Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins2003

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Marlins2003

  1. To suggest at this point in his career that Jeremy Hermida is anything but a disappointment and a chronic underachiever or Uggla has played healthy for three years when their histories show otherwise is just sticking your head in the sand. It's easy to make these kinds of blanket statements but another to actually factually make the case for either.
  2. Whether you agree or disagree about the 3rd...what about the 1st two "strikes?" I mean, seriously...that's two boneheaded decisions in the span of...one week? There's not smart...there's dumb...and there's retarded. Dan Uggla's first two "strikes" were, at best, borderline retarded. That's uncalled for. (especially in the span of a week, when you're fighting for the division). You'll notice I made no comment on them.
  3. All this job definition stuff is just ridiculous and misplaced. There is a time and a place for everything and this was not one of those times where barreling into the catcher would have accomplished anything. On this play the catcher comes to Dan not the other way around. The catcher is not at homeplate waiting for Dan. In fact it's quite the contrary. The Giants announcers say Uggla ran through a stop sign but there is no discernable image of Porter doing any such thing. The catcher receives the ball five feet, no let me review the tape, it's more like eight away from the plate in the direction of the third base dugout so it would have been a physical impossibility for Dan to slide hands OR feet first into the catcher and still score. It is the catcher who is way out of position and has to lung to his right trying to tag out Dan by reaching back into the basepath to get him from the side (hence the little "dance"). Dan is never in a position to physically confront the catcher. Just look at the video - the operative parts are seconds 11-16, watch it frame by frame - this whole argument is much to do about absolutely nothing. The video doesn't lie. The play was a screwup and the screwup was the third base coach not holding Dan when he had the chance to. Uggla, until he's well past the point of no return has no idea where the ball is because he's running as fast as he can and has to take a look for himself because he's getting nothing from Porter. So you know the video is posted on the Marlins homepage. http://florida.marlins.mlb.com/media/video...07&c_id=fla
  4. A good thing the expectations for LoDuca's performance aren't too high this evening. :brigginbounce
  5. Good to have you here :thumbup Finally someone else who saw Gibson pitch. There really is no way to explain how different the game is today especially the buddy-buddy relationships you see on the field between players on opposing teams. Can you imagine Bob Gibson saying anything remotely friendly to an opposing player...on or off the field? I just laugh out loud thinking about how players from the fifties, sixties would look at today's game.
  6. Gaby Sanchez received best defensive first baseman Gaby just became my favorite... I really don't see why he won't be our first baseman in '09. The same thought may have crossed Mike Jacobs' mind.
  7. does anyone have a list of precisely what injuries Baldelli has had in his career? Oh god, it seems like there's been so many but the most recent one was career threatening and worse and had something to do with his metabolism, I don't remember precisely what it was. He's also had a number of hammies and quad problems. If you're interested a good place to find out is query him on rotoworld and read through his "previous news" which goes back pretty much throughout his MLB career.
  8. Ideally what you're looking for is Hanley (or someone from the 7, 8, 9 spot in subsequent innings) being on base for LoDuca to move over or drive in, at least if you're interested in how he does situationally. Getting a single with nobody on almost doesn't count
  9. I'm not trying to continue this debate but if they just wanted to bring someone up to add a bat to the lineup there were any number of other choices they could have made. I don't pretend to have the inside baseball answers why LoDuca and not player X, but these decisions aren't made in a vacuum and you have think Dean Treanor and probably the scouting team drove the decision LoDuca's way. Or, as someone mentioned above (I think it was in this thread although it could have been another) LoDuca's deal with the Fish mandated him being placed on the major league roster on a certain day or after x days with the club, etc. and the fact he was doing well in Albuquerque or Treanor's injury had nothing to do with it. My point continues to be we don't know, and we won't know until it plays itself out.
  10. We really haven't seen LoDuca in game-altering pinch hit situations so I for one am willing to see how well he does when called upon to move a runner over or sacrifice to right field. I'm not sure anyone can know whether he's a good pinch hitting option or not until we've seen him called upon to perform situationally a number of times. it very well may be he is a bust, or he may do well, I say let's wait and see. Like Cantu, the smartest productive hitter on the team, LoDuca will be going to the plate knowing what he needs to accomplish, which potentially is a step up from "...guys trying to hit four run homers with no one base", as Fredi likes to say. I do think that not using him, and that includes looking for situations to use him, is a mistake. If all he does is ride the bench that's a roster spot that could better be used for other purposes.
  11. Should the Marlins go down this road I think it's less important to quantify a number - two high draft picks - the example being used here, than it is to acquire talent the team needs to improve itself. If Gregg is traded in the off-season I don't care who we get or how many players are involved so long as the 2009 Marlins are considered a better team than we're fielding now because of it. There's going to be any number of moves made this off-season so looking at one player in a vacuum makes little sense at least to me.
  12. Many of you seem to forget that Treanor is not healthy and is pretty much playing on borrowed time by putting off surgery until after the season (or if re-injures himself when his season ends). That's why LoDuca is here. Why that is controversial I have no idea, especially when you look at the options at the time LoDuca was brought in. David Ross is out there NOW that he's been released and I hoped the Fish would go get him at the trading deadline but that's just me. I don't think he will be a major contributing factor over the next six weeks, it's more insurance. That said I'm not sure that in a game like last night he couldn't have been used in the ighth or ninth inning in left or at first, just to get him into the game and perhaps an at bat or two.
  13. And it saved me so much heavy lifting :thumbup
  14. Oh, please...it just gets so boring after a while listening to this garbage from you. You haters, you liars, you come you go, the style is always the same, guilty until proven innocent. Neither MLB (the other owners or mgmt), the city or county would be making the investment in time or energy they have here if a shred of your insanity were true. Eventually you'll slither away and some other crackpot will take your place, with the same baseless accusations and rhetoric. It's frankly embarrassing to see shills like you thinking they can infect this messageboard again and again.
  15. Name another team in an unsupportive market and a crap stadium lease. Name me another team that makes more $ than what it spends on its payroll before it sells a single ticket, who's owner uses his own "salary" to help show a loss in the books, a team that gets multiple millions from revenue sharing, TV contracts, and MLB.com-and an owner he simply refuses to put it back into the team. There is no way the marlins arent extremely profitiable. The system set up makes them money makers. Their payroll could be doubled what it currently is and they would still be very far ahead. Yes the attendance and lease suck, but that doesnt stop the team from being extremely profitable from MLB wellfare alone. And I know this wont be popular, but I too dont think the state should put up money for a stadium. Not until Loria shows he is willing to keep a team together. Giving Hanely a big contract but flat out refusing to put a no trade clause in there doesn't help his cause. And not until Loria shows his books to an independent third party, to see once and for all that this franchise is destitute, which he wont do because there is simply no way that is the case. You don't have a single fact to back one thing up you say...over and over and over and over and over...
  16. mitre i wouldnt have a problem moving :banghead
  17. It's a difficult think to ferret out of the web because is it 100, 100+, 120. a hundred, etc. ? The search criteria would be maddening. But the consensus had to be the Marlins were the worst team in baseball finishing behind the Nationals and certainly below the resurgent Kansas City Royals.
  18. There are some clues here as to how this piece came to be. 1. Local10. 2. "...the phone calls I've received while doing radio shows on WQAM" 3. "...Why have Gregg get ready if you don't use him?" Because Will, you don't understand baseball. 4. "...You don't have to be a baseball expert to know that you're reliever can't get a save at home after the 9th inning" because I guess "saves" are more than "wins" to you Will, not to mention we're in agreement you aren't a baseball expert. 5. "...Rhodes was acquired for a reason, and he has not been used..." because Will, you don't seem to understand what Rhodes' job is. Will, good luck this fall with your Dolphins sycophantic labors. It is after all a job you were born to.
  19. Just because we start afresh tonight on the west coast I thought I'd mention Joe Capozzi's idea of batting LoDuca 2nd based on LoDuca's .292 number batting in the two hole this year and his recent, albeit short, performance at Albuquerque. At least the guy knows how to move a runner along (can he do it? That's a whole other question entirely). http://www.palmbeachpost.com/blogs/content...bat_second.html Oh, and the Herald mentioned Justin Miller is being sent to Albuquerque (rather than cut free) so we may not have seen the last of him this season.
  20. Fanfish, I was sure how to read what you wrote - are you suggesting Maybin won't be ready in 2009 (?) since the thrust of your post was about transactions that take place in the off-season leading up to 2009.
  21. A little rusty perhaps?
  22. If you're signed to a major league contract, it doesn't matter if you wind up getting sent to Greensboro, you're still getting a major league check. I started this thread but perhaps it might have been helpful if I had mentioned that if (big if) Kotsay were to come here it would have to be at the expense of Josh Willingham who would probably be DLed. I think you'd rather have Gonzo off the bench anyways where he at least an idea what needs to be accomplished when he comes to the plate, which is half the battle.
  23. up on ajc: Cox, teammates want Kotsay to stay with Braves By CARROLL ROGERS The Atlanta Journal-Consitution Monday, August 18, 2008 Mark Kotsay has made enough of an impression this season that his manager and Braves teammates have been saying lately they'd love to have him back next year. Kotsay is a free agent after the season. It was understood before the season started that he would be a one-year bridge to Jordan Schafer in center field for the Braves. But that was before Schafer was suspended 50 games for the use of HGH and lost momentum in his minor-league progress. That would leave the door open at least to the possibility of a Kotsay return. His manager wouldn't mind seeing it, though he didn't want to speculate on its likelihood just yet. "He's a great leader, that kid," manager Bobby Cox said. "He's a gamer, professional, does everything fundamentally sound, and he's hitting .300." Heading into Monday's game, Kotsay was hitting .302 in 82 games. "It's an option definitely," Kotsay said. "I love it here. I love playing for Bobby. It's a matter of what direction they're going to go." One possibility circulating Braves players and fans has been to have Kotsay back in a part-time capacity, maybe as a fourth outfielder and backup first baseman. Kotsay, 32, said Monday though, at this point in his career, he still wants to play every day. "I don't see coming back here as an option if I'm not an everyday guy," Kotsay said. "My family situation and time spent away from me is very important. To be away from them and not to be playing every day ? to be a four-hour flight away ? would be a real challenge from a mental aspect. "I'm not going to say that I would close my options off. If it was my only option, I'd have to think really hard about it." Kotsay makes his permanent home in San Diego. The big question coming into the season was how Kotsay's back would hold up, given his problems of the last several years. He missed 33 games on the disabled list with a lower back strain, but since his return July 1, he was hitting .313 (41-for-131) heading into Monday. He went 5-for-5 on Thursday night and became the fifth player in Braves franchise history since 1900 to hit for the cycle. "I'm just keeping an open mind," Kotsay said. "I've never been a free agent. I've never experienced what it feels like to go into an offseason like this. I really have no feelings in any direction other than to finish the season healthy and see where that takes me." http://www.ajc.com/braves/content/sports/b...ves_kotsay.html
  24. if we were interested, I'd think we'd have just put a claim on him instead. We're just playing what-if here but he does have that limited no-trade and when signed his contract it was with a west coast team, he being a west coast guy. Florida was probably the last he wanted to be traded to. In a previous contract he has a million dollar kicker if traded - plus Wren probably would want someone back. Could be multiple needs at work. Could also be there is no interest on the Marlins' part. Could be a lot of things. All we can do is tune in tomorrow...
  25. Yeah, sorry 'bout that.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.