June 15, 201412 yr What a stud. He is the most consistent player we have and more importantly comes through when the chips are down. There is no one id rather see at the plate when it counts. I would have been disappointed if Alvarez picked up a loss after a solid day.
June 15, 201412 yr Probably one of the more inexplicable stats I've seen is that McGehee currently has only a 0.4 WAR. through top 10 in BA, RBI's, unbelievable with RISP, less errors at 3rd that any NL 3rd base regular. WTF. So because he's only hit 1 HR all yr, he's just barely above replacement level. Wow! For those who have a healthy skepticism about the whole sabermetic exercise, McGehee's WAR is a good reason why.
June 15, 201412 yr Probably one of the more inexplicable stats I've seen is that McGehee currently has only a 0.4 WAR. through top 10 in BA, RBI's, unbelievable with RISP, less errors at 3rd that any NL 3rd base regular. WTF. So because he's only hit 1 HR all yr, he's just barely above replacement level. Wow! For those who have a healthy skepticism about the whole sabermetic exercise, McGehee's WAR is a good reason why. Back to my opinion that WAR is an opinion with a statistical basis. I think we can all agree McGehee has been worth more than half a win or so.
June 15, 201412 yr Back to my opinion that WAR is an opinion with a statistical basis. I think we can all agree McGehee has been worth more than half a win or so. No, you just don't understand what WAR is.
June 15, 201412 yr No, you just don't understand what WAR is. Wins above replacement. Said players WAR is the estimation of how many wins they are worth to their team over an ordinary, average major league player. It's based on upon many advanced statistics that factor batting, defense, and baserunning to gauge a player entirely.
June 15, 201412 yr Wins above replacement. Said players WAR is the estimation of how many wins they are worth to their team over an ordinary, average major league player. It's based on upon many advanced statistics that factor batting, defense, and baserunning to gauge a player entirely. Evidently, it must weigh heavily home runs in its calculus making it a bullshit stat if McGehee is ranked so low. Sent from my SGH-M919 using Tapatalk
June 15, 201412 yr Wins above replacement. Said players WAR is the estimation of how many wins they are worth to their team over an ordinary, average major league player. It's based on upon many advanced statistics that factor batting, defense, and baserunning to gauge a player entirely. Just because you understand what it stands for doesn't mean you understand how it's calculated. Clearly, you don't. If you're looking for a stat that shows what Casey Mcgehee's impact on wins and losses has been to our team so far, you might be more interested in WPA. WAR isn't big on factoring situational hitting, probably because Casey Mcgehee's season so far with men on base is not sustainable and isn't really a skill. It's just happened. Just because a statistic doesn't show you what you want to see in a specific instance, that doesn't make it "an opinion with a statistical basis," whatever that means. Not to mention that Mcgehee isn't exactly a stud defensively or on the bases so he's not creating value in those areas of the game/it's negatively impacting his WAR #. It's funny how you've cited WAR when it's convenient for your debates in the past, yet when it's not you shrug it off as an irrelevant "opinion with a statistical basis." Pick one or the other.
June 15, 201412 yr I will not bite. Still, setting all that aside, Casey's been great (particularly considering we weren't expecting much). No doubt we would all be screaming after every loss if Stanton were getting walked consistently and no one hitting 4th could do anything. The lack of homers has been sort of strange but we always go back to that big "who ya want at the plate in a big spot" question? I'll take him. And yeah sure BABIP etc he's bound to slow down, gloom doom, etc. I'm happy. Fangraphs has him at 1.1 WAR fwiw.. behind Stanton, Yelich, and Ozuna. Sounds about right to me.
June 15, 201412 yr Just because you understand what it stands for doesn't mean you understand how it's calculated. Clearly, you don't. If you're looking for a stat that shows what Casey Mcgehee's impact on wins and losses has been to our team so far, you might be more interested in WPA. WAR isn't big on factoring situational hitting, probably because Casey Mcgehee's season so far with men on base is not sustainable and isn't really a skill. It's just happened. Just because a statistic doesn't show you what you want to see in a specific instance, that doesn't make it "an opinion with a statistical basis," whatever that means. Not to mention that Mcgehee isn't exactly a stud defensively or on the bases so he's not creating value in those areas of the game/it's negatively impacting his WAR #. It's funny how you've cited WAR when it's convenient for your debates in the past, yet when it's not you shrug it off as an irrelevant "opinion with a statistical basis." Pick one or the other. I don't know the exact calculation, you're right. Do you? Also, saying that situational hitting, or hitting with men on base, is not a skill and "just happens" is just dumb. Batters don't always go to the plate against any pitcher in any situation with the same approach and just cross their fingers. Every at bat and situation is different and should be treated that way. And you either succeed in said situations or you don't based on your approach. McGehee is a solid ball player. Is he a gold glove winner? No, but he's not a turd either. He's probably been above average defensively. I also doubt he has cost us anything on the bases, either. I wouldn't be able to accept those two areas of his game have impacted him negatively, becuase they haven't really hurt us ever. I've said many times that I do believe in WAR and I do think WAR is a good way to gauge most players. Considering it accurately identifies the best players in baseball consistently it's hard to argue with that. That's why I have cited it before. However I don't think we should live or die by it, either.
June 15, 201412 yr I don't know the exact calculation, you're right. Do you? Also, saying that situational hitting, or hitting with men on base, is not a skill and "just happens" is just dumb. Batters don't always go to the plate against any pitcher in any situation with the same approach and just cross their fingers. Every at bat and situation is different and should be treated that way. And you either succeed in said situations or you don't based on your approach. McGehee is a solid ball player. Is he a gold glove winner? No, but he's not a turd either. He's probably been above average defensively. I also doubt he has cost us anything on the bases, either. I wouldn't be able to accept those two areas of his game have impacted him negatively, becuase they haven't really hurt us ever. I've said many times that I do believe in WAR and I do think WAR is a good way to gauge most players. Considering it accurately identifies the best players in baseball consistently it's hard to argue with that. That's why I have cited it before. However I don't think we should live or die by it, either. It's not a sustainable skill. If this were a skill, Casey Mcgehee would've never had to go to Japan because he would've just stayed in the big leagues as the clutchest hitter ever. This happens every year. Look at last year. Compare what Allan Craig did last year to what he's doing this year with men on base. Then you could just do the rest for the entire St. Louis Cardinals roster. If you put a team together based on a year of clutch hitting and expect similar results the next year, you're probably in a bit of trouble. If you believe in WAR, you probably know that a .439 .BABIP with men on base and a .460 .BABIP with RISP is simply not sustainable. It is nice that it has happened and it still counts, but you can't count on that continuing. I don't think that WAR is a stat to live and die by either. As a matter of fact, I rarely cite it by itself. I simply don't think it is an "opinion based on a statistical basis." I'm not even sure what that means, and I think it contradicts this last post of yours. I've already cited another # for you to look at that you might like more in this specific case. Casey Mcgehee has been a top-10 hitter this year based on WPA (win probability added). Stanton is first.
June 16, 201412 yr It's not a sustainable skill. If this were a skill, Casey Mcgehee would've never had to go to Japan because he would've just stayed in the big leagues as the clutchest hitter ever. This happens every year. Look at last year. Compare what Allan Craig did last year to what he's doing this year with men on base. Then you could just do the rest for the entire St. Louis Cardinals roster. If you put a team together based on a year of clutch hitting and expect similar results the next year, you're probably in a bit of trouble. If you believe in WAR, you probably know that a .439 .BABIP with men on base and a .460 .BABIP with RISP is simply not sustainable. It is nice that it has happened and it still counts, but you can't count on that continuing. I don't think that WAR is a stat to live and die by either. As a matter of fact, I rarely cite it by itself. I simply don't think it is an "opinion based on a statistical basis." I'm not even sure what that means, and I think it contradicts this last post of yours. I've already cited another # for you to look at that you might like more in this specific case. Casey Mcgehee has been a top-10 hitter this year based on WPA (win probability added). Stanton is first. The BABIP with men on base and RISP obviously is not sustainable. But that doesn't mean situational hitting, and hitting with men in scoring position, is not a skill. How do you think Jeff Conine became Mr. Marlin? Dude was a smart hitter, not necesarily a great one, and if memory serves he was consistely great during his entire career with RISP. It's all about your approach. Clearly Casey went to Japan and changed his.
June 16, 201412 yr The BABIP with men on base and RISP obviously is not sustainable. But that doesn't mean situational hitting, and hitting with men in scoring position, is not a skill. How do you think Jeff Conine became Mr. Marlin? Dude was a smart hitter, not necesarily a great one, and if memory serves he was consistely great during his entire career with RISP. It's all about your approach. Clearly Casey went to Japan and changed his. Without the absurd .BABIP with men on base, he's having a mediocre year. If hitting with .RISP is a skill, it's certainly overvalued. Hitters don't just turn on a switch because they have men on base. I'm pretty sure they want to get hits all the time.
June 16, 201412 yr I'm pretty sure they want to get hits all the time. This is where Wild Card's line of thinking falls apart. He's basically saying that players try harder to get hits with men on and don't give a shit when the bases are empty.
June 16, 201412 yr WAR isn't big on factoring situational hitting, probably because Casey Mcgehee's season so far with men on base is not sustainable and isn't really a skill. It's just happened. I really don't think that's a fair assessment at all. Just because WAR doesn't support something does not mean you immediately assume something is unsustainable, nor do you assume it's not intentional on McGehee's part. Nor do you assume it is just happening. Some things simply aren't capable of being measured. No, I'm not defending 'intangibles.' But what I'm saying is there's also a possibility that in fact his average woRISP is indeed the unsustainable number. Why? That's not the measurable factor. McGehee could be lazy when he feels as though it's not important to try. My point is that the variable here isn't necessarily RISP. It could be anything. But the bottom line is we will see something normalize. Whether it's WAR or RISP, we know there's plenty of relationships that aren't being satisfied that probably will be.
June 16, 201412 yr This is where Wild Card's line of thinking falls apart. He's basically saying that players try harder to get hits with men on and don't give a s*** when the bases are empty. It's definitely not a logic that you can claim wildly, but it's not impossible to be the answer. I just don't think in the case of McGehee you can claim much of anything at all.
June 16, 201412 yr Maybe Casey Mcgehee is a really cool guy who says "fuck it, I don't feel like hitting now because no one is on," I don't know. I've never been inside his mind. And maybe he simply is a better hitter with men on base. Quite frankly, you can look at career numbers and say that because he's actually been better with men on base his whole career. The rate at which he's hitting with men on base this year though is absolutely absurd. I can say with plenty of confidence that a ~.450 .BABIP with men on base is unsustainable. Hopefully it's a fluke that goes on all year because it's fun and I'm a Marlins fan, but that's just not some sort of long-term skill. That was my point. Like, when Giancarlo Stanton hits 40 HR's one year, you can pretty much go into the next year and say "well, if he stays healthy this year, he's going to hit another 40." That's a skill. The hitting with .RISP isn't as reliable because it's mostly based on smaller samples. It'll normalize over time.
June 16, 201412 yr If hitting with .RISP is a skill, it's certainly overvalued. Hitters don't just turn on a switch because they have men on base. I'm pretty sure they want to get hits all the time. This is where Wild Card's line of thinking falls apart. He's basically saying that players try harder to get hits with men on and don't give a s*** when the bases are empty. It's not about "turning on a switch" or "trying harder". When you think about it, in theory, EVERY player should hit better with RISP. Not only is the pressure on the pitcher and not the hitter, but in most of these scenarios what other options do most pitchers have other than to throw strikes and try to get outs? It's the hitter with the right plan that drives in the runners in scoring position constantly, like McGehee has. Just in this series, we've seen this guy hit an RBI singe, RBI double, sac fly RBI, and even have an RBI WALK (proving it's obviously not just HITTING with runners in scoring position) simply because of his approach in these situations.
June 16, 201412 yr It's not about "turning on a switch" or "trying harder". When you think about it, in theory, EVERY player should hit better with RISP. Not only is the pressure on the pitcher and not the hitter, but in most of these scenarios what other options do most pitchers have other than to throw strikes and try to get outs? It's the hitter with the right plan that drives in the runners in scoring position constantly, like McGehee has. Just in this series, we're seen this guy hit an RBI singe, RBI double, and even have an RBI WALK (proving it's obviously not just HITTING with runners in scoring position) simply because of his approach in these situations. If his approach is so successful with .RISP, why can't he maintain it when there's no one on base? Wouldn't you want to be successful all the time? I think humans tend to want to be successful all the time. Most people don't enjoy failure. This is not sustainable. And just because it's not sustainable doesn't mean that I don't think he has a good approach, by the way. It just means that the ball isn't going to fall in for him 45-50% of the time when he makes contact with men on base just because he wants to. For what it's worth, I'm not even in disagreement with him being an All-Star candidate. I also think that he'll show some more power as the season goes on to compensate for the regression with runners in scoring position.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.