August 3, 201115 yr Think Justin Upton type contract. Best comparison. More like an Evan Longoria contract no way in hell would stanton's agent ever allow that to happen. longoria signed his deal like a month into his major league career, so he did it for financial security but i'm sure he's kicking himself now. there is no way in hell we could sign stanton to a 9 year 44 million dollar deal.
August 3, 201115 yr Well, I typed a very large post, but I somehow managed to click back on the browser so it went away. I promise to type it up again since I have been bat signaled into this, but the end result bullet points are very easy. -Mike Stanton is two years away from arbitration, he will not get paid until 2014. He stands to make less than $1 million until February 2014. The Marlins have a ton of bargaining power as a result because if they do nothing, he is not entitled to any significant money. Huge. -The best comps are Justin Upton and Carlos Gonzalez. Upton is making $51 million years 2-8 of service time, Cargo $62 million. Cargo also has a $20 million year 9 tac'd on. -Stanton, is statistically neither of those guys so far. Cargo had a .975ish OPS before he signed his deal. Upton coming off a .900 OPS season. Mike is not there right now, but there are two months and September call ups left. -Stanton however, has much more power potential than those guys, and his future arbitration numbers would dwarf them based on Ryan Howard's numbers. -Basically, Stanton will not touch Cargo's numbers for years 2-8 based on being a year farther away from arbitration (Upton and Cargo were bought out after two years, not one, of service time) and not being statistically superior. -Inflation will drive up the comparison prices of Upton/Cargo contracts 5-10% -Goal of arbitration buy out is to secure multiple free agency years. Two is a must, three is a huge win. That is a 7 or 8 year contract. So, looking at Upton, Cargo, and inflation, I think Stanton grades out for a 7 year contract, 2012-2018, which is two free agency years, in the 7/$49-55 range. Tac on an 8th year option for an extra $20 million/$5 million buyout if you so desire. Stanton would be paid right in line with Longoria, Upton, and Gonzalez based on time of contract, service time, performance, and inflation, and Stanton would become a free agent at 29 or 30 years old, meaning he'd be eligible for "mega contract in prime," which will be very important to his agent. No agent is turning down $50 million for a 21 year old with under 2 years of service time that is market rate for other young stars. This is a win-win both ways. Mike is set up for life, the Marlins secure a potential HR champ for a rather drastic salary reduction....like If you go to arbitration even one year, Ryan Howard made $86 million his first 8 years, and has $118 million (lol) signed on his backend for the Phillies to secure those early free agency years. Our old boy Cabrera, made $75 million front 8, and has a more reasonable $86 million on the backend to secure those years. That's a lot of money that didn't necessarily needed to be spent. In the alternative, I don't think it's a bad idea to wait all through 2012 and sign him after that season. Yes, you have to pay him more, but you get another year of evaluation and you still end up with a really market friendly deal. Think higher than Cargo and a 7/$90 type deal (which would cover 2019 as well, making this really only about $20-25 million over 6 years more than signing him right now). This is still big big big market savings compared to Howard and Cabrera and their backend massive free agency deals. Signing post 2011, is a landslide savings. Signing post 2012, is still a strong "A," just not an "A+++++++++++." It's just a matter of, do you want to see another year of at bats to try and lessen the risk in doing the deal. End of the day, would I do it? Hell yea. Right now. Screw the rest of the season, right now. He's going to be worth that contract even if he's a low .800 OPS player, which he will sleepwalk to with his raw power, and his ceiling is much much much much much higher. But, I am happy as long as it gets done whether this offseason or next.
August 4, 201115 yr Think Justin Upton type contract. Best comparison. More like an Evan Longoria contract no way in hell would stanton's agent ever allow that to happen. longoria signed his deal like a month into his major league career, so he did it for financial security but i'm sure he's kicking himself now. there is no way in hell we could sign stanton to a 9 year 44 million dollar deal. As a side note as this is bothering me, Longoria does not have a $44 million contract. The RAYS have the ability to give Longoria a $40+ million contract, but Longoria only signed $17.5 million contract that has an additional three years of club options for another $27 million. That contract is insane for this reason, that it's not guaranteed at all, and for the reason that Carlos Gonzalez, who has a universally held extremely club friendly contract for the first 9 years of his career ($83 million), Longoria has HALF of that deal if the deal is even followed through (which it likely will be because he's awesome but still). The Rays hit a grand slam with Longoria's contract. It's arguably the best contract in MLB history and I don't think it will ever be repeated because it's just way to long for a player of his calibre. There comes a point where taking the safety net money hurts against your future earnings. Upton taking $50 million, even though he could arguably make double that going year to year in arbitration and free agency contracts, is a really good risk/reward for him. It's a lot of money and it's guaranteed. Longoria, if god forbid something happens to him, only gets that $17. I mean, that is enough money to live his life on no doubt, but you still have to view this as relative to the economics of baseball and he is taking a major risk not having those backend years, where "seriously" money starts coming in, guaranteed. He will have done "alright" compared to his piers as long as he doesn't get hurt and all the options are picked up, but that's a big big risk. All agents are going to point to Longoria and say to top 20 overall prospects, if they don't guarantee you at least one of the free agency years, play out 1-2 years and let's see if you become the superstar. With even a slight showing you will reach your potential, you probably turn that non-guaranteed $17/40+ deal, into a more lucrative all guaranteed deal. Big deal with this. There is no way in hell Stanton signs a Longoria type deal based on the guarantees and years (that 9th year of service time/third free agency year is the real killer), but, that doesn't mean the overall sum over 7 year isn't in the ball park. Mike would sign a 7 year extension as long as the first number in the deal is "5." I really like this template: 2012 - $.5 2013 - $1 2014 - $5 2015 - $7.5 2016 - $10 2017 - $12 2018 - $15 2019 - $20 club option / $ 4 buyout 7/$55 or 8/$71. Even better if that 7th year is an option, which I'd guess would be the only major fight with this deal as the Marlins would want a cheap cheap buy out, and Agent would want to be guaranteed. Regardless, at this point, that "risk/reward" factor for Mike goes out of the window because free agency years are guaranteed, this is serious coin, and much more than a guaranteed $17 million. Justin Upton is $52 these same years (remember, signed contract two years ago), Carlos Gonzalez is $83 (signed last year). It's rather a perfect contract for both sides and Stanton is a free agent 29/30. Would be so awesome. I hope that kind of answers the generalized question. This is how I view the Marlins situation. It's like watching Cabrera in 2004 and 2005. I just hope the front office is much smarter and signs the guy this time.
August 4, 201115 yr I dont think you get it. Signing Stanton long term won't change his salary for 2012 and 2013. It simply allows you to get his 2014-2017 at steep discounts. So you think he will sign a long term contract and still work for the minimum MLB salary for the next couple years?? Guess you didn't read the entire post. There is no need to do anything with him right now. He is currently under contract. And will be for quite some time. This kind of talk is only going to be worthwhile when he becomes arb eligible. THEN we may be able to save some $$$. Right now it's just spending money that needs to be spent elsewhere to ensure the general public keeps an interest in the team. This is an event oriented fan base. When it stays the place to be seen, the public will come.
August 4, 201115 yr It's like watching Cabrera in 2004 and 2005. I just hope the front office is much smarter and signs the guy this time. Are you saying that they weren't wise to deal Cabrera? "Much smarter" and "this time" sort of implies that. They couldn't sign Cabrera long-term absent a new stadium. Any deal would have been 1/2 or more of total payroll in '06-'09, with no ability to add supporting players without bankrupting Loria. If you're saying that they were smart to deal Cabrera and will be even smarter to sign Stanton, now that they will have a serious revenue stream to spend, I totally agree. I also agree that it doesn't matter whether it happens after this year or next year, it's a just a function of how comfortable they are that he will meet expectations.
August 4, 201115 yr I dont think you get it. Signing Stanton long term won't change his salary for 2012 and 2013. It simply allows you to get his 2014-2017 at steep discounts. So you think he will sign a long term contract and still work for the minimum MLB salary for the next couple years?? Guess you didn't read the entire post. There is no need to do anything with him right now. He is currently under contract. And will be for quite some time. This kind of talk is only going to be worthwhile when he becomes arb eligible. THEN we may be able to save some $$$. Right now it's just spending money that needs to be spent elsewhere to ensure the general public keeps an interest in the team. This is an event oriented fan base. When it stays the place to be seen, the public will come. So you've never looked into the details of long term contracts signed by pre-arbitration players, have you? They still get paid ~500k for those years. Look for yourself honey bunny
August 4, 201115 yr It's like watching Cabrera in 2004 and 2005. I just hope the front office is much smarter and signs the guy this time. Are you saying that they weren't wise to deal Cabrera? "Much smarter" and "this time" sort of implies that. They couldn't sign Cabrera long-term absent a new stadium. Any deal would have been 1/2 or more of total payroll in '06-'09, with no ability to add supporting players without bankrupting Loria. If you're saying that they were smart to deal Cabrera and will be even smarter to sign Stanton, now that they will have a serious revenue stream to spend, I totally agree. I also agree that it doesn't matter whether it happens after this year or next year, it's a just a function of how comfortable they are that he will meet expectations. They might have been able to afford Cabrera if they signed him long term. What Cabrera made w/o signing him '07: 7.4m (
August 4, 201115 yr Bottom line, honey bunny. He won't be signed long term this off seaon no matter how many sports board, arm chair GM/owners scream that they know better than the folks actually running this org. Maybe not even after next season. Guys like Cabs and Uggla were traded because it was well known they weren't going to sign here, for whatever their personal reasons. Guys like Hanley and JJ signed here because they wanted to be here. Same will go for the living god. This thread and future ones won't change that.
August 4, 201115 yr Bottom line, honey bunny. He won't be signed long term this off seaon no matter how many sports board, arm chair GM/owners scream that they know better than the folks actually running this org. Maybe not even after next season. Guys like Cabs and Uggla were traded because it was well known they weren't going to sign here, for whatever their personal reasons. Guys like Hanley and JJ signed here because they wanted to be here. Same will go for the living god. This thread and future ones won't change that. Whether he signs or not, I still don't think you understand how this works.
August 4, 201115 yr That's SO BroncoBob! Get called out on ignorant statements, change your argument, and insult everybody! Never change, kid
August 4, 201115 yr We need to just buy Stanton for life. Set him up with a house car Loria's daughter the works. btw Erick is a boss - knows his sh*t.
August 4, 201115 yr It's like watching Cabrera in 2004 and 2005. I just hope the front office is much smarter and signs the guy this time. Are you saying that they weren't wise to deal Cabrera? "Much smarter" and "this time" sort of implies that. They couldn't sign Cabrera long-term absent a new stadium. Any deal would have been 1/2 or more of total payroll in '06-'09, with no ability to add supporting players without bankrupting Loria. If you're saying that they were smart to deal Cabrera and will be even smarter to sign Stanton, now that they will have a serious revenue stream to spend, I totally agree. Look at the years 2004 (after one year of service time) and 2005 (after two years). These were years before they traded Cabrera. Comment has nothing to do with the trade. If you look at comparable arbitration buyouts during those years for young star players, the best comp was Hank Blalock who (literally) signed a 5/$15 deal with an option on the back. Cabrera was a bit younger and had a higher ceiling, but it was pretty realistic to think at the time that the Marlins could have signed Miguel Cabrera from 2005-2010 for around $25-30 million. They didn't, he went to arbitration, and the rest is history. The point was, you cannot let players do that as they become astronomically more expensive. Mike Stanton in 2011, is Miguel Cabrera in 2004. You know he is going to be awesome. You need to invest in him now (or next off season which as stated above is equally fine), or you will get destroyed in leverage in arbitration and free agency negotiations. It's the biggest mistake in franchise history - not buying out Cabrera's arbitration after 2004 or 2005. They were stupid not to do it, even with their payroll concerns. They could have easily done it and never had to make that trade (even though it was the right decision after the fact. They should have never got to the point where they had to trade him). Stupid Stupid Stupid.
August 4, 201115 yr I dont think you get it. Signing Stanton long term won't change his salary for 2012 and 2013. It simply allows you to get his 2014-2017 at steep discounts. So you think he will sign a long term contract and still work for the minimum MLB salary for the next couple years?? Guess you didn't read the entire post. There is no need to do anything with him right now. He is currently under contract. And will be for quite some time. This kind of talk is only going to be worthwhile when he becomes arb eligible. THEN we may be able to save some $$$. Right now it's just spending money that needs to be spent elsewhere to ensure the general public keeps an interest in the team. This is an event oriented fan base. When it stays the place to be seen, the public will come. I need you to understand why you are wrong. It has absolutely nothing to do with what his salary would be the next two years, which yes, all he is due is the minimum tender by the Marlins. It is about how much guaranteed money Stanton could lock up past that. There is a value to Stanton to guarantee future salaries when he is so young and so far away from being eligible for arbitration. This is why players like Stanton sign these contracts - the unknown. A lot could happen, he could regress, he could get injured. By "giving up" hypothetical money he could make in arbitration, he gets a lower amount guaranteed. That's why it's a win for Mike, guaranteed (did I say the word guaranteed yet?) money when he is not due any guaranteed money, and it's a win for the Marlins as Stanton becomes a cost-effective investment payroll wise where you hope he blossoms into the superstar we all want. And if he doesn't, he's still probably worth that contract annually as an average position player. You know how much money Justin Upton made in the first year of his $51.25 million dollar contract? $500,000. So yes, I think Mike Stanton would work for near the minimum MLB salary the next two seasons, because as soon as that money is guaranteed, it doesn't matter. He's going to get it, it's only a question of time. The Marlins don't need to front load it (which would be an interesting idea, but need not be discussed). And, you are right the Marlins don't have to do anything right NOW, but if they don't do it before the 2013 season, Stanton is going to be on the Ryan Howard track of paydays and the Marlins will not be in the position to retain his free agency years for any sort of early signing discount. They cannot let him get close to arbitration like Hanley or into arbitration like Cabrera. Stanton is a different beast. Chicks dig the long balls.
August 4, 201115 yr Look at the years 2004 (after one year of service time) (...) it was pretty realistic to think at the time that the Marlins could have signed Miguel Cabrera from 2005-2010 for around $25-30 million. 6 years for $25-30 million? Sure, but if you're Cabrera or his agent you would think that he was likely to get .4, .4, 6, 8, 10, 20+, and that's 45+ million for 6 years. Cabrera thought he was a super-human, not an occasional drunk and merely idiotic mortal who tells people that he will come back and kill them when he's sideways. No way he signs that deal, and he didn't, although it was probably offered and rejected while he was sober. It's the biggest mistake in franchise history - not buying out Cabrera's arbitration after 2004 or 2005. Loria wasn't about to bankrupt the franchise over one player. A wise move.
August 4, 201115 yr Bottom line, honey bunny. I never get tired of those elementary school comebacks! "I know you are but what am I?"
August 4, 201115 yr Look at the years 2004 (after one year of service time) (...) it was pretty realistic to think at the time that the Marlins could have signed Miguel Cabrera from 2005-2010 for around $25-30 million. 6 years for $25-30 million? Sure, but if you're Cabrera or his agent you would think that he was likely to get .4, .4, 6, 8, 10, 20+, and that's 45+ million for 6 years. Cabrera thought he was a super-human, not an occasional drunk and merely idiotic mortal who tells people that he will come back and kill them when he's sideways. No way he signs that deal, and he didn't, although it was probably offered and rejected while he was sober. It's the biggest mistake in franchise history - not buying out Cabrera's arbitration after 2004 or 2005. Loria wasn't about to bankrupt the franchise over one player. A wise move. How would such a move have put the franchise in bankrupt? I'm pretty sure that everyone would have been very happy around here since Cabrera was well on his way to stardom. It's like some of you aren't understanding that offering the deal now is a cost-efficent move for the long-term. I would actually be surprised if the Marlins front office isn't already talking about this for Stanton.
August 4, 201115 yr Look at the years 2004 (after one year of service time) (...) it was pretty realistic to think at the time that the Marlins could have signed Miguel Cabrera from 2005-2010 for around $25-30 million. 6 years for $25-30 million? Sure, but if you're Cabrera or his agent you would think that he was likely to get .4, .4, 6, 8, 10, 20+, and that's 45+ million for 6 years. Cabrera thought he was a super-human, not an occasional drunk and merely idiotic mortal who tells people that he will come back and kill them when he's sideways. No way he signs that deal, and he didn't, although it was probably offered and rejected while he was sober. It's the biggest mistake in franchise history - not buying out Cabrera's arbitration after 2004 or 2005. Loria wasn't about to bankrupt the franchise over one player. A wise move. You don't seem to be getting this because you are confusing topics. As to your later comment first, buying out Cabrera after 1 or 2 years of service time, 2004-2005, is astronomically a different situation than "bankrupting the franchise," which is what the Tigers did after 4 years of service time in 2008 and giving him a $152 million contract that covered six free agency years. Of course the Marlins could not afford a deal like that, or even a $12 million arbitration tender, so they were forced to trade him. The problem is the organization could have prevented the situation from happening had they bought him out. If they had bought him out in 2004 or 2005, after 1 or 2 years of service time, and three years before his mega contract, the organization avoids the entire problem with Cabrera. If they buy him out in 2004/2005, the Marlins never have to trade him because he is incredibly affordable as the comps in 2004/2005 show, like Hank Blalock . This is not criticizing the eventual Cabrera trade directly, which wasn't necessarily a bad trade based on the limited circumstances and opportunities they had. But you can criticize for putting themselves into the corner in the first place. This is criticizing the practice of the front office in not prospectively seeing Cabrera's talent and locking it down at a market friendly rate. i.e., the same situation concerning Mike Stanton right now. You are confused. Different issues entirely. Your hypothetical salary calculations of $45 million is also inaccurate, as first, the years are not guaranteed (this is a big deal!!!!) if he is going through arbitration so leaving money on the table in a buyout which is guaranteed has its value (which is lower annual contract prices!!!), and two, the Marlins would not have retained Cabrera for that "20" you speak of, as that is a free agency year and the Marlins could not tender him for a single year in free agency. As I said, Hank Blalock, who was considered a star young 3B and was having very good seasons, got a 5/$15 deal (with an option tac'd on at the end) at the same amount of service time as Cabrera. Remember, these contracts are over 7 years old and cannot be compared to current baseball contracts that suffered incredible inflation 2006-2011. Miguel Cabrera, signs a 6-7 year contract for $30 million in 2004 compared to all comparisons (it would have been the largest contract ever for a player his age/service time at the time of this deal). I am also over estimating that $30 drastically. It could have easily been $5-10 million less. It's not arguable. It's just what the Market was for baseball contracts in 04/05. The Marlins never offered it (their PR front office philosophy the whole time was making players "play for pay" was smarter), and thus were forced to trade him out of their own stupidity. Thankfully, they have gotten a bit smarter lately (Hanley, Johnson), so this appears to be changing.
August 4, 201115 yr People who didn't watch baseball in the 60s and 70s will never be right about anything.
August 6, 201115 yr What are they crazy??? THEY'LL BANKRUPT THE FRANCHISE AND WE'LL HAVE NO MONEY WHEN WE GET TO THE NEW PARK!! YOU MANIACS!
August 6, 201115 yr BEWARE! See: Alfonso Soriano + Jayson Werth (What do we do now types?) Huge contract problems. I'm not saying Stanton will regress that much, hell I don't think he will regress at all and if you want me to be really honest if he can get his BA walks up and his K's down he is Hall Of Fame bound (at this rate) especially considering how young he is (600 Club?). His stock is definitely high just make sure you know what you're getting. His numbers from last year and now this year his first full year are very similar and it has been seen he has done better in a few peripherals this year as compared to last. ----- Besides that I have never delved too much into contract specs but this is interesting stuff, I've enjoyed reading this second page.
August 6, 201115 yr Soriano was 30 and Werth was 31 when they signed their contracts. Stanton will be 22. He will also sign for about $70 million less overall than they did. So not comparable.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.