Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

dim

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by dim

  1. Like I said in the other thread, he names Garcia/Brice/Wittgren seemed like givens. I would've tried protecting Pineyro since I see him as one of our better starter prospects, but the team valued Esch over him (which I think is wrong). Only other guy who should've maybe been protected is Araujo, but I'm not gonna cry over losing a middle reliever.
  2. Gotta love the Marlins for always finding a way to trade players at their lowest value. Haren was the rare exception recently.
  3. Basically it came down to the Marlins valued Esch over Pineyro. I find Pineyro to be a better pitcher and a year and a half younger (plus closer to the majors). If I'm a major league team I'm looking to take Pineyro at the top of the draft.
  4. So they did protect Garcia/Wittgren/Brice, which was to be expected. Not sure why they didn't find a way to protect Pineyro. 24 years old and had a 2.70 ERA in New Orleans. Felt like a solid get in the Haren trade and now we're just gonna let any team take him in the Rule V Draft.
  5. dim replied to Erick's topic in Miami Marlins
    I thought this thread was about Brian Giles at first, and was confused since I thought he retired a while ago.
  6. Nah it's just guys who are potentially Rule V now. The Marlins have the opportunity to protect players, which I assume Garcia, Wittgren, Brice, Pineyro, and Araujo are guys they will look to protect.
  7. The whole story about Jose and Casey getting into a shouting match over Jose being late seems way too right. Jose's a bit arrogant and Casey an old school dick-ish player who believes in the "right" way of playing the game (think of him as the Brian McCann of this situation).
  8. Or he could just be off the computer.
  9. Well if Jose's the one who wants out then there could be some validity to this. Only way I'd see the Marlins seeking a trade is if Jose asked for it specifically. It would be interesting what the return would be since a team would have him for three more years on a great deal and only THEN have to pay him. For a top 5 pitcher with 3 cheap years left, you'd have to get a franchise altering deal.
  10. On a side note, isn't it great that we started Jose those first two weeks of 2013 so we only now have him through 2018 instead of 2019? That's a decision nobody should ever let anybody live down.
  11. Way too early to trade Jose. We've got him for a few more years and barring a complete breakdown his trade value should remain the same (top tier prospects in return). We're not going to be able to resign him unless Loria loses ownership of the team within the year and Mark Cuban/Mickey Arison take over. Jose will get $200 million on the open market in after 2018. Down the line I'm sure the team is considering the possibility of trading him, but I can't imagine that happening now. That would be sending us back to even further rebuild mode, and it isn't like we're going to get the Cubs old farm system for him anyway.
  12. I mean a platoon is the best thing possible for Bour. The last great catcher we had was the combo of Baker/Paulino. Don't understand why the team doesn't take advantage of platoon advantages a need positions more often.
  13. I'd say his offensive production is built highly on streaks. When you cut out the few and far between streaks he had at the start and end of this past season, he's a liability in the lineup. Most of the time he's an incredible liability in the lineup. He'll never learn how to walk, doesn't have real power potential (although he's a decent gaps hitter), and usually doesn't hit consistently enough to make up for his flaws. However, the expectations from the shortstop position across baseball have decreased over the years. Not a single shortstop with at least 400 AB's this past season had an .800+ OPS. A .717 OPS put you in among the top 10 hitting shortstops in baseball. I hate how little Hechavarria produces most of the season and hate him at the plate most of the season, but he is an important player when he gets hot. If he can continue to post seasons like last year where he's near or over a .700 OPS while maintaining top tier defense (which should be expected at this point), he's a long term player for this team. He's not the best player we can possibly put out there, but looking around the league we could do far, far worse. Definitely can't trade Hechavarria given there is no backup plan and he actually produced like a top 10 MLB shortstop last year when defense is accounted for. I think it's reasonable to temper down the hate for Hech.
  14. When I look at Leake, the best comparison I found in past markets to him was Anibal Sanchez. When he became a free agent, his numbers to that point were very similar to what Leake has produced now. Leake has actually produced a higher WAR and about 100 more innings pitched when entering free agency. Anibal Sanchez received a 5 year, $80 million and market inflation has only made the rate of contracts go higher. I don't see a team not pulling the trigger on a contract of at least $80 million on Leake.
  15. I was assuming Zimmermann would get over $100 million, but I'm imagining after the season Samardzija just had, he will warrant a 1 year, say $10 million kind of "prove it" kind of contract before going into the market next year. What better place to do it than in Miami where there will be relatively few eyes judging him and lower expectations than there have been for him in the past.
  16. I like Mike Leake too. But he'll get around $80 million to $100 million on a long term deal in free agency, and for a guy who has only once posted an ERA below 3.50 that doesn't seem like a smart investment. His numbers suggest he's a consistent #3 starter on a good team. Given how thin we are roster and salary wise, we can't be throwing big money at a player with only a "good" ceiling. Need to get a guy who has been consistently in the "really good" range (aka #2 range) and take a chance on another guy or two coming off a down year who we can give a chance on a one or two year deal.
  17. Don't understand why you are so quick to trash the players we trade away just because they aren't Marlins anymore. Hernandez is 24 years old with a high ceiling, Barnes is going to make a great utility player at worst, and Marisnick is a top tier defensive outfielder with room to improve at the plate. You don't have to be giving away future Hall of Famers to be upset with the players you give away. I'm pretty sure there are tons of World Series teams out there with few All Stars. The trades we have made have hurt the teams long term future, and players like Canha, Barnes, Hernandez, Heaney, Desclafani, German, etc... are all just examples of a decent farm system that we gave away in trades that didn't work out. You shouldn't be ostracizing fans who are open to reminding everyone that the lack of depth both in the majors and the minors is a result of all these moves over the past few years. It isn't a bad thing to talk about how the team gave away players who are performing admirably with other teams for guys who are either struggling or aren't even on the Marlins anymore (you can keep bringing up Gordon, which is cool because it is an even trade, but we've been burned a lot recently).
  18. It was obvious at the time even that the deal was a compensation one (after I wrote my post I figured that out). It is still hilarious going through this thread and seeing Admin talk all kinds of crap about Trevor Williams for absolutely no reason.
  19. They aren't getting a #2 for Ozuna. I don't think the Marlins understand that other teams know about player value, and that Ozuna's value is at a low.
  20. Austin Wates was coming off a huge amount of momentum when we traded for him. Low K, high BB numbers with a good mix of contact ability and a nice approach at the plate. The biggest problem that the Marlins FO overlooked was the lack of any power. That one season in AA where he posted an .871 OPS was the only time he showed any ability to hit more than just singles. When that contact skill took a nosedive (batting average from .310 to .299 to .252 to .236), and he walked more than half as much as he did the previous seasons, that low power started to really show itself. Definitely traded for Wates at his highest value and are now letting him go at his lowest. He's 27 years old and hasn't posted an OPS over .650 since joining the Marlins. I don't know if it was coaching or just a player falling back to where he should be, but just never fit with the Zephyrs. A good showing in 2014 and I have a feeling he would've gotten plate appearances in the majors to open 2015. It really sucks that 2 of the 3 guys we got in the Cosart trade are gone now, and we gave away a solid prospect in Colin Moran (will likely make majors), a top notch defensive OFer with room to grow in Marisnick (already in majors), and somebody who is already being considered one of the best young prospects in baseball after posting ridiculously good numbers in A and A+ ball in Francis Martes. I'm not even mentioning the compensatory pick that turned in Daz Cameron, one of the most talked about prospects of the draft. When it's all set and done, that Cosart trade could possibly be pointed towards as a major turning point for the both the Marlins and Astros franchises. There's a chance the Astros could end up with four major leaguers from the Marlins in that trade, where the Marlins have nobody left from the trade by 2017.
  21. dim replied to a post in a topic in Sports
    The hype was because he was a completely different hitter in the minors. He had one of the best plate disciplines in the minor, consistently posting .400+ OBP's and showing an ability to hit the ball to all parts of the field. His first year he actually showed some of what made him a top 25 prospect with a .390 OBP in over 200 AB's. I don't know what in the world happened, whether it be coaching, injuries, trying to learn left field when he should've been at 1B, a change in approach or just a combination of it all, but he stopped caring about getting on base and started swinging for the fences more. Morrison feels like a player who has a ton of wasted potential. The reasons I was incredibly high on Morrison had absolutely nothing to do with his personality.
  22. Jason Pierre Paul would kindly disagree.
  23. I'm with Admin on this one. Samson is going to say whatever sells tickets and raises public perception of the team. Saying Gordon is a top 10 player and letting the casual fan believe that we have 3 of the 10 best players in baseball is just good business.
  24. Well I'm just speaking as somebody who watches him play and doesn't see a gold glove caliber fielder. He covers decent ground but he's not somebody I watch in the field and think of as one of the top players at his position in the league.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.