Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Why not bring up McPherson to play 3rd?

Featured Replies

Jake has been struggling and Cantu has looked pretty good at 1B so far. Anyone like this idea? Instead of calling up Andino?

  • Author

LOL and what do you do with Jake?

 

 

keep giving him spot starts and hope he gets it back together or send him down to work on his game a bit? I don't know but you act as if we are obligated to let him start at first.

jake is slugging over .500, you keep starting him against righties and soft tossing lefties.

I agree, but that's just because I've never like Mike Jacobs and I'll agree with anything that has him not being there. He is incredibly meh to me.

jake is slugging over .500, you keep starting him against righties and soft tossing lefties.

 

I'd like to see him hit a couple more homers off of Moyer tomorrow.

Andino will be up for 1 day. We are going to either call up McPherson and DH Jacobs starting Friday, or we are going to call up a 13th pitcher

Andino will be up for 1 day. We are going to either call up McPherson and DH Jacobs starting Friday, or we are going to call up a 13th pitcher

That makes sense to me

Andino will be up for 1 day. We are going to either call up McPherson and DH Jacobs starting Friday, or we are going to call up a 13th pitcher

 

link?

At this point, trading or benching Jake would not solve anything for a few reasons. Jake is a good hitter, at the beginning of the year it looked like he would hit 50 homers, he just going through a rough patch. He hasn't been struggling that bad though, 2 homers last 2 games before tonight, and a multi-homer game in Philly. We can't trade him now because we would not get enough value for him, we at least need to trade him when he is swinging a hot bat and teams will give up more. We also can't bench him, because he is a terrible pinch-hitter, and if it is only his defense thats a problem, that can be worked out. If we do trade him, we should put Uggla at 1st and bring up Coghlan to play 2nd.

hmm im not the only one to think of this move

put jacobs on the bench or trade block idc ive just never been inpressed with him

Benching Jake would be a huge mistake...

 

I mean, it's not like he's doing bad. He's slugging .563. I HIGHLY doubt McPherson will produce as much as Jacobs.

what erickwiener says make sense and im gonna go with that, thats a perfect idea that will give mcphereson a chance and still have cantu and jacobs in the lineup.

:lol @ the link.

 

Anyways, yeah...I'd like to see Jacobs continue to get playing time, and I'd like to see anyone, but at Andino, at this point. McPherson would be nice.

what erickwiener says make sense and im gonna go with that, thats a perfect idea that will give mcphereson a chance and still have cantu and jacobs in the lineup.

 

Well, we might just call up a 13th pitcher and use Amezega and Helms as a 3B platoon

I think we have 13 up already. I guess this means Amezaga gets more time in the OF. :( :banghead :thumbdown

I think we have 13 up already. I guess this means Amezaga gets more time in the OF. :( :banghead :thumbdown

 

Nah, I think that Ross is going to get the time he deserves out there.

No thanks on Amezaga/Helms platoon. Our defense sucks...but I don't want to watch two bench players at the hot corner. Jacobs isn't going so bad..he's hitting around .250 (I think). If it drops much lower, he's on the bench. I think they bring up McPherson, just to have him...and get him going. If Dallas is hitting well (up here) and Jake is still struggling. Dallas would take over.

I like the idea too, but right now I'd leave it the way it is - letting McPherson prove he can stay healthy an entire season and also to see the kind of numbers Jacobs puts up for the whole year (assuming he too can stay healthy). However, if Jake gets injured call up McPherson and put Cantu at 1st.

 

I think we would upgrade defensively with McPherson at 3rd and Cantu at 1st (mainly cuz Cantu doesn't have to throw the ball, which seems to be his main problem, although he can pick it pretty well) and from what I've read McPherson is better than Cantu at 3rd.

 

But, remember at the beginning of the year we were calling Jake the clubhouse leader... I think it would be a bad idea to take such a "supposedly" prominent clubhouse figure away from the team unnecessarily - hence waiting for an injury or the end of the season (especially if he doesn't perform up to expectations).

I like the idea too, but right now I'd leave it the way it is - letting McPherson prove he can stay healthy an entire season and also to see the kind of numbers Jacobs puts up for the whole year (assuming he too can stay healthy). However, if Jake gets injured call up McPherson and put Cantu at 1st.

 

I think we would upgrade defensively with McPherson at 3rd and Cantu at 1st (mainly cuz Cantu doesn't have to throw the ball, which seems to be his main problem, although he can pick it pretty well) and from what I've read McPherson is better than Cantu at 3rd.

 

But, remember at the beginning of the year we were calling Jake the clubhouse leader... I think it would be a bad idea to take such a "supposedly" prominent clubhouse figure away from the team unnecessarily - hence waiting for an injury or the end of the season (especially if he doesn't perform up to expectations).

 

Jacobs gives the "juicy" quotes many fans like to read but I don;t think that makes him a leader. Cantu at 3B and Jacobs at 1B are both horrible defensively. Cantu at 1B would probably be a defensive upgrade over Jacobs and Fredo / Helms / Whoever would be a defensive upgrade over Cantu at 3B. We would probably lose some offense but would get a big defensive upgrade. I would give it a shot.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.