Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins Built for 2009

Featured Replies

I understand, Raynor is the exact same age as Hermida, makes me wary of the guy, i haven't seen the guy play, so i cannot judge him by what i have seen, just by what i have heard. And the comparisions i have heard is that of a Juan Pierre, which makes me excited about the possibilities. Most of u hate on Pierre, but he was a great player for us, constant 200 hit guy

 

 

Hermida produced much better #'s at the age of 21 in 'AA than Raynor did this year at the age of 24.

 

You've changed the topic of this thread, and have added a whole lot of nonsense to it. It's a shame...it was a nice article.

He doesnt suck. He just had a bad year.

 

 

 

Bad year my a**, he has no desire for the game. He shows that every time he is on the field. I would rather see some other team deal with his a**

 

 

Go and look at his 2007 stats. When you do, come back and tell me how he did that year

 

And You believe there is no such thing as a one year wonder

 

 

If he was 32 years old, and the marlins were his 5 team, then yea, he wouldve been a one year wonder. BUT, he was 23 years old. And he tore it up. Thats called POTENTIAL.

 

I would've considered it a breakout year if he came back this year and put up at least similar #'s, but he didn't.

How do you have a breakout year by having the same season as the last one?

 

 

It should've been a breakout year. A breakout year is supposed to be followed by a year where he begins to show himself as a star player on the team, the problem is he digressed. I am just saying i really have seen much improvement in Hermida's game. He hasn't improved his fielding, and my biggest issue with him is that he hasn't decided what kind of hitter he is, thus making it harder for Fredi to decide where to put him in the lineup

That's not what a breakout year means.

 

Noly had a breakout year. Ryan Ludwick had a breakout year.

Hermida still needs time to grow. We need to stick with him for one more year IMO. Willingham can probably command something real decent on the trade market. I think he needs to be the one to go, especially with the season Ross had. I think Cody can be more successful next year full-time, and will be much more comfortable in left field.

 

This is what I believe but I just dont think they could get much for Willingham.

 

 

Ok, now back to the ACTUAL TOPIC.

 

I believe the Marlins should stick with Olsen, i dont believe Sanchez is as good as him

And until Miller proves he has matured and is ready, neither is he.

 

Marlins want better defense? Let's start with giving Hanley a smaller glove!

Im sure that wont cost around $21 million dollars >_>

Marlins want better defense? Let's start with giving Hanley a smaller glove!

Im sure that wont cost around $21 million dollars >_>

Hanley was an above average defender in 2008. He is not the problem.

Marlins want better defense? Let's start with giving Hanley a smaller glove!

Im sure that wont cost around $21 million dollars >_>

Hanley was an above average defender in 2008. He is not the problem.

He'd be better if he got better at moving the ball from glove to hand.

Marlins want better defense? Let's start with giving Hanley a smaller glove!

Im sure that wont cost around $21 million dollars >_>

Hanley was an above average defender in 2008. He is not the problem.

 

 

 

Not me, but according to some people it was Hanley's defense that cost us a playoff spot (Braves game).

  • Author

Back to the article, I'm just ready for the off-season to unfold. There's so many different directions this club could take, that speculation this season is going to be more rampant than ever before. It's a good rpoblem to have though. I think any direction Beinfest heads, we're going to field a competitive team, guaranteed.

pitchers that K a lot of players tend to usually have more injuries in the future

 

Huh? That's completely false. POWER pitchers tend to have more injuries, yes, but there's no guarantee power pitchers are always successful with Ks.

I prefer to look at history...Actually most of the durable pitchers were power pitchers

Seaver, Ryan, Carlton, Clemons, Hunter, ......

Hermida still needs time to grow. We need to stick with him for one more year IMO. Willingham can probably command something real decent on the trade market. I think he needs to be the one to go, especially with the season Ross had. I think Cody can be more successful next year full-time, and will be much more comfortable in left field.

 

 

Of course, we all know Cody is staying. I really don't see the trade value we could get for Willingham. Sure if he was healthy all year and kept up what he did in the first month and a half for an entire year then he would've commanded some trade value, but he has a history of back issues, and is nothing more than a short first baseman with minimal power at this point in his career

 

As long as you get Willingham healthy, you literally know exactly what you're getting: .260+ avg, .360+ obp, 20+ HR, 90+ rbi.

 

That will ALWAYS be worth something. He has never missed significant time in his career until this season. That, mixed with the fact Herminda is five years younger and left-handed, is why I want him gone.

Willy will probably never be able to play more than 125 games per season. His back condition will forever limit his career

That made no sense.

Why doesn't it work the other way around? Y'know...players have bad years. Especially players at Hermida's age. Not everyone develops like Hanley Ramirez.

but a Carlos Quentin typer turnaround is part of the rarity in baseball. We somehow expect Hermida to suddenly do what very few in baseball have done

Dim there are many late bloomers in baseball, the most famous being Koufax. Most recently you have Carlos Pe?a, Ryan Ludwick and Brandon Phillips. Not that unheard of as you appear to indicate

Marlins want better defense? Let's start with giving Hanley a smaller glove!

Im sure that wont cost around $21 million dollars >_>

Hanley was an above average defender in 2008. He is not the problem.

He'd be better if he got better at moving the ball from glove to hand.

I think getting a better 1B in there will help much as well, not just Hanley, but everyone else in the infield (wishes we still had D-Lee).

pitchers that K a lot of players tend to usually have more injuries in the future

 

You've forfeited the right to use words now... please stop

 

 

no, I have seen many power pitchers get injuries, its been rare to see a slow ball pitcher sustain many injuries

 

Power pitcher =/= Strikeout pitcher

 

and "slowball" pitchers can strike out plenty... see: Maddux, Greg or Hamels, Cole or any other number of pitchers that strike out plenty

 

Hamals thorws pretty hard around 93 or so most of the time. His out pitch is slow though.

I do hope we're built for '09. I certainly think the rotation and possibly bullpen could be perfectly set. If Andrew Miller is ready it could be scary good. 'Course the pen arms sometimes are a crap shoot but we're not short on options.

 

The position players I'm not sure will be ready for a series run...

 

Mostly because we don't yet know who's staying and who's leaving. It's not out of the question we could have new starters at 6 of the 8 positions from opening day last season. 1B, 2B, 3B, CF, LF, C.

 

Maybin's going to go through his struggles, no one's quite sure what to expect from Dallas if he's starting, Gaby's a rookie (as well as Cogs or Raynor or anyone else who might get called up), the jury's still out on Hermida, and we're not sure who'll be in left field. That's not to say rookies can't excel by the way, just that it's a question mark.

 

Now do I think it'll be that severe? No, I would hope they'll retain 2/3 of Uggla, Cantu, Ross. And Baker exceeded all expectations at least through a half season.

 

But I'll hold off on predictions until the team is set.

I do hope we're built for '09. I certainly think the rotation and possibly bullpen could be perfectly set. If Andrew Miller is ready it could be scary good. 'Course the pen arms sometimes are a crap shoot but we're not short on options.

 

The position players I'm not sure will be ready for a series run...

 

Mostly because we don't yet know who's staying and who's leaving. It's not out of the question we could have new starters at 6 of the 8 positions from opening day last season. 1B, 2B, 3B, CF, LF, C.

 

Maybin's going to go through his struggles, no one's quite sure what to expect from Dallas if he's starting, Gaby's a rookie (as well as Cogs or Raynor or anyone else who might get called up), the jury's still out on Hermida, and we're not sure who'll be in left field. That's not to say rookies can't excel by the way, just that it's a question mark.

 

Now do I think it'll be that severe? No, I would hope they'll retain 2/3 of Uggla, Cantu, Ross. And Baker exceeded all expectations at least through a half season.

 

But I'll hold off on predictions until the team is set.

HC I believe it's very feasible for the Marlins to keep 3 out of 3 of those guys. Uggla will not be that easy to trade, not because the other teams may not want him but that the right trade will be very complicated to construct. He is easily the 2nd best 2nd baseman in the NL, One of the best powerhitting 2nd baseman of all time. He is in his prime and regardless of what may happen contract wise he will be a bargain salary-wise. This will not be a salary-dump, Beinfest will not just give Uggla away just because he doesn't need to right now. Cantu and Ross will undoubtably be back. Cody has been just incredible in his role with the team, he plays when asked and always gives 110%, He actually was misused by Fredi IMO, just because of Fredi's insistance to overutilize Amezaga. Cantu has done much more than expected, he basically was a force in the lineup and will be so next year but maybe in a slightly bit more diminished role, just resulting from the infusion of youth in the lineup. It is clear that he will be in the lineup in some way because the Marlins were quick in resigning Wes Helms, Cantu will not be used in a utility role, it makes more sense he will be platooning around the infield.

I do hope we're built for '09. I certainly think the rotation and possibly bullpen could be perfectly set. If Andrew Miller is ready it could be scary good. 'Course the pen arms sometimes are a crap shoot but we're not short on options.

 

The position players I'm not sure will be ready for a series run...

 

Mostly because we don't yet know who's staying and who's leaving. It's not out of the question we could have new starters at 6 of the 8 positions from opening day last season. 1B, 2B, 3B, CF, LF, C.

 

Maybin's going to go through his struggles, no one's quite sure what to expect from Dallas if he's starting, Gaby's a rookie (as well as Cogs or Raynor or anyone else who might get called up), the jury's still out on Hermida, and we're not sure who'll be in left field. That's not to say rookies can't excel by the way, just that it's a question mark.

 

Now do I think it'll be that severe? No, I would hope they'll retain 2/3 of Uggla, Cantu, Ross. And Baker exceeded all expectations at least through a half season.

 

But I'll hold off on predictions until the team is set.

 

Do you consider this building for 2009?

 

Note: This is keeping the pitching intact and having a veteran bench, versus paying Uggla, trading Olsen, and getting a cheaper 4th OF than Gonzo. Either scenario is my optimum lineup for 2009, and approaches that magical $35 million number. If payroll is $40, I expect to sub in Uggla (mid $4mil salary) into the below scenario and send Coghlan to AAA. Everything else stays the same. This is also assuming an entire in house lineup (besides a club controlled catcher, which could be Rabelo, but I see the Marlins obtaining a better younger one), and everything received in trading off Gregg, Jacobs, Willingham, and whoever else, produces all minor league talent.

 

Bolds have their salaries locked for contracts of club controlled.

 

John Baker $405,000

Gaby Sanchez $400,000

Chris Coghlan $400,000

Jorge Cantu $4,500,000

Hanley Ramirez $5,500,000

Cody Ross $3,000,000

Cameron Maybin $400,000

Jeremy Hermida $2,500,000

 

Alfredo Amezaga $1,750,000

Wes Helms $950,000

Dallas McPherson $600,000

Luis Gonzalez $2,000,000

Right Handed Cat. $400,000

 

Josh Johnson $1,750,000

Ricky Nolasco $3,000,000

Scott Olsen $2,250,000

Chris Volstad $405,000

Anibal Sanchez $425,000

 

Matt Lindstrom $425,000

Joe Nelson $800,000

Reynel Pinto $425,000

Andrew Miller $1,350,000

Logan Kensing $550,000

Taylor Tankeresly $420,000

Ryan Tucker $400,000

 

$35,005,000

 

Notable AAA - (Coghlan), Andino, Raynor, Rabelo, Mobley, Cruz, Owens, Trahern, Vanden Hurk Doolittle, Delgado, Badenhop

Notable AA - Morrison, West, Sinkbiel, Thompson, Taylor, Winters, Wood, Leroux, Cousins, Petersen

 

--

 

As for contending, I think this team is better than 2008. Team defense skyrockets getting Jacobs out, Cantu/G. Sanchez to 1B, and McPherson to 3B. Likewise in the OF, you now have two plus defenders, and maybe the team will think about switching Hermida to LF which should provide an improvement (plus a Hermida who better show up more focused). Pitching wise, we won't be tossing 40 starts to Hendrickson, Badenhop, and ill prepared Tucker's and Cruz's. We'll have a huge net gain just because of that, and if we have continued progression from Johnson, Volstad, Anibal, Lindstrom, and A. Miller, and Nolasco doesn't come down to hard, we'll have a rather enormous pitching upgrade. I also find it likely some of the relievers figure it out, and someone like Tucker, Mobley, Vanden Hurk, etc, really becomes a serious pen arm.

 

The only question is the rookie hitters. Let's look analytically. Marlins catchers had a .664 OPS last year. This is going up big time with Baker and a decent right handed backup. Even if Baker comes down hard, we should expect at least a 50 point jump here. At 1B, we had an .811 team OPS (Jacobs splits out .833, with most importantly a .300 OBP). Since this was so slugging heavy, this can easily be replaced by a stronger OBP. Assuming the Marlins do the smart thing and ease Sanchez in slowly (let him face most lefties, some righties), and give Cantu most of the playing time vs RHP here, the Marlins should easily be able to match this production. Even if the line drops to say, .270/.340/.450 (.790), this is arguably more valuable than Jacobs line because of the enormous OBP advantage. And I'm really knocking down the slugging there. I say, this is a wash, and an overall gain because of defense. 3B, same thing as 1B. McPherson slamming righties (even at a very Jacobs clip of .240/.310/.475, and it is likely he can do this), and Cantu getting most lefties at 3B is creating a relative wash at 3B. Marlins had a weak .761 OPS from 3B in 2008, mostly thanks to Helms really sucking it up. This should not be hard to replace. Wash or gain. As for the OF, if Cody is one corner, that is more than adequate and can wash one OF slot, which leaves Maybin and Hermida. Hermida just has to be better. I have nothing more to say than that because other factors come into play like, they have to give him another shot and see if the upside is there because we don't want him to go Brandon Phillips on our ass for another franchise. We talk about Hermida to much already. Which leaves Maybin, and Marlins CF hit a .750 OPS last year. For the level of prospect Maybin is, I don't have many concerns replacing a .262/.318/.432 line. And even if we have a problem here, we can always Cody/Amezaga CF, and Cody/Gonzo LF. Further, if we end up having OF problems with Maybin and Hermida both busting, outfielders are typically easy to find at the deadline and that should fix OF issues in a worst case scenario. I'm not worried here, in the same way I am not worried about potential shifting of players at 1B and 3B.

 

Which leaves 2B, which there is no way, shape, or form they could replace Dan's offensive contribution. This is at least a .100 OPS drop if they shift to a Coghlan/Amezaga regime at 2B for 2009, and while that would help the defense a lot, they just would not match the slugging. The only hope here would be, if we are washing 1B, SS, 3B, LF, and CF with offense, and we have at least a 50 point and 100 point gain at C and RF (which I do not think is unrealistic), this will basically cancel out all the offense we are losing with Dan. This is not really stretch of the imagination. I think we are looking at a huge offensive wash regardless of the rookies struggling, because we can easily match the performances from last year. Improvement would come in someone like Hermida repeating 2007, or Baker, Maybin, McPherson, G. Sanchez, or Coghlan reaching an .800 OPS level of production instead of a lower-mid 700s, out of the gate.

 

This is a contending team, even with 5-6 significant rookies, and production concerns from younger players like Hermida, Anibal, Tank, etc.

 

I agree to hold off on real predictions until we see everything, but I'm just using this post to show an example of, this team has a lot of directions it could go in, and most of them end in contending town because of our SP 1-5, a few good pen arms, and a solid offensive core that should be very versatile.

  • Author

I do hope we're built for '09. I certainly think the rotation and possibly bullpen could be perfectly set. If Andrew Miller is ready it could be scary good. 'Course the pen arms sometimes are a crap shoot but we're not short on options.

 

The position players I'm not sure will be ready for a series run...

 

Mostly because we don't yet know who's staying and who's leaving. It's not out of the question we could have new starters at 6 of the 8 positions from opening day last season. 1B, 2B, 3B, CF, LF, C.

 

Maybin's going to go through his struggles, no one's quite sure what to expect from Dallas if he's starting, Gaby's a rookie (as well as Cogs or Raynor or anyone else who might get called up), the jury's still out on Hermida, and we're not sure who'll be in left field. That's not to say rookies can't excel by the way, just that it's a question mark.

 

Now do I think it'll be that severe? No, I would hope they'll retain 2/3 of Uggla, Cantu, Ross. And Baker exceeded all expectations at least through a half season.

 

But I'll hold off on predictions until the team is set.

HC I believe it's very feasible for the Marlins to keep 3 out of 3 of those guys. Uggla will not be that easy to trade, not because the other teams may not want him but that the right trade will be very complicated to construct. He is easily the 2nd best 2nd baseman in the NL, One of the best powerhitting 2nd baseman of all time. He is in his prime and regardless of what may happen contract wise he will be a bargain salary-wise. This will not be a salary-dump, Beinfest will not just give Uggla away just because he doesn't need to right now. Cantu and Ross will undoubtably be back. Cody has been just incredible in his role with the team, he plays when asked and always gives 110%, He actually was misused by Fredi IMO, just because of Fredi's insistance to overutilize Amezaga. Cantu has done much more than expected, he basically was a force in the lineup and will be so next year but maybe in a slightly bit more diminished role, just resulting from the infusion of youth in the lineup. It is clear that he will be in the lineup in some way because the Marlins were quick in resigning Wes Helms, Cantu will not be used in a utility role, it makes more sense he will be platooning around the infield.

 

I agree that Uggla will be hard to trade for that exact reason. He should get as high of a return as anyone would in baseball, considering his production as a second baseman. I think we'd be smart in keeping Uggla, unless the right deal presents itself AND the front office is confident Coghlan is near MLB-ready.

 

I completely disagree in platooning Cantu. Give him a set position, whether it's second, third, or first, and start him everyday. He is going to be just as good if not better next year offensively IMO. He's still enetering his prime, remember. He's younger than Uggla, Willingham, Jacobs, Ross, and even McPherson.

 

To Hotcorner, I agree, we could be fielding a brand new team come next season, but certainly in a good way. I have a feeling we won't be going outside the organization at first base, considering we have a bunch of guys there. I like the prospect of putting Cantu at first and McPherson at third best at this point. I think Sanchez could benefit from a little more time in the minors, as well as Morrison obviously.

 

At second, I doubt Coghlan is ready. If we move Uggla, there's not doubt it's going to be for a top arm or a big piece in the outfield. If and when that happens, Andino will be the obvious immediate choice there considering the speed and defense factor.

 

In the outfield, I'd very much like to keep Hermida out there. Throw Maybin into center, and put the outfielder we receive for either Jacobs or Uggla in left. Two nice options in an Uggla deal could be either Kemp or Ethier from LA. Kemp is younger with great speed and defense, but at the plate you're still looking at a guy that struck out 150+ times, where Ethier K'd 88 times with better numbers in most categories outside of SB. The only question there would be is LA willing to part with Ethier after the year he had?

 

Potential destinations for Jacobs could be Toronto, NY Yankees, Baltimore, LA Angels, Seattle, San Fransisco, and Arizona. The only problem with most of these teams is nothing is very attractive to Florida outside of Nick Markakis, who will be next to impossible to pry away unless you package Jacobs with some real attractive arms, or a possible three-way deal including Uggla.

Uggla will not be that easy to trade, not because the other teams may not want him but that the right trade will be very complicated to construct.

I disagree completely. Teams will be lining up. Teams like St. Louis, San Francisco, LAD, Cleveland, Minnesota, Washington, Seattle, even the Yankees as they are already trying to dish Cano for outfielders. It's not going to be hard to find 1 person interested in him and get a package back. A bad post, where he still had a .739 OPS which is a lot better than most teams, isn't counter-weighing the fact he has averaged 30 HR at 2B the last three years in a pitchers park. Some idiot like Sabean or Coletti will go for it.

Well, most of the platoon ideas with Cantu is him playing everyday switching between 1st and 3rd with McDallas and Gaby getting days off.

In the outfield, I'd very much like to keep Hermida out there. Throw Maybin into center, and put the outfielder we receive for either Jacobs or Uggla in left. Two nice options in an Uggla deal could be either Kemp or Ethier from LA. Kemp is younger with great speed and defense, but at the plate you're still looking at a guy that struck out 150+ times, where Ethier K'd 88 times with better numbers in most categories outside of SB. The only question there would be is LA willing to part with Ethier after the year he had?

 

Potential destinations for Jacobs could be Toronto, NY Yankees, Baltimore, LA Angels, Seattle, San Fransisco, and Arizona. The only problem with most of these teams is nothing is very attractive to Florida outside of Nick Markakis, who will be next to impossible to pry away unless you package Jacobs with some real attractive arms, or a possible three-way deal including Uggla.

Kemp isn't moving. Ethier is going to be a Super Two, and we do not need to be acquiring more payroll. We need players with tops, one year of experience.

 

Toronto has Overbay under contract for 2 more seasons, and a bevy of OF prospects they could be forced to play there if he doesn't improve. LAA will stick in house and go with Morales, or one of their OF as they have billions of them. Seattle will be playing Clement their a lot, as SF will with Sandoval. Ari has their own problems with Chad Tracy, Conor Jackson, and Marc Reynolds to all play, with maybe resigning Dunn. I suspect Teixeira goes to NYY or Balt which eliminates one of them, and Dunn is always around. I do not find any of these as good destinations for Jacobs. Jacobs will be hard to move for good value. Maybe they can trick someone in the AL for RHP DH. They are probably going to have to do what they did with Lowell and Willis with Jacobs. Package him with a better piece, like Uggla, Olsen, or maybe Gregg to the right team, and do a larger trade.

I hate it that Hermida will have to be starter just because of all the hype that this front office gave him, even though he sucks. Damn man, just get rid of the man already, I'll take Willingham, if he gives us what he showed in the first 2 months of the season

 

 

He doesnt suck. He just had a bad year.

 

When has he had a good year ? :whistle

I hate it that Hermida will have to be starter just because of all the hype that this front office gave him, even though he sucks. Damn man, just get rid of the man already, I'll take Willingham, if he gives us what he showed in the first 2 months of the season

 

 

He doesnt suck. He just had a bad year.

 

When has he had a good year ? :whistle

Hermida was around the 41st best hitter in baseball in 2007, minimum 475 PA (he didn't qualify by a few PA). The OFs directly in front of him were named Manny Ramirez, Carlos Beltran, and Carlos Lee. The OFs directly behind him were Ken Griffey Jr., Hideki Matsui, and Grady Sizemore. That year sucks though. He's finished at 24 years old.

I have a quick question...when does everyone think we will see the marlins start to make moves? I really can't wait to see what kind of team we are going to win the division with.

15 days after the final World Series game when the free agency filing period ends. This is when the master list of free agents is completed so teams can asses if they will go after those players, or opt to go the trade route. Theoretically, they can do trades now with teams out of post season contention, but the clubs will wait to see how free agency shapes first.

 

This is a very exciting off season. 4-5 major arbitration players will be off this team, and don't necessarily need MLB replacements because of the depth of our farm system. They have a lot of directions to go in.

Uggla will not be that easy to trade, not because the other teams may not want him but that the right trade will be very complicated to construct.

I disagree completely. Teams will be lining up. Teams like St. Louis, San Francisco, LAD, Cleveland, Minnesota, Washington, Seattle, even the Yankees as they are already trying to dish Cano for outfielders. It's not going to be hard to find 1 person interested in him and get a package back. A bad post, where he still had a .739 OPS which is a lot better than most teams, isn't counter-weighing the fact he has averaged 30 HR at 2B the last three years in a pitchers park. Some idiot like Sabean or Coletti will go for it.

Lou there will be at least 10 or 15 teams interested in Uggla, we agree on that entirely. Our disagreement lies in the fact that you feel this is gonna be a walk in the park for Beinfest. I believe it will be probably a most difficult project. I will clarify my point by saying that Uggla should not be traded for minor league prospects, We have a whole legion of those in every level. The team is ready to take a step forward and assert themselves in the NL, not just to make the playoffs but in pursuit of a championship. This trade will be a large move in that direction, however Beinfest will need to still manage a very limited payroll. We are then talking about a package of young, ready to perform players for Uggla. Not many teams are able to offer that, at least not to the level needed. What would it take? A package of maybe a reliever, power hitting outfielder and a minor leaguer. The reliever and outfielder will both have to fit in under the budget. Still think it will be easy to put together?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.