March 5, 200917 yr Author Hopefully Morrison gets a look in the lead-off spot next year which would allow Maybin to move down to a more natural position. Even if Maybin steals 30+ bases this year, I don't want him leading off again in 2010. Letting his power go to waste is stupid. Huh? I dont think morrison is a leadoff guy. You mean coghlan?
March 5, 200917 yr Hopefully Morrison gets a look in the lead-off spot next year which would allow Maybin to move down to a more natural position. Even if Maybin steals 30+ bases this year, I don't want him leading off again in 2010. Letting his power go to waste is stupid. hmmm morrison is a 3-4-5 hitter type not a 1-2 type. Maybin is a OBP/SB type guy in the hanley build are you sure you arent mixed up with morrison for someone else?
March 5, 200917 yr Hopefully Morrison gets a look in the lead-off spot next year which would allow Maybin to move down to a more natural position. Even if Maybin steals 30+ bases this year, I don't want him leading off again in 2010. Letting his power go to waste is stupid. You can't possibly mean Logan Morrison leading off.
March 6, 200917 yr From what I've been hearing, Gaby is making a fool of himself so far. It looks like the 1B job is more open than we thought but hopefully that will just mean Cantu/Dallas at the corners. Wouldn't surprise me a bit if Coghlan gets the nod at 3B if Gaby fails to make the roster. He's getting all his time in there and he has looked better with the glove than Dallas has to this point. I find this very doubtful. I think Dallas, Gaby, Gibbons, and Helms, and maybe even Bonifacio and Morrison, would have to fail at 1B/3B respectively for him to become a starter at 3B this season. He's not on the 40, he is being groomed as our longterm 2B, and does not have the power potential for 3B. Spring training is spring training. They have to give Uggla, Andino, Bonifacio, and Amezaga reps at 2B this spring, so it's not a horrible idea to let Chris play at 3B a little and let McDallas/Gibbons DH, etc. Dallas has shown no defensive ability so far in the minimum amount of time I have seen him. Last year in ST and a couple games this year. And the couple articles I have read about Coghlan this ST says the team is looking hard at him for 3B. And near as I can tell, that's the only position he has been playing this Spring. Plus he is showing a decent glove there. Do I think he will make the team? I have no idea. Just saying it wouldn't surprise me. It would surprise me more if Andino and Dallas are still on the team by Opening Day. Speed, defense, pitching. Dallas hasn't shown he is a fit yet. Helms is here for 2 years to be a bench guy and supply that veteran leadership/defensive replacement if needed. I think they want Morrison and Gibbons to get more time in the minors first. And I don't think either of them are on the 40 man either. That just leaves Bonifacio. Not sure what they are looking at with him except maybe grooming him to be The Amazing's replacement should he out price himself next year. It's just an opinion. And seeing that I only see them game time, not what they are doing during practices, and I have no inside info on what the coaches are seeing or thinking...It's just an uneducated guess. Just like everyone else's opinions. We're going to have a platoon at the opposite end of Cantu. I don't think anyone is going to dispute that. McDallas, Helms, Gaby, Gibbons, and Bonifacio are going to share 162 starters. Coghlan is pretty much a worst case scenario at 3B, because it means we've had widespread utter failure there from at least a half dozen guys. Getting reps in spring training means nothing. Spring training fluff pieces where the Marlins say they are going a "hard look" to Coghlan at 3B, Bonifacio leading off, Thompson and West for the bullpen, etc, mean nothing either. I cannot see the Marlins starting the arbitration clock on their probable longterm 2B starter, just because the above list of players all have their own negatives at 3B right now. I really don't think Coghlan at 3B is an option. It also wouldn't surprise me if Andino and Dallas are on the team opening day. Dallas is a 100% lock. We have a natural hole at his position, and he is a left hander which we desperately need. Andino only has to beat out Bonifacio and not get traded. Having no options drastically helps both of them here. We're never going to agree on this. And that's cool. And I get the feeling that no matter how it plays out, the other one won't be happy about it, I know I won't be. And that's cool too. But if Dallas makes the 25 man roster then we will all know Beinfest was just teasing us with all those speed, defense, pitching speaches the last few months. And I will not be a happy camper. But then, I'm still looking for a defensive catcher.
March 6, 200917 yr If you're entire roster is made up of "pitching, defense, and speed" you're going to lose a whole lot of ballgames. You need some hitters, you know.
March 6, 200917 yr Hopefully Morrison gets a look in the lead-off spot next year which would allow Maybin to move down to a more natural position. Even if Maybin steals 30+ bases this year, I don't want him leading off again in 2010. Letting his power go to waste is stupid. Huh? I dont think morrison is a leadoff guy. You mean coghlan? So I mixed up my prospects. My bad.
March 6, 200917 yr Author Hopefully Morrison gets a look in the lead-off spot next year which would allow Maybin to move down to a more natural position. Even if Maybin steals 30+ bases this year, I don't want him leading off again in 2010. Letting his power go to waste is stupid. Huh? I dont think morrison is a leadoff guy. You mean coghlan? So I mixed up my prospects. My bad. Its cool, I figured Coghlan was who you were talking about.
March 7, 200917 yr If you're entire roster is made up of "pitching, defense, and speed" you're going to lose a whole lot of ballgames. You need some hitters, you know. Of course you do. And we already have them. But those were the top three they were to work on. Along with cutting down on the Ks. I don't care if you are a lefty or a righty, you still look silly watching that 3rd strike go by you. So again I say, where does Dallas fit into that mix?
March 7, 200917 yr McPherson is off to a better start than usual in ST and it's up to him whether he continues to the upside (including showing his power) or not. Assuming that Cantu can get moved to first (the Fish are willing to send Gaby to AAA??) McPherson hitting down in the order is not the worst guy to have there. If you have Ramirez, Cantu, Uggla, Hermida, Ross and McPherson (however you want to place them in the batting order) you have a lot of power and some speed mixed in. But as I said, it's in McPherson's hands, he can play himself into a starting spot, a bench spot or cut, it's up to him.
March 7, 200917 yr If you're entire roster is made up of "pitching, defense, and speed" you're going to lose a whole lot of ballgames. You need some hitters, you know. Of course you do. And we already have them. But those were the top three they were to work on. Along with cutting down on the Ks. I don't care if you are a lefty or a righty, you still look silly watching that 3rd strike go by you. So again I say, where does Dallas fit into that mix? You are reading way to into offseason comments by Beinfest. Bob is right. For starters, the team improved pitching drastically (healthy rotation, growth of minor leaguers, acquisition of multiple relievers in FA/trade), defense (Maybin fixes CF defense enormously, switching Hermida/Cody is an upgrade, getting Jacobs off the team could literally improve the team by 30-40 plays next year regardless if it is Gaby or McPherson playing at the other corner predominantly, you hope for the overall progression of Hanley at SS, and the team added Bonifacio to the bench), and speed (Maybin and Bonifacio can blaze, G. Sanchez can probably sneak 10 from 'smarts'). As for Dallas, let's break it down. He is the only left handed infielder we have. You may not care about that, but the manager and organization does. And really, it does matter. He led the minor leagues in HR last year, knows how to take a walk, and could become a poor man's Jack Cust overnight. There is a lot of hitting potential there even if he is going to whiff every 3-4 PA. Even if he only can mash right handers, that's still going to be pretty beneficial as Helms can handle lefties. He is 28, which is historically a 'prime' year also, so it's not like he is on the decline. He has a $500,000 salary and is better than any replacement we could find out there. The Marlins also paid him $400,000+ to sit in AAA last year, so if they didn't feel like he was a keeper, they wouldn't have offered him that kind of cash last year. This is still low risk money wise when it comes down to it, but they've invested enough into him to see if the juice is worth the squeeze. Longterm, we have no other legitimate 3B options at the AAA or AA level, so when Cantu prices himself off the team next year, you have to imagine McPherson is penciled into the starting 3B slot in 2010. He could be an internal bridge to Dominguez, and that is huge. He is also, out of options. So if he is not on the 25 man roster. We lose him for nothing. I mean, there are so many positives to keeping McPherson it's ridiculous. He may not be great, he may not work out. But he's cheap, there is solid potential, and we have moderate organizational depth problems at his position (and as a left handed hitter). He's a 100% lock for the roster. How much playing time he gets, is the only question.
March 8, 200917 yr Anyone notice the lack of Morrison sightings. The Marlins have seen all they wanted He hits lefties and righties Has significant power Hit's well in clutch situation. However it will be time soon for him to get some crawfish and gumbo, the Marlins do not wanna showcase him anymore, it would be too tempting, especially with Gabby struggling so badly.
March 8, 200917 yr Anyone notice the lack of Morrison sightings. The Marlins have seen all they wanted He hits lefties and righties Has significant power Hit's well in clutch situation. However it will be time soon for him to get some crawfish and gumbo, the Marlins do not wanna showcase him anymore, it would be too tempting, especially with Gabby struggling so badly. He's not going to skip AA and go to NOLA, he's going to go to Jacksonville.
March 8, 200917 yr They don't have crawfish and gumbo in Jacksonville as well? Sorry about it my mistake!
March 8, 200917 yr They don't have crawfish and gumbo in Jacksonville as well? Sorry about it my mistake! It's probably really bad crawfish and gumbo. Jacksonville is a pit that I-95 runs through. Nothing more.
March 8, 200917 yr The more the front office talked up Sanchez, the more I bought it, despite the feeling in my gut. Now I'm thinking I need to trust my gut. I still think Gaby can have a real good career, but for right now, I really want to see McDallas at the hot corner. His bat is WAY too tempting to keep out of the lineup, and with him out there platooning with Helms we're only upgrading our D at third. Cantu should keep us idle in comparison to Sanchez at first. As of right now, Dallas is really putting himself into the starting lineup, and Gaby's sending himself to triple-A. On Morrison, the kid is absolutely scary good. Like I said Lou, I don't see him spending much time in the minor leagues beyond June/July.
March 9, 200917 yr The more the front office talked up Sanchez, the more I bought it, despite the feeling in my gut. Now I'm thinking I need to trust my gut. I still think Gaby can have a real good career, but for right now, I really want to see McDallas at the hot corner. His bat is WAY too tempting to keep out of the lineup, and with him out there platooning with Helms we're only upgrading our D at third. Cantu should keep us idle in comparison to Sanchez at first. As of right now, Dallas is really putting himself into the starting lineup, and Gaby's sending himself to triple-A. On Morrison, the kid is absolutely scary good. Like I said Lou, I don't see him spending much time in the minor leagues beyond June/July. You really shouldn't trust our FO propoganda. When practically all of the trades we make are cost-cutting give aways (ie Willy and Olsen for a triple A IF and some minor leagye scrubs) you can't believe when they try and pass off trades as "baseball movies". Sanchez may end up being a decent player, but I'm not for one second going to believe that losing Jacobs and Hammer isn't gonna affect our offense because we have a guy like Sanchez waiting in the wings. The reality is that Gaby is going to emerge as average at his position in a best-case scenario and there's very little chance of that best case happening this year. Starting a guy like him at first is not a move that a team that should be moving towards contention should be doing.
March 9, 200917 yr The more the front office talked up Sanchez, the more I bought it, despite the feeling in my gut. Now I'm thinking I need to trust my gut. I still think Gaby can have a real good career, but for right now, I really want to see McDallas at the hot corner. His bat is WAY too tempting to keep out of the lineup, and with him out there platooning with Helms we're only upgrading our D at third. Cantu should keep us idle in comparison to Sanchez at first. As of right now, Dallas is really putting himself into the starting lineup, and Gaby's sending himself to triple-A. On Morrison, the kid is absolutely scary good. Like I said Lou, I don't see him spending much time in the minor leagues beyond June/July. You really shouldn't trust our FO propoganda. When practically all of the trades we make are cost-cutting give aways (ie Willy and Olsen for a triple A IF and some minor leagye scrubs) you can't believe when they try and pass off trades as "baseball movies". Sanchez may end up being a decent player, but I'm not for one second going to believe that losing Jacobs and Hammer isn't gonna affect our offense because we have a guy like Sanchez waiting in the wings. The reality is that Gaby is going to emerge as average at his position in a best-case scenario and there's very little chance of that best case happening this year. Starting a guy like him at first is not a move that a team that should be moving towards contention should be doing. If Gaby is an average 1B at the plate and brings the glove that got him named the best fielding 1B in the SL, he'll much better than Jacobs ever was. Also, you didn't mention the Jacobs/Nunez trade, which is a plus. You didn't mention the Gregg/Ceda trade, which is a plus. Don't trust the anti-FO propaganda, this wasn't an offseason of nothing but giveaway trades.
March 9, 200917 yr The more the front office talked up Sanchez, the more I bought it, despite the feeling in my gut. Now I'm thinking I need to trust my gut. I still think Gaby can have a real good career, but for right now, I really want to see McDallas at the hot corner. His bat is WAY too tempting to keep out of the lineup, and with him out there platooning with Helms we're only upgrading our D at third. Cantu should keep us idle in comparison to Sanchez at first. As of right now, Dallas is really putting himself into the starting lineup, and Gaby's sending himself to triple-A. On Morrison, the kid is absolutely scary good. Like I said Lou, I don't see him spending much time in the minor leagues beyond June/July. You really shouldn't trust our FO propoganda. When practically all of the trades we make are cost-cutting give aways (ie Willy and Olsen for a triple A IF and some minor leagye scrubs) you can't believe when they try and pass off trades as "baseball movies". Sanchez may end up being a decent player, but I'm not for one second going to believe that losing Jacobs and Hammer isn't gonna affect our offense because we have a guy like Sanchez waiting in the wings. The reality is that Gaby is going to emerge as average at his position in a best-case scenario and there's very little chance of that best case happening this year. Starting a guy like him at first is not a move that a team that should be moving towards contention should be doing. I agree and disagree. I do believe Sanchez can't be expected to replace Jacobs in the lineup. But I am not one bit worried about our offense, as I think despite losing all-or-nothing Jacobs and glassman Willingham we'll be equally as productive if not more. We're going to have a full season of Baker, McDallas should be easily as good as Jacobs offensively if he gets the hotcorner, Cantu should be just fine, Uggla and Hanley are stars, Hermida is looking mighty fine this spring, Ross should be extremely productive with 600+ ab's, and Maybin is looking like he might have a HanRam-esque rookie season. I'll be happy if Sanchez starts and is productive. I'll be glowing if they give the spot to a very deserving Dallas McPherson, who should improve us offensively and defensively with his presence.
March 9, 200917 yr Anyone notice the lack of Morrison sightings. The Marlins have seen all they wanted He hits lefties and righties Has significant power Hit's well in clutch situation. However it will be time soon for him to get some crawfish and gumbo, the Marlins do not wanna showcase him anymore, it would be too tempting, especially with Gabby struggling so badly. kid where are you getting your information from Morrison played today he is 0 for 6 in spring with 2K next time you see him will be in the back fields.also do your self a favor and check todays game and see Gaby struggling with 2 hits
March 9, 200917 yr Anyone notice the lack of Morrison sightings. The Marlins have seen all they wanted He hits lefties and righties Has significant power Hit's well in clutch situation. However it will be time soon for him to get some crawfish and gumbo, the Marlins do not wanna showcase him anymore, it would be too tempting, especially with Gabby struggling so badly. kid where are you getting your information from Morrison played today he is 0 for 6 in spring with 2K next time you see him will be in the back fields.also do your self a favor and check todays game and see Gaby struggling with 2 hits He posted that before the game, check the timestamp.
March 9, 200917 yr The more the front office talked up Sanchez, the more I bought it, despite the feeling in my gut. Now I'm thinking I need to trust my gut. I still think Gaby can have a real good career, but for right now, I really want to see McDallas at the hot corner. His bat is WAY too tempting to keep out of the lineup, and with him out there platooning with Helms we're only upgrading our D at third. Cantu should keep us idle in comparison to Sanchez at first. As of right now, Dallas is really putting himself into the starting lineup, and Gaby's sending himself to triple-A. On Morrison, the kid is absolutely scary good. Like I said Lou, I don't see him spending much time in the minor leagues beyond June/July. You really shouldn't trust our FO propoganda. When practically all of the trades we make are cost-cutting give aways (ie Willy and Olsen for a triple A IF and some minor leagye scrubs) you can't believe when they try and pass off trades as "baseball movies". Sanchez may end up being a decent player, but I'm not for one second going to believe that losing Jacobs and Hammer isn't gonna affect our offense because we have a guy like Sanchez waiting in the wings. The reality is that Gaby is going to emerge as average at his position in a best-case scenario and there's very little chance of that best case happening this year. Starting a guy like him at first is not a move that a team that should be moving towards contention should be doing. I agree and disagree. I do believe Sanchez can't be expected to replace Jacobs in the lineup. But I am not one bit worried about our offense, as I think despite losing all-or-nothing Jacobs and glassman Willingham we'll be equally as productive if not more. We're going to have a full season of Baker, McDallas should be easily as good as Jacobs offensively if he gets the hotcorner, Cantu should be just fine, Uggla and Hanley are stars, Hermida is looking mighty fine this spring, Ross should be extremely productive with 600+ ab's, and Maybin is looking like he might have a HanRam-esque rookie season. I'll be happy if Sanchez starts and is productive. I'll be glowing if they give the spot to a very deserving Dallas McPherson, who should improve us offensively and defensively with his presence. I think Gaby is just starting and will be MVP of this league as he was of AA and will bring the Marlins a gold glove too
March 9, 200917 yr Anyone notice the lack of Morrison sightings. The Marlins have seen all they wanted He hits lefties and righties Has significant power Hit's well in clutch situation. However it will be time soon for him to get some crawfish and gumbo, the Marlins do not wanna showcase him anymore, it would be too tempting, especially with Gabby struggling so badly. kid where are you getting your information from Morrison played today he is 0 for 6 in spring with 2K next time you see him will be in the back fields.also do your self a favor and check todays game and see Gaby struggling with 2 hits Don't forget his average almost doubled to .188
March 9, 200917 yr I'll echo some of the above. If the guy is an average first baseman with the bat and plays the defense he's starting to show he's capable of, I'm more than okay with that. I do think he's under a tremendous amount of pressure right now having gotten off to a shaky start but if he starts playing everyday and producing up to the standards he no doubt set for himself, I think he'll be fine. Let's wait until the end of March before throwing him under the bus. That's what spring training is for.
March 9, 200917 yr I'll echo some of the above. If the guy is an average first baseman with the bat and plays the defense he's starting to show he's capable of, I'm more than okay with that. I do think he's under a tremendous amount of pressure right now having gotten off to a shaky start but if he starts playing everyday and producing up to the standards he no doubt set for himself, I think he'll be fine. Let's wait until the end of March before throwing him under the bus. That's what spring training is for. I would never want one of our players to play himself out of a job. BUT, what I would love to see if another player perform well enough he gets the job he deserves. I think McPherson did that in '08, and he's doing it again right now. I hope he is in the starting lineup on opening day. That's my opinion.
March 9, 200917 yr Who is this McPherson you guys keep refering to? Surely not the Marlins Dallas that is very questionable with the glove and still dosen't hit very well at this level. I know, I know. He's a lefty and lefties look far better watching that 3rd strike go by. Plus he just tore up the PCL last year and we all know how hard it is to hit there.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.