Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Done with this team thread

Featured Replies

4 hours ago, EricWiener1970 said:

Why are the Marlins showing signs of life? This could totally make for a second disappointment this year

their pitching finally showed up to be what it was expected to be.  their offense is still a landfill fire though and they traded their best offensive piece so i don't think they're gonna do much when they struggle to get to 3 runs a game.  i think your initial disappointment will be plenty this year.

I had no idea what our record was, but based on the score updates, I know we're winning a bit more recently....and still are 17 under lol..    -79 run diff haha.

 

looking elsewhere around the league - the Royals - who...you know.....actually made moves/signings in an attempt to be competitive, are 13 over at 34-21.  Amazing what actually trying does...

Interestingly, from May 5th to now (day after Arraez was traded to pick a random inflection point), we're just 1 under .500, which is around what I predicted overall for the season.  Remove the atrocious start from pitching injuries (who could've seen us needing pitching help, aside from everyone but the FO?), and we're and average team that keeps in it because of pitching and severely needs offense (same story the last 6 years lol)

Rosenthal says Luzardo is 100 percent a goner.

Seriously. F this team.

42 minutes ago, Valid said:

Rosenthal says Luzardo is 100 percent a goner.

Seriously. F this team.

At least Max Meyer can step right in to replace.....oh nevermind.

5 hours ago, Das Texan said:

I mean....

This is basically been KNOWN since February*

 

 

 

*at least

No. It hasn't. That was literally speculation. Saying "yeah he might get traded" is different from "he's definitely gone."

But right on track as always, Das.

Edited by Valid

2 hours ago, Valid said:

No. It hasn't. That was literally speculation. Saying "yeah he might get traded" is different from "he's definitely gone."

But right on track as always, Das.

It has been known since Bendix took over that Luzardo was getting moved, especially when this team did literally nothing to improve the team all winter, preaching this gotta build the farm system because Bruce Sherman has no intention of spending.  

Once Arraez was moved nothing more needed to actually be said.

I said the clock was ticking on Bruce Sherman to show he was serious about winning, he failed miserably.

If there is any guy you sign long term...its a literally home grown talent from Miami.

Its actually still speculation honestly, since Bendix or Sherman havent come out and say 'Jesus Luzardo is being traded'  

8 hours ago, Das Texan said:

It has been known since Bendix took over that Luzardo was getting moved, especially when this team did literally nothing to improve the team all winter, preaching this gotta build the farm system because Bruce Sherman has no intention of spending.  

Once Arraez was moved nothing more needed to actually be said.

I said the clock was ticking on Bruce Sherman to show he was serious about winning, he failed miserably.

If there is any guy you sign long term...its a literally home grown talent from Miami.

Its actually still speculation honestly, since Bendix or Sherman havent come out and say 'Jesus Luzardo is being traded'  

season 5 richard GIF

 

Shut the FUCK up, Das!

22 hours ago, Valid said:

Rosenthal says Luzardo is 100 percent a goner.

Seriously. F this team.

 

14 hours ago, Valid said:

No. It hasn't. That was literally speculation. Saying "yeah he might get traded" is different from "he's definitely gone."

But right on track as always, Das.

 

1) Until a trade is announced, "he's definitely gone" is also "literally speculation".

2) It's been pretty evident with them doing nothing in the offseason, and a new regime with a new vision led by someone from the "always trade everyone" Rays, and a horribly cheap owner, that trades (and unpopular ones at that) would be incoming.

3) with us doing so badly and having literally nothing to come up and help this or next year bat wise, Luzardo is unfortunately our biggest trade chip.  (Scott is our only 99.9% "to be traded" guy since he's a FA after the season, and we're surely not signing him....in fact, it'd be negligence to NOT trade Scott)

4) the big question is potential return of trade offers, and whether Bendix accepts a package of guys that are years away, or if he gets back immediate MLB or MLB-ready players if a trade is made.

11 minutes ago, TaiwanMarlins said:

Bendix is still very young so it's ok for him to have a 30 year rebuilding plan. 

 

Us when the rebuild is finally complete:

Animated GIF

1 hour ago, rmc523 said:

 

4) the big question is potential return of trade offers, and whether Bendix accepts a package of guys that are years away, or if he gets back immediate MLB or MLB-ready players if a trade is made.

he won't get back MLB players because they cost more - and he'll be tearing down the team anyway so as we're "not ready" (because of their own inaction)

23 hours ago, rmc523 said:

 

 

1) Until a trade is announced, "he's definitely gone" is also "literally speculation".

2) It's been pretty evident with them doing nothing in the offseason, and a new regime with a new vision led by someone from the "always trade everyone" Rays, and a horribly cheap owner, that trades (and unpopular ones at that) would be incoming.

3) with us doing so badly and having literally nothing to come up and help this or next year bat wise, Luzardo is unfortunately our biggest trade chip.  (Scott is our only 99.9% "to be traded" guy since he's a FA after the season, and we're surely not signing him....in fact, it'd be negligence to NOT trade Scott)

4) the big question is potential return of trade offers, and whether Bendix accepts a package of guys that are years away, or if he gets back immediate MLB or MLB-ready players if a trade is made.

To me, hearing "he's definitely gone" from someone like Rosenthal is MUCH more significant than "the Marlins might trade this guy."

Let's put it this way: the Marlins are 15-13 over their last 28 games. If they were playing solid baseball like this all year along, I don't think there is any chance that Arraez would have been dealt (at least not in early May, anyway), and I also don't think they would be trying to move Luzardo.

I am one of the most optimistic people here and it really just feels hopeless.

Trading Luzardo would yield one of two outcomes.

1.) They trade him for a bag of balls;

2.) They actually get some good prospects for him, and then repeat the cycle again in five years once those prospects hit the bigs and become good.

Edited by Valid

1 hour ago, Valid said:

2.) They actually get some good prospects for him, and then repeat the cycle again in five years once those prospects hit the bigs and become good.

even if they are good in 5 years, will those prospects even be called up?  I mean, Max Meyer is literally just pitching away in the minors for no reason other than saving $$$. He doesn't really have anything left to prove in the minors so continuing to stash him there and have him compete against inferior talent only stunts his growth.  But i guess that'll make him cheaper so yay?

  • Author
3 hours ago, Valid said:

To me, hearing "he's definitely gone" from someone like Rosenthal is MUCH more significant than "the Marlins might trade this guy."

Let's put it this way: the Marlins are 15-13 over their last 28 games. If they were playing solid baseball like this all year along, I don't think there is any chance that Arraez would have been dealt (at least not in early May, anyway), and I also don't think they would be trying to move Luzardo.

I am one of the most optimistic people here and it really just feels hopeless.

Trading Luzardo would yield one of two outcomes.

1.) They trade him for a bag of balls;

2.) They actually get some good prospects for him, and then repeat the cycle again in five years once those prospects hit the bigs and become good.

Bendix is here to build his own team and get rid of the Ng and before guts. Only reason lizard and arraez weren’t traded off season is because of the optics coming off a playoff year. 

I just realized something pretty sad - the only time the Marlins have won more than 90 games was 1997 and 2003. Their lack of success is astounding. 

2 hours ago, canada-marlin24 said:

I just realized something pretty sad - the only time the Marlins have won more than 90 games was 1997 and 2003. Their lack of success is astounding. 

And what did they do with those 90+ wins?

On 6/2/2024 at 11:08 AM, Michael said:

And what did they do with those 90+ wins?

 Yes obviously but it’s those two and nothing else. 

Edited by canada-marlin24

10 hours ago, canada-marlin24 said:

He’s obviously but it’s those two and nothing else. 

He's obviously?

HE'S OBVIOUSLY?!

 

I AM SO OFFENDED RIGHT NOW

9 minutes ago, Michael said:

He's obviously?

HE'S OBVIOUSLY?!

 

I AM SO OFFENDED RIGHT NOW

Shut the fuck up, Das 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.