February 23, 200917 yr Still doesn't do anything for your Logan Morrison talk I will phrase my point this way to make it easier to see and understand. I guess we all wanna see the best team possible on the field. If Morrison is a better player at his position than anyone else in the organization right NOW. I would see no reason to hold him back if he has a killer spring training, What would be his developmental goals to achieve? Those are big "ifs". This is a moot point on my behalf because the Marlins will send Morrison to Jacksonville and he will not be seen again til august just because they will not want him facing arbitration any sooner than they have too in the future. If Morrison is a phenom it just bothers me to see him being held back Nothing to do with arbitration. Everything to do with player development. Now, if Logan hits .320/.410/.550 in Jax, they call him up in September and pulls a Maybin and goes 10/25 in 6 games, and then send him to NOLA to start 2010 and let Gaby play 1B and Cousins/Raynor LF until June 2010, then this becomes an arbitration issue. But not now. This kid isn't out of A+ ball yet. To far ahead. Leave him in AA. It's for the best. The developmental goals are having him see real breaking pitches for the first time (plus breaking stuff usually is routine by AA as the scrubs don't make it past A ball), real LOOGYS and use of bullpens, a lot of journey"men" and not "kids" as competition, and continued work defensively hopefully at both 1B and LF (where he needs to improve each). Logan would be creamed by lefties at the big league level right now, and we'd be creating a "Daric Barton" situation. This is not a finished product. He really needs this despite how promising his future looks right now. Look at Alex Gordon. Logan has no shot at replicating the AA year Gordon had, and look at how much he's struggling. The Royals should have left him in the minors for 2007, but they got greedy. They probably didn't mess him up longterm because he's just that good, but he could have turned out better with some more seasoning. Look at us, maybe we could be saying the same with a more consistent Hermida also if we didn't have him on the 2006 squad. Don't let your excitement over a player cloud your judgement here. He is 21 years old. He hasn't played in AA. This time last year, he was a sleeper prospect with huge question marks. He has come a hell of a long way, but not all the way just yet. He really needs to stay in the minors. And also, let's give Gaby some credit here. I mean, the guy hit .314/.404/.513 in AA last year - which is a better statistical year than Morrison at a higher level of competition. He deserves a serious look right now. He may not have the same upside or be the better player by 2012, but he could easily be a valuable bat. I looked at the numbers a couple of days ago and was quite astounded. There are a lot of reasons to like Gaby as a hitter and his existence is a clear reason why Morrison doesn't need to be rushed.
February 23, 200917 yr You're saying that before 1974 when Yount debuted, not one SS in baseball OPS better than .600? With the Brewers The whole Yount argument just doesn't compare with this situation because we have several players who have demonstrated that they deserve a shot at the everyday job before Morrison.
February 23, 200917 yr Author The only guy I can think of who really made the jump from A ball to the majors recently and ripped is hamilton. But he did have a year in Cin to kinda get used to the majors where he didnt play alot. He did play a few games in double a and triple but not much and i dont think he did to well. Nothing against Logan but i dont think he has the kinda talent Hamilton has. Still though if hes mashing in in double A and by the AS and we have a need Id like him to come up. I think he should at least get some time in double a before he comes up even if he has a great spring.
February 27, 200917 yr Hamilton is a completely different animal than anyone else in baseball hanley ramirez disagrees as do the upton brothers and a few others top flight young talented players..
February 27, 200917 yr Hamilton is a completely different animal than anyone else in baseball hanley ramirez disagrees as do the upton brothers and a few others top flight young talented players.. um no they don't. Those players went through the minor leagues and didn't do crack. Then mysteriously turn sober, get selected in the Rule5, and then blast the crap out of baseball. Hamilton, is his own monster. Unless Jeff Allison comes up this year and throws 150 innings at a 1.90 era.
February 27, 200917 yr Lou I don't entrely disagree with anything you have said, however in the AFL Morrison has seen the best pitching offered by double A and some triple A and destroyed them. That swing is sooo sweet, he really shows little flaw if any that he requires more seasoning. I just don't see him making it past the all star break in the minors. I know the 40 man roster is a huge factor, but strikeouts is not a concern at all. Jacksonville is probably too small of a Pond for Morrison right now This sounds a lot like Hermida in 2005 to me. You should check to see LaRoche's K numbers through the minors/majors also. These guys start whiffing with the breaking pitches and LOOGYs. Leave Morrison alone. If he kills AA, move him to AAA in July. McPherson, Gaby, and hopefully Gibbons, will be fine for 2009. Not so sure on that AAA move. I more like the instruction and the different type pitching in AA. But it couldn't hurt and I sure wouldn't be opposed to it. I do agree he needs to simmer a bit more in the minors. For the benefit of him and our 40 man.
February 27, 200917 yr Hamilton is a completely different animal than anyone else in baseball hanley ramirez disagrees as do the upton brothers and a few others top flight young talented players.. pretty much what lou said they are completely different animals
February 27, 200917 yr Hamilton is a completely different animal than anyone else in baseball hanley ramirez disagrees as do the upton brothers and a few others top flight young talented players.. um no they don't. Those players went through the minor leagues and didn't do crack. Then mysteriously turn sober, get selected in the Rule5, and then blast the crap out of baseball. Hamilton, is his own monster. Unless Jeff Allison comes up this year and throws 150 innings at a 1.90 era. talking about pure talent wise they are in the same bracket. Hamilton is a unique story and hopefully for him continues just saying though ther e are alot of young talents like that over the years and currently. Considering I would say Stanton has the potential to become like that... Either way Morrison is a very high potential player with nice ability that doesnt have to be rushed The marlins rush when the feel the need but are patient too unless they have a use because of money reasons. We wont see him before afte the super 2 deadline at earliest time and I doubt it even then honestly.
February 27, 200917 yr imo, Hamilton is in his own bracket when it comes to pure talent I disagree, I think Hanley has as much if not more raw talent.
February 27, 200917 yr I just can't see any other players taking years off because of a drug addiction, then stepping foot in the majors and destroying pitching from day one.
February 27, 200917 yr Ontop of which, that drug being heroin, a drug that completely drains you physically and is almost as much of a phsyical addiction as it is a mental addiction.
February 28, 200917 yr I just can't see any other players taking years off because of a drug addiction, then stepping foot in the majors and destroying pitching from day one. You can't see it because no one else with that much potential has thrown their careers away in such a fashion. If you look at their MiLB numbers from 18-19, before the age where Hamilton started doing drugs, their numbers are similar with an edge in Hanley's favor. It's not fair to say Hamilton has more talent than Hanley just because he didn't destroy his life first.
February 28, 200917 yr Author Florida Marlins love what they see in Logan Morrison Regardless of when first baseman Logan Morrison arrives in the major leagues, the Marlins are confident he will stand out when he gets there PORT ST. LUCIE -- Some say hitting comes naturally to Logan Morrison. He would dispute that, saying part of his rise to can't-miss-prospect status with the Marlins is the product of long hours spent refining his swing from the time he was 11. Every day in the summer, Morrison's father would grab a bucket of 100 baseballs, head out to the local diamond, and throw pitch after pitch to his determined son until the sun gave out. Think the father didn't know, a father who played football at the University of Kansas and now serves as a small arms instructor for the Coast Guard? That's why, Morrison said, he is where he is. That's why the Marlins are without-a-doubt convinced that he's their next great one -- no ifs, ands or buts. ''I see a kid that can flat out swing a bat,'' said Marlins hitting coach Jim Presley, who hadn't laid eyes on Morrison until just 10 days ago. Just 10 days. That's all it has taken to convince Presley that Morrison is the real deal. The statistics show he hit .332 with 13 home runs at Single A Jupiter last season, earning the first baseman Player of the Year honors in the Florida State League. But Presley said the numbers don't do justice to Morrison, a 21-year-old left-hander whose swing is as sweet as the player he idolized growing up in the Kansas City area, George Brett. ''I think it's God-given ability,'' Presley said, ``but his dad preached that to him. He hits the ball the other way, which for most young hitters, it takes them a few years to do that. He already knows how to do it. He's physically strong, and he can turn on the ball. His approach is as good as anybody's in camp.'' SUMMERTIME ARRIVAL? Morrison is in his first big-league spring training camp with the Marlins, a nonroster invitee whose chances of surviving all the cuts are slim. He probably will end up at Double A Jacksonville to start the year. Around June or July, though, the Marlins might find a need for him, the way they did in the summer of 2003 with another young, standout batsman. That is the year they promoted Miguel Cabrera from Double A and watched him provide a midseason spark on the way to a World Series title. ''I'm ready for any challenge,'' Morrison said. ``If I make the team out of [spring training], or it's go down and play in Double A and get called up later in the season, that would be great.'' Presley hesitates to mention Morrison in the same breath as Cabrera. ''To me, Cabrera is in a class by himself,'' Presley said. ``But this kid, the thing that sets him apart from a lot of young hitters is he knows what he's trying to do.'' HIS TIME IS COMING Presley and manager Fredi Gonzalez said they don't see any reason why Morrison won't succeed in the majors -- and succeed instantly -- once he arrives. Perhaps more amazing is that Morrison was drafted in 2005 by the Marlins in the 22nd round. The only lower picks for the Marlins ever to make it to the major leagues have been infielder Dave Berg (38th round in 1993) and pitcher Kevin Olsen (26th round in 1998). ''I think he went lower in the draft for two reasons,'' said Jim Fleming, the Marlins' vice president of player development. ``One, people knew he wanted to go to school.'' Morrison played at a junior college after high school. ''But also, I don't think he was seen by everybody,'' Fleming said. Morrison played his high school baseball in Louisiana. He said only the Marlins, Atlanta Braves and Kansas City Royals scouted him. Now, just four years removed from high school, Morrison is an attraction. Other teams ask the Marlins about him all the time as potential trade material. The Marlins have no interest in moving him, at least not now. They would prefer to keep him for themselves. ''If he's tearing up Double A, he'll tell you whether he's ready or not,'' Fleming said. 'He looks like he's getting very close. Double A will tell us whether it's this year or next year. There are no real issues with him, no things we say, `Oh, we've got to clean this up or do that.' He's right on schedule.'' ------------------------------------- Just another article on him. I think the last quote by fleming pretty much says hes going to double a no mattter how good a spring he has.
February 28, 200917 yr Dom did we just try to post the same article at the same time? What r the chances of that happening?
February 28, 200917 yr I just can't see any other players taking years off because of a drug addiction, then stepping foot in the majors and destroying pitching from day one. You can't see it because no one else with that much potential has thrown their careers away in such a fashion. If you look at their MiLB numbers from 18-19, before the age where Hamilton started doing drugs, their numbers are similar with an edge in Hanley's favor. It's not fair to say Hamilton has more talent than Hanley just because he didn't destroy his life first. Considering it's my opinion, I could pretty much say whatever I want and it would be fair. That being said, I still think Josh Hamilton is in his own class when it comes to talent.
February 28, 200917 yr I watched him play in Jupiter several times last year...he's one heck of a player. One of the nicest ballplayers I've met, too..
March 1, 200917 yr I just can't see any other players taking years off because of a drug addiction, then stepping foot in the majors and destroying pitching from day one. You can't see it because no one else with that much potential has thrown their careers away in such a fashion. If you look at their MiLB numbers from 18-19, before the age where Hamilton started doing drugs, their numbers are similar with an edge in Hanley's favor. It's not fair to say Hamilton has more talent than Hanley just because he didn't destroy his life first. Considering it's my opinion, I could pretty much say whatever I want and it would be fair. That being said, I still think Josh Hamilton is in his own class when it comes to talent. Yes, because you've never commented on someone's opinion. Seriously, that statement was almost comical coming from you.
March 2, 200917 yr From what I've been hearing, Gaby is making a fool of himself so far. It looks like the 1B job is more open than we thought but hopefully that will just mean Cantu/Dallas at the corners.
March 2, 200917 yr From what I've been hearing, Gaby is making a fool of himself so far. It looks like the 1B job is more open than we thought but hopefully that will just mean Cantu/Dallas at the corners. Gaby certainly hasn't helped his chances with his spring performance thus far. Defense is what the organization is looking for from him, and he's made two errors at first base. He's certainly not alone in that department but for a guy in his position the errors hurt alot more. Starting out 0-9 doesn't help anything either. I'm still rooting for Sanchez to make the opening day roster and hopefully he can turn things around. We're only a week into playing games, so we'll see. For those of you who were calling for McPherson to be DFA'd, I hope you understand now that he provides valuable insurance. Even if Gaby solidifies first base, McPherson becomes valuable coming off the bench.
March 2, 200917 yr From what I've been hearing, Gaby is making a fool of himself so far. It looks like the 1B job is more open than we thought but hopefully that will just mean Cantu/Dallas at the corners. Gaby certainly hasn't helped his chances with his spring performance thus far. Defense is what the organization is looking for from him, and he's made two errors at first base. He's certainly not alone in that department but for a guy in his position the errors hurt alot more. Starting out 0-9 doesn't help anything either. I'm still rooting for Sanchez to make the opening day roster and hopefully he can turn things around. We're only a week into playing games, so we'll see. For those of you who were calling for McPherson to be DFA'd, I hope you understand now that he provides valuable insurance. Even if Gaby solidifies first base, McPherson becomes valuable coming off the bench. It's not encouraging to see our other guys make errors either, but when you're talking about an infield with Cantu, Ramirez, and Uggla in it, they have all proven themselves with the bat but are not outstanding defenders. If Gaby is gonna present himself as a defensive liability as well, then its gonna be a lot harder for them to hand a starting job to him considering that his bat doesn't project to be an above average bat for his position.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.