Everything posted by Valid
-
What gift will the Marlins give Miggy?
The biggest mistake the Marlins ever made (and they've made a lot of them) was not buying out his arbitration years. Dude should have been a Marlin for life, or at least for a much longer time than five years. Cabrera is probably the single greatest talent that has ever put on a Marlins uniform.
-
David Robertson to the Marlins
Robertson has long been one of the best relief pitchers in baseball. The fact that so many people here don't seem to know who he is is mind-boggling to me. This is a great acquisition. EDIT: @Erick beat me to it. This is a significant get for the Marlins.
-
Trade deadline thread
To be fair, this was more due to the ineptitude of the front office of not putting the appropriate talent around him all those years. Yeah we had Yelich and Ozuna but that was basically it. As far as him getting traded for nothing in 2017, again, that was the FO's fault. The dude was coming off of one of the greatest runs in MLB history, was still in his 20s and we got squat for him. I understand Stanton kind of handicapped them by giving them a short list of teams, but the FO should have at least been able to salvage something for him. Obviously hindsight is 20/20, but I still stand by the decision in concept not to trade him for Manny in 2008.
-
Trade deadline thread
I'm not sure it would have been guaranteed, though. While I do think the Marlins would have made the playoffs in 2008 had they traded for Manny, there was also a chance they wouldn't have (remember: that bullpen had major issues), and if they didn't win the WS, then they would have just traded a generational prospect for an essential rental. Now the difference here, as @SilverBullet said, is that there is absolutely no one in this current farm system who is even remotely close to Stanton, so I have no problem moving anyone in the system for an established star. What I don't want to do is move someone like Garrett or Rogers for a decent player who is only going to be here for a couple of months.
-
Trade deadline thread
To be fair, I don't think anyone here is saying we should save the farm system. I think the concern is more that we shouldn't trade someone like Braxton Garrett for a rental.
-
Trade deadline thread
I have no idea. Apparently they like his fastball. But I was speaking more in general and less about Lopez specifically.
-
Trade deadline thread
While this is true, the Marlins not wanting to trade Stanton for Manny is entirely understandable and I still agree with that decision in concept 15 years later. The true failure was not putting enough adequate pieces around Stanton during his time here.
-
Trade deadline thread
If they're going to be "buyers" then they better be actual buyers and acquire legitimately productive players; not fringe guys with good peripherals who might be good someday.
-
Trade deadline thread
So basically what they've been committed to for most of the last 10 years.
-
7/23 Post Game Thread
Well at least the streak didn't reach double digits. How they respond from this point out will tell us everything about this team. If they go on a little winning streak here, then it means they have some resolve and that they are still very much in this. If not, then oh well. Like I've been saying all along: my expectations are tempered.
-
7/21 Post Game Thread
As we knew it would be, but I don't think Eury himself would have stopped what we are seeing now. This is primarily the result of an absolutely horrific offense. Both Arraez and Soler had been fantastic all year and carried things. Now that they are both in a slump, we are seeing truly just how bad the rest of the lineup is.
-
7/21 Post Game Thread
The only hope is to think that maybe they are getting their losing streak out of the way early. But then there is the potential reality that this team just isn't that good. Still trying to believe, but luckily, my expectations have been tempered all along.
-
Trade deadline thread
You can say this about 95 percent of the teams in baseball. Should everyone just sit and do nothing because the Braves look really dominant?
-
Trade deadline thread
Under previous regimes, yes. Kim seems to have a little bit more of a clue, so I can't see her selling the farm for Perez. We'll see, though.
-
Trade deadline thread
Haven't seen this anywhere else. Not sure how reliable this Twitter page is.
-
7/15 at orange birds
While I completely agree that this team needs to add at least one bat, it's been two games. Let's relax. And the "first half cupcake schedule" argument is silly. They were 53-39 after 92 games at the ASB. To act like that was entirely a result of a "cupcake schedule" is disingenuous.
-
Trade deadline thread
To be fair, us expecting the worst in every series has worked out well for the Marlins so far (except against the Braves...), so I'll agree just for the sake of it.
-
Marlinsbaseball.com The Movie!
Serious question: I keep seeing people here talk about "the other site." I think I know which site it is and I used to post over there years ago. What's the deal with this? Is there some kind of bad blood between this site and that site?
-
Trade deadline thread
To be fair, wasn't that because they were limiting his innings (not sure if I remember that correctly)? I'm not saying he's a pretty good pitcher right now, but he has shown he can be really good in the past and I absolutely think he can be good in the future. I don't think he has insane value, but I absolutely think there would be tons of teams willing to acquire him because he is still young and has good stuff (I am not advising the Marlins trade him, either; just saying I definitely think there would be significant interest if they decided to). I think he could be one of those guys the Marlins could potentially regret trading in that scenario. I also don't necessarily think lumping him in with Cabrera is fair because Cabrera has no track record of ever being all that good on the MLB level, and his command is awful.
-
Some thoughts so far..
Gonna give Coop some love here. June: .288/.329/.525 (5 HR, 16 RBI in 85 PA) July: .333/.412/.567 (2 HR, 7 RBI in 34 PA) He has been really, really good since the May from hell.
-
Trade deadline thread
I've seen this posted here before and I'm not sure where it comes from. Rogers had one "bad" month in 2021, which came in July when he had a 4.08 ERA in four starts. He then got hurt and didn't pitch in August, but posted a 3.52 ERA with a 4.67 K/BB ratio in five starts afterward. He also only gave up one home run during that span. That's solid stuff. I mean yeah he obviously sucked wind in 2022, but he's 25, he's a lefty, he's club-controlled and he is just two years removed from an All-Star season. I think he has more value than you're giving him credit for.
-
7/7 Post Game Thread (for real this time)
Seems like this historically describes most Marlins closers in a nutshell.
-
6/29 Post Game Thread
Definitely. They need a couple of more bats. They need to add another arm or two because Eury is going to be shut down at some point, and I'm not sure how much they can depend on Rogers, Cueto and Cabrera (and Sixto lol) staying healthy and/or producing. I will say, though, that if Sandy can get himself together for the stretch run, the Marlins will have a pretty lethal trio of Sandy, Luzardo and Garrett at the top of their rotation even after Eury gets shut down. I think a Sandy turnaround is actually more important (or at least as important) as any deadline deals Kim will make.
-
My Marlins wall at the office
I first read this as "my wife made me move out of the house when our son was born."
-
6/29 Post Game Thread
But they were never this good any of those years, though. That's the thing. I am absolutely being cautious with my optimism for this team, because, as @SilverBullet said, I think they are good, not great. But just because past Marlins teams imploded in a certain month doesn't mean this one will. Completely different teams, completely different seasons, completely different circumstances. I guess we as fans are just conditioned to expect the worst after two decades of it. But I mean, the Royals went to back-to-back World Series in 2014 and 2015 and won it in the latter year, and that was after three decades of missing the playoffs. The Cubs won a title after 108 years. If those things can happen, then the 2023 Marlins can certainly be for real.