Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Cameron Maybin in CF

Featured Replies

My favorite thing about opening day (besides Publix Chicken Tender subs) is people who are so starved for baseball that they take every little thing and blow it completely out of proportion.

 

If this game had happened in May nobody would have any comments beyond "Gaby had a bad day". We all assume that opening day has to be indicative of some larger truth, because of how much importance we put on it. But it's just one game, no different than any other. I'm no more worried about anyone than I was yesterday.

 

 

 

I love you.

My favorite thing about opening day (besides Publix Chicken Tender subs) is people who are so starved for baseball that they take every little thing and blow it completely out of proportion.

 

If this game had happened in May nobody would have any comments beyond "Gaby had a bad day". We all assume that opening day has to be indicative of some larger truth, because of how much importance we put on it. But it's just one game, no different than any other. I'm no more worried about anyone than I was yesterday.

 

 

 

I love you.

 

First Miami-Fan, now Bobbob. If this doesn't happen in one of my posts soon, I'm going to [insert depressed/violent/suicidal? action here] myself.

I'm way more concerned about Gaby Sanchez's defense. Apparently nobody ever taught him to stretch at first base. No excuses there, just poor fundamentals.

 

:notworthy :notworthy Took it right out of my mouth

I don't really get the big deal about the stretching. Yeah, he should do it, but I don't buy that it makes a significant (or even a perceptible) difference. The physics don't match up.

 

We're talking about a ball traveling 65+ MPH between 90-150 feet. You're talking about a difference of hundredths of a second if he stretches. It's being overblown simply because it's an accepted fact of baseball, but I question whether the difference is even within the scope of most people's perception.

 

I'm not saying I think he shouldn't stretch for balls, I just don't think it's worth getting upset over. If he's comfortable that way, and it allows him to judge throws better, I'm fine with it.

 

The problem with him today was that he couldn't catch the damn ball when it hit hs glove. I don't buy that we get any extra outs if he stretches.

I don't really get the big deal about the stretching. Yeah, he should do it, but I don't buy that it makes a significant (or even a perceptible) difference. The physics don't match up.

 

We're talking about a ball traveling 65+ MPH between 90-150 feet. You're talking about a difference of hundredths of a second if he stretches. It's being overblown simply because it's an accepted fact of baseball, but I question whether the difference is even within the scope of most people's perception.

 

I'm not saying I think he shouldn't stretch for balls, I just don't think it's worth getting upset over. If he's comfortable that way, and it allows him to judge throws better, I'm fine with it.

 

The problem with him today was that he couldn't catch the damn ball when it hit hs glove. I don't buy that we get any extra outs if he stretches.

 

 

I think it makes a difference in the way the umpire see's it to be honest with you. That stretch may lean the umpire more to an out than a safe call. There were 2-3 plays were the runner looked safe because of Gaby not stretching.

 

And to get back on this topic... I may have to change the sig and avatar real soon! I still have hope though :|

But don't most umpires look at the bag and listen for the ball hitting glove?

 

I just question how big of a deal it is.

The one thing I was afraid of was people expecting us to have the same start to this season as last year's 11-1 start. We lost this one, but there is always Wednesday.

My favorite thing about opening day (besides Publix Chicken Tender subs) is people who are so starved for baseball that they take every little thing and blow it completely out of proportion.

 

If this game had happened in May nobody would have any comments beyond "Gaby had a bad day". We all assume that opening day has to be indicative of some larger truth, because of how much importance we put on it. But it's just one game, no different than any other. I'm no more worried about anyone than I was yesterday.

 

 

 

I love you.

 

First Miami-Fan, now Bobbob. If this doesn't happen in one of my posts soon, I'm going to [insert depressed/violent/suicidal? action here] myself.

 

Your time will come.

By the way I think we have found the boards new Hermi in Cam.

 

 

Hypothetically lets say Maybin plays like he did last year at the start of the season, how long does the team give him to get it together? Does he get sent back to the minors or sit the bench? Who replaces him Cousins, Peterson Carrol, maybe Stanton if hes killing it? I'm figuring Ross will go back to center. I think the team will give Maybin a little more time than last year but not much.

 

 

Nobody will ever be as infuriating a player as Jeremy Hermida was. Hermida is a world of his own. Nobody will ever be the next Jeremy Hermida, no matter how bad they are. I hope to god we don't ever have another player like Hermida.

 

There, I got that out of my system.

I don't really get the big deal about the stretching. Yeah, he should do it, but I don't buy that it makes a significant (or even a perceptible) difference. The physics don't match up.

 

We're talking about a ball traveling 65+ MPH between 90-150 feet. You're talking about a difference of hundredths of a second if he stretches. It's being overblown simply because it's an accepted fact of baseball, but I question whether the difference is even within the scope of most people's perception.

 

I'm not saying I think he shouldn't stretch for balls, I just don't think it's worth getting upset over. If he's comfortable that way, and it allows him to judge throws better, I'm fine with it.

 

The problem with him today was that he couldn't catch the damn ball when it hit hs glove. I don't buy that we get any extra outs if he stretches.

 

 

Okay, I love you, also.

 

I would love to see a study on the amount of plays where it actually makes a difference. And I would want that compared to the increased likelihood that a first baseman drops the ball or accidentally comes of the bag due to being stretched out.

 

Both are extremely small possibilities, and they probably cancel each other out in such a way that it's a nearly nil difference.

 

I'm guessing the only reason this actually matters is because it plays to the fans' perception of a player hustling.

By the way I think we have found the boards new Hermi in Cam.

 

 

Hypothetically lets say Maybin plays like he did last year at the start of the season, how long does the team give him to get it together? Does he get sent back to the minors or sit the bench? Who replaces him Cousins, Peterson Carrol, maybe Stanton if hes killing it? I'm figuring Ross will go back to center. I think the team will give Maybin a little more time than last year but not much.

 

 

Nobody will ever be as infuriating a player as Jeremy Hermida was. Hermida is a world of his own. Nobody will ever be the next Jeremy Hermida, no matter how bad they are. I hope to god we don't ever have another player like Hermida.

 

There, I got that out of my system.

 

Jamarcus Russell and Vernon Gholston.

By the way I think we have found the boards new Hermi in Cam.

 

 

Hypothetically lets say Maybin plays like he did last year at the start of the season, how long does the team give him to get it together? Does he get sent back to the minors or sit the bench? Who replaces him Cousins, Peterson Carrol, maybe Stanton if hes killing it? I'm figuring Ross will go back to center. I think the team will give Maybin a little more time than last year but not much.

 

 

Nobody will ever be as infuriating a player as Jeremy Hermida was. Hermida is a world of his own. Nobody will ever be the next Jeremy Hermida, no matter how bad they are. I hope to god we don't ever have another player like Hermida.

 

There, I got that out of my system.

 

Jamarcus Russell and Vernon Gholston.

 

 

That was just an over exaggeration. Hermida at least had some success.

By the way I think we have found the boards new Hermi in Cam.

 

 

Hypothetically lets say Maybin plays like he did last year at the start of the season, how long does the team give him to get it together? Does he get sent back to the minors or sit the bench? Who replaces him Cousins, Peterson Carrol, maybe Stanton if hes killing it? I'm figuring Ross will go back to center. I think the team will give Maybin a little more time than last year but not much.

 

 

Nobody will ever be as infuriating a player as Jeremy Hermida was. Hermida is a world of his own. Nobody will ever be the next Jeremy Hermida, no matter how bad they are. I hope to god we don't ever have another player like Hermida.

 

There, I got that out of my system.

 

Jamarcus Russell and Vernon Gholston.

 

I was never a Raiders or Jets fan.

I think it's every baseball fan's instinctive reaction to say "omfg how could he not stretch you learn that in middle school", but when you actually think about it, I just don't see how it's something that makes a tangible difference.

When was the last time you saw a 1B do what Gaby Sanchez, consistently, did today? When a stretch is necessary, a 1B stretches. All of them do. Even Mike Jacobs, who is absolutely horrible, stretches.

 

And it is important if he can't stretch, or doesn't like to stretch. A 1B can save a lot of errors. It's an underrated position, defensively. I'm not asking for another Derrek Lee, but c'mon. The guy looked like he was just playing catch today with a friend. And he didn't even catch them all. That has to be fixed, and I'm sure someone will tell him something about it, for sure.

I think he should do whatever he is comfortable with. The problem today was that he got hit 3 times in the glove and didn't come up with it. That isn't a result of stretching for a play, it's him making bad plays.

I'm really not sure I agree with that. It was bang bang, there's no guarantee the extra 3 feet made the difference. That's such a miniscule difference in time.

 

I know rich and Tommy were all pissed about it, but I'm not sure I buy it.

I'm really not sure I agree with that. It was bang bang, there's no guarantee the extra 3 feet made the difference. That's such a miniscule difference in time.

 

 

That's possible. I was watching the Mets telecast and they showed it a couple of times in slow motion. It looked closer to 4-5 feet. And there didn't seem to be any doubt Castillo would have been out if he had stretched like a normal first baseman.

This is gonna be a bit stream of consciousness, but here we go:

 

I'm going to assume that a 1st baseman stretching completely gives him an extra 3 feet.

Let's assume the average IF throw is coming at 80 MPH.

 

80 MPH = 422,400 feet per hour = 7,040 feet per minute = 117.33 feet per second.

 

3/117.33 = .0256 second different. That's less than 3 hundredths of a second. One-fortieth of one second, roughly.

 

Now the key question: does that make a difference? My guess is it makes a very, very slight one. How many plays were +/- 1/40th of a second being the difference between being safe or out?

A few more rough calculations. By the way, feel free to argue my assumptions and argue for a recalculation.

 

If the average step is 3 feet, it would take 30 steps to get to 1st base from the batters box. Let's say the average player takes 4 seconds to get to first base. So, that would be 30 steps in 4 seconds = 7.5 steps per second.

 

So, each step takes 1/7.5 = .133 seconds.

 

.0256/.133 = .1925.

 

Translation: Given my assumptions, the play would have to be determined by roughly 1/5th of a step in either direction for the stretching 1st baseman to make any difference.

 

And this is not even counting the increased likelihood that the 1st baseman drops the ball due to him stretching out (I am quite sure this is more likely; it is definitely easier to catch a ball while standing upright than it is bent over and stretched out (OH MY GOD THAT SOUNDS HORRIBLE)).

It might have made a difference had Gaby stretched, but that doesn't change the fact that we couldn't do squat against Santana.

You guys are just looking at the plays today, though. What happens when he has to stretch for a bad throw and save a run or something? If he can't make an easy stretch, how horrible is he going to make the rest of our infielders look when they don't make the picture perfect throws? My point is, he seems very unathletic out there.

You guys are just looking at the plays today, though. What happens when he has to stretch for a bad throw and save a run or something? If he can't make an easy stretch, how horrible is he going to make the rest of our infielders look when they don't make the picture perfect throws? My point is, he seems very unathletic out there.

 

 

I don't think the issue is whether he CAN stretch; the issue is if he DOES stretch.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.