Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Marlins interested in Mark DeRosa

Featured Replies

Any upgrate is significant? This upgrade would be HUGE!

 

 

DeRosa is a scrappy player who gives it his all every game. Get this done! Give up some prospects so we can compete. I would give up Matt Dominguez and a pitching prospect for him in a heartbeat.

 

Bonifacio is also a scrappy player who gives it his all every game.

 

 

His all costs the team 2 runs today.... The guy is a joke out there, and sorry I personally don't want him on the Marlins anymore I'm sick of him costing us runs, and games.

 

He is by far the worst ball player in baseball right now, and by far the worst everyday player this franchise has ever had at the big league level.

Any upgrate is significant? This upgrade would be HUGE!

 

 

DeRosa is a scrappy player who gives it his all every game. Get this done! Give up some prospects so we can compete. I would give up Matt Dominguez and a pitching prospect for him in a heartbeat.

 

Bonifacio is also a scrappy player who gives it his all every game.

 

 

His all costs the team 2 runs today.... The guy is a joke out there, and sorry I personally don't want him on the Marlins anymore I'm sick of him costing us runs, and games.

 

He is by far the worst ball player in baseball right now, and by far the worst everyday player this franchise has ever had at the big league level.

His all cost the team 1 run today, because he got on back on the heads up running at the end there.

david Wright looks like a scrappy player.

 

Emilio Bonifacio looks like Joe Girardi when I see him, and I want to punch Joe Giardi---

 

and Josh Phelps

I think the 2003 team was more fundamentally sound for making a playoff run, especially by the point of the season when that trade was made.

 

 

While I would agree overall they were a better team with few weaknesses, comparing the '03 team to this team at THIS point of the season, there are some startling similarities:

 

20032009After 72 gms34W-38L0.47236W-36L0.5April14W-15L0.48314W-8L0.636May12W-16L0.4299W-20L0.31June (through 23)12W-8L0.613W-8L0.619

So, the 03 team stated slow, had a slide in May and started to pick it up in June (following the firing of Jeff Torborg). This year's version had a great start, had a major slide in May and have picked it up in June. Through the 23rd in June, both teams had essentially the same June records. To me, that's a sign that even though we have glaring holes in this team (ML-calibre 3B, closer, healthy BP), they're starting to galvanize at the right time just like the 03 squad.

 

What I find funny is Torborg went 16-22 in the first 38 games before getting replaced by Trader Jack (who went 18-16 in the next 34 games). Freddi went 18-20 in the first 38, 18-16 the next 34.

 

While key contributors like D-Train, Miggy, Hammer and Jacobs aren't on this team, is this year's team necessarily any different then the '06 and '08 teams that were surprise contenders until late in the season? With the Mets being decimated by injuries and the Phillies going cold as we're getting hot, I have no reason to believe we're not a 3b and some pitching help away from making a serious playoff run. This year's Miggy, Urbina and Willis could be DeRosa or Gaby, West and dare I say it- Pedro Martinez....

 

Commence the flaming.

The post isn't flameworthy, of course, but I don't see it the same way. My point was that you can't view this in terms of records, but the actual talent itself.

 

My initial point regarding the 2003 was that at the midseason point (about where we are now), the 2003 group was actually a better team than their record showed. Of course many here will disagree with me, but I don't view this current 2009 group (as it stands) as being remotely playoff caliber. I think there are numerous glaring holes and rampant inconsistency that perhaps indicates that this team is actually overperforming. I think this is definitely a .500 or better team, but I think the reason why the Marlins are only two games back says more about the division than the quality of the team itself.

Can someone explain what a "scrappy" player is?

 

Only Joe Morgan has that ability.

With a little more seasoning, Reynolds may be able to challenge him.

Any upgrate is significant? This upgrade would be HUGE!

 

 

DeRosa is a scrappy player who gives it his all every game. Get this done! Give up some prospects so we can compete. I would give up Matt Dominguez and a pitching prospect for him in a heartbeat.

 

 

Why would you choose our top prospect at the position where we have the least depth? They can't afford to trade this guy, unless they are absolutely convinced that Gaby can be "the answer" at 3B, and even then they probably can't afford to.

 

 

Some people are in love with their own players too much. I always thought Dominguez wouldn't hit enough to be a pro. I can't see Dominguez ever being a better pro than DeRosa is and I've seen Matt play alot.

 

You don't ruin a chance at making the playoffs with a solid pitching staff by not trading an overrated prospect.

 

Go for the playoffs!

 

It's not about whether he's overrated. If he merely projects to an extremely average ML 3B, it's probably still a bad idea for the Marlins to trade him. They have no legitimate 3B prospecs in the pipelines as I understand it.

 

Also, what about my post made you think I'm "in love" with my own player too much? He's still the top prospect at 3B. For someone who seems to feel he is such a brilliant writer, a little reading wouldn't kill you.

 

 

What?! Matt Dominguez right now doesn't even project to be as good as Mark DeRosa in the future right now! He still has a long way to improve on his K's and his .300 slugging percentage. I know he's very young and great at D; I just don't see this guy ever becoming a star. Go for the playoffs and pull the trigger. Who knows if Dominguez would even be involved or if anyone would want him at this point. He isn't even hitting in low Single A.

You cant be serious. First of all, Dominguez is tearing it up after a slow start. Secondly, he isnt in low A...he is at Jupiter, a step below AA, in one of the toughest hitters leagues in minor league baseball.

 

 

 

I meant high A. Last season Dominguez hit .296 with 18 HR at Greensboro, a good year. This season he's slugging in the .300's, is K ing at a very high rate, and only has 4 homers (yes I know it's a pitcher's league).

 

I'm not saying he's a bust at all. I'm saying he will NOT be an all star major league 3rd baseman. De Rosa can help us get to the next level, then it would be smart to get an extra bat with the good rotation we have.

 

And sure Matt has had a better June but he's hit just .200 in May with a .270 slugging percentage! The jury's still out on him but I hope he picks it up.

You cant be serious. First of all, Dominguez is tearing it up after a slow start. Secondly, he isnt in low A...he is at Jupiter, a step below AA, in one of the toughest hitters leagues in minor league baseball.

 

 

 

I meant high A. Last season Dominguez hit .296 with 18 HR at Greensboro, a good year. This season he's slugging in the .300's, is K ing at a very high rate, and only has 4 homers (yes I know it's a pitcher's league).

 

I'm not saying he's a bust at all. I'm saying he will NOT be an all star major league 3rd baseman. De Rosa can help us get to the next level, then it would be smart to get an extra bat with the good rotation we have.

 

And sure Matt has had a better June but he's hit just .200 in May with a .270 slugging percentage! The jury's still out on him but I hope he picks it up.

 

Okay, but why trade Matt? Again, regardless of his current status, he's still the only potentially viable 3B we have in the system. We don't even have one at the ML-level right now. Why would you trade from the position where you have the LEAST DEPTH? We have more talent at other positions, it seems. Maybe you think that teams trading a 3B want a 3B in return? I disagree. Not to mention DeRosa plays several positions.

If Cleveland says "Dominguez or no thank you", then sure, that's something to consider. But we have other MiLB talent at positions where we could more afford to trade away some depth.

I agree w/ El Penguino that this team is not currently as talented as the '03 team. But then again, this isn't the '03 season. The Fish don't have to be better than the '03 team, they just have to win more games than the Phillies and the Mets, who both have their own problems too.

 

It really all boils down to whether or not the front office believes this team has a shot at it. If so, they will go for it and won't be afraid to trade top prospects. I see a lot of talk about not wanting to give up this guy or that guy, but you have to remember that the Marlins don't build dynasties. If they believe they have a shot this year they will put all of their eggs in that basket. I'm not saying they should or they shouldn't... I think I need to watch 'em for a few more weeks before I form my opinion on that. I'm just saying that this is an organization that works year after year toward that perfect storm, and then strikes when the iron is hot. I don't think they'll be afraid to make any move if they really believe it's the right time.

 

We'll see.

DeRosa would be great. However, both Gaby and Coghlan are free. There are other teams interested that will probably outbid us so I doubt this will be happening.

 

And WMM, you're out of your mind, as usual.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.