November 18, 201016 yr http://joefrisaro.mlblogs.com/archives/2010/11/edwins_tentative_lineup.html 1) Chris Coghlan, CF 2) Omar Infante, 2B 3) Hanley Ramirez, SS 4) Mike Stanton, RF 5) Gaby Sanchez, 1B 6) Logan Morrison, LF 7) John Buck, C 8) Matt Dominguez/Emilio Bonifacio, 3B Hmmm... I really don't like Logan batting 6th.
November 18, 201016 yr Edwin said 4-7 could go a bunch of ways with those 4 guys, he hadn't really decided yet.
November 18, 201016 yr I'd go Coghlan, Infante, LoMo, Hanley, Stanton/Sanchez, Sanchez/Stanton, Buck, other
November 19, 201016 yr I'd go Coghlan, Infante, LoMo, Hanley, Stanton/Sanchez, Sanchez/Stanton, Buck, other So you'd bat our best player fourth and a guy with no power third and our biggest power threat fifth/sixth?
November 19, 201016 yr Is Coghlan really being considered in Center? I can't see him in CF at all. I feel you man, it sounds weird. But yeah, the team sounds pretty serious about it.
November 19, 201016 yr I'd go Coghlan, Infante, LoMo, Hanley, Stanton/Sanchez, Sanchez/Stanton, Buck, other So you'd bat our best player fourth and a guy with no power third and our biggest power threat fifth/sixth? Lots of great hitters hit cleanup. You could look it up. Stanton is going to strike out a ton, If/when he matures in his plate discipline and contact, he moves up to bat fourth. I see no reason to make believe that he is presently a polished hitter. I expect LoMo to drive the ball, be selective and give Hanley a lot of first and thirds and first and seconds after one of the first two get on base. I also expect Morrison to hit 15 HR next season and a lot of doubles.
November 19, 201016 yr Morrison needs to be hitting higher in the lineup if he gets on base like he did last year. Move down Coghlan if they have to.
November 19, 201016 yr I'd go Coghlan, Infante, LoMo, Hanley, Stanton/Sanchez, Sanchez/Stanton, Buck, other So you'd bat our best player fourth and a guy with no power third and our biggest power threat fifth/sixth? Lots of great hitters hit cleanup. You could look it up. Stanton is going to strike out a ton, If/when he matures in his plate discipline and contact, he moves up to bat fourth. I see no reason to make believe that he is presently a polished hitter. I expect LoMo to drive the ball, be selective and give Hanley a lot of first and thirds and first and seconds after one of the first two get on base. I also expect Morrison to hit 15 HR next season and a lot of doubles. Can you tell me of a team where the 3rd hitter is substantially worse than the 4th hitter and maybe the 5th-7th best hitter on the team?
November 19, 201016 yr I'd bat LoMO 5th because he'd be a great RBI Man since he puts the ball in play well and will get a ton of extrabasehits driving in guys like Coghlan, Stanton, Infante and Hanley.
November 19, 201016 yr still a fun lineup even without uggla it looks like. Infante and cogs 2 great batting avg guys and we still have a ton of power hanley stanton gaby buck morrison can all knock it around. I'll miss uggla but looking towards the future with excitment and a bullpen !
November 19, 201016 yr I'd go Coghlan, Infante, LoMo, Hanley, Stanton/Sanchez, Sanchez/Stanton, Buck, other So you'd bat our best player fourth and a guy with no power third and our biggest power threat fifth/sixth? Lots of great hitters hit cleanup. You could look it up. Stanton is going to strike out a ton, If/when he matures in his plate discipline and contact, he moves up to bat fourth. I see no reason to make believe that he is presently a polished hitter. I expect LoMo to drive the ball, be selective and give Hanley a lot of first and thirds and first and seconds after one of the first two get on base. I also expect Morrison to hit 15 HR next season and a lot of doubles. Can you tell me of a team where the 3rd hitter is substantially worse than the 4th hitter and maybe the 5th-7th best hitter on the team? No. But LoMo is not the 5th 6th or 7th best hitter on the Marlins in 2011.
November 19, 201016 yr I'd go Coghlan, Infante, LoMo, Hanley, Stanton/Sanchez, Sanchez/Stanton, Buck, other In no way should LoMo bat 3rd...nor Hanley 4th.
November 19, 201016 yr Then LoMo bats second. It would stupid to put a 400 obp guy sixth or seventh. He never OBPed .400 in his career in the minors and had under 300 ABs last year.
November 19, 201016 yr Then LoMo bats second. It would stupid to put a 400 obp guy sixth or seventh. He never OBPed .400 in his career in the minors and had under 300 ABs last year. Well, except for 2008, 2009 and 2010 - you are correct.
November 19, 201016 yr I dont hate all these offseason moves, color me in the minority, but from opening day last year to this year, I think our lineup has improved overall. If we were able to add Upton I would be thrilled. Also if Boni starts at third, it will only be temporary until the give Dominguez a shot. Boni is a worse version of Infante at this point and not a bad piece to have on your bench, but a bad starter.
November 19, 201016 yr Then LoMo bats second. It would stupid to put a 400 obp guy sixth or seventh. He never OBPed .400 in his career in the minors and had under 300 ABs last year. Well, except for 2008, 2009 and 2010 - you are correct. Sorry, didn't know we were counting A and A+ and a half season in AAA.
November 19, 201016 yr Then LoMo bats second. It would stupid to put a 400 obp guy sixth or seventh. He never OBPed .400 in his career in the minors and had under 300 ABs last year. Well, except for 2008, 2009 and 2010 - you are correct. Sorry, didn't know we were counting A and A+ and a half season in AAA. It takes a big man to admit he was wrong. And little fellow, LoMo did .411 OBP in AA.
November 19, 201016 yr It takes a big man to admit he was wrong. And little fellow, LoMo did .411 OBP in AA. In 79 games. And Jeremy Hermida did .457 in a full season of AA. Don't get me wrong, I think Morrison has above average OBP potential in the majors but just because he put up a .390 in his first 62 games, doesn't mean he must hit second, especially over Infante who has put up two straight .350+ full years.
November 19, 201016 yr It takes a big man to admit he was wrong. And little fellow, LoMo did .411 OBP in AA. For someone who bristled at perceived condescension so much the other day, you do a good job of it yourself.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.