September 1, 200620 yr 6 innings doesn't elevate him to solid reliever status. right, but he had been the 8th inning guy the past few outings.... for whatever reason
September 1, 200620 yr This is my problem with the move...wasn't Tank our de facto 8th inning/setup guy for the last month, and hasn't he performed well? Why switch that up now? The answer is there was no switch up. Tank was not the de facto setup man. Mitre had been used as the setup man in each of his three previous relief appearances (Aug. 21 vs Washington + Aug. 25 & 27 vs Milwaukee) prior to last night,. In those three appearances he had given up a total of one walk, no hits and no runs. Well said. Noone complained while Mitre was the "8th inning guy" and he pitched well but the second he is the "8th inning guy" and blows the lead then Girardi is an idiot. Also, the last time Tank came in to pitch a full 8th with a lead he blew it.
September 1, 200620 yr Now some of you are saying he shouldn't have pinch hit for Dontrelle? Are you the same guys who complained that Dontrelle was being allowd to go too deep into games? And we have a "de facto" 8th inning guy? For use in every eighth inning, no matter how he looks to the pitching coach and bullpen coach? No matter how he feels, or if he spent the day puking his guts up because he ate something bad in the hotel buffet line? There are people here who think that they know better than the coaching staff which pitcher was ready to go? And yet they show their ignorance by blaming it on Girardi when the pitching coach and bullpen coach would have been involved in telling Joe who was ready, who needed a day off if possible, etc. Do you even have a clue as to how decisions like that are made? Obviously not. And you little league coaches keep up the ignorant ranting even though Tank DID pitch, and let the Cards blow the game wide open. Check the box score. Tank's inherited runners scored, 2-2. He gave up a hit and walked one. Obviously, Tank was one lefty who could not dominate last night. Thankfully, you guys aren't allowed to manage, or you'd probably have the same result as the fans in the Northern league, who took a team that was in first place the first half of the season, and with ideas like the ones on this board, ran it into the ground. http://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-base...dlines-business
September 1, 200620 yr Why isn't anyone else acknowledging that Girardi didn't have anyone else warming up after Mitre gave up the game tying home run? why would he have someone warming up? I mean Duncan homered on the first pitch and again, Girardi wanted the righty to face Pujols and Rolen, as wrong or as right as that may be Now some of you are saying he shouldn't have pinch hit for Dontrelle? Are you the same guys who complained that Dontrelle was being allowd to go too deep into games? And we have a "de facto" 8th inning guy? For use in every eighth inning, no matter how he looks to the pitching coach and bullpen coach? No matter how he feels, or if he spent the day puking his guts up because he ate something bad in the hotel buffet line? There are people here who think that they know better than the coaching staff which pitcher was ready to go? And yet they show their ignorance by blaming it on Girardi when the pitching coach and bullpen coach would have been involved in telling Joe who was ready, who needed a day off if possible, etc. Do you even have a clue as to how decisions like that are made? Obviously not. And yet Tank came in the game anyway.... so needless to say he could have been ready 10 minutes earlier, if asked. And yea, Tank did give up some runs, but he didnt allow any of HIS runs to score. The Cards had their best guys up to bat, and we should have brought in our best and most talented arm in the pen.
September 1, 200620 yr This is my problem with the move...wasn't Tank our de facto 8th inning/setup guy for the last month, and hasn't he performed well? Why switch that up now? The answer is there was no switch up. Tank was not the de facto setup man. Mitre had been used as the setup man in each of his three previous relief appearances (Aug. 21 vs Washington + Aug. 25 & 27 vs Milwaukee) prior to last night,. In those three appearances he had given up a total of one walk, no hits and no runs. Wait a minute...Tank pitched the 7th inning (scoreless) on Aug. 25th and got the hold before Mitre came in against Milwaukee, he pitched the 8th inning on the 27th, got the win (and blown save) on the 22nd, pitched a scoreless 8th on the 20th (and got the hold), pitched part of the 7th and all of the 8th inning on the 19th, pitched the 8th inning (got the hold) on Aug. 13th, pitched the 8th inning on Aug. 11th, pitched part of the 7th and the entire 8th on Aug. 9th....etc, etc. You can't make it out like Girardi was not previously using him in this role. If Girardi would rather use Mitre in this role than Tank, I think it is just another example of bad judgment on the part of Girardi.
September 1, 200620 yr This is my problem with the move...wasn't Tank our de facto 8th inning/setup guy for the last month, and hasn't he performed well? Why switch that up now? The answer is there was no switch up. Tank was not the de facto setup man. Mitre had been used as the setup man in each of his three previous relief appearances (Aug. 21 vs Washington + Aug. 25 & 27 vs Milwaukee) prior to last night,. In those three appearances he had given up a total of one walk, no hits and no runs. Well said. Noone complained while Mitre was the "8th inning guy" and he pitched well Uh, I complained. It was a poor move then, and it's a poor move now.
September 1, 200620 yr This is my problem with the move...wasn't Tank our de facto 8th inning/setup guy for the last month, and hasn't he performed well? Why switch that up now? The answer is there was no switch up. Tank was not the de facto setup man. Mitre had been used as the setup man in each of his three previous relief appearances (Aug. 21 vs Washington + Aug. 25 & 27 vs Milwaukee) prior to last night,. In those three appearances he had given up a total of one walk, no hits and no runs. Wait a minute...Tank pitched the 7th inning (scoreless) on Aug. 25th and got the hold before Mitre came in against Milwaukee, he pitched the 8th inning on the 27th, got the win (and blown save) on the 22nd, pitched a scoreless 8th on the 20th (and got the hold), pitched part of the 7th and all of the 8th inning on the 19th, pitched the 8th inning (got the hold) on Aug. 13th, pitched the 8th inning on Aug. 11th, pitched part of the 7th and the entire 8th on Aug. 9th....etc, etc. Thank you for proving my point for me. Mitre, not Tank, was used in the 8th for the majority of the games since Aug. 21 to hold down close games. He had been successful in all of those minus last night. And like I wrote earlier, Joe will probably not put him in as the setup man again unless his back is against the wall (Tank is tired/doesn't have his best stuff) after last night's abortion of an outing.
September 1, 200620 yr Wow, it took a little longer than expected for this thread to start but alas, here it is. When you manage a team that is expected to lose 100 games into the NL wildcard chase in this day and age in baseball, then you can talk sh*t about Girardi. Until then, keep your comments to yourself. This game should not rest on Girardi. Period. When you have a young bullpen, are consequences. Games like this happen. Mitrie was awful. It wasn't one of D-Train's greatest outings, either. While I do agree that Girardi's in game management could be better, remember that he is a first year manager. The man knows the game and he's got a great future as an ML manager. I really am sick of these threads every single time we lose.
September 1, 200620 yr Wow, it took a little longer than expected for this thread to start but alas, here it is. When you manage a team that is expected to lose 100 games into the NL wildcard chase in this day and age in baseball, then you can talk sh*t about Girardi. Until then, keep your comments to yourself. This game should not rest on Girardi. Period. When you have a young bullpen, are consequences. Games like this happen. Mitrie was awful. It wasn't one of D-Train's greatest outings, either. While I do agree that Girardi's in game management could be better, remember that he is a first year manager. The man knows the game and he's got a great future as an ML manager. I really am sick of these threads every single time we lose. Umm, actually it was probably one of his best outings of the year. If you are refering to his high pitch count, I think this time of year when you are battling for the wild card you can extend your starters a little more. I would have no problem if he threw 120 or so pitches in that situation.
September 1, 200620 yr Wow. Mitre blew the lead. End of story. How is it possible that Girardi gets blamed for this? WE DONT HAVE AN 8th INNING GUY YOU HALF BRAINED, SHORT SIGHTED IDIOTS! Can we just have ONE game where we lose and the manager doesnt get blamed for it? Jesus.
September 1, 200620 yr Can we just have ONE game where we lose and the manager doesnt get blamed for it? Jesus. Nope, everytime we lose someone has to blame Joe even if it is a certain players fault. If the Fish win and Joe makes a bad desicion we never hear about anything. :whistle
September 1, 200620 yr Wow. Mitre blew the lead. End of story. How is it possible that Girardi gets blamed for this? WE DONT HAVE AN 8th INNING GUY YOU HALF BRAINED, SHORT SIGHTED IDIOTS! Can we just have ONE game where we lose and the manager doesnt get blamed for it? Jesus. I agree that we don't have an eighth inning guy...not Joe's fault. But isn't that all the more reason to stick with Dontrelle with the middle of the Cardinals line up due to hit, which, oh by the way, includes one of the top 5 best hitters in the past decade?? Or would you rather have Mitre come in, who is the very definition of medicore? I'd rather my best face theirs and if we lose, then well, at least we had the best chance possible.
September 1, 200620 yr Wow. Mitre blew the lead. End of story. How is it possible that Girardi gets blamed for this? WE DONT HAVE AN 8th INNING GUY YOU HALF BRAINED, SHORT SIGHTED IDIOTS! Can we just have ONE game where we lose and the manager doesnt get blamed for it? Jesus. I agree that we don't have an eighth inning guy...not Joe's fault. But isn't that all the more reason to stick with Dontrelle with the middle of the Cardinals line up due to hit, which, oh by the way, includes one of the top 5 best hitters in the past decade?? Or would you rather have Mitre come in, who is the very definition of medicore? I'd rather my best face theirs and if we lose, then well, at least we had the best chance possible. In my opinion I would have stuck Brorowski for 2 inning and worry about who closes the next day
September 1, 200620 yr I don't agree with everything Catch said but most of it, and allow me to add in another factor. It's not like games are played in a vacuum. This isn't football where you have a taxi squad and a week to get ready for the next game. We have a tough series coming up in Milwaukee. That as much as anything plays a part in the management and decision-making as a number of other factors.
September 1, 200620 yr When you manage a team that is expected to lose 100 games into the NL wildcard chase in this day and age in baseball, then you can talk sh*t about Girardi. Until then, keep your comments to yourself. Gee, that isn't fallacious. Can we just have ONE game where we lose and the manager doesnt get blamed for it? Jesus. Nope, everytime we lose someone has to blame Joe even if it is a certain players fault. If the Fish win and Joe makes a bad desicion we never hear about anything. :whistle Why do we even have a manager then? so people have someone to blame when we lose
September 1, 200620 yr I don't agree with everything Catch said but most of it, and allow me to add in another factor. It's not like games are played in a vacuum. This isn't football where you have a taxi squad and a week to get ready for the next game. We have a tough series coming up in Milwaukee. That as much as anything plays a part in the management and decision-making as a number of other factors. Right, it's not like games are played in a vacuum, but that doesn't make sense of our manager's decisions. Starting with Tuck in the first game of the series - Taking out Olsen for the 9th and putting in Brian Moehler, a long relief guy. Make sense of that. The following night, when it became obvious that Nolasco didn't have his stuff, we couldn't turn to Moehler because he was inexplicably used the night before to pitch the ninth inning. Then, after the game was out of hand, Pinto, another long relief guy, gets up to warm up with two outs in seventh inning. We have four more outs left to record until the game is over and again, the long relief guy, who would have been useful in the fifth inning when needed, gets up to throw. They were really thinking ahead.
September 1, 200620 yr he got ripped apart today upon multiple radio shows specially the hammer. I dont like his pulling of willis there. I think that was just foolishness for Ross.
September 1, 200620 yr he got ripped apart today upon multiple radio shows specially the hammer. I dont like his pulling of willis there. I think that was just foolishness for Ross. The Hammer doesnt like the Marlins (or baseball for that matter) so his opinions are biased and have no merit.
September 2, 200620 yr I don't agree with everything Catch said but most of it, and allow me to add in another factor. It's not like games are played in a vacuum. This isn't football where you have a taxi squad and a week to get ready for the next game. We have a tough series coming up in Milwaukee. That as much as anything plays a part in the management and decision-making as a number of other factors. Right, it's not like games are played in a vacuum, but that doesn't make sense of our manager's decisions. Starting with Tuck in the first game of the series - Taking out Olsen for the 9th and putting in Brian Moehler, a long relief guy. Make sense of that. The following night, when it became obvious that Nolasco didn't have his stuff, we couldn't turn to Moehler because he was inexplicably used the night before to pitch the ninth inning. Then, after the game was out of hand, Pinto, another long relief guy, gets up to warm up with two outs in seventh inning. We have four more outs left to record until the game is over and again, the long relief guy, who would have been useful in the fifth inning when needed, gets up to throw. They were really thinking ahead. I'm not going to say I have some inside knowledge or know better from the next guy, but the kinds of things that come to mind, in reference to your examples of of Moehler and Pinto, could be they needed work, or in Moehler's case, Borowski had a tired arm or several other reasons. Or in Pinto's case he wanted a lefty for one reason or another if LaRussa did this or that. That said, I was unhappy how the bullpen was employed but I just said to myself "the guys making the decisions know what's going on and I don't...". I was as surprised as anyone that they pinch hit for Willis.
September 2, 200620 yr The thing is, Olsen had only thrown 89 pitches and the game was an absolute blowout. He shouldve finished the game and the bullpen would be well rested if needed for the rest of the series. I dont assume "the guys making the decisions know what's going on and I don't" and that's the problem. And if they do know, they don't know how to use that knowledge.
September 2, 200620 yr I don't agree with everything Catch said but most of it, and allow me to add in another factor. It's not like games are played in a vacuum. This isn't football where you have a taxi squad and a week to get ready for the next game. We have a tough series coming up in Milwaukee. That as much as anything plays a part in the management and decision-making as a number of other factors. Right, it's not like games are played in a vacuum, but that doesn't make sense of our manager's decisions. Starting with Tuck in the first game of the series - Taking out Olsen for the 9th and putting in Brian Moehler, a long relief guy. Make sense of that. The following night, when it became obvious that Nolasco didn't have his stuff, we couldn't turn to Moehler because he was inexplicably used the night before to pitch the ninth inning. Then, after the game was out of hand, Pinto, another long relief guy, gets up to warm up with two outs in seventh inning. We have four more outs left to record until the game is over and again, the long relief guy, who would have been useful in the fifth inning when needed, gets up to throw. They were really thinking ahead. I'm not going to say I have some inside knowledge or know better from the next guy, but the kinds of things that come to mind, in reference to your examples of of Moehler and Pinto, could be they needed work, or in Moehler's case, Borowski had a tired arm or several other reasons. Or in Pinto's case he wanted a lefty for one reason or another if LaRussa did this or that. That said, I was unhappy how the bullpen was employed but I just said to myself "the guys making the decisions know what's going on and I don't...". I was as surprised as anyone that they pinch hit for Willis. Yeah but 2003, you know if Girardi leaves Willis in the game and he goes back to the mound and gets shelled that everyone would be screaming, "why did he leave Willis in the game??!!!!!" Its second guess city.
September 2, 200620 yr Removing Willis from the game in that situation is what needed to be done. However, putting Mitre in was flat out retarded. But I guess it was just because we need to see a righty get that done. Who cares if a lefty can do it better. "TheDon", you seem to think Girardi deserves no blame. Let me guess, if we win, he deserves so much credit because Buster Olney thought we would lose 120. But if we lose, we were expected lose? Yeah, Nolasco didn't have it the other night, maybe Girardi should've been ready with a long reliever for the fifth inning before it got out of hand. The manager needs to put his team in position to win, Joe doesn't do that.
September 2, 200620 yr I don't agree with everything Catch said but most of it, and allow me to add in another factor. It's not like games are played in a vacuum. This isn't football where you have a taxi squad and a week to get ready for the next game. We have a tough series coming up in Milwaukee. That as much as anything plays a part in the management and decision-making as a number of other factors. Right, it's not like games are played in a vacuum, but that doesn't make sense of our manager's decisions. Starting with Tuck in the first game of the series - Taking out Olsen for the 9th and putting in Brian Moehler, a long relief guy. Make sense of that. The following night, when it became obvious that Nolasco didn't have his stuff, we couldn't turn to Moehler because he was inexplicably used the night before to pitch the ninth inning. Then, after the game was out of hand, Pinto, another long relief guy, gets up to warm up with two outs in seventh inning. We have four more outs left to record until the game is over and again, the long relief guy, who would have been useful in the fifth inning when needed, gets up to throw. They were really thinking ahead. I'm not going to say I have some inside knowledge or know better from the next guy, but the kinds of things that come to mind, in reference to your examples of of Moehler and Pinto, could be they needed work, or in Moehler's case, Borowski had a tired arm or several other reasons. Or in Pinto's case he wanted a lefty for one reason or another if LaRussa did this or that. That said, I was unhappy how the bullpen was employed but I just said to myself "the guys making the decisions know what's going on and I don't...". I was as surprised as anyone that they pinch hit for Willis. Yeah but 2003, you know if Girardi leaves Willis in the game and he goes back to the mound and gets shelled that everyone would be screaming, "why did he leave Willis in the game??!!!!!" Its second guess city. exactly. happens every time.
September 2, 200620 yr Removing Willis from the game in that situation is what needed to be done. However, putting Mitre in was flat out retarded. But I guess it was just because we need to see a righty get that done. Who cares if a lefty can do it better. "TheDon", you seem to think Girardi deserves no blame. Let me guess, if we win, he deserves so much credit because Buster Olney thought we would lose 120. But if we lose, we were expected lose? Yeah, Nolasco didn't have it the other night, maybe Girardi should've been ready with a long reliever for the fifth inning before it got out of hand. The manager needs to put his team in position to win, Joe doesn't do that. Sounds like you need to go find a new favorite team then Mr. Manager In Training because I think Girardi is gonna be around at least for another month or so. :thumbup
September 2, 200620 yr Wow. Mitre blew the lead. End of story. How is it possible that Girardi gets blamed for this? WE DONT HAVE AN 8th INNING GUY YOU HALF BRAINED, SHORT SIGHTED IDIOTS! Can we just have ONE game where we lose and the manager doesnt get blamed for it? Jesus. THANK you! :thumbup :thumbup :thumbup :thumbup :thumbup :thumbup :thumbup
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.