Everything posted by jonnylons
-
Productive Outs.... Yanks/Marlins
Sounds like clutch hitting to me...
-
So... I'm guessing AJ will stay...
Exactly.
-
Did Lee's glove anchor our defense?
I agree with that yet the other blind ppl here in these forums seem to dismiss that and say it was a good move..no it wasnt our defense will struggle and lee saved agon at least 10 or more would be errors! Umm...some may be blind, but not everyone who thinks this is a good deal is blind. I consider this a good deal. Fact, we were going to lose Lee. Fact, he was a luxury for this team financially. Fact, D Lee was a gold glove winner and did save a lot of errors on this team. But because of the other reasons, this deal had to be made. The fact that we got Choi out of this deal - and didnt stand to get a prospect of that caliber AT ALL, this is a damn good deal.
-
Can anyone tell me...
Does anyone remember the Cub's A Gon hitting home runs? Does anyone else remember Kerry Woods' blast? Need I say more?
-
I wanted to keep Lee!
I am going to miss Lee in that black and teal. Its not going to be the same with out him holding down first base. But I think it was the best for the team because this allows us to keep more important parts of the team. Also I dont think he would have improved much more unless he played in a hitters park or at least no PPS. Exactly. Lee was not going to improve much more - at least not to the height of his paycheck. Not here. He is a class act and will be missed in that regard, but Choi is a solid prospect who actually may be better offensively. I think this is a very shrewd move by Beinfest.
-
stop the complaining
No one is complaining. And I agree, Lee will blow up in Chicago - and I will be there to see it. But the Marlins will still be beating the Cubs next year when it matters.
-
Should the Marlins keep Pudge?
No. Only because we have other priorities (Lowell) and we could replace him with Castro who may not match his numbers, but will come pretty close. The key is money, Pudge is going to get at least $7M - I would rather spend that on a certain RF who played for the Expos...but that is just me.
-
Jason Stokes
You're just making assumptions based on little substance. And remind me again what you are doing? You said the Marlins wouldn't have won the World Series if they didn't make that trade. You can't really assume that. If you can, then I will assume the Marlins lost 3 World Series' by trading ADRIAN. Miggy, I posted that and you said I was making assumptions. Juanky just happened to defend my post. But I will do it for myself - we traded Adrian for Urbina, right? Let me put it this way, without Urbina, our bullpen doesnt get solidified and our climb gets that much harder. Am I stretching? Maybe, but not by much and if you consider we have Stokes, Conine and Choi - I fail to see why we should have kept Adrian Gonzalez too. Seems we got enough talent at 1B right now AND a World Series trophy. Again, if you think not getting Urbina would have still allowed us to win the WS, then you are definetly a Braves fan - f'in crazy.
-
Are you satisfied with who you got for Derrek Lee?
Considering we were just going to lose Lee, yes. Not only did we get a prospect, but one of the best hitting prospects in MLB. Choi is no slouch, and stands to be a good one. We have plenty of insurance if not though (Conine, Stokes...).
-
Vladimir Status After Choi/Lee Deal
Im sick of this. You're all a bunch of idiots. Why do you care so much about big bad vlad like he can carry a team on his own? You're all turning into Wayne wanting a fire sale of your own. Now I hear you want to get rid of Lowell. So who's gone now? Lee, Pudge, Castillo, and now you don't want LOWELL?!?!!? I have said time and time again that priority #1 is extending Lowell's contract. You dont deal a 3B who hit 30+HR and 100+RBI because he IS THE ONLY ONE IN BASEBALL TO DO IT AT HIS POSITION. And he was out for a month... You do let Pudge go because we can replace him (Castro, Willingham in a year...) and you let Castillo go because you dont invest $6M on a problematic hip - especially for a player who relies on speed. His SBs #'s are in decline, that is a fact. That alone could net Vlad and Pubes' post above for Vlad's possible deal is exactly what I was talking about. C'mon people, be smart, be alert. As they say in Italian: attenzione, concentrazione, ritmo vitalita
-
What is Choi capable of?
I think it is best to platoon Conine with Choi at this point. Also, you can have Conine be the unofficial 4th OF (play LF, occasionally RF). I think Enc is on his way out...I would like to see him dealt for Dotel...but I may be dreaming.
-
Jason Stokes
The Braves haven't "choked" in their entire playoff run. There is a reason other teams make the playoffs. A lot of the teams the Braves have faced were fighting in September for a spot while much of the time the Braves were just cruising along. They just haven't been able to get in the groove. yeah a 'groove'. Right, that is their problem...didnt they have one of the best offenses in the game last season? Didnt they have one of the best records in baseball? Didnt they have a ridiculous closer in Smoltz and a starting staff that was very good too? When will they find this 'groove'?!!!
-
Jason Stokes
Shouldn't have traded ADRIAN.... please Adrian tore it up in AFL action while Stokes, who was on his team, did ZERO. Hell, Stokes did NEGATIVE SIX. Now we have Choi - and if we did what you proposed, we would have the following: Adrian Gonzalez Jason Stokes Choi Conine and NO World Series trophy Hmm....you're wrong this time...sorry. As for the future we have: Stokes Choi Conine AND A World Series trophy...
-
Vladimir Status After Choi/Lee Deal
this board still thinks we will make a run for Vlad. . . Explain to me how? If we keep Lowell, forget about Vlad Or is Lowell a goner? Here is a start: Ok, I see now. Pudge's salary this year would be $7M + $3M deferred = total $10M. Castillo is making $6M = total $16M. Call me crazy, but I think we would be better off by putting Castro in there (yes, he has to be found innocent) at roughly 300-400K. Then you let Redmond go and replace him with a cheaper backup, around 300-500K. Next, replace Castillo with minor leaguer/FA/prospect. That could be anywhere from 300K-$2M. Then, sign Vlad at about $10M this year, and increase it over the next several years (3 years total?) to get him what he wants financially. It would look something like this: Pudge 10,000,000 Castillo 6,000,000 Redmd 1,100,000 total 17,100,000 Castro 400,000 bckup 500,000 2B 2,000,000 Vlad 10,000,000 total 12,900,000 Still save about $4M AND get, in my opinion, a better team. Vlad is easily the best hitter on this team - put him in the middle of the lineup. Castro could replace Pudge - and even improve in some categories of offense (more power). Find a capable backup, and there are plenty around, for catcher; could even retain Redmond if you chose. There are plenty of options for 2B out there that wont hurt our team either - trade for Roberts (O's), sign Reese, Young, or even work a deal out for Alomar (which I DONT suggest), or possibly go with Medrano/Hooper/Valdez(?). Either way, there is actually a lot of flexibility and this could get done. Remember, that is maximum figures I proposed above, and you could even use the extra money to increase Vlad's pay. Quoting myself...sorry
-
Lee, Encarnacion, & Urbina should do it.
Ok, I see now.? Pudge's salary this year would be $7M + $3M deferred = total $10M.? Castillo is making $6M = total $16M.? Call me crazy, but I think we would be better off by putting Castro in there (yes, he has to be found innocent) at roughly 300-400K.? Then you let Redmond go and replace him with a cheaper backup, around 300-500K.? Next, replace Castillo with minor leaguer/FA/prospect.? That could be anywhere from 300K-$2M.? Then, sign Vlad at about $10M this year, and increase it over the next several years (3 years total?) to get him what he wants financially.? It would look something like this: Pudge 10,000,000 Castillo 6,000,000 Redmd? 1,100,000 total? ? 17,100,000 Castro? ? 400,000 bckup? ? ? 500,000 2B? ? ? ? 2,000,000 Vlad? ? 10,000,000 total? ? 12,900,000 Still save about $4M AND get, in my opinion, a better team.? Vlad is easily the best hitter on this team - put him in the middle of the lineup.? Castro could replace Pudge - and even improve in some categories of offense (more power).? Find a capable backup, and there are plenty around, for catcher; could even retain Redmond if you chose.? There are plenty of options for 2B out there that wont hurt our team either - trade for Roberts (O's), sign Reese, Young, or even work a deal out for Alomar (which I DONT suggest), or possibly go with Medrano/Hooper/Valdez(?).? Either way, there is actually a lot of flexibility and this could get done.? Remember, that is maximum figures I proposed above, and you could even use the extra money to increase Vlad's pay. why the obssesion with Vlad? The last move basicaly set the table for keeping the OF as Status Quo (Conine, Pierre, Cabrera). Unless we decide to go ahead and trade Lowell. Why change a proven winning combination? With all those moves you suggest, it is pretty much a brand new team. That's what I've been saying for the past month. Keep this team together. We didn't win with high priced superstars. We won with pitching and defense. Let's just say we sign Vlad to a 6 year $15 million contract. What are we going to do when our staff is due to get the big bucks, because you know they will, they're that good. With Vlad's huge contract on our payroll our chance of signing them is slim to none. Keep the team together, we know it's capable of winning, why risk our future with Vlad? We are not going to sign Vlad to a 6 year deal @ $15M per. We dont believe in long term deals like that - look around at this roster. No one is signed past 2005. 3 years tops per player I think. Vlad will get the same - if he gets a deal it will be deferred anticipating a stadium is built. We deal all those guys I mentioned away because we have capable replacements to step in for cheaper. So if this teams philosophy is winning with pitching and defense, tell me how my proposal effects that? If you are as astute as you believe, you would notice that it only increases our resources of keeping the core of this team together - Beckett, Burnett, Penny, Willis, Cabrera and Lowell.
-
What I know....
Can someone explain how the Marlins could accommodate a $10 mil a year player with a $60 mil payroll that includes $11 million in deferred payments to Pudge and Hampton? I will, give me a sec... Here we go: Ok, I see now. Pudge's salary this year would be $7M + $3M deferred = total $10M. Castillo is making $6M = total $16M. Call me crazy, but I think we would be better off by putting Castro in there (yes, he has to be found innocent) at roughly 300-400K. Then you let Redmond go and replace him with a cheaper backup, around 300-500K. Next, replace Castillo with minor leaguer/FA/prospect. That could be anywhere from 300K-$2M. Then, sign Vlad at about $10M this year, and increase it over the next several years (3 years total?) to get him what he wants financially. It would look something like this: Pudge 10,000,000 Castillo 6,000,000 Redmd 1,100,000 total 17,100,000 Castro 400,000 bckup 500,000 2B 2,000,000 Vlad 10,000,000 total 12,900,000 Still save about $4M AND get, in my opinion, a better team. Vlad is easily the best hitter on this team - put him in the middle of the lineup. Castro could replace Pudge - and even improve in some categories of offense (more power). Find a capable backup, and there are plenty around, for catcher; could even retain Redmond if you chose. There are plenty of options for 2B out there that wont hurt our team either - trade for Roberts (O's), sign Reese, Young, or even work a deal out for Alomar (which I DONT suggest), or possibly go with Medrano/Hooper/Valdez(?). Either way, there is actually a lot of flexibility and this could get done. Remember, that is maximum figures I proposed above, and you could even use the extra money to increase Vlad's pay. Check out the thread 'Lee, Encarnacion...' for more discussion/reaction. Of course, you notice, that the trade of Lee was anticipated.
-
What I know....
i heard it from a birdie.... and you want me to give you proof? Pubes, take it from me, Ramp has an excellent source.
-
What is Choi capable of?
I also don't see many people on this board liking Choi much because most of you value batting average a ton and don't give a s*** about walks. Choi is very patient and will probably be in the mold of Lee, but has a higher ceiling offensively. Patient? That is what scouts say, but I dont see it in his stats - truthfully, I havent seen Choi play, but I do like what he has. 6'5", lefty. Wow. This guy comes highly regarded, is only 24 and has more of an upside offensively than Lee does, believe it or not. I say he gets 5 more HRs due to being lefty when he is in his prime. But here is where I disagree Sham: 50ABs 15/7 K/BB 2002 202ABs 71/37 K/BB 2003 He needs to cut those numbers down (K's) and make better contact. He has displayed good power though, but he was playing at Wrigley. He had a .350OBP and a .421SLG = .771OPS. I dont see any reason why these numbers wont improve - he has got the skills. But I will be more comfortable if the PTBNL is Cruz - that would be a rape of the Cubs in my opinion. Either way, both teams have gotten better and gotten what they wanted and needed by this deal. I am excited to see Choi in action, I just dont know what happens with Conine now. We have a lot of flexibility though...another A for Beinfest.
-
Bye bye Bandwagon
Seems there is no one here disappointed with this trade - at least in this post. Everyone here is waving bye to bandwagoners - I hope they dont leave because we need them. This is a very good trade for us though...but I have yet to scope the landscape...
-
Lee, Encarnacion, & Urbina should do it.
You could even trade Redman and sign a spot starter for the meantime or bring someone up out of ST (Wayne? Doubt it...but possible). That would save us even more money and not kill this team. So far: Pudge Castillo Lee Encarnacion Redman (?) all gone None would be irreplaceable, in fact, I would think the only one that makes baseball sense to keep is Lee. Everyone else we could find a replacement for.
-
Lee, Encarnacion, & Urbina should do it.
Ok, I see now. Pudge's salary this year would be $7M + $3M deferred = total $10M. Castillo is making $6M = total $16M. Call me crazy, but I think we would be better off by putting Castro in there (yes, he has to be found innocent) at roughly 300-400K. Then you let Redmond go and replace him with a cheaper backup, around 300-500K. Next, replace Castillo with minor leaguer/FA/prospect. That could be anywhere from 300K-$2M. Then, sign Vlad at about $10M this year, and increase it over the next several years (3 years total?) to get him what he wants financially. It would look something like this: Pudge 10,000,000 Castillo 6,000,000 Redmd 1,100,000 total 17,100,000 Castro 400,000 bckup 500,000 2B 2,000,000 Vlad 10,000,000 total 12,900,000 Still save about $4M AND get, in my opinion, a better team. Vlad is easily the best hitter on this team - put him in the middle of the lineup. Castro could replace Pudge - and even improve in some categories of offense (more power). Find a capable backup, and there are plenty around, for catcher; could even retain Redmond if you chose. There are plenty of options for 2B out there that wont hurt our team either - trade for Roberts (O's), sign Reese, Young, or even work a deal out for Alomar (which I DONT suggest), or possibly go with Medrano/Hooper/Valdez(?). Either way, there is actually a lot of flexibility and this could get done. Remember, that is maximum figures I proposed above, and you could even use the extra money to increase Vlad's pay.
-
Diamondbacks news,
We dont need Counsel back, I dont want to get into reminiscing. I have been keeping my eye on this Schilling deal - and it seems ready to go down. I think this will have a bigger effect on the offseason than most realize - because it forces the Yankees to counter, which means more spending - which means driving the market up. The Red Sox, Gammons hallucinates, are trying to trade Ramirez for A Rod. That would drive the Boss crazy. Should the D backs trim payroll, they could add Lee - I dont know why they would trim $12MM only to turn around and add $8.6 (Sexson) - it seems smarter to add Lee at $7MM max.
-
Castillo News
This is a sign more than ever to let Luis go! If the Mets want him, there must be something very bad looming with him...truthfully, I hope the Muts move fast and do steal him from us. That would free us up with money and save us from suffering bad PR by not being able to re-sign Luis who is demanding too much money in my opinion. You can have him Mets - he is just going to blow up with injuries on your roster anyway... Uggy...is pretty good, but not Rivera. Sorry...wish we could re-sign him though.
-
Lee to O's a no go
Agreed, I said this on another thread I believe too - Lee is more important than Castillo. And certainly worth the money - eventhough Lee will never be the force he could be playing at JRS.
-
Rumor: Lee visits O's
That's right - my girlfriend lives up there...and yes, she is a Cubs fan. But I love her, and I will be up in the Windy City this time next year...damn, I miss her...