April 25, 201412 yr Oy vey. Alvarez is not consistent. Just because he hasn't given up more than 3 earned runs in a start this year does not make him "consistent." He had a great start last time out, but before that, just about every ball hit off of him was ripped. Just like last year. He gets hit hard, a lot of the outs he gets are hard hit. It's amazing how you claim to use the "eye test" when you evaluate players, yet you must turn away when Alvarez pitches cause you seem to be blind to the fact that a lot of the contact he allows is a hard hit ball somewhere. The numbers are a bit skewed, as well, because a hard hit ground ball doesn't show up in a line drive percentage. If they did, I'm sure he'd be in the 70 LD% range.
April 25, 201412 yr Author No question that the fish won the Toronto deal Exactly! No matter what happens with the players acquired, the Marlins won this trade by getting rid of the Reyes and Buehrle contracts
April 25, 201412 yr reinvest any of that money that they freed up? Yeah, maaan, in a catcher thing and a first baseman thing and a guy who can hit lefties thing and a stopgap at third thing.
April 26, 201412 yr I'll never understand how the Reyes contract went from being fair in 2012 to being an albatross in 2013 the second he was dealt. That was a fair contract. It most likely wouldn't have hindered this team before the last year or two. Buehrle's contract was also a 3 year deal. It wasn't that big of a problem.
April 26, 201412 yr Massive losses tend to get your attention when you're the one suffering them. I almost feel sorry that Loria suffered massive losses for one year, almost enough to ignore the massive profits he made in the decade before that which offset those massive losses he suffered in that one year by a factor of ten.
April 27, 201412 yr I'll never understand how the Reyes contract went from being fair in 2012 to being an albatross in 2013 the second he was dealt. That was a fair contract. It most likely wouldn't have hindered this team before the last year or two. Buehrle's contract was also a 3 year deal. It wasn't that big of a problem. Yea, that was a 4 year deal. Reyes' deal was fair. That's why he was clearly the centerpiece of the deal.
April 27, 201412 yr And maybe they didn't deal him in '12 because he wasn't worth s*** and nobody made a good offer? He had a bunch of value in 2012. That's why the scouts were following him around before the deadline.
April 27, 201412 yr He had a bunch of value in 2012. That's why the scouts were following him around before the deadline. And if I remember correctly the scouts were telling their teams he wasn't worth much, which was why a deal was never made. We wanted more than anyone was offering so we held onto him. Maybe you don't remember that.
April 27, 201412 yr Scouts told their teams that Johnson wasn't worth what the Marlins were asking, which was far more than what he was worth. However, what he was actually worth (lower than what the Marlins were asking) at the time, was still greater value than what the Marlins got from him in the Toronto trade.
April 27, 201412 yr Scouts told their teams that Johnson wasn't worth what the Marlins were asking, which was far more than what he was worth. However, what he was actually worth (lower than what the Marlins were asking) at the time, was still greater value than what the Marlins got from him in the Toronto trade. That is seriously debatable. You're not considering the value of those contracts that were dumped AS WELL AS the talent that came back. I'm totally fine with the decisions they made. Can't believe you're actually upset about it 2 years later the way things have played out until this point.
April 28, 201412 yr That is seriously debatable. You're not considering the value of those contracts that were dumped AS WELL AS the talent that came back. I'm totally fine with the decisions they made. Can't believe you're actually upset about it 2 years later the way things have played out until this point. I'm saying that Johnson's overall value was higher during the season than when it was when he was traded. You cannot say for sure what would have happened, but based on the interest he received from half of MLB before the deadline, it is safe to assume they would have gotten a better return. I desperately wanted the Marlins to trade Johnson during that disaster of the season before the Toronto trade even happened. To say I'm upset about it is also a pretty big overstatement.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.