Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

A-Rod / Marlins Rumor Talk

Featured Replies

Yea, and Bud Selig directly violated all those provisions by owning the Brewers during his first years as commissioner, and like, George Mitchell sitting on the board of executives to the Red Sox during the steroid investigation.

 

Wouldn't be the first conflict of interest in baseball. If A-Rod would secure a stadium in South Florida (as in, MLB could finally become situated in the # 4 media market in the country, and maybe more importantly, get a brand new venue in a perfect location for the World Baseball Classic and rake in cash from that), I have all the confidence in the world MLB will make an A-Rod exemption for this uber-generational-centennial player and allow "stock options" for future ownership, or as Swift muses, some sort of holding company, or who knows what they/Boras will think of, to make it happen. It's in the best interest of everyone for the Marlins to stay here (Marlins, get the stadium, ARod, gets paid, Baseball, gets to stay in the population dense region, Loria, value of franchise skyrockets, City, gets a new stadium with assumed regional rehabilitation) and if A-Rod can make that happen, they will figure it out if that's what the parties want.

 

Very unlikely, but I wouldn't just categorically write it off like some of you. Crazier things have happened. Like AJ Piersynski winning world series games by striking out and running to first.

How about you look at SUBSECTION D in my post.

 

I mean, jeez.

 

(d) LEAGUE OFFICIALS. "No officer, employee or umpire of a League shall, directly or indirectly, own stock or any other proprietary interest or have any financial interest in any Club of his or her League, or loan money to or become surety or guarantor for any such Club."

 

ARod is a league employee.

Please provide a definition of a "league employee." As far as I know, the players are team employees.

 

I thought that might have been the section you were referring to, but he's not a league employee.

The fact that in subsection A the rule specifically provides that it includes a player as a team employee and that subsection D does not indicates to me that a player is not a league employee.

I think that AROD ownership thing is BS. However, the possibilty of AROD to the Marlins might not be as far fetched as people think. If they did sign Arod that makes Cabrera expendable. So they trade Cabrera and D-Train which almost would cover Arods salary. Tell me the Yanks wouldn't love to have those 2. We could get Melky and Joba or Hughes and someone else.

:weed

Rules:

 

Rule 20 ? 1

 

(a) OWNERSHIP AND FINANCIAL INTERESTS. "No Club, or owner, stockholder, officer, director or employee (including manager or player) of a Club, shall, directly or indirectly, own stock or any other proprietary interest or have any financial interest in any other Club in its League, provided, however, that any owner or stockholder of a Major League Club (who is not also an officer, director or employee of a Club) whose interest does not exceed 5% of such Club and whose interest does not constitute a control interest [as defined] may own a non-control interest not exceeding 5% of any other Club or Clubs in its League, unless the Commissioner determines that such ownership would not be in the best interests of Baseball."

 

? LOANS TO CLUBS AND OTHER INDIVIDUALS. "No Club, or owner, stockholder, officer, director or employee (including manager or player) of a Club shall, directly or indirectly, loan money to or become surety or guarantor for any Club, officer, employee or umpire of its, his or her League, unless all facts of the transaction shall first have been fully disclosed to all other Clubs in that League, and also to the Commissioner, and the transaction has been approved by them."

 

(d) LEAGUE OFFICIALS. "No officer, employee or umpire of a League shall, directly or indirectly, own stock or any other proprietary interest or have any financial interest in any Club of his or her League, or loan money to or become surety or guarantor for any such Club."

 

http://www.roadsidephotos.com/baseball/02-4rules.htm

This is how Ted Turner got in trouble when he decided to take over as manager of the Braves in the 70s. :mischief

Whether the ownership is true or not, the fact that many different reporters are talking about the Marlins and Arod makes me believe something is up. Like MarlinsLou said the benefits to this is huge. As much as I hate Arod, a move like this would not only be huge for the Marlins but for baseball as a whole

Whether the ownership is true or not, the fact that many different reporters are talking about the Marlins and Arod makes me believe something is up. Like MarlinsLou said the benefits to this is huge. As much as I hate Arod, a move like this would not only be huge for the Marlins but for baseball as a whole

Will A-Rod make our pitchers better?

Whether the ownership is true or not, the fact that many different reporters are talking about the Marlins and Arod makes me believe something is up. Like MarlinsLou said the benefits to this is huge. As much as I hate Arod, a move like this would not only be huge for the Marlins but for baseball as a whole

Will A-Rod make our pitchers better?

 

Yes, by allowing us to trade Cabrera for some serious arms

Yes, by allowing us to trade Cabrera for some serious arms

Who's buying?

 

Also, the market isn't fraught with talented FA pitchers. I'd also like to know how signing ARod would FREE UP money for anyone?? [scratches head]

 

Last time I checked, the Yankees - the evil empire/deepest pockets in sports - just dumped ARod's salary. Who do you think will win in a bidding situation for the 1 or 2 good arms that will become available? The DRays?

 

I still think ARod is bad for baseball. No team can afford to pay the guy what he is worth and still field a team with quality pitchers.

I try to stay dispassionate about these kinds of rumors/pie-in-the-sky stuff but I agree with Lou that the "get A-Rod trade Miggy" idea works on so many levels.

 

It would certainly put us on the map. And in contention. ARod is probably the only player even vaguely attainable that would mute the chorus of media critics were Miggy traded. Plus the players you get back in return...

 

And I do think, when it all falls together with a new stadium, yes MLB would sanction ARod's ownership participation however it was crafted to provide the obvious protections and not creating a precedent (which is one of the big big problems).

 

I'm going back to work now, I can't think about this any more...but it is fascinating if for no other reasons than the complexities of such a move.

Please provide a definition of a "league employee." As far as I know, the players are team employees.

 

I thought that might have been the section you were referring to, but he's not a league employee.

 

No, you're wrong.

 

US Court of Appeals in Baltimore Orioles, Inc. v. MLBPA 805 F.2d 663 established a player to be an employee sufficient to satisfy league requirements and disestablishing the MLBPA as an entity that has required consent for broadcasting. Rather, unless there is an agreement expressly to revoke team's rights of broadcasts, Clubs are presumed to own all telecast right of the game.

 

I'm not saying we couldn't argue all day long, but the court system has established the players and employees to not be a separable entity.

I wish we had money to afford someone like A-ROD, it would be huge to have him down here in Miami.

Yes, by allowing us to trade Cabrera for some serious arms

Who's buying?

 

Also, the market isn't fraught with talented FA pitchers. I'd also like to know how signing ARod would FREE UP money for anyone?? [scratches head]

 

Last time I checked, the Yankees - the evil empire/deepest pockets in sports - just dumped ARod's salary. Who do you think will win in a bidding situation for the 1 or 2 good arms that will become available? The DRays?

 

I still think ARod is bad for baseball. No team can afford to pay the guy what he is worth and still field a team with quality pitchers.

 

I think you're completly misreading what I said. Trading D-Train and Cabrera would free up money for the Marlins

I have no idea why you're talking about FA pitchers. IF YOU TRADE CABRERA YOU CAN TRADE HIM FOR PITCHERS. Example, I trade Cabrera to the Yankees and in return the Yankees trade Joba and Melky. That's a trade

I have no clue why you're talking FA pitchers

I still think ARod is bad for baseball. No team can afford to pay the guy what he is worth and still field a team with quality pitchers.

 

I don't buy that. As long as you are smart with your money a team can afford pitchers and pay A-Rod. If the Yankees had spent the money they were paying Pavano, Mussina, Igawa, and even Clemens in smarter ways they could have fielded a team with quality pitchers.

I have no idea why you're talking about FA pitchers. IF YOU TRADE CABRERA YOU CAN TRADE HIM FOR PITCHERS. Example, I trade Cabrera to the Yankees and in return the Yankees trade Joba and Melky. That's a trade

Melky isn't a pitcher. And we need a lot more than Joba. :mischief

Please provide a definition of a "league employee." As far as I know, the players are team employees.

 

I thought that might have been the section you were referring to, but he's not a league employee.

 

No, you're wrong.

 

US Court of Appeals in Baltimore Orioles, Inc. v. MLBPA 805 F.2d 663 established a player to be an employee sufficient to satisfy league requirements and disestablishing the MLBPA as an entity that has required consent for broadcasting. Rather, unless there is an agreement expressly to revoke team's rights of broadcasts, Clubs are presumed to own all telecast right of the game.

 

I'm not saying we couldn't argue all day long, but the court system has established the players and employees to not be a separable entity.

 

Where does that say that a player is a league employee? It says that a player is an employee to satisfy league requirements... what requirements are those?

 

I'll look up that case.

Please provide a definition of a "league employee." As far as I know, the players are team employees.

 

I thought that might have been the section you were referring to, but he's not a league employee.

 

No, you're wrong.

 

US Court of Appeals in Baltimore Orioles, Inc. v. MLBPA 805 F.2d 663 established a player to be an employee sufficient to satisfy league requirements and disestablishing the MLBPA as an entity that has required consent for broadcasting. Rather, unless there is an agreement expressly to revoke team's rights of broadcasts, Clubs are presumed to own all telecast right of the game.

 

I'm not saying we couldn't argue all day long, but the court system has established the players and employees to not be a separable entity.

 

No, you're wrong.

 

Here is a quote from that same case:

 

"With regard to the relationship between the Clubs and the Players, the district court found, and the Players do not dispute, that the Players are employees of their respective Clubs. We add only that this finding is consistent with the broad construction given to the term "employee" by courts applying the "work made for hire" doctrine. See Evans Newton Inc. v. Chicago Systems Software, 793 F.2d 889, 894, 230 U.S.P.Q. (BNA) 166 (7th Cir. 1986) (a person acting under another's direction and supervision is an employee for the purpose [**17] of the work made for hire doctrine); Aldon Accessories v. [*670] Spiegel, Inc., 738 F.2d 548, 551-53, 222 U.S.P.Q. (BNA) 951 (2d Cir.) (same), cert. denied, 469 U.S. 982, 105 S. Ct. 387, 83 L. Ed. 2d 321 (1984)."

 

http://www.law.uconn.edu/homes/swilf/ip/cases/baltimore.htm

 

You can find the quote about a third of the way down the page.

 

 

 

BOTTOM LINE: A-ROD can get an ownership interest in the Marlins.

 

Swift, I hope you're not in law school.

I still think ARod is bad for baseball. No team can afford to pay the guy what he is worth and still field a team with quality pitchers.

 

I don't buy that. As long as you are smart with your money a team can afford pitchers and pay A-Rod. If the Yankees had spent the money they were paying Pavano, Mussina, Igawa, and even Clemens in smarter ways they could have fielded a team with quality pitchers.

I agree with you - but the Yankees are an extreme example. I think you have to take teams like the Yankees, Redsox, and Mets out of the picture when you start talking about money since they are SO far ahead of the mean.

 

Let's assume ARod will make roughly $30 million per year. The Marlins ENTIRE roster last year made $30.5 million. The median team is the Toronto Blue Jays with a payroll of $82 million. If a team at the median signs Arod, they are committing roughly 37% of their salary to a single player. A guy like Johan Santana makes another $13 million. All of a sudden, you have more than 1/2 of your payroll tied up in just two players.

 

THAT is why I think the numbers don't work. Clearly, Arod is an amazing player and will put up huge numbers wherever he goes. The question is, can a team afford him?

 

The teams that can truly afford him [Yankees, Redsox, Mets] don't need him. The only logical choices remaining of the big $ teams are the Angels, Dodgers, and M's. Of the 3? You'd have to think the Angels are a really good bet.

Please provide a definition of a "league employee." As far as I know, the players are team employees.

 

I thought that might have been the section you were referring to, but he's not a league employee.

 

No, you're wrong.

 

US Court of Appeals in Baltimore Orioles, Inc. v. MLBPA 805 F.2d 663 established a player to be an employee sufficient to satisfy league requirements and disestablishing the MLBPA as an entity that has required consent for broadcasting. Rather, unless there is an agreement expressly to revoke team's rights of broadcasts, Clubs are presumed to own all telecast right of the game.

 

I'm not saying we couldn't argue all day long, but the court system has established the players and employees to not be a separable entity.

 

No, you're wrong.

 

Here is a quote from that same case:

 

"With regard to the relationship between the Clubs and the Players, the district court found, and the Players do not dispute, that the Players are employees of their respective Clubs. We add only that this finding is consistent with the broad construction given to the term "employee" by courts applying the "work made for hire" doctrine. See Evans Newton Inc. v. Chicago Systems Software, 793 F.2d 889, 894, 230 U.S.P.Q. (BNA) 166 (7th Cir. 1986) (a person acting under another's direction and supervision is an employee for the purpose [**17] of the work made for hire doctrine); Aldon Accessories v. [*670] Spiegel, Inc., 738 F.2d 548, 551-53, 222 U.S.P.Q. (BNA) 951 (2d Cir.) (same), cert. denied, 469 U.S. 982, 105 S. Ct. 387, 83 L. Ed. 2d 321 (1984)."

 

http://www.law.uconn.edu/homes/swilf/ip/cases/baltimore.htm

 

You can find the quote about a third of the way down the page.

 

 

 

BOTTOM LINE: A-ROD can get an ownership interest in the Marlins.

 

Swift, I hope you're not in law school.

 

 

I'm jumping in here late, but it appears prinmemito is right in the readong of the statute. There would not be a seperate provision for players if players were to be included in the definition of employee in subsection D.

 

Also the case has top do with labor disputes and differentiates a league player from an independent contractor and the such.1

 

There is no reason why the club can't give A-rod an ownership interest based on the laws that have been cited in this post. Also, to assume that every single media outlet that has mentioned this has not done any research is also a bit far fetched. Sure the sports media gets carried away, but a rule like that would seem glaring.

Yes, by allowing us to trade Cabrera for some serious arms

Who's buying?

 

Also, the market isn't fraught with talented FA pitchers. I'd also like to know how signing ARod would FREE UP money for anyone?? [scratches head]

 

Last time I checked, the Yankees - the evil empire/deepest pockets in sports - just dumped ARod's salary. Who do you think will win in a bidding situation for the 1 or 2 good arms that will become available? The DRays?

 

I still think ARod is bad for baseball. No team can afford to pay the guy what he is worth and still field a team with quality pitchers.

ARod dumped the Yankees, not the other way around.

 

ARod is not bad for baseball in any way. It would be stupid for a team to pay him $25 million or $30 million but that's not his fault. If a team pays him that much it would be stupid and it would be bad for the team that pays it but that doesn't means ARod is bad for baseball. Stupid GMs are bad for baseball. Great players are good for baseball.

Yup, I guess I'm wrong:

A-Rod's huge numbers couldn't have come at a better time. Ten days after the World Series ends, A-Rod can opt out of the $252 million contract he signed with the Texas Rangers six years ago. He is scheduled to make $27 million in each of the next three seasons.

 

Yankees president Randy Levine also responded harshly to the magazine piece.

 

"It's a silly story, and we don't believe it," he told ESPN.com's Buster Olney on Sunday evening. "However, if it was true, it would be grounds to disqualify the applicant even before he went through the process, because it would demonstrate a disregard for major league rules and procedures, and we're confident the commissioner would feel the same way."

 

Levine later said he spoke to Bud Selig, and the commissioner agreed with Levine's interpretation of the story, and its possible implications. A player can neither have part ownership of a team nor negotiate for future ownership.

 

:thumbup

 

http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/news/story?id=3033203

ARod dumped the Yankees, not the other way around.

 

ARod is not bad for baseball in any way. It would be stupid for a team to pay him $25 million or $30 million but that's not his fault. If a team pays him that much it would be stupid and it would be bad for the team that pays it but that doesn't means ARod is bad for baseball. Stupid GMs are bad for baseball. Great players are good for baseball.

If you want to argue semantics, by Arod's decision to opt out of his existing contract, the Yankees made it official that they would not pursue. Which is a mutual break up. However, that doesn't change the fact that they dumped/shed/expunged/insert-word-of-choice-here all that money.

 

Okay, I might have been harsh by saying AROD is bad for baseball, but the point remains that an Arod contract IS bad for baseball. Read my later post which does a pretty good job of explaining the dollars and cents.

How the hell are the Padres so in tuned to what exactly is going to happen within our front office???

 

Kevin Towers knows all. He's reading this post right now

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.