November 14, 201016 yr I don't get why it frustrates you, though. This is a Marlins message board, and it's the off season. It's fun to throw ideas around and see what the Marlins can do. Not against people being creative, but against the ideas being mis-branded as real possibilities. To group Gaby Sanchez together with Nunez/Uggla in terms of trade possibilities sends the wrong message.
November 14, 201016 yr I don't get why it frustrates you, though. This is a Marlins message board, and it's the off season. It's fun to throw ideas around and see what the Marlins can do. Not against people being creative, but against the ideas being mis-branded as real possibilities. To group Gaby Sanchez together with Nunez/Uggla in terms of trade possibilities sends the wrong message. To be fair, I never said it was a "real possibility," if you're referring to me. The Gardner thing was just a hypothetical question on my part. I know that realistically the Yankees have very little reason to trade Gardner.
November 14, 201016 yr Nay, yay, nay. I don't like Nunez. Almost every time he pitched I was afraid of what was happening next. He's a roller coaster ride or maybe a train wreck just waiting to happen
November 14, 201016 yr I don't get why it frustrates you, though. This is a Marlins message board, and it's the off season. It's fun to throw ideas around and see what the Marlins can do. Not against people being creative, but against the ideas being mis-branded as real possibilities. To group Gaby Sanchez together with Nunez/Uggla in terms of trade possibilities sends the wrong message. I don't think anyone called it a real possibility. It's something to toy with if certain things were to fall into place. The Yankees haven't obtained an OF to replace Gardner and the Marlins haven't expressed interest in obtaining an OF
November 14, 201016 yr Trading Gaby doesn't make much sense either. As stated, he's still very cheap. Do you really think you are going to get much for him? Not worth it.
November 14, 201016 yr Trading Gaby doesn't make much sense either. As stated, he's still very cheap. Do you really think you are going to get much for him? Not worth it. That's pretty much what my point is here. The chances of Gaby Sanchez being traded this offseason are 0.00% and yet there seems to be a prevailing opinion that he will be moved. This only complicates realistic discussion of moves from here on out (trading Uggla and such).
November 14, 201016 yr Gaby needs to be moved either this offseason or next offseason because Morrison will be a lot more detrimental to our defense in LF than Coghlan ever was. Morrison needs to be a 1B sooner rather than later.
November 14, 201016 yr At this point I think Gaby will only be moved if bundled with Uggla or Nunez in a deal. Alone Gaby won't get you much.
November 14, 201016 yr Gaby needs to be moved either this offseason or next offseason because Morrison will be a lot more detrimental to our defense in LF than Coghlan ever was. Morrison needs to be a 1B sooner rather than later. This. I want Morrisson at first base, not left field.
November 14, 201016 yr I was for trading Gaby, and moving Morrison to 1B. However, if Uggla is being traded, Gaby has to stay. Plus, Gaby's trade value probably = quality reliever, and after getting 2 quality relievers for Maybin, our need for relief pitching isn't as great as it once was. Assuming we trade Uggla (seems likely), we're going to need all the offense we can get.
November 15, 201016 yr Gaby needs to be moved either this offseason or next offseason because Morrison will be a lot more detrimental to our defense in LF than Coghlan ever was. Morrison needs to be a 1B sooner rather than later. Well you can''t trade everyone, dim. You need guys to who can play positions. Right now we're looking at this: LF - Morrison CF - ??????? RF - Stanton 3B - Coghlan SS - Ramireze 2B - ??????? 1B - Gaby C - ????? If you trade Gaby and move Morrison to first, there are far too many holes.
November 15, 201016 yr Author Yes, I know the Marlins haven't openly come out and said they are trying to move Gaby... and why should they? But do you think he is untouchable if an offer presents itself? Of course not. Gaby doesn't look like he fits into the Marlins long term plans. Besides, these are just fun little guesses where we get to play virtual GM. Give me a break, its one of the fun things I get to do right now lol. I'm just trying to see what teams would have needs in certain areas and see what prospects/players look good on that team. Who knows if Brett Gardner is available? But isn't it fun to imagine him in a Marlins uniform and what it possibly might take to bring him here? And it's been well-documented the Rays aren't bringing Pena back and Soriano is getting very expensive. Leo Nunez is about 1/3rd cheaper than Soriano, and Gaby is about 1/15th cheaper than Pena will be. And they have a surplus of amazing starters. Why can't I dream up of a trade? It's the offseason. Let us fantasy GM's have our fun.
November 15, 201016 yr Catcher will be Baker/Paulino in all likelihood. Even if Baker isn't ready and Paulino isn't brought back, Hayes will probably start considering he did a decent job last year. This team can probably get away with a Hayes/Davis platoon. Hell if needed AJ Pierzynski has said he would like to come to the Marlins. At 2B, my plan has been and will continue to be first and foremost try and resign Uggla. Only if worst comes to worst and Uggla simply refuses to resign do we trade him. CF is an issue, but again, a worst comes to worst situation could be either Coghlan in CF ( ) or Bonifacio/Cousins filling in at CF for a bit. Still a lot of uncertainty. I'd like Gaby on the team next year, I just wish he played 3B instead of 1B (I know he's played 3B before, he just wasn't good at it), it would make things a lot more simple. Still, within the next two years it will be nearly impossible to have BOTH Morrison and Sanchez on the team together. With Morrison being a long term fixture, Gaby will be the piece up for trade.
November 15, 201016 yr Gaby needs to be moved either this offseason or next offseason because Morrison will be a lot more detrimental to our defense in LF than Coghlan ever was. Morrison needs to be a 1B sooner rather than later. Well you can''t trade everyone, dim. You need guys to who can play positions. Right now we're looking at this: LF - Morrison CF - ??????? RF - Stanton 3B - Coghlan SS - Ramireze 2B - ??????? 1B - Gaby C - ????? If you trade Gaby and move Morrison to first, there are far too many holes. You try to trade Gaby for a fielder if Uggla is traded for pitching. If Gaby is traded for an outfielder(preferably a CF'er) in a package here's what we have... C N/A 1B- Morrison 2B- Martinez/Coghlan SS- Hanley 3B- Dominguez/Coghlan Lf- Coghlan/Cousins/Peterson CF- Traded Player/Cousins/Bonifacio RF- Stanton Considering our catching situation I wouldn't be surprised if we sign A.J. Pierzynski.
November 15, 201016 yr Catcher will be Baker/Paulino in all likelihood. Even if Baker isn't ready and Paulino isn't brought back, Hayes will probably start considering he did a decent job last year. This team can probably get away with a Hayes/Davis platoon. Hell if needed AJ Pierzynski has said he would like to come to the Marlins. Brett Hayes is not going to be this team's starting catcher next year. No chance.
November 15, 201016 yr Author Catcher will be Baker/Paulino in all likelihood. Even if Baker isn't ready and Paulino isn't brought back, Hayes will probably start considering he did a decent job last year. This team can probably get away with a Hayes/Davis platoon. Hell if needed AJ Pierzynski has said he would like to come to the Marlins. Brett Hayes is not going to be this team's starting catcher next year. No chance. Hope not lol. I would love AJ, but I don't think he is worth a multi-year contract. If Baker is ready, I have faith in him to hold the position down until Paulino is back and they can platoon again.
November 15, 201016 yr The Baker/Paulino platoon was good enough, really. I'm really not concerned about an upgrade as much as I am about keeping that level of production in that spot. Whether you bring them both back or not, we can't afford to just lose production from the catcher spot if this team plans on trading Uggla.
November 15, 201016 yr Gaby might be traded eventually but it's practically impossible that he goes this offseason, Uggla or no Uggla. He is incredibly cheap and is consistent with the bat. That will be essential for the Marlins for 2011. Yes, Morrison might be a minus defender in LF, but that isn't reason enough to move Sanchez at this point. The Marlins will at least give Morrison more innings out there to give him a chance to improve, and I think he will. What many people here don't seem to realize is that the front office obviously has little reservations about playing certain guys outside of their natural positions. Take Beinfest's comments about Coghlan in CF as proof of this. Cost has a lot to do with this, which is why Sanchez will be staying.
November 15, 201016 yr Gaby needs to be moved either this offseason or next offseason because Morrison will be a lot more detrimental to our defense in LF than Coghlan ever was. Morrison needs to be a 1B sooner rather than later. Well you can''t trade everyone, dim. You need guys to who can play positions. Right now we're looking at this: LF - Morrison CF - ??????? RF - Stanton 3B - Coghlan SS - Ramireze 2B - ??????? 1B - Gaby C - ????? If you trade Gaby and move Morrison to first, there are far too many holes. You try to trade Gaby for a fielder if Uggla is traded for pitching. If Gaby is traded for an outfielder(preferably a CF'er) in a package here's what we have... C N/A 1B- Morrison 2B- Martinez/Coghlan SS- Hanley 3B- Dominguez/Coghlan Lf- Coghlan/Cousins/Peterson CF- Traded Player/Cousins/Bonifacio RF- Stanton Considering our catching situation I wouldn't be surprised if we sign A.J. Pierzynski. This all seems very logical, but I'm not so sure it's desirable. Looks like our offense loses a lot of punch this way.
November 15, 201016 yr And then there's the question of Coghlan. It's not out of the question that he doesn't regain form. Trading away more than one piece from our lineup has the potential to seriously hurt this team, especially if we have one of our younger guys struggle.
November 15, 201016 yr i still like the idea of getting bj upton......but that's just me. i think he'd look good patrolling center and leading off for us. with pena and soriano leaving in free agency the rays could use nunez or gaby.
November 15, 201016 yr i still like the idea of getting bj upton......but that's just me. i think he'd look good patrolling center and leading off for us. with pena and soriano leaving in free agency the rays could use nunez or gaby. I like his talent but he should be a lot better then he has been, I mean .237 AVG OPS Under .800 and 137 SO is not something I'd want on my team, we could basically keep Maybin and get similar offensive numbers with worse defense and less of an attitude.
November 15, 201016 yr Upton made $3 million in 2010, and that will only increase through arbritration. I'll give him a big no.
November 15, 201016 yr I would bring back Miguel Olivo to catch. Like his power and durability and he has shown some productivity after leaving the Marlins a few years back. Seems to be a good guy too. He's a free agent. The best opportunity to get something for Uggla could be gone. I was excited about the rumors of getting Jonathan Sanchez for Uggla last off season. There is no way a team will give up that kind of talent just for the right to pay Uggla over $10 million to play second base now. However, I would at least target the Padres as a trade partner again. They could use power in their lineup and might be willing to give up a young pitcher (Latos?) in a package that included Uggla and maybe Volstad or even Nolasco. In any case, I would move Uggla at this point for the best deal out there ... even minor league prospects. A quality left starter would be nice ... and I would trade for as many of those prospects as possible. Sure don't want any more veteran Nate Robertsons just for the heck of it. I think Sanabia is going to be really good. Don't like Morrison in the outfield and I don't think he will ever show the power needed at first base. He might be decent trade bait. For the next couple years, Sanchez will supply better offense than Morrison.
November 15, 201016 yr Author I would bring back Miguel Olivo to catch. Like his power and durability and he has shown some productivity after leaving the Marlins a few years back. Seems to be a good guy too. He's a free agent. The best opportunity to get something for Uggla could be gone. I was excited about the rumors of getting Jonathan Sanchez for Uggla last off season. There is no way a team will give up that kind of talent just for the right to pay Uggla over $10 million to play second base now. However, I would at least target the Padres as a trade partner again. They could use power in their lineup and might be willing to give up a young pitcher (Latos?) in a package that included Uggla and maybe Volstad or even Nolasco. In any case, I would move Uggla at this point for the best deal out there ... even minor league prospects. A quality left starter would be nice ... and I would trade for as many of those prospects as possible. Sure don't want any more veteran Nate Robertsons just for the heck of it. I think Sanabia is going to be really good. Don't like Morrison in the outfield and I don't think he will ever show the power needed at first base. He might be decent trade bait. For the next couple years, Sanchez will supply better offense than Morrison. Sorry to burst your bubble, but that was the Coors field effect. If we bring him back, he would be the same old catcher. But that is still an upgrade defensively over anything we have now. Though it would be a dream come true, we sadly could never get Latos from the Padres... I think they probably consider him untouchable right now.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.