Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

The Bullpen

Featured Replies

Im just sitting here and thinking to myself about what exactly the marlins were thinking when they were making the bullpen. I mean they let nelson, rhodes, and waechter go all of whom we could have signed for 3 million total and the we traded de la cruz who was supposed to be one of the keys in the cabrera deal.

 

then we have scott proctor who was coming off surgery more money than even waechter was asking for and nelson was only asking for 850,000. This really blows my mind how one of the best front offices could do that.

 

Unless maybe something went wrong....what do you guys think?

Indeed.

 

While we are only 5 games into the season, I think that if we're still in contention by the trading deadline then I have no doubt that the FO will pull the neccessary strings to upgrade the bullpen like they did last year with Rhodes.

Im just sitting here and thinking to myself about what exactly the marlins were thinking when they were making the bullpen. I mean they let nelson, rhodes, and waechter go all of whom we could have signed for 3 million total and the we traded de la cruz who was supposed to be one of the keys in the cabrera deal.

 

then we have scott proctor who was coming off surgery more money than even waechter was asking for and nelson was only asking for 850,000. This really blows my mind how one of the best front offices could do that.

 

Unless maybe something went wrong....what do you guys think?

 

Time of contracts and what they were looking for

 

We did up our offer to $850 K to Nelson, and he turned it down. Signed with Tampa for 1 yr, $1.3 mil. (Still think it wasn't just by chance and everything was legal about his appearance at those Vegas meetings.)

 

Rhodes signed with Cincy for 2 years and $4 mil.

 

Waechter signed with KC for 1 year, $650K.

 

That's double your $3 mil commited total on those 3 guys. Evidently they got what they were looking for, or at least close (as in under).

 

DLC still ticks me off because I liked the kid. But he's a pen guy for the Padres and 5 games in has only pitched one inning. 1 BB and 1 K. Didn't exactly impress here either.

 

It's 5 games in. We are 4-1. Starters will begin to get more innings in as this month wears on. If they don't, it won't matter who we have in the pen.

Indeed.

 

While we are only 5 games into the season, I think that if we're still in contention by the trading deadline then I have no doubt that the FO will pull the neccessary strings to upgrade the bullpen like they did last year with Rhodes.

 

 

No doubt.

We did up our offer to $850 K to Nelson, and he turned it down. Signed with Tampa for 1 yr, $1.3 mil. (Still think it wasn't just by chance and everything was legal about his appearance at those Vegas meetings.)

 

Rhodes signed with Cincy for 2 years and $4 mil.

 

Waechter signed with KC for 1 year, $650K.

 

Bob, I think you answered your own questions. Waechter ran out of gas, and stuff, in the last couple of months of the season ( see http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/players/spli...g&year=2008 ), teams were hitting over .425 against him in both August and Sept. In light of that I think you can decide for yourself if you'd want to make a commitment to that going into 2009.

 

Rhodes is a tougher one but coming off surgery I understand why they didn't want to make the two year commitment to AR he wanted and ultimately got. I would have but it isn't my money and I don't have the insider info to know what they were thinking. Of all of them this is the most questionable non-move of the off-season. Especially in light of what you have right now.

 

Nelson, as you implied may have orchestrated this but again when you trade in reclamation players there's a built-in health issue to deal with. So much of Nelson's career has been injury plagued.

 

Look at this season, they sign Proctor and Kiko, so far it looks questionable at best on one and brilliant on the other. You never know.

So far this season:

 

Waechter: 1 appearance 1.0 innings 1 hit 1 BB 1 K 0 ER

Nelson: 3 appearances 3.1 innings 3 hits 2 BB 5K 0 ER

Rhodes: 3 appearances 3.0 innings 0 hits 0 BB 3K 0 ER

 

 

vs.

 

 

Calero: 3 appearances 3.0 innings 0 hits 1 BB 4 K 1 ER

Nunez: 2 appearances 3.0 innings 3 hits 1 BB 1 K 2 ER

Miller: 2 appearances 2.1 innings 5 hits 2 BB 0 K 1 ER

Kensing: 2 appearances 2.0 innings 3 hits 2 BB 1 K 2 ER

Lindstrom: 2 appearances 2.0 innings 2 hits 2 BB 2 K 1 ER

Meyer: 2 appearances 2.0 innings 3 hits 1 BB 1 K 2 ER

Penn: 1 appearance 2.0 innings 4 hits 1 BB 4 K 0 ER

Pinto: 2 appearances 1.0 inning 2 hits 1 BB 2 K 1 ER

I'm sure most of you know what FIP is, but just a quick reiteration, FIP looks at the three main things a pitcher is responsible for (K's, BB's, HR's) and shows what his expected ERA would be. It's not perfect; GB pitchers normally out perform their FIPs due to their ability to limit all XBH [as FIP only looks at HRs and not 2b/3b/ect]. Absolute dominant guys like Pedro out-perform their FIPs because their harder to get base hits off of, and hittable guys underperform their FIPs, as FIP goes under the assumption that every pitcher is around the .300 BABIP threshold. It takes away the defensive factor, it takes away "luck" (i.e. broken bat singles or hard line drives right at guys, which should equal themselves out over time but often don't in small sample sizes), it helps show what exactly a pitcher does to help his own cause.

 

But anyway, going back to Pinto.

 

Pinto has had a pretty good ERA in the majors so far at 3.92, just barely below the league average ERA. But his FIP is all the way up at 4.78, nearly a full run above and very very poor.

 

A lot of people point to the start of last year as saying hey, Pinto figured it out. Fredi over worked him, hence why he was horrible at the end. And ERA would show as much. First two months of the season, he finished with a 1.57 ERA. He'd post a 7.71 ERA the rest of the way.

 

And he was definitely overused. Through the four months of the season, he appeared in 58 games, 53% of the games the Marlins played. If he was around the entire season, he'd have thrown in 86 games with 112 innings. No doubt, obscene and stupid.

 

The issue though is, was he actually good at the start of the season?

 

The first two months of the season, he finished with a 4.77 FIP even though he had a 1.57 ERA. How? Just a .188 BABIP, extremely low, just 5 hits per 9 innings.

 

But he wasn't striking people out. He'd finish those two months with just a 6.30 K/9, and he was still walking a ton at 5.50 per 9. It was really a tale of two months (in April, he K'd at just a 3.85 rate per 9, but also walked at only a 2.89 rate. But then May came, his K's came back at a 9.17 rate, but so did his walks at a 8.60 rate).

 

Without a doubt he was overworked last season, and that showed in his regression in the later months. But I'm also willing to say a lot of that was normalization.

 

His K-rate has gone down every season. His hr-rate has gone up every season. His BB rate went down in '07 compared to '06 (although that's no compliment considering his '06 bb rate was 8.19), but it went up again last year.

 

Yeah, he K's a lot. But he also gives up a ton of HRs. He also gives up a ton of walks. Both of which shows up in the minors as well.

 

And for being left handed, he also a 4.64 FIP against left handed batters, barely better than his 4.86 FIP against right handers. While part of that has to do with his huge HR rate against LHB (1.41 HR/9), if we normalize that to the rate to be expected out of him (1 hr/9, or 6 HRs over his career), he still has a 4.14 FIP, well below what an average reliever would do, let alone an average left handed pitcher against a left handed batter.

 

I mean yeah, his K rates are obscene. He's just 26 years old. He is left handed. My problem is right now, he is set up as the #1 go to left handed pitcher. And that to me is a problem.

 

I mean, let's look at our bullpen. Out of our 7 pitchers, we have 3 things we have faith in to atleast be around average (Lindstrom, Nunez, Kiko), and 4 that we're worried about (Pinto, Kensing, Meyer, and Penn).

 

To me, if you only have one left hander in your top 5 bullpen, you want your #6 guy to be left handed, and you're #7 guy is then just a right handed long relief option. And if Pinto was our #6 guy, that'd be great. Let him see if he can work out his stuff there.

 

But Pinto isn't. He's, what, our #4 at the moment with Kensing #5? That right there is the fault with our bullpen. Kensing is basically in the same boat as Pinto: Bunch of K's, bunch of walks, bunch of HRs, carer FIP of 5.17 with a 4.79 last year, but just 26 years old if he could figure out his control he'd be ace. Put him as the #7 guy and money. Have him as your #5 guy and f***.

 

Right now we have 4 out of option, high upside former good prospect still young with something to prove players, perfect molds of #6 and #7 guys. But we need to replace two if we want to fix our bullpen. And considering Pinto is arbitration eligible at the end of the season and Kensing will be in his second year of arbitration, and Meyer/Penn still have starting possibilities, they're easily the guys to point to considering how we have to run things. And I'll shed no tear when we do.

 

Right now I'm just real pissed we didn't sign Ohman. If things "work out", Proctor is healthy this season and replaces Kensing in late May/early June, or one of Tucker/Ceda/whoever figure it out in AAA. But outside of Tank figuring it back out, we have no LOOGY, anywhere. And we're probably going to have to give up another Gaby Hernandez this year to fix the problem.

 

I sure as hell hope Pinto (And Kensing) prove me wrong this season but I really don't have much hope.

Speaking of the bullpen, anyone read or hear anything on Jose Ceda's condition? He's shutdown I guess, on the Suns roster (surprisingly not the the Zephyrs) but not pitching, and didn't in all of spring training.

 

I know he came to camp overweight and his shoulder ailing, but I can't find much of anything on him except in the context of the Gregg/Ceda trade.

It's was a complete and utter retarded move letting go of Joe Nelson. Completly baffling.

Nelson's a dick.

 

 

Why? Not that I really care for having him. His #'s last year were deceiving.

It's was a complete and utter retarded move letting go of Joe Nelson. Completly baffling.

Considering how cheap he was, absolutely.

 

Same goes for Waechter. He was barely going to make over the minimum. Not much of a risk there.

 

I'm afraid that the biggest mistake the FO is making is putting so much trust in Kensing. What has he really shown in his MLB career to warrant him still being in this bullpen? In his two full seasons in the majors (2006 and 2008) he had ERAs of 4.54 and 4.23 respectively. That's basically league average when you look at ERA+.

Nelson's a dick.

 

 

Why? Not that I really care for having him. His #'s last year were deceiving.

I agree there. Probably could have traded him for something though.

 

He's a dick for his demands last off season. He asked for $700k, he got $700k. Then he asked for $800k and got that. He then asked for $900k and we gave him that too. Then he decided he wanted $1m. All this while shopping himself around during the winter meetings. Terrible person.

It's was a complete and utter retarded move letting go of Joe Nelson. Completly baffling.

Considering how cheap he was, absolutely.

 

Same goes for Waechter. He was barely going to make over the minimum. Not much of a risk there.

 

I'm afraid that the biggest mistake the FO is making is putting so much trust in Kensing. What has he really shown in his MLB career to warrant him still being in this bullpen? In his two full seasons in the majors (2006 and 2008) he had ERAs of 4.54 and 4.23 respectively. That's basically league average when you look at ERA+.

What's so wrong with being average?

The FO is counting on everything going perfect with the guys we have in the bullpen. Many here tend to think that Kensing and Co. will emerge into good relievers because they are magically going to lower their BB rates. I haven't seen any indication that is going to happen and that has me worried. We're 4-1 now, but the pen really hasn't contributed to that and the way they have looked we're gonna have to make yet another scramble for bullpen help which has backfired as many times as it has worked in recent years (Ron Villone). That, and we're gonna have to give up a prospect to do it when guys were available that wouldn't have cost us talent to sign.

I still think this is going to work out just fine.

 

RHP - Lindstrom, Nunez, Kensing, Proctor, Calero, Penn, Tucker, Ceda, Vanden Hurk, Leroux, Wood, Owens, Trahern, Badenhop, Sinkbiel, Winters, Doolittle, Mobley, Allison

LHP - Pinto, Meyer, Tank, Thompson, West, G. Taylor

 

That is all AA or higher. We're going to get 7 (seven) out of this. Mark my words. Just try and no be to frustrated with the attrition process and hope we won't lose to many games as it sorts itself out. And you know if we're still in it last week of July, Beinfest isn't going to be gun shy if we need to add another veteran arm.

 

There is a lot, a lot, of talent here. It's going to be ok.

I still think this is going to work out just fine.

 

RHP - Lindstrom, Nunez, Kensing, Proctor, Calero, Penn, Tucker, Ceda, Vanden Hurk, Leroux, Wood, Owens, Trahern, Badenhop, Sinkbiel, Winters, Doolittle, Mobley, Allison

LHP - Pinto, Meyer, Tank, Thompson, West, G. Taylor

 

That is all AA or higher. We're going to get 7 (seven) out of this. Mark my words. Just try and no be to frustrated with the attrition process and hope we won't lose to many games as it sorts itself out. And you know if we're still in it last week of July, Beinfest isn't going to be gun shy if we need to add another veteran arm.

 

There is a lot, a lot, of talent here. It's going to be ok.

 

 

There are a lot of right-handed options. Lindstrom and Nunez should be fine. I'm confident they can be good enough. Kiko has shown promise. I'm sure we'll find 1 or 2 more righties that I'll feel ok with before year's end from that group.

 

Left-handed pitching is a problem out of the pen. We need a LOOGY. We need Taylor Tankersley to be Taylor Tankersley again.

He's a dick for his demands last off season. He asked for $700k, he got $700k. Then he asked for $800k and got that. He then asked for $900k and we gave him that too. Then he decided he wanted $1m. All this while shopping himself around during the winter meetings. Terrible person.

 

I agree with all of that except perhaps the "terrible" part. Maybe "not terribly smart" would be more apropos.

 

The guy's 34, been around for 10 years (7 of them in the minors,) has 3 young children and has never scored any big bucks. I'll guess he figured he's both injury-prone AND running out of time and better squeeze every out every dime possible.

 

His 4 major surgeries:

 

1999 Tommy John

2001 Labrum

2002 Labrum

2007 Labrum

 

Considering his history and circumstances, who would blame him? The repeated requests for more was certainly the wrong way to approach it, but he's a ballplayer, not a negotiating genius. Apparently, he's also too cheap to hire an agent, judging by his pitiful self-shopping episode.

 

The funniest thing is that he married the radiology fellow who read his '99 MRI.

 

The comments about him reminded me of an old article about him that contains the facts I mentioned above and which can be read here:

 

http://www.sun-sentinel.com/sports/basebal...,4979986.column

 

Were I he, I wouldn't be proud of the tactics, but I can certainly understand the motivations.

 

Who knows what he'll be by the end of the year? He could be anything from a $2 mill/yr RP to a released bust back under the surgical knife. I think the FO had a line in the sand drawn according to his risk of injury and he crossed it. So it goes.

 

If nothing else, he should get some credit for trying even though his execution was severely lacking. After all, he did get $1.3 mill, not a bad pay-day. Beats the heck out of $700K. With any luck, we'll kick his ass when we play the Rays.

We did up our offer to $850 K to Nelson, and he turned it down. Signed with Tampa for 1 yr, $1.3 mil. (Still think it wasn't just by chance and everything was legal about his appearance at those Vegas meetings.)

 

Rhodes signed with Cincy for 2 years and $4 mil.

 

Waechter signed with KC for 1 year, $650K.

 

Bob, I think you answered your own questions. Waechter ran out of gas, and stuff, in the last couple of months of the season ( see http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/players/spli...g&year=2008 ), teams were hitting over .425 against him in both August and Sept. In light of that I think you can decide for yourself if you'd want to make a commitment to that going into 2009.

 

Rhodes is a tougher one but coming off surgery I understand why they didn't want to make the two year commitment to AR he wanted and ultimately got. I would have but it isn't my money and I don't have the insider info to know what they were thinking. Of all of them this is the most questionable non-move of the off-season. Especially in light of what you have right now.

 

Nelson, as you implied may have orchestrated this but again when you trade in reclamation players there's a built-in health issue to deal with. So much of Nelson's career has been injury plagued.

 

Look at this season, they sign Proctor and Kiko, so far it looks questionable at best on one and brilliant on the other. You never know.

 

Apparently I didn't make myself very clear. My bad. I have no questions, other than being a little ticked over losing DLC. And that's only because I liked the kid for reasons other than his numbers.

 

Rhodes is one I would have liked to sign, but not questoning that move either. We just don't sign reclamation projects, or any pitcher, to more than 1 year deals. And he obviously wanted more $$$ than we thought he was worth to this team.

 

We also have to remember that they all probably ended up getting far less than they figured they could get. The downfall of the economy is mostly to blame. The FA market suffered greatly. And still is. There is still a future HOFer on the market. Despite what he is asking for, in past years somebody would have scooped him up just for the name recognition. Anyone that dosen't think the economy made this FA year bad should look at the numbers the PBP put out in Sunday's paper.

 

Yankees spent $441 mil in FA this winter but the rest of the AL spent a piddly $176 mil, and the entire NL only spent $534 mil. (Let's not forget that after the Yanks spent that cash they went back to the city and county for more cash to ensure their new palace would open on time. But that's another discussion)

 

Guys were signing for alot less than they figured they could get. But these three guys still got more than they were worth to this team. It's just that simple.

 

I'm liking Kiko. And Leo. And I have this thing for Meyer. I may come around on Penn. Proctor has something to prove. We still have a guy that is serving his suspension. We have so many guys in the minors that you have to believe some are going to make a mark and get the call (get it together Tank!!!). BUT If our starters can't start going longer in games it dosen't matter who we have in that pen.

 

I took this thread as us losing a game and someone thinking the sky is falling.

I still think this is going to work out just fine.

 

RHP - Lindstrom, Nunez, Kensing, Proctor, Calero, Penn, Tucker, Ceda, Vanden Hurk, Leroux, Wood, Owens, Trahern, Badenhop, Sinkbiel, Winters, Doolittle, Mobley, Allison

LHP - Pinto, Meyer, Tank, Thompson, West, G. Taylor

 

That is all AA or higher. We're going to get 7 (seven) out of this. Mark my words. Just try and no be to frustrated with the attrition process and hope we won't lose to many games as it sorts itself out. And you know if we're still in it last week of July, Beinfest isn't going to be gun shy if we need to add another veteran arm.

 

There is a lot, a lot, of talent here. It's going to be ok.

 

Just responding to your PM response here since it'll make it all the easier.

 

I agree that yeah, average, we got average all over the place. The average ERA this millennium is ~4.

 

I want my elitez though.

 

I mean, we have what, 4 option, lindstrom/nunez/trucker/ceda?

 

Lindstrom I have some major concerns over. His HR/FLY the past two years is just 2.5%. We're talking about a guy who has a 12.5% HR/FLY rate in the minors. The chances of him maintaining a 0.20 HR/9 is slim. A normalization would put him at a 1.00 HR/9, 11 more HRs in his career. We're talking about a guy who's only had success in the majors because of the fact he hasn't given up many HRs. Even giving him the benefit of the doubt and giving him a 9% HR/FB rate, that's ups his career FIP all the way to 3.69. Still nice, but we're not talking about the 3.00 FIPs he's put up two years running. There's then the K issue, where he only K'd 6.75 last year and had only a 7.5 K/9 in the minors. I'm not worried about his control even though he put up a 4.08 BB/9 last year. After his demotion/promotion, he put up a 3 BB/9 rest of the way, and had a 2.82 BB/9 in '07. I mean, if he can put up a 0.7 HR/9, 7.5 K/9, 3.0 BB/9, that's pretty damn solid, I just have questions if he can actually do that.

 

Nunez is basically in the same boat. A optimsicly-fair prediction is, what, 7.5 K/9, 2.5 BB/9, 1.0 HR/9? That gives a MR average FIP. He has a career 1.2 HR/9 with a 9.5 HR/FB% rate, 9.1% in the minors, so I mean, he's like a 1.2 HR/9 guy, and Royals stadium is basically duplicate Dolphin stadium, but he is going from AL to NL. And like Lindstrom, we're asking about strike out problems even though guys is a flamethrower. 7.6 MILB K/9, just 5.8 in the majors. Control beat though, certainly wonder if he could dip down the 2 BB/9 range. But the problem is, I could just as easily see him putting up a 6.5 K/9, 2.5 BB/9, 1.2 HR/9, and that really isn't good.

 

I'm cool with Nunez being an average reliever, but with his FB rates he's gonna give up too many HRs to be an elite guy. Unless he starts King at, like, a 9 plus K/9, or starts getting more GBs, his ceiling is an average MR.

 

Which then leaves the two minor guys. Jose Ceda has some marks, basically his control and his questionable work ethic. But we're also talking about obscene K numbers and two plus pitches. Just the biggest knock is what has happened so far as a Marlin: He hasn't pitched at all because he came into camp out of shape and also has a shoulder injury. With him it isn't so much can he do it, but will he get the chance.

 

And I know I've already gone over Tucker with you, but reiteriating for public view. His K/rates have gone to absolute ass since he has left the NY PENN league. He's gotten by the past two years with improved control, which is real nice to see, but also a dreadfully low HR?9 much like Lindstrom. He had just a 3.5% HR/9 in Jupiter, and then a f'n 2.1% HR/9 in Carolina. Those just aren't sustainable. He certainly has pretty decent GB/FB rates but he's not going to be putting up 0.30 HR/9's. It's just a think of what the hell happened to his K-rates. If they don't come back, he's in trouble. Maybe it's outside forces that play on it (i.e. being told to work more on his secondary pitches), but even then, we're still talking about a guy with only 1 plus pitch. He's littered all over top prospect lists so there's obviously something the scouts like, which I have no problem defaulting too, but I'm also not going to blindly follow the shepherd.

 

God I'm getting even MORE pissed we got rid of DLC. His GB rates are f***ing amazing and his HR/9 is going to be real nice, his control was continually improving, argggggg

 

I just want my 2 elitez. I certainly agree wholeheartly we're nowhere close to a bad stituation. But I want to be great everywhere, I want to smash faces to a pulp. We'll have the hitting several years running. We'll have the rotation several years running. We can be so f'n elite with a better back end bullpen. Good one, above average 2, average 3-5, below average high upside 6-7, that'll give us what damn good bullpen. Right now though it's looking more like we'll be having average 1-5, below average 6-7, which just really isn't something to fawn over.

 

I also agree with you though about the assertion of, we'll be making a lot of trades. Chances of us getting a very high BP arm certainly are up there.

I agree with the comment that if the starters can't give us 7 innings each night we're in trouble anyway. Nolasco is making me nervous right now. Miller can't throw strikes. Those are my two biggest concerns right now. With good starting pitching on a regular basis, Nunez and Calero can get us by in the pen. Oh, yeah, Lindstrom worries me too.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.