Everything posted by Marlins2003
-
Mark Kotsay anyone?
:lol I would rather have Ross with 2 broken legs! CF is def not the problem right now... There is NO CHANCE we get a CF... get over it already.. Maybin in 09 He can play left. This Ross is God thing never ceases to amaze me. I thought I made it clear production and defense in leftfield was at the core of my concerns after watching yesterday unravel. And I did mention he's a free agent right? How Maybin in '09 plays into this is beyond me. He'd be a rental, I thought that was obvious. And a long shot to boot.
-
Mark Kotsay anyone?
Hmmm... We're in an ideal position from a waiver wire standpoint. The Fish could block a better team in the standings. After watching Gonzo in left yesterday (and 100% that's not a knock on a guy who contributed a lot earlier in the year when it was really needed) and Willingham's falling off, or for that matter Hermida, Kotsay has a limited no-trade but at least would be in the play-off hunt here, and can play all three outfield positions PLUS he's free agent at the end of the season. Pro outfielder. Good get in my opinion. His recents are good as far back post ASG. And five runs don't score in an inning with him in leftfield. The choices get slimmer as we approach the end of the month. I bet LB and company are kicking the tires on a trade with Frank Wren.
-
Cody Ross
Keep Cody because hes so valuable to this team he can field like a gold glover hit for power and average and hes clutch and theres no reason to trade him we dont need any more prospects. Jacobs or Olsen(who i want to keep) will be traded for a catcher and we look good with our pitchers. Awesome. This is like hitting a golden sombrero. Does that have anything to do with a donkey in Tijauna ?
-
Daily Roundup 8/14/08
Impressive performance by Eulogio De La Cruz, and Jesus Delgado + Chris Mobley lookin' like a good relief tandom in AA, along with Tucker, who did not pitch last night. As far as all the "bring up Maybin" posts...I'm still not convinced the guy is ready. Erik, just a friendly suggestion. You may have a little extra time on your hands the next couple of days, listen/skim through some archived Mudcats games. I think you'll be surrpised how far he has progressed both offensively and defensively especially since he came off the DL. (A little trick. If you go to the MiLB scoreboard and pick a game by date there will be a recap - a written play by play - so you know for example Maybin bats in the 1st, 2nd, 4th, etc innings, and you can read he makes a put out in the fifth, or someone flies out to him in the7th etc. you can skim through a game pretty quickly this way and get the (then) real-time announcer's comments. the guys who do Mudcats baseball are great announcers (for AA). What is sometimes more interesting though is to listen to the opposing side's announcers (there is always a home/away feed to chose from) when some Mudcat makes a great play or drives in an important run. You get the idea.
-
The Baseball Stadium Agreement
It is 100% worth an afternoon read, especially with this TS upon us. It is impossible to read without coming away with the conclusion this is a deal good for the city, the county and the Marlins and answers all the haters' lies right down the line. From "Can the Marlins move?" to just about every what-if scenario you can think of are addressed in there. BTW, the answer is "no". The franchise could fail (ownership goes bankrupt, etc, something happens along those lines) the MLB has agreed the framchise is tied to that stadium for the duration of the lease.
-
Is it ok to blame it on the payroll?
I didn't misunderstand anything you said, you just want to walk away from what you said like you never said it. Those were your guys, not mine. I'm not looking to tear apart your ideas or anything like that. What you missed is the suggestion you have the ability to come up with better ideas if you just do a little research before you offer up ones like those. I seldom post without checking Cots and stats on ESPN or elsewhere because it's so easy to do so. If you don't know what Cot's is, it's the definitive baseball contract database ( http://mlbcontracts.blogspot.com/ ) it's a great resource. It has every MLB contract, service time, etc. Don't leave home without it.
-
Shades of 2005
We have to many free swingers on this team. Like uggla and jacobs. those guys ALWAYS go for the Homerun and end up striking out. no matter how much it pains me to say this, we have to trade him in the offseason and call up chris coglhan. Do you think it might be helpful if Coghlan learned how to play the position first?
-
Fire Sale
Isn't there a football forum you guys can go bump heads or helmets or whatever? We're not talking about football. :banghead it was a joke
-
Is it ok to blame it on the payroll?
Yes you are lacking and yes iIwill share with you. You want to sign players who have to outperform their 2009 contracts by 150% to make it worth signing them. Adam Dunn, $13 million, his entire career in the National League, approx 50 at bats at Dolphin Stadium in the last four years - homeruns - *one*. I could have gone back through his entire career to see how many he hit here by after *one* in four years I don't need to do much more research. Even if he gets less than last year, say $ 9million instead of $13, is he worth it to the Marlins? Of course not. In order for his contract to bring value to this team he has to outperform that contract. If he hits 32 hrs (so far) with half his games played in the bandbox of all bandbox stadiums in Cincy and he he hits *one* here in four years, how many does he have to hit here (when he isn't striking out at a rate of 170 times a season) to make that $9 million pay off for the Marlins? The answer? It will never be enough. Mark Texiera, 29 next season, great player, makes $12.5 million this season. Free agent next. Cashing in big time. Let's say conservatively $15 million for five years. $75 million. Think Gary Matthews Jr. He was going to be the answer to the Angels problems in CF. Signed for 5 years at the top of his game. This season he's hitting .220-ish and playing part-time. Think Juan Pierre (who I love) signed at the top of his game and 100%+ value. Carl Pavano. AJ Burnett. Even Derrek Lee. You think those 17 homeruns (let's give him 22+/- for 2008) would be worth $13+ million to the Marlins? They're barely worth it to the Cubs and they sell out every game. If the Cubs could replace Lee is with a good glove 1B man with 15-18 homeruns for $400,000 a year they'd do it in a heartbeat. You are looking at players and a) expecting that they will always have great seasons and b) be worth what they're paid. That is a longshot. The chances are if you look at similar players signed over the last few years, neither will outperform their contracts, especially Dunn, who is a .211/.298 waiting to happen. The Marlins are not a team that can afford, literally or figuratively, players who underperform their contracts. And more and more, a lot of other teams are learning the same lesson. You are making a false leap of faith. If we pay MT $15 million a year, he will produce, he will stay healthy, the sun will come up in the morning and the birds will sing and all will be right with the world. A team like the Angels can afford to deal with MT being out for eight weeks with a torn hamstring, the Marlins, and most MLB teams can't, not with $15 mil per on the line. You also don't seem to respect the money. You are more than willing to spend someone elses $20 million because it isn't yours. Are you starting to get the picture? If you want to spend $20 million and pray for the best possible outcome. You don't put it into one or maybe 1 1/2 players. You trade for a guy who is entering his arb years with the credentials to pay him $ 5million next season, another guy you sign for three years $20 million, etc. I'm sorry if you think I am a jerk but I bet you didn't spend one second looking at Adam Dunn's numbers or how he's performed here at Dolphin Stadium, where he would be playing 81 games next season if you had your way. or the trends in his numbers. You want to propose trades, I'm all for it but use your head, look at some stats, try to figure out who has the chance of giving you more than your money's worth not a couple of guys who, for different reasons, have great names but don't fit, or even if they potentially did who have to have back to back career years to make it worthwhile.
-
Is it ok to blame it on the payroll?
Here is my issue for those saying who cares about the payroll. First of all, your scouts aren't ALWAYS going to be better than the other teams scouts. And if thats your main defense, its a pretty lame one. Second, if we were to just have a normal sized payroll, we could replace Jacobs with Texiera, Willingham with Dunn, and fill out our bullpen in the offseason, and be World Series contenders next year. Instead we will have to wait on more prospects to grow up. Have I accepted its going to be like this at least til we get a new stadium? Obviously, or I wouldn't be a Marlins fan. Am I envious we can't just buy whoever we want like the Yankees or Red Sox? No, I think they run their ballclubs terribly (well much moreso the Yankees). Do I wish we could just spend enough to keep the players we really want? YES!!!! But we can't even do that, in most cases. God forbid they ever have to trade Hanley. Did you figure all this out on your PlayStation?
-
Fire Sale
Isn't there a football forum you guys can go bump heads or helmets or whatever?
-
Is it ok to blame it on the payroll?
I forget most of the time what the payroll is. I'm not sure when I look at how many signings blow up in the faces of so many front offices every year that even a $40 million payroll would have changed where we are today. Would I have done some things differently? Sure. But since I have about 5% of the information and back story the front office has I have to defer to them. Dallas McPherson isn't up here for a reason. Dan Uggla isn't on the DL (or coming off it) for a reason. They didn't just wake up one morning and decide to screw Justin Miller and send him packing, especially with Waechtner on the DL. You have to think it had more to do with his slider being flat as a pancake more than anything else. If you want to make an argument the front office is incompetent you can but you do so at the risk of looking ridiculous when all the facts are in. They take the data they have and do the best they can with it. Sometimes things work and sometimes they don't. I'm willing to bet that if the FO had any indication it would take Uggla this long to recover they would have DLed him before the ASG but they didn't and we all know why - because Phil Garner played every single position player he had in 2006 and left Uggla on the bench in humilation, and Clint Hurdle let Uggla know that wouldn't be the case in 2008 (even though it blew up in Uggla's face). There's an old saying, "The road to hell is paved with good intentions". We are where we are. We have six weeks left. We finish with three games in NYC vs the Mets. I'm not throwing in the towel and I don't think anyone ought to be either. Oh, did I mention Billy Wagner's pitching arm is so stiff after throwing 20 pitches today in rehab the scuttlebut is he may be done for the season? Sh*t happens. Stay tuned.
-
Fire Sale
Actually what happened at the end of the 2005 season was Joe Arriola pulling the rug out from underneath a stadium deal that was near complete when he tried to force Loria to sell the team to a political crony and the Marlins response was justifiably to go **** himself. Left with no prospects for a future predictable revenue stream the outcome was totally predictable.
-
Fire Sale
First off, Barry Jackson is a joke. Second off, I would like to state that the 2005-2006 off season was NOT a fire sale. I like how whenever the marlins make a trade, it's a "firesale" and not "making the organization better." if we're any other team, this is a non-issue. But OH sh*t THE MARLINS ARE MAKING ANOTHER TRADE, THOSE SLY BASTARDS ARE HAVING ANOTHER FIRESALE!!! f***ing idiotic talking heads This is Barry being Barry. Using the Marlins to cast what he hopes will be a little national attention on himself regardless of how fast and lose he has to play with the truth. I give him credit he knows the words "firesale" and "Marlins" will get him where he wants to go (which is probably out of Miami before the next round of cut-backs at One Herald Sq.) but hopefully sports editors he's pitching will have a better respect for the whole truth than their McClatchy counterparts.
-
Miller DFA, LoDuca Up
Justin will be back. No doubt. He has replaced Andino as the team yo-yo. No, he won't. He's out of options. He's DFA'd. In other words, his tenure with this team is done. That is why DFAing him instead of optioning Kensing is a head scartcher. Because now we lose Miller, end of story. We option Kensing, we can keep both. Am I wrong that we can still sign him to minor league contract should no one sign him?
-
Cote: Bad reviews for Marlins
Anytime someone uses a Shakespearean turn of a phrase they have me hooked and generally I agree with Cote, but the idea that the Marlins have been coddled and above criticism or somehow given a pass this season by the local and national media is a hint that Cote's suffering some sort of dementia or early onset Alzheimer's if he's having trouble remembering back to April when every pundit, here or elsewhere proclaimed us the laughingstock of baseball guaranteed to finish somewhere behind the Nationals and most certainly with worst record in baseball. You might want to schedule an appointment promptly with your neurologist or geriatric phychiatrist Greg, before you have trouble finding One herald Square in the morning.
-
Quite Interesting
I'm not sure what the big new is. They lost three out of four in their own house with pitching performances that deserved better results and so in the heat of a pennant race the owner met with his baseball operations people to discuss where to go from here. Beyond that everything is supposition. Hermida. That's the reporters guess. Gee, Josh Willingham needs back surgery and wants to avoid it, Maybin might be an answer or it's time for McPherson (who just hit #40 and may be regaining his health and stroke being mired in a slump since before the ASG) and LoDuca in a small sample size is tearing up the PCL. Okay so here's my guesses. McPherson to 3rd, Cantu to 2nd, Gonzalez to first, Jacobs to the bench and Uggla to the DL. Willingham sent down and Maybin or Murphy or Raynor promoted, or McPherson to 3rd, Cantu to first, LoDuca spells Treanor who goes back on the 15 day DL, or Willingham down, Ross to left, Amezaga to center, LoDuca comes up and they carry three catchers. None of the above should be taken with any seriousness. It's just wildly speculative and not news. But that's the point. Neither is anything written beyond reporting a meeting took place.
-
Injury news
in the limited action iv seen he has a hell of a strong arm but just hasnt got adjusted to hitting major league pitching yet You need to see major league pitching on a consistent basis to get adjusted to it, to use your term. With the guys coming up through the system he could be the next Tagg Bozied or he could come into camp in the spring healthy and in a position to win the job if the opportunity is there. We all saw Robert Andino beginning to improve at the plate after becoming more familiar with MLB pitching after struggling early on, it may be Carroll is the same. Defensively he is such a plus outfielder you have to give him a chance offensively in spring training if he's healthy, although, I do wonder if he and Fredi have a conflict - actually we pretty much know they had a conflict - the question is will it linger into 2009 spring training. that is why i included "yet" at the end of my comment - i fully understand that you need to see major league pitching on a consistent basis before u get adjusted to it wot sorta numbers has carroll been getting in the minors in the past couple of years? I was agreeing with you.
-
Lineup idea
Since we're going there...why see if you can ignite the offense by reuniting Hanley and Dan at the top of the lineup. Worked once, might again. Just a passing thought.
-
Jorge Cantu and Jose Castillo
Poor Dontrelle.
-
Jorge Cantu and Jose Castillo
DLC is the one guy (maybe Carroll) where I feel Fredi handled the kid's entry into MLB badly. It may be that Wiley didn't want him and felt the FO shoved him down their throats but they threw him to the wolves and he was clearly punch-drunk by the time they returned him to Albuquerque. That he's returning to his previous form is encouraging. As for a comment above regarding taking McPherson over Cantu, I know we're talking in the hypothetical but mcPherson was injured most of spring training and was never even in the picture. The reason it would have been a bad choice is not necessarily because Cantu is that much better but Cantu was healthy and McPherson needed six weeks in Albuquerque as essentially his spring training to get where he could play everyday.
-
Injury news
in the limited action iv seen he has a hell of a strong arm but just hasnt got adjusted to hitting major league pitching yet You need to see major league pitching on a consistent basis to get adjusted to it, to use your term. With the guys coming up through the system he could be the next Tagg Bozied or he could come into camp in the spring healthy and in a position to win the job if the opportunity is there. We all saw Robert Andino beginning to improve at the plate after becoming more familiar with MLB pitching after struggling early on, it may be Carroll is the same. Defensively he is such a plus outfielder you have to give him a chance offensively in spring training if he's healthy, although, I do wonder if he and Fredi have a conflict - actually we pretty much know they had a conflict - the question is will it linger into 2009 spring training.
-
Raul Ibanez
We were able to outbid other teams for Arthur Rhodes (and I think we definitely got a good acquisition there) for Gaby Hernandez whose 7+ ERA in AAA hasn't improved since he took a step back and is now getting shelled at AA. While I doubt Ibanez makes it all the way through waivers to reach us in another league, were it to happen (in answer to your question) he potentially is a difference maker in left field who fits a number of criteria, good bat, good D, free agent, probably a draft pick coming back and little of his 2008 contract left. I think you afford to give up anything the FO finds reasonable and not look back and wished you hadn't. The Bedard trade really hurt their organization so they may need pitching or position help and I don't pretend to know which they need more. Obviously he' isn't Ryan Tucker or probably not a top ten, it's a matter of giving them more than they could hope get in the draft (and I'm assuming he's worth at least one pick in the draft) as he'll go free agent. I would worry more about being in a position waiver-wise to get him before I worried what to give up for him.
-
Miami Arena?
I'm a little late on the uptick here but I'm totally excited about the revival of a downtown site. Let's make this happen. The idea of delay for site shifting is a joke considering idiot Braman's lawsuit means delays at OB too. Everyone knows the OB site is terrible, so why on earth we aren't pouncing on Straub's offer is beyond me. As for it costing more, wasn't it shown that OB would be more expensive? Because what Straub owns is isn't big enough to build a stadium on, not even remotely, which would leave the three partners - city, county, Marlins - in the unenviable task of trying to acquire other parcels to get a big enough footprint and, well, you don't have to go further than that. Straub has no offer, he hasn't spoken to anyone outside of the press and Norman Braman and to think he only wants what's best for the Marlins is the laugh riot of the century.
-
losses this upcoming offseason
McPherson, if you've noticed is playing hurt and has since just before the PCL ASG and hasn't hit a homer in what seems like two weeks and is generally underachieving offensively. He continues to play through whatever it is but his production numbers didn't evaporate by accident nor were they a mirage in the first place. The 'Topes announcers allude to it once in a while but never get specific. I think it is one of the reasons you didn't see some other moves possibly made at the trade deadline. The fact that he's injured is not good, the fact he is able to defend his position while injured should be taken as a positive.