Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

RANT: Get off Red's back

Featured Replies

Its a move nearly every manager makes once the season is a couple weeks old, its a move I say no manager makes on Day 1.

 

​I'd put $5 that says Maddon would make that move.

 

 

  • Author
Its a move nearly every manager makes once the season is a couple weeks old, its a move I say no manager makes on Day 1.

 

​I'd put $5 that says Maddon would make that move.

 

​Too bad we will never know

 

 

Its a movearrow-10x10.png nearly every manager makes once the seasonarrow-10x10.png is a couple weeks old, its a move I say no manager makes on Day 1.

 

​I'd put $5 that says Maddon would make that move.

 

​Too bad we will never know

 

​

 

He would have. Certain managers don't care about starter labels and player salaries; they just play matchups.

 

Maddon didn't even start his starting catcher in Game 1 because he wanted his backup to catch Jon Lester.

 

If Maddon were managing the team, Salty would probably never play against LHP since he's never been good against them even in his one good year.

 

I don't mind Redmond and I do agree that he gets criticized too much at times, but he tends to disregard platoon splits a lot. He's an old-school, show me your grit and character type of guy who doesn't care much for advanced statistics as is the case with the organization as a whole. It is what it is.

 

 

Salty's one good season was thoroughly unsustainable and even the slightest glimpse at his numbers beyond batting average would have told the Marlins that. .372 BABIP for a guy who runs like he's in quicksand? Never going to repeat that. Anyone with a slight analytic mind knew that Salty would regress and that it would be ugly. Even when he was "good", he struck out in 30% of his plate appearances and only walked in 9% of them.

 

 

I know this topic is about this year, but last year Red made a lot of questionable moves or lack of. Maybe the Marlins should install a rocking chair in the dugout for McKeon to give some advice to Red when in time of need.

 

But it all seriousness, no way he would've pinched hit for Salty, he's not ruining the team chemistry within the first few days.

 

and I did ask if TK was coming back out for the 7th in the game thread, but it's damn if you do damn if you don't for Red, just the nature of the sport and media.

 

 

from the 5th inning on he was getting hit. I think he should have taken him out I said it before the home run

 

 

Actually if Red had pinch hit for salty and the game ends up being tied after a double play, I don't think anyone blasts him. Tie game, and even casuals know salty is garbage. It's not like the situation came up in the 3rd inning.

 

​Incorrect IMO. Pinch hitting for your starting catcher in his first opportunity of the year is the wrong move. If he is not going to be allowed to hit there, stop starting him.

 

​

 

Red is proably being forced to start Salty tbh, due to his terrible contract.

 

 

If you PH for Salty in that spot, there is no logical reason he is the starting catcher. And he probably shouldn't be the starting catcher but he IS.

 

​I think that's terrible logic.

 

I'm not really into finance or economics so I don't really recall the exact term, but you can't judge something's value based off it's original perceived value. If it's netting you a loss, you cut your losses before you lose more.

 

You use your players the best way to get a win. Not PH a guy with a career .597 OPS against LHP with a career .868 OPS (Baker) late in a close game with a huge scoring opportunity is terrible decision making. Anything about "starting catcher" is fluff and doesn't mean anything when it comes to wins. Runs do.

 

 

​Incorrect IMO. Pinch hitting for your starting catcher in his first opportunity of the year is the wrong move. If he is not going to be allowed to hit there, stop starting him.

 

​I mean, he should be a platoon starter to begin with. He was with every team before coming here.

 

 

It sends a horrible message also to Salty, the fanbase, his teammates. Some of you really think this is a video game you can manage only with stats and disregard for these human beings.

 

​Did that happen to John Baker?

 

 

Every game counts the same and these are players with long track records to tell you just how to expect them to perform.

 

The fact Salty is the de-facto starter and not in a platoon is just silly.

 

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.