Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

Roster Moves Thread - 2025 Season

Featured Replies

24 minutes ago, TaiwanMarlins said:

I don't get DFA'ing Simon. We could have optioned him if you want to send him down. He has terrific plate discipline and great speed. I do think he will adjust to big league pitching eventually and I don't think the Marlins are in a position where they cannot afford to wait for that.

As for the two guys they added. Hernandez and Winkler. It appears that they are high exit velo guys, so maybe they are hoping to replicate Kyle Stowers to a lesser degree. Still don't know why Troy Johnston keeps getting overlooked. Reminds me of Mark Canha who we just let slip away before he had a reasonably productive career that could have helped us at the time.

20 minutes ago, FishFan95 said:

I don't get DFA'ing Simon. We could have optioned him if you want to send him down. He has terrific plate discipline and great speed. I do think he will adjust to big league pitching eventually and I don't think the Marlins are in a position where they cannot afford to wait for that.

He'll likely clear waivers anyway right? Should remain in organization.

5 minutes ago, Admin said:

He'll likely clear waivers anyway right? Should remain in organization.

I think he gets claimed. But maybe I'm wrong.

I'm not a student of the 40-man roster rules but by using the dfa, it removes them from the 40-man roster and opens up for the new guys, right?

Winkler has been good at Jacksonville. He deserves a shot.

Dane should be playing every day at center.

They needed another OF so it was Heriberto.

Simon has a good bat but his defense (ever before his meltdown game) is atrocious.

Neither guy is expected to be a big part of the future and can be optioned once Cronin and Eury are ready.

On 5/29/2025 at 5:32 PM, pollythewog said:

What’s your ideal 2026 opening day roster looking like?

C- Mack, Hicks

1B/DH- Agustin, DDLS

2B- X

3B- Norby

SS- Otto (or trade)

UTIL- Sanoja

LF- Stowers

CF- Dane (trade or prospect)

RF- Conine

Bench- (trade or prospect)

SP- Weathers, Eury, Braxton, Mazur, Snelling

RP- Bender, Henriquez, Bellozo, Nardi, Belgrave (Dax or McJonny Cambley or FA)

CP- Max Meyer, Ekness

Spring Training Decisions- Pauley, Acosta, Mesa, Marsee, Pintar, Dax, McCambley, Soriano, Arias

TRADED- Sandy, Fortes, Eddy, Jesus, Bachar, Faucher.

Trade targets- CF (Kevin Alcantara, Zyhir Hope, Rayner Arias, Jonny Farmelo)

SP (Kyle Harrison, Jackson Ferris, Ryan Sloan)

SS (Maui Ahuna, Cole Young, Edwin Arroyo, Felnin Celestin-longshot, Arjun Nimmala-longshot)

Obviously whoever we got back in trades would affect the mix and there are very few, if any, free agents I would go after.

I would go as young as possible, explain to the fan base that we have a 5-year plan and are committed to playing these guys every day and sticking with them and that our goals are to win 70 games in 2026, be .500 in 2027, contending for a wild card in 2028, and championship contenders in 2029 and 2030. I would also flip Stowers after 3 years, Conine if he actually has value, and Dane as well.

Our marketing slogan would be "The Kids are ALL right" and we would be completely transparent with what we are doing. We would commit above average league resources to international signings, drafting, and scouting and our analytics department would be second to none.

  • Author
On 5/30/2025 at 9:03 PM, TheMarlinsProject said:

C- Mack, Hicks

1B/DH- Agustin, DDLS

2B- X

3B- Norby

SS- Otto (or trade)

UTIL- Sanoja

LF- Stowers

CF- Dane (trade or prospect)

RF- Conine

Bench- (trade or prospect)

SP- Weathers, Eury, Braxton, Mazur, Snelling

RP- Bender, Henriquez, Bellozo, Nardi, Belgrave (Dax or McJonny Cambley or FA)

CP- Max Meyer, Ekness

Spring Training Decisions- Pauley, Acosta, Mesa, Marsee, Pintar, Dax, McCambley, Soriano, Arias

TRADED- Sandy, Fortes, Eddy, Jesus, Bachar, Faucher.

Trade targets- CF (Kevin Alcantara, Zyhir Hope, Rayner Arias, Jonny Farmelo)

SP (Kyle Harrison, Jackson Ferris, Ryan Sloan)

SS (Maui Ahuna, Cole Young, Edwin Arroyo, Felnin Celestin-longshot, Arjun Nimmala-longshot)

Obviously whoever we got back in trades would affect the mix and there are very few, if any, free agents I would go after.

I would go as young as possible, explain to the fan base that we have a 5-year plan and are committed to playing these guys every day and sticking with them and that our goals are to win 70 games in 2026, be .500 in 2027, contending for a wild card in 2028, and championship contenders in 2029 and 2030. I would also flip Stowers after 3 years, Conine if he actually has value, and Dane as well.

Our marketing slogan would be "The Kids are ALL right" and we would be completely transparent with what we are doing. We would commit above average league resources to international signings, drafting, and scouting and our analytics department would be second to none.

I commend you for having blind faith but….

lol aka start another rebuild during the current rebuild? Already trading the current crop of rebuilders? Aka perpetual rebuild and push the can down the road forever.

“Just wait, it’ll happen in 20XX!!!!!”

-Marlins FO in 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024, 2025, 2026, 2027, 2028, 2029, 2030…….

2 hours ago, rmc523 said:

I commend you for having blind faith but….

lol aka start another rebuild during the current rebuild? Already trading the current crop of rebuilders? Aka perpetual rebuild and push the can down the road forever.

“Just wait, it’ll happen in 20XX!!!!!”

-Marlins FO in 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024, 2025, 2026, 2027, 2028, 2029, 2030…….

There is no new rebuild. It's a continuous upward trajectory of what we already started. We are always going to trade older, declining assets because that is how you succeed (Sandy, Fortes, Faucher, Bachar). None of them are going to get any better and you could argue they are all negative assets in the present.

The other two (Cabrera, Sanchez) I would trade because they are both lazy, low baseball IQ players who will never fulfill their potential (a la Jazz). May as well compile assets if some other team is dumb enough to gamble on their potential.

Keep the core around for a couple of years. They are young and are likely only going to get better. Where you see a rebuild in that I am puzzled by.

9 hours ago, TheMarlinsProject said:

There is no new rebuild. It's a continuous upward trajectory of what we already started. We are always going to trade players making more than the league minimum because that is how you succeed at saving Bruce money (Sandy, Fortes, Faucher, Bachar). None of them are going to get any prospects in return so why not trade them for cash?

Keep the pre-arb around for a couple of years. They are young and are likely only going to get better. Where you see a rebuild in that I am puzzled by.

FTFY

  • Author
On 6/1/2025 at 12:36 AM, TheMarlinsProject said:

There is no new rebuild. It's a continuous upward trajectory of what we already started. We are always going to trade older, declining assets because that is how you succeed (Sandy, Fortes, Faucher, Bachar). None of them are going to get any better and you could argue they are all negative assets in the present.

The other two (Cabrera, Sanchez) I would trade because they are both lazy, low baseball IQ players who will never fulfill their potential (a la Jazz). May as well compile assets if some other team is dumb enough to gamble on their potential.

Keep the core around for a couple of years. They are young and are likely only going to get better. Where you see a rebuild in that I am puzzled by.

You're already trading guys like Stowers and Conine, who are part of the current rebuild.

I don't care about Cabrera and Sanchez....i'm over them.

1 hour ago, rmc523 said:

You're already trading guys like Stowers and Conine, who are part of the current rebuild.

I don't care about Cabrera and Sanchez....i'm over them.

No, I said I would trade Stowers and Conine in three years. They are both very old for rookies/prospects. I would definitely keep Stowers through his peak years (ages 27, 28,29) and then if he is still an asset trade him. If Stowers is 23, we keep him 6 or 7 years. Conine is really not more than a replacement level player today or in the future, to pretend he is not is malpractice. I say that loving the guy and his effort but let's be realistic.

4 hours ago, TheMarlinsProject said:

Conine is really not more than a replacement level player today or in the future, to pretend he is not is malpractice. I say that loving the guy and his effort but let's be realistic.

Pro rated to 500 ABs Conine has an fWAR of 1.7 and an rWAR of 3.0. A WAR of 2.0 is the standard for starting position players in a full season. 100% disagree with the notion that he is merely "not much more than a replacement level player" based on the available numbers.

Plus he was only 129 days older than his dad was comparing their respective Marlins debuts. I know Jeff played a couple of seasons with the Royals beforehand, but his career didn't really take off until he was a Marlin. He had a fairy productive and long career after that point. I don't see any reason to think that Griffin is incapable of that kind of longevity.

On 5/30/2025 at 12:57 PM, FishFan95 said:

I think he gets claimed. But maybe I'm wrong.

Simon was in fact claimed and we may see him next week in Pittsburgh.

On 5/30/2025 at 6:31 PM, TheMarlinsProject said:

Winkler has been good at Jacksonville. He deserves a shot.

Dane should be playing every day at center.

They needed another OF so it was Heriberto.

Simon has a good bat but his defense (ever before his meltdown game) is atrocious.

Neither guy is expected to be a big part of the future and can be optioned once Cronin and Eury are ready.

Hernandez rates even worse at defense than Simon. His batting profile is more of less what we have seen from Mervis. The good power is significantly undermined by poor plate discipline. That is the kind of thing that rarely translates to the Big Leagues. Maybe it's splitting hairs on which fringe bench player you think will be better in 2 years, but I do think that letting go of Simon for Hernandez was a mistake.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.