November 20, 200718 yr Author Rollins Home: .300 Avg, .556 SLG, .892 OPS Away: .293 Avg, .507 SLG, .856 OPS Holliday Home: .376 Avg, .722 SLG, 1.157 OPS Away: .301 Avg, .485 SLG, .860 OPS Again, I wont argue for either one of them, I just think this is what the voters had in mind.
November 20, 200718 yr I assume they put a lot of weight on what they each perveive the Colorado factor to be. I don't know about that. A lot of people think the humidor has turned Coors into a fair hitters park and that's a completely false. It contineus to be the best hitters park. False. Citizen Bank Park is the best hitters park.
November 20, 200718 yr I bet if he had hit 28-29 homers instead of 30, he would have received less votes. But congrats to him anyways.
November 20, 200718 yr Look, I'm just going to say this... Rollins had a great all around season. He played a postion harder to field. 30 SS Hrs to 36. LF..... Come on! 100 RBI from a leadoff? Way more steels. only 85 SO compared to compared to 126? The award could have gone either way. Nothing to cry about, J-Roll Deserved it. So did Holliday. J-Roll won. You guys are mad because he is a Phillie.
November 20, 200718 yr I assume they put a lot of weight on what they each perveive the Colorado factor to be. I don't know about that. A lot of people think the humidor has turned Coors into a fair hitters park and that's a completely false. It contineus to be the best hitters park. False. Citizen Bank Park is the best hitters park. Below are the Park Factors according to baseball-reference. Citizens was 5th. Coors, as expected, was 1st. COL 109 CHC 107 ARI 105 LAD 105 PHI 104 CIN 103 MIL 102 SFG 100 FLA 100 STL 99 NYM 98 ATL 98 PIT 96 HOU 94 WSN 93 SDP 89 Over 100 favors batters, under 100 favors pitchers.
November 20, 200718 yr I find it funny that Carlos Marmol got a vote.. (a 10th place vote but a vote none-the-less lol)
November 20, 200718 yr You guys are mad because he is a Phillie. Or it could be that he wasn't even the most deserving player on his team.
November 20, 200718 yr Look, I'm just going to say this... Rollins had a great all around season. He played a postion harder to field. 30 SS Hrs to 36. LF..... Come on! 100 RBI from a leadoff? Way more steels. only 85 SO compared to compared to 126? The award could have gone either way. Nothing to cry about, J-Roll Deserved it. So did Holliday. J-Roll won. You guys are mad because he is a Phillie. :lol none of us are petty enough to be made because Rollins is a Philly grow up
November 20, 200718 yr He's not even the best shortstop in the NL. Who is? JR is... but him winning the MVP just proves that the voters have learned nothing over the past 30 years of course, this isn't as bad as when Pudge got his MVP, but it's still bad
November 20, 200718 yr .344 OBP for an MVP hooray Since it is measured as an all around player, I'm glad they dont use just one stat. J-Roll said, "we are the team to beat in the NL east." He backed it up from day one. Howard was hurt, J-Roll played well. Howard Stunk for a while and Utley got hurt, but still J-Roll played well. His game as an all around player is awesome, he was the leader of the Phillies, and picked up the slack for the rest of the guys when they were injured. He deserved it.
November 20, 200718 yr He's not even the best shortstop in the NL. Who is? Hanley Ramirez. He has the potential to be the best. Sure he can hit, but his fielding is Sub Par.
November 20, 200718 yr I'm just glad that fruitcake David Wright didn't win. That kid really grinds my gears.
November 20, 200718 yr I'm just glad that fruitcake David Wright didn't win. That kid really grinds my gears. Jose Reyes grinds mine, his stupid dancing in the dugout BS.
November 20, 200718 yr He's not even the best shortstop in the NL. Who is? Hanley Ramirez. He has the potential to be the best. Sure he can hit, but his fielding is Sub Par. His fielding may be subpar at the moment, but he's a better hitter/base stealer than Rollins. Hanley's defense will get better in time.
November 20, 200718 yr He's not even the best shortstop in the NL. Who is? Hanley Ramirez. He has the potential to be the best. Sure he can hit, but his fielding is Sub Par. His fielding may be subpar at the moment, but he's a better hitter/base stealer than Rollins. Hanley's defense will get better in time. I dont disagree. When you are an SS your Defense is pretty damn important though.
November 20, 200718 yr I'm just glad that fruitcake David Wright didn't win. That kid really grinds my gears. Jose Reyes grinds mine, his stupid dancing in the dugout BS. Speaking of Reyes and how childish he acts, I was reading an article the other day saying how Reyes and Heilman are the 2 longest tenured Mets players since Tom Glavine. On June 10, 2003, Reyes made his major-league debut with the Mets, during an inter-league game in Texas, batting ninth in a lineup that included Roger Cedeno, Timo Perez, Roberto Alomar, Cliff Floyd, Jeromy Burnitz, Ty Wigginton, Jason Phillips and Vance Wilson with Steve Trachsel on the mound. Hah. Crazy how things have changed. /end thread jack. Sorry.
November 20, 200718 yr This is getting out of hand... Holliday and Fielder edged out by a guy who isn't even the best player at his position in his own division.
November 20, 200718 yr This is getting out of hand... Holliday and Fielder edged out by a guy who isn't even the best player at his position in his own division. I would argue Rollins is the best "player" at SS in the NL East
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.