Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

The remaining pitchers

Featured Replies

I think Hill or Nova would make this offseason a success in my eyes. Not one of those guys is Jose Fernandez I know but I think many of us were pretty sure we were getting nothing better than CJ Wilson or Justin Masterson. Getting Volquez and one of the above two would be significant I think.

 

 

Marlins should stay away from Nova. 64 decent innings down the stretch with the pirates doesn't make him good. Saw a lot of the Yankee games this season were he was starting. Terrible stuff. Especially the fastball. Mediocre K/9 rate. Another Tom Koehler at best. Would hate to see the Marlins buy high on him and be stuck with his contract for years to come.

 

 

I think Hammel would be solid for us. Probably looking for something very similar to what Volquez just got.

 

 

I don't want any of those remaining starters. 

 

You're legitimately ok with relying on Phelps as the 5th starter?

 

 

You're legitimately ok with relying on Phelps as the 5th starter?

 

I don't think I would mind Phelps starting if we could add another bullpen arm (Jensen?).  

 

 

I love Phelps and what he provides for us. But we've seen year after year that you can never have enough depth. I don't want to rely on Phelps. I want Phelps to be a backup option along with Nicolino, Urena, Esch and whoever else. I want something more significant before Phelps. Opening the season with Phelps in the rotation is probably not the best scenario.

 

 

You're legitimately ok with relying on Phelps as the 5th starter?

 

I'm more okay with it than overpaying another starter. Ivan Nova might get Wei-Yin Chen money for 60 good innings. I don't believe in spending in free agency out of necessity.

 

 

  • Author
why? if he maintains the velo boost he could be a very effective starter as his secondary stuff has always been solid

 

Cause I'd rather have a guy like Rich Hill in the rotation and Phelps in the pen, better team overall.

 

 

Cause I'd rather have a guy like Rich Hill in the rotation and Phelps in the pen, better team overall.

 

I don't agree although I'd rather have both starting. I think the Phelps velo boost (and his injuries before 2016) are being very understated/underrated

 

 

I would actually be more interested in a guy we were rumored to have interest in before...Travis Wood. I think he'd be good for depth. Has experience starting and is very good out of the pen. We could even get creative and do what the Indians did. Limit our starters to two times through the order and use Phelps/Wood for multiple innings out of the pen. 

 

I'm gonna text Mike Hill this now to let him know. 

 

 

***Breaking News!!!*** knowing that the Marlins fans want a Hill pitching for them, Mike Hill has signed himself to be the team ace with a 10yr/$200M deal. The deal includes a no trade clause.

 

 

If we couldn't trade for an ace,than we have no choice and need to go all in to sign HILL !!!

 

This logic is how teams find themselves in last place.  You don't throw money at an unsure thing if a sure thing falls through and expect the same result.  Hill does not deserve Ace money but I am afraid he will get Ace money.  I just hope it isn't from the Marlins

 

 

This logic is how teams find themselves in last place.  You don't throw money at an unsure thing if a sure thing falls through and expect the same result.  Hill does not deserve Ace money and I am afraid he will get Ace money.  I just hope it isn't from the Marlins

 

id have no problem with a 2/40 deal for Hill fom the marlins

 

 

id have no problem with a 2/40 deal for Hill fom the marlins

Yeah but you gotta figure someone is gonna pay way more and he'll go there.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.