certain needs, in other areas. Coghlan, on the other hand...there's no point in trading him, imo. What are you really going to get for Chris Coghlan, that's worth trading him? If anything...stick with Uggla this year, and keep Coghlan in the minors. That's probably the best idea, at this point, really. Yeah, but that's not what you brought up. I was just calling you on implying that keeping Uggla would somehow mean we would have to lose Noly or JJ.
October 9, 200818 yr Yes...but trading Uggla can also give you very good value, as well...and this team has certain needs, in other areas. Coghlan, on the other hand...there's no point in trading him, imo. What are you really going to get for Chris Coghlan, that's worth trading him? If anything...stick with Uggla this year, and keep Coghlan in the minors. That's probably the best idea, at this point, really. Yeah, but that's not what you brought up. I was just calling you on implying that keeping Uggla would somehow mean we would have to lose Noly or JJ. Well...I kinda think it does, to be honest. I wouldn't trust Loria to keep all 3. I'm pretty sure he could pay all 3...but I don't see that happening. I don't see Uggla staying here long-term (I sound like a broken record by now b/c I've been saying this about Uggla for awhile).
October 9, 200818 yr Yes...but trading Uggla can also give you very good value, as well...and this team has certain needs, in other areas. Coghlan, on the other hand...there's no point in trading him, imo. What are you really going to get for Chris Coghlan, that's worth trading him? If anything...stick with Uggla this year, and keep Coghlan in the minors. That's probably the best idea, at this point, really. Yeah, but that's not what you brought up. I was just calling you on implying that keeping Uggla would somehow mean we would have to lose Noly or JJ. Well...I kinda think it does, to be honest. I wouldn't trust Loria to keep all 3. I'm pretty sure he could pay all 3...but I don't see that happening. I don't see Uggla staying here long-term (I sound like a broken record by now b/c I've been saying this about Uggla for awhile). You have to look at the easy calls. Gregg and Jacobs are gone. Johnson, Nolasco, and Amezaga will be retained. This leaves six other significant arbitration cases - Uggla, Hermida, Willingham, Olsen, Ross, and Cantu. They can afford 3-4 of them with a $35 million payroll, depending on what they do with the bench and bullpen. Cody and Cantu are probably pretty safe because they can play all over the OF and IF respectively, and help ease in younger options. This leaves, 1-2 of Uggla, Hermida, Willingham, and Olsen that they can keep. If you're keeping two here, it's very easy to keep Hermida and Uggla over a DH type and a 4th finesse starter (where you have 5 other SP options ready to go). If you're keeping one, that's when it gets scary because excellent arguments can be made for both of them. But having Coghlan and no corner OF ready in the minors, and Hermida still young enough to reach his upside, tips this to Hermida. I'm hopeful they keep both in 09, but this is really the only major question that I see for the front office. Uggla, Hermida, or both. It's not Uggla, Nolasco, or Johnson. That's just silly and not really looking at the situation.
October 9, 200818 yr Yes...but trading Uggla can also give you very good value, as well...and this team has certain needs, in other areas. Coghlan, on the other hand...there's no point in trading him, imo. What are you really going to get for Chris Coghlan, that's worth trading him? If anything...stick with Uggla this year, and keep Coghlan in the minors. That's probably the best idea, at this point, really. Yeah, but that's not what you brought up. I was just calling you on implying that keeping Uggla would somehow mean we would have to lose Noly or JJ. Well...I kinda think it does, to be honest. I wouldn't trust Loria to keep all 3. I'm pretty sure he could pay all 3...but I don't see that happening. I don't see Uggla staying here long-term (I sound like a broken record by now b/c I've been saying this about Uggla for awhile). You have to look at the easy calls. Gregg and Jacobs are gone. Johnson, Nolasco, and Amezaga will be retained. This leaves six other significant arbitration cases - Uggla, Hermida, Willingham, Olsen, Ross, and Cantu. They can afford 3-4 of them with a $35 million payroll, depending on what they do with the bench and bullpen. Cody and Cantu are probably pretty safe because they can play all over the OF and IF respectively, and help ease in younger options. This leaves, 1-2 of Uggla, Hermida, Willingham, and Olsen that they can keep. If you're keeping two here, it's very easy to keep Hermida and Uggla over a DH type and a 4th finesse starter (where you have 5 other SP options ready to go). If you're keeping one, that's when it gets scary because excellent arguments can be made for both of them. But having Coghlan and no corner OF ready in the minors, and Hermida still young enough to reach his upside, tips this to Hermida. I'm hopeful they keep both in 09, but this is really the only major question that I see for the front office. Uggla, Hermida, or both. It's not Uggla, Nolasco, or Johnson. That's just silly and not really looking at the situation. I'd rather have Hermida, as well.
October 9, 200818 yr Yes...but trading Uggla can also give you very good value, as well...and this team has certain needs, in other areas. Coghlan, on the other hand...there's no point in trading him, imo. What are you really going to get for Chris Coghlan, that's worth trading him? If anything...stick with Uggla this year, and keep Coghlan in the minors. That's probably the best idea, at this point, really. Yeah, but that's not what you brought up. I was just calling you on implying that keeping Uggla would somehow mean we would have to lose Noly or JJ. Well...I kinda think it does, to be honest. I wouldn't trust Loria to keep all 3. I'm pretty sure he could pay all 3...but I don't see that happening. I don't see Uggla staying here long-term (I sound like a broken record by now b/c I've been saying this about Uggla for awhile). You have to look at the easy calls. Gregg and Jacobs are gone. Johnson, Nolasco, and Amezaga will be retained. This leaves six other significant arbitration cases - Uggla, Hermida, Willingham, Olsen, Ross, and Cantu. They can afford 3-4 of them with a $35 million payroll, depending on what they do with the bench and bullpen. Cody and Cantu are probably pretty safe because they can play all over the OF and IF respectively, and help ease in younger options. This leaves, 1-2 of Uggla, Hermida, Willingham, and Olsen that they can keep. If you're keeping two here, it's very easy to keep Hermida and Uggla over a DH type and a 4th finesse starter (where you have 5 other SP options ready to go). If you're keeping one, that's when it gets scary because excellent arguments can be made for both of them. But having Coghlan and no corner OF ready in the minors, and Hermida still young enough to reach his upside, tips this to Hermida. I'm hopeful they keep both in 09, but this is really the only major question that I see for the front office. Uggla, Hermida, or both. It's not Uggla, Nolasco, or Johnson. That's just silly and not really looking at the situation. I'd rather have Hermida, as well. Yes you would and it if comes down to both of them, despite me like Uggla more than Hermida, our depth just falls in a way that makes trading Danny the right choice. But it's perfectly reasonable to see us keeping both of them.
October 9, 200818 yr Author In a situation that comes down to keeping 2 out Uggla, Hermida, Willingham, and Olsen, my choice is pretty clear. Uggla's trade value is as high as it will ever be, and will bring this team a very valuable piece. And in trading Uggla, you meet your immediate goal of increasing team speed and defense, considering I think his most likely immediate successor will be Andino, not Coghlan (A. I don't think Coghlan is ready, B. Providing Andino a chance could boost his future trade value significantly). Hermida will be retained, not a doubt in my mind. I do think someone needs to light a fire under his ass, but he's just too damn talented to let walk at this point. Willingham is going to be easily replaced by Ross, at worst. If Ross isn't out there full-time next year, it's because we found a greater option via trade. Olsen should be retained if this franchise is ready to win NOW. Anibal Sanchez is great and all, I'd love to watch him develop, but he could bring us a really nice piece as well, and he's just too inconsistent at this point in his career for my liking. Olsen improved too much for us to let him walk, and he gives us a second left-handed arm in the rotation aside Miller.
October 9, 200818 yr In a situation that comes down to keeping 2 out Uggla, Hermida, Willingham, and Olsen, my choice is pretty clear. Uggla's trade value is as high as it will ever be, and will bring this team a very valuable piece. And in trading Uggla, you meet your immediate goal of increasing team speed and defense, considering I think his most likely immediate successor will be Andino, not Coghlan (A. I don't think Coghlan is ready, B. Providing Andino a chance could boost his future trade value significantly). Hermida will be retained, not a doubt in my mind. I do think someone needs to light a fire under his ass, but he's just too damn talented to let walk at this point. Willingham is going to be easily replaced by Ross, at worst. If Ross isn't out there full-time next year, it's because we found a greater option via trade. Olsen should be retained if this franchise is ready to win NOW. Anibal Sanchez is great and all, I'd love to watch him develop, but he could bring us a really nice piece as well, and he's just too inconsistent at this point in his career for my liking. Olsen improved too much for us to let him walk, and he gives us a second left-handed arm in the rotation aside Miller. I dislike Andino...and Sanchez is better than most teams' #5, when healthy. You have to take Olsen / Sanchez contracts into consideration, as well. Also...I'm unsure if Sanchez would bring us a nice return, as you say. As young as he is...and as good of an '06 2nd half he had, fact remains he's coming back, from a torn labrum. That will, easily, decrease his trade value.
October 9, 200818 yr Author In a situation that comes down to keeping 2 out Uggla, Hermida, Willingham, and Olsen, my choice is pretty clear. Uggla's trade value is as high as it will ever be, and will bring this team a very valuable piece. And in trading Uggla, you meet your immediate goal of increasing team speed and defense, considering I think his most likely immediate successor will be Andino, not Coghlan (A. I don't think Coghlan is ready, B. Providing Andino a chance could boost his future trade value significantly). Hermida will be retained, not a doubt in my mind. I do think someone needs to light a fire under his ass, but he's just too damn talented to let walk at this point. Willingham is going to be easily replaced by Ross, at worst. If Ross isn't out there full-time next year, it's because we found a greater option via trade. Olsen should be retained if this franchise is ready to win NOW. Anibal Sanchez is great and all, I'd love to watch him develop, but he could bring us a really nice piece as well, and he's just too inconsistent at this point in his career for my liking. Olsen improved too much for us to let him walk, and he gives us a second left-handed arm in the rotation aside Miller. I dislike Andino...and Sanchez is better than most teams' #5, when healthy. You have to take Olsen / Sanchez contracts into consideration, as well. Also...I'm unsure if Sanchez would bring us a nice return, as you say. As young as he is...and as good of an '06 2nd half he had, fact remains he's coming back, from a torn labrum. That will, easily, decrease his trade value. Scott Olsen will help this team much more than Sanchez will in 2009. And at $2.5 Million, Olsen is a bargain. This is a left-handed kid that just threw for 200 innings with a 4.20 ERA. Sanchez hasn't even proven to be healthy in 2 years. When he is, he hasn't been consistent.
October 9, 200818 yr In a situation that comes down to keeping 2 out Uggla, Hermida, Willingham, and Olsen, my choice is pretty clear. Uggla's trade value is as high as it will ever be, and will bring this team a very valuable piece. And in trading Uggla, you meet your immediate goal of increasing team speed and defense, considering I think his most likely immediate successor will be Andino, not Coghlan (A. I don't think Coghlan is ready, B. Providing Andino a chance could boost his future trade value significantly). Hermida will be retained, not a doubt in my mind. I do think someone needs to light a fire under his ass, but he's just too damn talented to let walk at this point. Willingham is going to be easily replaced by Ross, at worst. If Ross isn't out there full-time next year, it's because we found a greater option via trade. Olsen should be retained if this franchise is ready to win NOW. Anibal Sanchez is great and all, I'd love to watch him develop, but he could bring us a really nice piece as well, and he's just too inconsistent at this point in his career for my liking. Olsen improved too much for us to let him walk, and he gives us a second left-handed arm in the rotation aside Miller. I dislike Andino...and Sanchez is better than most teams' #5, when healthy. You have to take Olsen / Sanchez contracts into consideration, as well. Also...I'm unsure if Sanchez would bring us a nice return, as you say. As young as he is...and as good of an '06 2nd half he had, fact remains he's coming back, from a torn labrum. That will, easily, decrease his trade value. Scott Olsen will help this team much more than Sanchez will in 2009. And at $2.5 Million, Olsen is a bargain. This is a left-handed kid that just threw for 200 innings with a 4.20 ERA. Sanchez hasn't even proven to be healthy in 2 years. When he is, he hasn't been consistent. Consistent isn't a word linked with Olsen, either. I'd much rather keep Sanchez, and pay Uggla instead of Olsen (considering the last 3 options would be Uggla / Hermida / Olsen, as Lou states).
October 9, 200818 yr Author In a situation that comes down to keeping 2 out Uggla, Hermida, Willingham, and Olsen, my choice is pretty clear. Uggla's trade value is as high as it will ever be, and will bring this team a very valuable piece. And in trading Uggla, you meet your immediate goal of increasing team speed and defense, considering I think his most likely immediate successor will be Andino, not Coghlan (A. I don't think Coghlan is ready, B. Providing Andino a chance could boost his future trade value significantly). Hermida will be retained, not a doubt in my mind. I do think someone needs to light a fire under his ass, but he's just too damn talented to let walk at this point. Willingham is going to be easily replaced by Ross, at worst. If Ross isn't out there full-time next year, it's because we found a greater option via trade. Olsen should be retained if this franchise is ready to win NOW. Anibal Sanchez is great and all, I'd love to watch him develop, but he could bring us a really nice piece as well, and he's just too inconsistent at this point in his career for my liking. Olsen improved too much for us to let him walk, and he gives us a second left-handed arm in the rotation aside Miller. I dislike Andino...and Sanchez is better than most teams' #5, when healthy. You have to take Olsen / Sanchez contracts into consideration, as well. Also...I'm unsure if Sanchez would bring us a nice return, as you say. As young as he is...and as good of an '06 2nd half he had, fact remains he's coming back, from a torn labrum. That will, easily, decrease his trade value. Scott Olsen will help this team much more than Sanchez will in 2009. And at $2.5 Million, Olsen is a bargain. This is a left-handed kid that just threw for 200 innings with a 4.20 ERA. Sanchez hasn't even proven to be healthy in 2 years. When he is, he hasn't been consistent. Consistent isn't a word linked with Olsen, either. I'd much rather keep Sanchez, and pay Uggla instead of Olsen (considering the last 3 options would be Uggla / Hermida / Olsen, as Lou states). Olsen was much more consistent this season than maybe expected, and his durability is key. Plus, you have to realize keeping Olsen is probably at a rate of about $2.5 Million. Uggla is going to get $5+ Million. And placing Andino at second and keeping Olsen is mirroring what this franchise is trying to accomplish: pitching, speed, defense.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.