Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Morrison impressing Marlins

Featured Replies

Lou, we rarely disagree, but I have to here. I think they're going to have Morrison on the same track they had Volstad, especially if someone is struggling or if there is a hole we need to fill at the All-Star break and they decide to deal Hermida to fill it.

 

If he spends the first couple months stroking Double-A, you bet Beinfest will make room for him while adding some strength in another area.

I heard all of this in 2005 with Hermida, and they brought him up the last possible day for playoff inclusion. And I'm willing to bet Morrison does not outhit Hermida at the AA level. They also kept Maybin in AA the entire year. I don't know why you guys think all of a sudden Morrison is going to break this trend even if he is raking. He is still 21, and he ain't Cabrera.

 

There are a bunch of outfielders ahead of Morrison - Raynor, Cousins, Petersen, even Jai Miller and Carroll. Plus Gaby, Bonifacio, and Coghlan, and even invitees like Gibbons. Morrison is going to seriously have to outhit over 5 guys to be considered jumping over everyone for a 25 man spot. Sure, he has the most long term potential. That doesn't mean you start rolling the dice with him. Develop him.

Lou, we rarely disagree, but I have to here. I think they're going to have Morrison on the same track they had Volstad, especially if someone is struggling or if there is a hole we need to fill at the All-Star break and they decide to deal Hermida to fill it.

 

If he spends the first couple months stroking Double-A, you bet Beinfest will make room for him while adding some strength in another area.

I heard all of this in 2005 with Hermida, and they brought him up the last possible day for playoff inclusion. And I'm willing to bet Morrison does not outhit Hermida at the AA level. They also kept Maybin in AA the entire year. I don't know why you guys think all of a sudden Morrison is going to break this trend even if he is raking. He is still 21, and he ain't Cabrera.

 

There are a bunch of outfielders ahead of Morrison - Raynor, Cousins, Petersen, even Jai Miller and Carroll. Plus Gaby, Bonifacio, and Coghlan, and even invitees like Gibbons. Morrison is going to seriously have to outhit over 5 guys to be considered jumping over everyone for a 25 man spot. Sure, he has the most long term potential. That doesn't mean you start rolling the dice with him. Develop him.

 

I'm willing to bet he out-hits Hermida's stay in double-A. And they kept Maybin in double-A because he was too raw, and the numbers clearly showed that. Morrison is much, much more polished than Maybin and has an advanced approach at the plate beyond his years, the kind that very special players (such as Cabrera) have. I don't have any doubt in my mind that if he's raking, they're going to make room for him. If he's tearing up double-A come July, and we have a hole in our organization that needs filling, I have no doubt in my mind that someone will be moved.

 

Logan is going to surpass a lot of expectations in my opinion. This kid is going to be Helton-like. As a hitter, he's got it all. I think a few months in double-A is all he's going to need to show this organization he's ready to take on the big leagues.

I'm willing to bet he out-hits Hermida's stay in double-A. And they kept Maybin in double-A because he was too raw, and the numbers clearly showed that. Morrison is much, much more polished than Maybin and has an advanced approach at the plate beyond his years, the kind that very special players (such as Cabrera) have. I don't have any doubt in my mind that if he's raking, they're going to make room for him. If he's tearing up double-A come July, and we have a hole in our organization that needs filling, I have no doubt in my mind that someone will be moved.

 

Logan is going to surpass a lot of expectations in my opinion. This kid is going to be Helton-like. As a hitter, he's got it all. I think a few months in double-A is all he's going to need to show this organization he's ready to take on the big leagues.

It would be nice if you're right, but I just find this very doubtful. I can't imagine a scenario where Logan OPS's over .975 in AA. Hermida had almost a double BB rate, and was slugging higher with less average. Shocked if Logan does that. It would be a serious jump in slugging for him to do this, and I'm not sure if that happens as a 21 year old. Maybe in a few years.

 

And that's another thing, I don't think we're going to have a hole. This team is very deep right now across the board. Maybe if Gaby, McPherson, and Gibbons flame out they try him at 1B, but it's not going to be the outfield when they have Carroll, Jai, Cousins, Petersen, and hell they like De Aza too, all at the AAA/AA levels. And over half of those guys are on the 40 already.

 

I love Morrison, don't get me wrong. I suspect he has .850-.900 OPS potential at the big league level in a few years, but jumping him at 21 is a very very bad idea. Give him a taste, let him earn it next year. And if not, just stash him in NOLA until he fights his way onto the team. That's a more than acceptable career path.

The Klesko comps are right on for Logan. Not in what kind of player he will be, but the body is and will mature into being.

 

Also, like lou said, if Morrison outhits Hermida in AA (.975OPS), he will easily be the best prospect in baseball.

 

Rushing Morrison to the bigs is not a smart idea at this point. There's plenty of options around right now that kind fill in adequately (or better) while Morrison seasons a bit more in Jacksonville.

Stuff like this gets me excited about the future almost as much more than this season! An outfield of Maybin-Morrison-Stanton with an infield of HanRam,Sanchez,Skipworth,Coughlan and Dominguez. Man that sounds like World Series in about what 2012 when we move into the new stadium? What are the chances of any of these guys failing what 50/50?

what is failing?

 

not being an all star? not being a solid player? not making the team ever?

 

 

Not winning the whole sabang baby!

The Klesko comps are right on for Logan. Not in what kind of player he will be, but the body is and will mature into being.

 

Also, like lou said, if Morrison outhits Hermida in AA (.975OPS), he will easily be the best prospect in baseball.

 

Rushing Morrison to the bigs is not a smart idea at this point. There's plenty of options around right now that kind fill in adequately (or better) while Morrison seasons a bit more in Jacksonville.

I hear you I still don't see the physical comparison with Klesko but hey each with their own opinion. My problem with Morrison is that I just don't see what Jacksonville offers him in his development. He is too mature of a hitter for that level of pitching, What do you do if he starts devouring opposing pitching?

Promote him to Triple A in the PCL?... Where pitching sucks even more? I don't get the age thing at all Raynor is too old...Stanton is too young...Readiness has no age. I remember an 18 y/o SS once that was given the starting job after a strong spring training once and he did pretty good for himself. In fact he made it to the HOF. Anyone ever hear of Robin Yount?

The Klesko comps are right on for Logan. Not in what kind of player he will be, but the body is and will mature into being.

 

Also, like lou said, if Morrison outhits Hermida in AA (.975OPS), he will easily be the best prospect in baseball.

 

Rushing Morrison to the bigs is not a smart idea at this point. There's plenty of options around right now that kind fill in adequately (or better) while Morrison seasons a bit more in Jacksonville.

I hear you I still don't see the physical comparison with Klesko but hey each with their own opinion. My problem with Morrison is that I just don't see what Jacksonville offers him in his development. He is too mature of a hitter for that level of pitching, What do you do if he starts devouring opposing pitching?

Promote him to Triple A in the PCL?... Where pitching sucks even more? I don't get the age thing at all Raynor is too old...Stanton is too young...Readiness has no age. I remember an 18 y/o SS once that was given the starting job after a strong spring training once and he did pretty good for himself. In fact he made it to the HOF. Anyone ever hear of Robin Yount?

 

We're getting a little ahead of ourselves right now in comparing Morrison to HOFers. I like the guy as much as anyone, but I find it ironic that everyone is suddenly raving about a guy that was putting up good numbers before last year but for some reasons wasn't good enough to get mentioned at all in prospect talk. Now he's suddenly a future HOFer?

It would be too funny if Morrison makes it to the majors before supposed "best prospect in all the minors and former top first-round pick" Andrew McCutchen. What are the odds of that happening?

The Klesko comps are right on for Logan. Not in what kind of player he will be, but the body is and will mature into being.

 

Also, like lou said, if Morrison outhits Hermida in AA (.975OPS), he will easily be the best prospect in baseball.

 

Rushing Morrison to the bigs is not a smart idea at this point. There's plenty of options around right now that kind fill in adequately (or better) while Morrison seasons a bit more in Jacksonville.

I hear you I still don't see the physical comparison with Klesko but hey each with their own opinion. My problem with Morrison is that I just don't see what Jacksonville offers him in his development. He is too mature of a hitter for that level of pitching, What do you do if he starts devouring opposing pitching?

Promote him to Triple A in the PCL?... Where pitching sucks even more? I don't get the age thing at all Raynor is too old...Stanton is too young...Readiness has no age. I remember an 18 y/o SS once that was given the starting job after a strong spring training once and he did pretty good for himself. In fact he made it to the HOF. Anyone ever hear of Robin Yount?

 

Only a very exceptional few make the jump to the big leagues without playing at least half a season of AA ball. I don't understand the point of all this talk behind Morrison. If the guy is hitting .330/.420/.540 in Jacksonville come July, and we happen to have an opening, then fine. But as it stands he hasn't played a game at the Double A level and we are in February. Speculation is fun and everything but take it easy. I don't even want to discuss Stanton.

Lou, we rarely disagree, but I have to here. I think they're going to have Morrison on the same track they had Volstad, especially if someone is struggling or if there is a hole we need to fill at the All-Star break and they decide to deal Hermida to fill it.

 

If he spends the first couple months stroking Double-A, you bet Beinfest will make room for him while adding some strength in another area.

I heard all of this in 2005 with Hermida, and they brought him up the last possible day for playoff inclusion. And I'm willing to bet Morrison does not outhit Hermida at the AA level. They also kept Maybin in AA the entire year. I don't know why you guys think all of a sudden Morrison is going to break this trend even if he is raking. He is still 21, and he ain't Cabrera.

 

There are a bunch of outfielders ahead of Morrison - Raynor, Cousins, Petersen, even Jai Miller and Carroll. Plus Gaby, Bonifacio, and Coghlan, and even invitees like Gibbons. Morrison is going to seriously have to outhit over 5 guys to be considered jumping over everyone for a 25 man spot. Sure, he has the most long term potential. That doesn't mean you start rolling the dice with him. Develop him.

 

I think they will wait till after he wont be considered a super 2 personally dude just like Maybin last year. That seems to be the style. I agree with you mostly no need to waste the 40 spot yet. I think though for a projection he might be a little bit better then you think when that doubles power will translate into HR power. I do agree totally about the lefty breaking stuff. That is where most young hitters have issues. I am curious how he will do in AA, also with Jacksonville being far better for a place for AAA. I think we will see alot more players going that route now. Since Really our AAA before was horrid for our needs specially pitching.

The Klesko comps are right on for Logan. Not in what kind of player he will be, but the body is and will mature into being.

 

Also, like lou said, if Morrison outhits Hermida in AA (.975OPS), he will easily be the best prospect in baseball.

 

Rushing Morrison to the bigs is not a smart idea at this point. There's plenty of options around right now that kind fill in adequately (or better) while Morrison seasons a bit more in Jacksonville.

I hear you I still don't see the physical comparison with Klesko but hey each with their own opinion. My problem with Morrison is that I just don't see what Jacksonville offers him in his development. He is too mature of a hitter for that level of pitching, What do you do if he starts devouring opposing pitching?

Promote him to Triple A in the PCL?... Where pitching sucks even more? I don't get the age thing at all Raynor is too old...Stanton is too young...Readiness has no age. I remember an 18 y/o SS once that was given the starting job after a strong spring training once and he did pretty good for himself. In fact he made it to the HOF. Anyone ever hear of Robin Yount?

 

You not seeing what Jacksonville and the Southern League (arguably the best pitchers league in the minors year in, year out) can do for the development of Logan Morrison is your problem, not mine. If he starts dominating in AA, that's fantastic. Let him do it for 3-4-5 months and give him a call to end the year.

 

And yea, Robin Yount. I remember him. I remember him OPSing .622 as an 18 year old, followed by seasons of .674, .593, .710, .751 and .679 until he FINALLY matured into an actual hitter at age 24. The Brewers are lucky they didn't end his career. I won't claim to know what they were thinking, but it looks like this was out of necessity as they had no one else to play shortstop. This is a terrible comparison.

I think they will wait till after he wont be considered a super 2 personally dude just like Maybin last year. That seems to be the style. I agree with you mostly no need to waste the 40 spot yet. I think though for a projection he might be a little bit better then you think when that doubles power will translate into HR power. I do agree totally about the lefty breaking stuff. That is where most young hitters have issues. I am curious how he will do in AA, also with Jacksonville being far better for a place for AAA. I think we will see alot more players going that route now. Since Really our AAA before was horrid for our needs specially pitching.

They aren't going the Super 2 route with Maybin - that would be keeping him in the minors until mid June (like they did with Volstad). I suspect when Logan is ready, they bring him up. But really, that isn't until 2010 at earliest. And even then, I'd maybe even say Summer 2010.

 

That also brings up a good idea with Gaby. Call him up in June. Let McDallas and Gibbons share the other corner infield spot and delay Gaby's arbitration.

The Klesko comps are right on for Logan. Not in what kind of player he will be, but the body is and will mature into being.

 

Also, like lou said, if Morrison outhits Hermida in AA (.975OPS), he will easily be the best prospect in baseball.

 

Rushing Morrison to the bigs is not a smart idea at this point. There's plenty of options around right now that kind fill in adequately (or better) while Morrison seasons a bit more in Jacksonville.

I hear you I still don't see the physical comparison with Klesko but hey each with their own opinion. My problem with Morrison is that I just don't see what Jacksonville offers him in his development. He is too mature of a hitter for that level of pitching, What do you do if he starts devouring opposing pitching?

Promote him to Triple A in the PCL?... Where pitching sucks even more? I don't get the age thing at all Raynor is too old...Stanton is too young...Readiness has no age. I remember an 18 y/o SS once that was given the starting job after a strong spring training once and he did pretty good for himself. In fact he made it to the HOF. Anyone ever hear of Robin Yount?

 

You not seeing what Jacksonville and the Southern League (arguably the best pitchers league in the minors year in, year out) can do for the development of Logan Morrison is your problem, not mine. If he starts dominating in AA, that's fantastic. Let him do it for 3-4-5 months and give him a call to end the year.

 

And yea, Robin Yount. I remember him. I remember him OPSing .622 as an 18 year old, followed by seasons of .674, .593, .710, .751 and .679 until he FINALLY matured into an actual hitter at age 24. The Brewers are lucky they didn't end his career. I won't claim to know what they were thinking, but it looks like this was out of necessity as they had no one else to play shortstop. This is a terrible comparison.

Not really it was a different era. SS was a defensive position and he was the best glove in the organizationThat was an era where if your SS could hit .250 you were mote than happy.

Now it sounds like you are just pulling stuff out of your tuchus. I know errors are not the greatest stat when talking about how good someone's defense is but in his first 5 seasons in the bigs, your boy Yount had 150 errors. 150. You can let that sink in for awhile. One-hundred and fifty.

holy sh*t Robin Yount was god awful fielding

 

1974: 107 GP 19 errors

1975: 145 GP 44 errors

1976: 161 GP 31 errors

1977: 153 GP 26 errors

1978: 125 GP 30 errors

1979: 149 GP 25 errors

1980: 133 GP 28 errors

holy sh*t Robin Yount was god awful fielding

 

1974: 107 GP 19 errors

1975: 145 GP 44 errors

1976: 161 GP 31 errors

1977: 153 GP 26 errors

1978: 125 GP 30 errors

1979: 149 GP 25 errors

1980: 133 GP 28 errors

 

It's strange how different we look at players now than we use to 30 years ago. That certainly is a lot of error but I remember Yount having a lot of range and making alot of throws from deep in the hole. However baseball was covered differently back then, there was no internet and no cable. You saw your local games and there was the game of the week with Tony Kubeck and Curt Gowdy. If you were lucky you could get 3 or 4 games on radio. I know that now players are under a microscope. As a 13 y/o I saw Yount play SS and he was an exciting player to watch. He had a strong arm as well. I guess I remember the good and not so much the bad. There was a reason he was made a CF, At that time it was said to be because of a shoulder injury, BTW before Yount played with the Brewers not one SS had an OPS that was .600 or better. Heck one or two didn't reach .500 OPS

You're saying that before 1974 when Yount debuted, not one SS in baseball OPS better than .600?

 

edit: you could very well be correct, but none of this is a great reason, or even close to one as to why Logan Morrison should be rushed

You're saying that before 1974 when Yount debuted, not one SS in baseball OPS better than .600?

 

edit: you could very well be correct, but none of this is a great reason, or even close to one as to why Logan Morrison should be rushed

No it isn't but why do you say Morrison is being rushed? If he is ready then he is ready why hold him back, The only reason is the 40 man roster IMO

Still doesn't do anything for your Logan Morrison talk

 

I will phrase my point this way to make it easier to see and understand.

I guess we all wanna see the best team possible on the field. If Morrison is a better player at his position than anyone else in the organization right NOW. I would see no reason to hold him back if he has a killer spring training, What would be his developmental goals to achieve? Those are big "ifs". This is a moot point on my behalf because the Marlins will send Morrison to Jacksonville and he will not be seen again til august just because they will not want him facing arbitration any sooner than they have too in the future. If Morrison is a phenom it just bothers me to see him being held back

Still doesn't do anything for your Logan Morrison talk

 

I will phrase my point this way to make it easier to see and understand.

I guess we all wanna see the best team possible on the field. If Morrison is a better player at his position than anyone else in the organization right NOW. I would see no reason to hold him back if he has a killer spring training, What would be his developmental goals to achieve? Those are big "ifs". This is a moot point on my behalf because the Marlins will send Morrison to Jacksonville and he will not be seen again til august just because they will not want him facing arbitration any sooner than they have too in the future. If Morrison is a phenom it just bothers me to see him being held back

Nothing to do with arbitration. Everything to do with player development. Now, if Logan hits .320/.410/.550 in Jax, they call him up in September and pulls a Maybin and goes 10/25 in 6 games, and then send him to NOLA to start 2010 and let Gaby play 1B and Cousins/Raynor LF until June 2010, then this becomes an arbitration issue. But not now. This kid isn't out of A+ ball yet. To far ahead.

 

Leave him in AA. It's for the best. The developmental goals are having him see real breaking pitches for the first time (plus breaking stuff usually is routine by AA as the scrubs don't make it past A ball), real LOOGYS and use of bullpens, a lot of journey"men" and not "kids" as competition, and continued work defensively hopefully at both 1B and LF (where he needs to improve each). Logan would be creamed by lefties at the big league level right now, and we'd be creating a "Daric Barton" situation. This is not a finished product. He really needs this despite how promising his future looks right now. Look at Alex Gordon. Logan has no shot at replicating the AA year Gordon had, and look at how much he's struggling. The Royals should have left him in the minors for 2007, but they got greedy. They probably didn't mess him up longterm because he's just that good, but he could have turned out better with some more seasoning. Look at us, maybe we could be saying the same with a more consistent Hermida also if we didn't have him on the 2006 squad.

 

Don't let your excitement over a player cloud your judgement here. He is 21 years old. He hasn't played in AA. This time last year, he was a sleeper prospect with huge question marks. He has come a hell of a long way, but not all the way just yet. He really needs to stay in the minors. And also, let's give Gaby some credit here. I mean, the guy hit .314/.404/.513 in AA last year - which is a better statistical year than Morrison at a higher level of competition. He deserves a serious look right now. He may not have the same upside or be the better player by 2012, but he could easily be a valuable bat.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.