Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

ESPN Page 2 story on the Fish

Featured Replies

By Jeff Pearlman

Special to Page 2

 

One hundred twenty-five.

 

That was my guess six months ago, based on every statistic and scouting evaluation and gut feeling within my body. The 2006 Florida Marlins would lose 125 games, fielding what would surely be the worst lineup and pitching staff in the history of major league baseball.

 

Hell, how could they possibly do any better? Florida's $15 million payroll was the league's lowest, and any Marlin worth his weight (Josh Beckett, Mike Lowell, A.J. Burnett, etc.) other than Miguel Cabrera and Dontrelle Willis had been dumped . In their place was, well, liquid crud. Nobodies like Dan Uggla and Reggie Abercrombie. Has-beens like Matt Herges and Joe Borowski. Grade-C youngsters like Mike Jacobs and Chris Aguila. Minor league lifers like Matt Treanor.

 

Matt Treanor!?

 

"This is the worst team I have ever seen," I told a colleague at the time. "I mean, the absolute worst."

 

I was not alone. While on assignment for ESPN the Magazine at the Marlins' spring training facility in Jupiter, Fla., I spoke regularly with the handful of beat writers and columnists and radio and TV reporters following the club.

 

"A joke," said one.

 

"Pathetic," said another.

 

"Little Leaguers."

 

"Don't belong here."

 

"Embarrassing."

 

"Pathetic."

 

I took an unofficial poll. One writer thought 110 loses. Another said 115. A young radio reporter -- the wisest of us all -- settled on 95. "If a few things go right?" she started to say.

 

A veteran TV guy cut her off. "Things can't go right. They'll lose 110 games if everything goes right."

 

It was the surest bet since Mike Tyson-Steve Zouski. Even if the Marlins were to shock the world and play, say, .450 ball for the first three months, there inevitably would be the midsummer lull of performing in 100-degree heat before 376 fans in a run-down football stadium. "I'll admit that could be a challenge," Uggla told me over lunch at a Cheesecake Factory, where he was recognized by absolutely no one. "Hopefully we won't be in that position. Hopefully we'll be winners."

 

I laughed. Not outside, of course, but in my head. Winners? Yeah, right. The next day I stood behind the batting cage before an exhibition game and interviewed Joe Girardi, the rookie manager who surely, beneath his breath, would admit to hoping for 70 wins. Girardi had been around a long time -- a gritty former catcher who knew the truths of major league reality. There was a reason he won with the Yankees and lost with the Cubs; a reason Ken Griffey Jr. hits 40 homers a year and Mark Merchant is lying on a couch eating Ho Hos. It's called talent, and the Marlins didn't have it. Right, Joe?

 

"Our goal is the World Series," he told me.

 

What?

 

"I mean it," he said. "We enter this season with the same aspiration as any other team."

 

I peered closely at his features, desperate for a raised eyebrow or slight smirk or wink or nod or nudge or ? something.

 

"Do you really mean that?" I asked. "I mean, your team has no?"

 

Girardi scowled. He knew the next word would be less than flattering, and he cut it off. "I've always believed that hard work, discipline, attention to details -- those are things that make a profound difference," he said. "Are we young? Yes. Are we overmatched? Maybe. But can we surprise people? I truly believe so."

 

I didn't. Upon leaving the Marlins after four days, I wrote a lead to my story that dumped on the club as a bunch of misfits running around like chickens with their heads chopped off. "These are the Marlins," I wrote. "Your Marlins. They are Willie Mays Hayes and Rick 'Wild Thing' Vaughn and Pedro Cerrano -- men who barely belong in Triple-A, not to mention the major leagues."

 

The lead never made print. Too harsh, I was told -- and boy, was my editor right. The Marlins -- your Marlins -- are not the potential baseball story of the year. They are not the potential story of the decade. They are the potential story of my lifetime -- the long-awaited proof that heart and desire and grit can actually prevail. Once 20 games under .500, Florida is now right at .500 and 3? games behind San Diego in the wild-card race. The Marlins boast four rookies in the starting rotation, three rookie infielders, two rookie outfielders.

 

Uggla, the most unlikely MVP candidate in history, was a Rule 5 pickup from Arizona. Willis, superstud, is their third-best starter.

 

Most of all, there is Girardi. Turns out the BS he was spreading in spring wasn't BS after all. Turns out he truly believed that this team -- this wacky, wild team -- could compete with the best.

 

If only I could say the same.

 

 

link

WOW great article, feels good to finally get respect. Too bad at the start we were the only ones believing in them.

Well, kudos to the writer for writing a feel-good story and making himself look like an absolute moron, but it still doesn't change the fact that his predictions make him look like an absolute moron.

 

Losing 125 games? Clearly this guy has no idea about baseball.

 

Losing 100? Even 110? Sure, I can see how you'd come to that conclusion. But no team will ever lose 125.

A half hearted apologia at best. He spends most of the article recalling his whole four days covering the Marlins and how they would be the worst ever and finally, at the very end of the article, basically says "Well, looks like I was fooled. But who can blame me?" I suppose it is good he at least admitted he was wrong.

I think most telling is the lack of respect anyone covering the team had early on, as shown by the quotes from beat writers, etc. Just more gasoline to put on the "South Florida Media Sucks" fire.

Outstanding article! It all began with Joe G he made these kidz believe in themselves because he believed in them. I love my Marlins but it was pretty heart wrenching as a fan when we had Mitre, Moe and Vargas in our rotation. Joe G made the right moves also in putting JJ and Nolasco in the rotation and calling up Sanchez, Our baby Marlins are great but Joe G has allowed them to be great! They are shocking the world but the last to realize it was the S. Fl media because they have been too busy covering who the backup longsnapper for the Dolphins will be next season. The Miami Herald gets an F. The Sun Sentinel gets a D. well a D plus. They missed out on the miracle of the Marlins. Leaving millions of S Floridian unaware of the wonders of the History making Marlins. The Herald can keep on kissing H Wayne's big, ugly fat ass if they want, in fact that is what they deserve. The S. Florida media is clueless, useless and worthless.

Outstanding article! It all began with Joe G he made these kidz believe in themselves because he believed in them. I love my Marlins but it was pretty heart wrenching as a fan when we had Mitre, Moe and Vargas in our rotation. Joe G made the right moves also in putting JJ and Nolasco in the rotation and calling up Sanchez, Our baby Marlins are great but Joe G has allowed them to be great! They are shocking the world but the last to realize it was the S. Fl media because they have been too busy covering who the backup longsnapper for the Dolphins will be next season. The Miami Herald gets an F. The Sun Sentinel gets a D. well a D plus. They missed out on the miracle of the Marlins. Leaving millions of S Floridian unaware of the wonders of the History making Marlins. The Herald can keep on kissing H Wayne's big, ugly fat ass if they want, in fact that is what they deserve. The S. Florida media is clueless, useless and worthless.

 

 

You didn't grade the Palm Beach Post so I will if you don't mind. I go with a D+, which I think is the highest mark I have ever given them. Heck, back in '01 when CJ was a much ballyhooed aquisition to catch AJ, Josh, and Brad (also Chuck Smith, if anyone remembers him) they had a full front page shot of a catcher in the Sports section. It was Piazza. After I sent them an email to voice my displeasure I had to wash my keyboard out with soap.

It's interesting that this doofus only asked media types what they thought the Marlins' record would be at the end of the season... doesn't sound like he asked any baseball people what they thought. What an idiot.

You didn't grade the Palm Beach Post so I will if you don't mind. I go with a D+, which I think is the highest mark I have ever given them. Heck, back in '01 when CJ was a much ballyhooed aquisition to catch AJ, Josh, and Brad (also Chuck Smith, if anyone remembers him) they had a full front page shot of a catcher in the Sports section. It was Piazza. After I sent them an email to voice my displeasure I had to wash my keyboard out with soap.

 

Oh come on now, you couldn't expect them to know that Piazza was no longer a Marlin. :p

Just a little off comment from the article,"playing in a run-down football stadium..". It is not a good baseball stadium, but it is far from a run-down football stadium. Maybe he thought we played in the Orange Bowl.

Just something I found interesting-I know it is meaningless as it relates to the article as a whole.

Uggla told me over lunch at a Cheesecake Factory, where he was recognized by absolutely no one.

Not true, Ohggla mom did love him

I like the sound of that "Story of a Lifetime"

 

 

Very interesting article. I also like the sound of "Story of a Lifetime". Our team is showing the rest of the league that you don't need 100+ millions on payroll to be competitive. Let's keep enjoying what is left of the season and witness history in the making.

This is a terrible article. He spoke to people who based their opinion on a cursury glance at the roster, and wrote an entire article about how terrible they were supposed to be -- not an article about how good they are. He presupposed that he has an authoritative opinion to begin with, then when his opinion proved to be wrong wrote a short retraction.

This is a terrible article. He spoke to people who based their opinion on a cursury glance at the roster, and wrote an entire article about how terrible they were supposed to be -- not an article about how good they are. He presupposed that he has an authoritative opinion to begin with, then when his opinion proved to be wrong wrote a short retraction.

 

but that is how the national media see us...they look down on us and most are shocked at how well we have played...and he is a writer for espn...every single one of them writes from the point of view that they know something about X topic in particular when really, the only reason they are writing it is because X is getting national press from other publications and they have to keep up

You didn't grade the Palm Beach Post so I will if you don't mind. I go with a D+, which I think is the highest mark I have ever given them. Heck, back in '01 when CJ was a much ballyhooed aquisition to catch AJ, Josh, and Brad (also Chuck Smith, if anyone remembers him) they had a full front page shot of a catcher in the Sports section. It was Piazza. After I sent them an email to voice my displeasure I had to wash my keyboard out with soap.

 

Oh come on now, you couldn't expect them to know that Piazza was no longer a Marlin. :p

 

LOL You would have thought the Mets uniform would have been a dead give away. Even more surprising is that even tho we have a lot of NYers here the most "other team" fans would be for the Cards and the Braves. Atlanta because they had their ST and minor league team here before the big club even moved to Atlanta. Of course that ball park is now a Home Depot thanks to the foreward thinking of West Palm Beach's mayor at that time. But that's another story. Probably one that should be told in a thread praising a car dealership owner for getting things rolling on a new ball park and having the Expos and Cards move in there. Roger Dean.

great article. I like Girardi's comments to him regarding the team.

 

And he gets to eat lunch with Uggla at the cheescake factory...omg he's so damn lucky

Great article? All he did was rant about how bad he thought we were going to be. He says he sees now he was wrong, but doesn't provide analysis or insight of ANY sort.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.