Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

PWG vs Retro Marlins

Featured Replies

  • Author

so what are you guys actually betting? like what's up for grabs?

 

I don't really care... sig, ban... whatevs... someone can suggest something anytime they want

I think 20 is definitely a good betting number.

 

Personally, I think his season is going to nearly mirror Hanley's 2006... Which means just shy of 20.

 

Sorry, PWG... We always agree... just not today.

I am inclined to believe that if healthy throughout the season, Maybin can hit at least 21 homers. He will become a consistent 30/30 threat for years to come. Go PWG you got this one locked up!

 

Im I the only one who thinks maybin is not a power hitter and more of a contact hitter?

 

I'll take this bet any day.

  • Author

I suppose I should explain some of my rationale

 

There's no doubt Maybin has insane tools, but consider the following:

 

Past few rookies with 20+ HRs...

 

2008

 

Soto: 494

Votto: 526

Bruce: 413

Longoria 448

Alexei Ramirez 480

 

2007

 

Josh Fields: 373

Braun: 451

Chris Young: 569

 

 

2006:

 

Zimmerman: 614

 

and the list goes on...

 

Braun and Fields being the only "bad" comparisons here, assuming Maybin gets roughly 600 ABs, there's almost no way he doesn't just play himself into 20 HRs

I would go with the under. He only hit 13 last year and that's his high. The knock on him is he hits too many balls on the ground.

He hit 15 in about 420 PA in 2007. Second, yea he did that in 2008, in just under 500 combined PA. You missed the entire point of what he's arguing. An additional 150 PA, and a little progression from Maybin gets him to 20. Arguing last year's HR stats isn't a deal breaker here.

 

Now pointing out he hit 17 doubles is another thing.

I got your back PWG. I believe in Maybin, he will hit 23, book it.

 

The bet should be that the loser goes to a marlin game with a sign saying they lost the bet :lol

I got your back PWG. I believe in Maybin, he will hit 23, book it.

 

The bet should be that the loser goes to a marlin game with a sign saying they lost the bet :lol

 

 

The loser wears a dress and holds a sign at game.

I got your back PWG. I believe in Maybin, he will hit 23, book it.

 

The bet should be that the loser goes to a marlin game with a sign saying they lost the bet :lol

 

 

The loser wears a dress and holds a sign at game.

 

 

This was an actual bet a year or two ago, can anybody find that thread or remember what the bet was??

PWG you got my back man! Maybin will hit 20 and surprise evry1!

 

IMO, this post shows why 20 is high. yes, it would be a surprise. if you got this bet from a real bookmaker, I believe the number would be lower. makes sense for some inflation to occur on a Marlins board, though.

I would go with the under. He only hit 13 last year and that's his high. The knock on him is he hits too many balls on the ground.

He hit 15 in about 420 PA in 2007. Second, yea he did that in 2008, in just under 500 combined PA. You missed the entire point of what he's arguing. An additional 150 PA, and a little progression from Maybin gets him to 20. Arguing last year's HR stats isn't a deal breaker here.

 

Now pointing out he hit 17 doubles is another thing.

He'll get an additional 150 PAs if he stays injury free and if he doesn't struggle... not every top 10 prospect shines from the get go. There may be a little progression but he'll face much better pitching. The safe bet is the under.

Just for the record, PECOTA projects Maybin at 15 HRs in 588 PAs.

Just for the record, PECOTA projects Maybin at 15 HRs in 588 PAs.

+/- 3 for inaccuracies sake, plus 2 lucky ones that just make the wall, and there you go!

Just for the record, PECOTA projects Maybin at 15 HRs in 588 PAs.

+/- 3 for inaccuracies sake, plus 2 lucky ones that just make the wall, and there you go!

 

I know, because either way, barring injury, it is going to be close. That's why this is so intriguing.

Just for the record, PECOTA projects Maybin at 15 HRs in 588 PAs.

+/- 3 for inaccuracies sake, plus 2 lucky ones that just make the wall, and there you go!

 

I know, because either way, barring injury, it is going to be close. That's why this is so intriguing.

Agreed.

  • Author

I'll bet PWG $50 monopoly money.

 

I don't think so sweetheart, we're making this fun... someone come up with something... I can't go to many games, so let's not base it on that....

no way maybin hits 20 this year.

if hanley couldnt hit 20 his rookie season than how could maybin?

remember his strikeout issues?

i think when he steps into the batter's box he's going to be worried more about just getting contact on the ball.

all that being said, Cameron hits 15-16 home runs...tops.

 

if he hits 20 or more i would love that.

but i dont see it happening.

 

retro wins.

Well with in light of the recent news that boner will be hitting lead off i think it drastically decreases maybins chances of hitting 20 with him in the 8 hole, but theres a prettty good chances boner doesnt stay in the lead off spot.

I would go with the under. He only hit 13 last year and that's his high. The knock on him is he hits too many balls on the ground.

Hanley's MiLB high was 8 and he hit 6 at 21.

 

 

Not saying that Maybin is Hanley, I'm just giving an example (and implying it).

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.