June 24, 200917 yr So how do the Marlins go from being so stubborn to even bench Bonifacio to consider trading for a highly sought replacement? I mean, while none of the current 25-man roster replacement options are ideal (Cantu/Coghlan at 3B), the front office seems committed to seeing Bonifacio start hitting. If they think he is mediocre enough to warrant trading for DeRosa, why don't they bench him right now?
June 24, 200917 yr Don't make this trade. I like DeRosa too but what we should do is shift Coghlan to 2B, call up Gaby, and trade Uggla for a closer. He playing a little better now so we might be able to get something better for him. Keep Lindstrom around in the pen for awhile to make adjustments or send him down. Our starting pitching is starting to be really good now and our middle relief pitchers have been decent. We need that "closer" now. If Lindstrom gets better, fine. Play him in the 8th or something. Remember Looper and Urbina? I'm seeing the same thing happening here. This can only potentially, possibly be reasonable if they are convinced that Maybin is ready to man an OF spot. Otherwise you are starting Brett Carroll everyday??? Also, I would think that most teams that might be interested in Uggla would be contenders; and contenders wouldn't trade away a good closer; so we're unlikely to trade Uggla for a closer, in my view.
June 24, 200917 yr Yes, bring up Maybin or keep Carroll. I don't know about Uggla. The Giants were interested. Who are there "closers." Maybe we can bring back Messenger.
June 24, 200917 yr So how do the Marlins go from being so stubborn to even bench Bonifacio to consider trading for a highly sought replacement? I mean, while none of the current 25-man roster replacement options are ideal (Cantu/Coghlan at 3B), the front office seems committed to seeing Bonifacio start hitting. If they think he is mediocre enough to warrant trading for DeRosa, why don't they bench him right now? Stop. Deep Breath. Look at your sig. Impose Boner over Jorge Julio. That's why.
June 24, 200917 yr Yes, bring up Maybin or keep Carroll. I don't know about Uggla. The Giants were interested. Who are there "closers." Maybe we can bring back Messenger. Isn't it a bit XXX having a Randy reliever and a Boner on the same team?
June 24, 200917 yr Yeah this makes no sense. Bonifacio should already NOT being playing baseball. The Fish have guys that could take his spot yet the Marlins continue to play him.
June 24, 200917 yr Anyone who defends bonifacio after seeing he has a .502 ops since the first week is a dummy. Gotta love that speed! He does have good speed, but his base running skills suck. I've seen him get thrown out so many times at the plate this season. That and his terrible ops. I don't understand why the guy is still up in the majors. We have one of the most indepth farm system in baseball. They should send him packing to New Orlean and bring up Gaby Sanchez use him at 1st, then either use Uggla, Cantu, Coghlan or do a trade for someone like DeRosa to play 3rd. We have so many option it is just puzzleing we still have him playing.
June 24, 200917 yr If I've learned one thing on this site from Marlins2003, it's "don't trust Ken Rosenthal."
June 24, 200917 yr Mark DeRosa is exactly the type of player this team could use. Unfortunately he fits that for many other teams to so the bid to get him will probably be pretty high. I doubt Beinfest and Co are willing to give up a whole lot for what would essentially be a rental. Uqeth Urbina for Adrian Gonzalez was a top prospect-for-rental swap similar to what a DeRosa trade would be, so don't rule it out. If the numbers work and the asking price isn't too high, don't discount the Marlins from making a move like this.
June 24, 200917 yr I think the 2003 team was more fundamentally sound for making a playoff run, especially by the point of the season when that trade was made.
June 24, 200917 yr Any upgrate is significant? This upgrade would be HUGE! DeRosa is a scrappy player who gives it his all every game. Get this done! Give up some prospects so we can compete. I would give up Matt Dominguez and a pitching prospect for him in a heartbeat. Why would you choose our top prospect at the position where we have the least depth? They can't afford to trade this guy, unless they are absolutely convinced that Gaby can be "the answer" at 3B, and even then they probably can't afford to. Some people are in love with their own players too much. I always thought Dominguez wouldn't hit enough to be a pro. I can't see Dominguez ever being a better pro than DeRosa is and I've seen Matt play alot. You don't ruin a chance at making the playoffs with a solid pitching staff by not trading an overrated prospect. Go for the playoffs! Dominguez's bat actually has alot of potential and he already plays gold glove calibre defense.
June 24, 200917 yr Yes, bring up Maybin or keep Carroll. I don't know about Uggla. The Giants were interested. Who are there "closers." Maybe we can bring back Messenger. Brian wilson is pretty nasty. I think he had a good year last yea but im not sure how hes doing this year.
June 24, 200917 yr Don't make this trade. I like DeRosa too but what we should do is shift Coghlan to 2B, call up Gaby, and trade Uggla for a closer. He playing a little better now so we might be able to get something better for him. Keep Lindstrom around in the pen for awhile to make adjustments or send him down. Our starting pitching is starting to be really good now and our middle relief pitchers have been decent. We need that "closer" now. If Lindstrom gets better, fine. Play him in the 8th or something. Remember Looper and Urbina? I'm seeing the same thing happening here. If we trade Dan Uggla for "a closer" I'm quitting.
June 24, 200917 yr Don't make this trade. I like DeRosa too but what we should do is shift Coghlan to 2B, call up Gaby, and trade Uggla for a closer. He playing a little better now so we might be able to get something better for him. Keep Lindstrom around in the pen for awhile to make adjustments or send him down. Our starting pitching is starting to be really good now and our middle relief pitchers have been decent. We need that "closer" now. If Lindstrom gets better, fine. Play him in the 8th or something. Remember Looper and Urbina? I'm seeing the same thing happening here. If we trade Dan Uggla for "a closer" I'm quitting. Good thing someone else said it.
June 24, 200917 yr If you listened to David Samson on LeBatard tonight he as much as said Gaby Sanchez is your new third baseman. When asked by a regular Marlins caller about Coghlan or Sanchez at third he by-passed the former to concentrate his remarks on Sanchez who "...is a guy who is showing he wants to play in the major leagues..." or words to that effect. Interestingly though, he also said as part of his answer to the same question that "every team in the NL East is flawed" and that if the team shows they want to be in it the FO and ownership will reciprocate, which sounded a lot like they're willing to go out and get whatever they need to reward a winning team for their success. Also, while not committing to a long term contract for Johnson, clearly his words suggested they are very open to the idea once Admin Beinfest makes the "official" request. I don't think there's any question the subject has been broached.
June 24, 200917 yr Don't make this trade. I like DeRosa too but what we should do is shift Coghlan to 2B, call up Gaby, and trade Uggla for a closer. He playing a little better now so we might be able to get something better for him. Keep Lindstrom around in the pen for awhile to make adjustments or send him down. Our starting pitching is starting to be really good now and our middle relief pitchers have been decent. We need that "closer" now. If Lindstrom gets better, fine. Play him in the 8th or something. Remember Looper and Urbina? I'm seeing the same thing happening here. If we trade Dan Uggla for "a closer" I'm quitting. Agreed.
June 24, 200917 yr If you listened to David Samson on LeBatard tonight he as much as said Gaby Sanchez is your new third baseman. When asked by a regular Marlins caller about Coghlan or Sanchez at third he by-passed the former to concentrate his remarks on Sanchez who "...is a guy who is showing he wants to play in the major leagues..." or words to that effect. Samson has nothing to do with the baseball side of the team though, so what he says can be taken with a grain of salt. Remember, this is the same guy who said that the Marlins had 0% interest in Pudge, right before Loria said we were interested in Pudge and during the reports that we were talking to Pudge.
June 25, 200917 yr I would rather have Sanchez up playing third, keeping the prospects we'd give up for 1/2 a year of DeRosa. Sanchez, likely, would be better than Emilio (spring training notwithstanding), and any kind of upgrade would be positive at this point.
June 25, 200917 yr Piss poor Boner's Defense. He reminds me of a gay latino Justin Timberlake trying to play baseball
June 25, 200917 yr I think the 2003 team was more fundamentally sound for making a playoff run, especially by the point of the season when that trade was made. While I would agree overall they were a better team with few weaknesses, comparing the '03 team to this team at THIS point of the season, there are some startling similarities: 20032009After 72 gms34W-38L0.47236W-36L0.5April14W-15L0.48314W-8L0.636May12W-16L0.4299W-20L0.31June (through 23)12W-8L0.613W-8L0.619 So, the 03 team stated slow, had a slide in May and started to pick it up in June (following the firing of Jeff Torborg). This year's version had a great start, had a major slide in May and have picked it up in June. Through the 23rd in June, both teams had essentially the same June records. To me, that's a sign that even though we have glaring holes in this team (ML-calibre 3B, closer, healthy BP), they're starting to galvanize at the right time just like the 03 squad. What I find funny is Torborg went 16-22 in the first 38 games before getting replaced by Trader Jack (who went 18-16 in the next 34 games). Freddi went 18-20 in the first 38, 18-16 the next 34. While key contributors like D-Train, Miggy, Hammer and Jacobs aren't on this team, is this year's team necessarily any different then the '06 and '08 teams that were surprise contenders until late in the season? With the Mets being decimated by injuries and the Phillies going cold as we're getting hot, I have no reason to believe we're not a 3b and some pitching help away from making a serious playoff run. This year's Miggy, Urbina and Willis could be DeRosa or Gaby, West and dare I say it- Pedro Martinez.... Commence the flaming.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.