Everything posted by Marlins2003
-
Paul Lo Duca
There's a difference between being a defensive replacement and a utility player, or for that matter a hitter who has three gloves. It might be worthwhile that his fall from grace with the Nationals had much to do with a broken hand, a seemingly chronic injury (at least in the sense he's broken it in one fashion or another multiple times) which hampered his play. As for left field he's played 40 games there over his career. I'm not suggesting and I don't think anything I wrote would suggest his specialty is defense at any position. I do believe though with double switches and pinch hitting as it happens in the National League, I can imagine scenarios where Fredi inserts PLD as a pinch hitter and uses him at first or left field because another player has been used previously or because of the way the lineup is constructed or who the opposing team has pitching or in the bullpen and Fredi wants to get him another at bat later in the game. The guy has caught one game so far and made two errors (I don't remember what they were or the circumstances). He isn't going to make two errors every time he catches certainly but I'll say again he's here for his bat and anything he can provide in the field takes a back seat to that. From what Fredi said yesterday I guess he's going to try to find more ways to get LoDuca more at bats and that means to me more playing time. How he does it we'll have to wait and see.
-
FISH OF THE GAME 8/24
I voted for Arthur Rhodes only because he deserved so love after his stint today. Clearly Ricky is the guy with game ball, but Rhodes once again proves the pundits wrong who mocked the Marlins for trading for him.
-
Paul Lo Duca
As I watched Matt Treanor contributing mightly to today's save in the ninth with plays behind the plate John Baker only dreams of making someday I'm baffled at some of the responses here. For those of you who are confused let me help you. You obviously missed the memo when LoDuca came aboard so I'll just paraphrase for you. Paul LoDuca is here as a pinch hitter and an irregular catcher, first baseman and left fielder as the manager decides to play him. He is not an everyday catcher, he isn't even your number two catcher, he's a utility player with a good understanding of what he's doing when he goes up to bat, who can catch. Matt Treanor remains the best defensive catcher, injury or no, hands down. That is not open to debate. When you need a win, when a must-win series is on the line, Matt Treanor is going to be the guy. As long as his health lasts he's here to do what he does best. John Baker has proven himself to be exactly what he always was, good bat, no glove. Would you really have liked Baker catching the ninth inning today with sliders in the dirt? No, I didn't think so. His bat can sometimes make up for his defensive shortcomings against certain types of pitchers and he'll be used that way. Hopefully that helps clear things up for some of you. And for those looking for Justin Miller he's in Albuquerque on the reserve list as the roster is full so he's still in the organization.
-
Question: Can a player...?
I love antedoctal evidence. Thanks, works for me. I was thinking about it in the context of stealing Reggie Willits from the Angels without dealing with Moreno. Purely fantasy stuff for my own amusement. I was thinking about who needed someone we're probably going to move bad enough that they'd play the patsy with the Halos.
-
Jeremy Hermida
You start with a faulty belief, that Willingham gets on base more frequently than LoDuca and you ignore what's happening on the field of play right now. It is not even remotely faulty and ignores nothing. If a guy goes 2-3 with a walk one day, and 3-4 with 2 doubles the next we shouldn't start to pretend he is a .714 / .750 / .1000 player. Oh please Eric, you're a good guy but to ignore the freefall Willingham is in ridiculous. You note I said LoDuca can't possibly keep up this pace, I realize his numbers are not representative either. I'm not saying use the best of one guy and the worst of another at all. When LoDuca falls back to earth and is human again, and something lights a fire under Willingham's ass and he regains his earlier form I have zero, nada, no argument with him in the two hole. But first he has to start hitting. We're a week away from September. This season is 5/6th over. Time is running out. I know I'm repeating myself but you have to go with the hot hand.
-
Jeremy Hermida
Not sure...but is this directed towards my lineup proposal? I promise Erik, no, if you had a lineup idea I either missed it or forgot it existed.
-
Jeremy Hermida
That all may be true if the only options LoDuca can provide result in an out. What he seems to be able to do is get hits out of the two hole (at least so far and at an extraordinary rate - no I'm not saying it continues) so by handicapping the stats all you do is come up with the result you wanted. So far he's batting .444, with an OBP of .540 and almost all those hits are to right, right center and center. As for Willingham you have again find stats that fit the result because you can't possibly use his numbers since he came back from missing 50 games (in other words what a real-time picture of what he's doing right now). You start with a faulty belief, that Willingham gets on base more frequently than LoDuca and you ignore what's happening on the field of play right now. May, pre-injury, was a thousand years ago. You can't possibly make the argument Willingham is the same hitter he was before he was hurt. In the same vein I can't make an argument that LoDuca is going to continue at this torrid and unsustainable pace. All Fredi or any manager can do is go with the guy with a hot hand and right now that's LoDuca. However flawed it may seem, between the two there isn't a whisper of chance Willingham replaces LoDuca hitting second until simultaneously LoDuca falls off AND Willingham regains with stroke.
-
Jeremy Hermida
Trust me, I'm the last guy suggesting LoDuca in right field now or ever.
-
Jeremy Hermida
Jeremy has been better than Hammer in the 2nd half is the other. Help me here. Maybe I'm looking at the wrong #s but post ASG Willingham seems at least incrementally better offensively than Hermida. Am I wrong or dyslexic or both?
-
Jeremy Hermida
People ought to recognize (I guess it's their choice but I think it's so obvious) that the currently configured team cannot make it to October. I don't suggest Mark Kotsay because I love Mark Kotsay - he's cleared waivers and is with a team right behind us with only the Nationals able to make a claim in our way (he'd have to agree but since he's a free agent next season I can't see him saying no and having at least some chance of playing in October on his resume). You can wish all you want (Ligero not you specifically, the figurative "you") that LoDuca could do this or Gonzo or Helms or whoever could do that, but if they could they already would be. The only conceivable thing you could do when Hanley is 100% is play Amezega in CF and Ross in one of the corners, or the opposite but otherwise the manager's hands are really tied. He can play all three outfield positions but assuming Cody stays in center (if it ain't broke, don't fix it) with the arrival of Kotsay one of the two - Hermida or Willingham - is benched or sent to AAA where he can still be back with the team the next day (sort of) with Sept call ups. I might be wrong about that and I'll let Nny figure it out but I think so many of Willingham's and Hermida's trips to the minors were rehab assignments they don't count, both players can be sent to AAA without exposing them to other teams and if someone wanted them we cross that bridge when we get there. Willingham is at least showing some life. Here are their two gamelogs. Compare July and August. The guy who loses his job is obvious: http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/players/gamelog?playerId=6199 Hermida http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/players/gamelog?playerId=6024 Willingham Maybe this is what Hermida needs. Maybe it will ruin his psyche (an old argument here at MB.com that he was fragile and sensitive and taking a boot camp mentality with him would only damage him more). I cannot predict. And I admit, I know 1% of what the front office knows so this isn't me telling them what to do but it's as plain as the nose on your face something has to change with our corner outfielders and the one most replacable with Kotsay is Hermida if for no other reason than Kotsay's experience there. You gain nothing by taking Josh's arm out of left field and his bat is warming up. Or is it? Do I see him making better contact or am I seeing what I want to see? I'm open to any opinion contrary to mine on this. But, if I had to bet on who has the better Sept my money is on Willingham. Oh yeah, and while you're at it Mike, grab David Weathers too will ya? He will not be playing on the Reds on Sept 1, better us than Philly or the Mets, both of whom need relievers. Unless I am missing something he's the spare closer/setup guy you need. Waechter is coming back, Kensing goes to AAA to make room anyways. I absolutely love the all old guy bullpen of Waechter, Rhodes, Nelson, Hendrickson and Weathers with Lindstrom and Gregg (sometimes) setting up. Well back to work. Have fun with this one.
-
Jeremy Hermida
i wish we'd stop entertaining the idea of gonzo playing everyday at an outfield spot.... though his bat may be slightly better than hermida's right now... his defense is amazingly horrifying and aggravating to watch. at least for me. yes :thumbup (and that's no knock on Gonzo, it just is what it is) go get Kotsay in the next few days, certainly before the upcoming mets series
-
trade ideas....
I think acquiring an eighteen year old to be your catcher of the future has disaster written all over it if the price is a major league hitter who will conceivably hit 30 homeruns this season. And yes I know the Marlins drafted a high school catcher this summer so I'm not ignoring that the front office thinks otherwise. I'll be happy to be wrong on all counts.
-
trade ideas....
I think acquiring an eighteen year old to be your catcher of the future has disaster written all over it if the price is a major league hitter who will conceivably hit 30 homeruns this season. And yes I know the Marlins drafted a high school catcher this summer so I'm not ignoring that the front office thinks otherwise. I'll be happy to be wrong on all counts.
-
Chone Figgins....
Well you aren't going to get him via free agency because of the cost and you *aren't* going to be doing a lot of trading with a team owned by Artie Moreno so the chances are pretty slim. A few years ago when Figgins briefly fell out of favor perhaps, but not now and not n the immediate future.
-
6 games
We are playing for one thing right now. To be less than three games behind going into the final series at Shea in September. I have no doubt of the results should we make it to Flushing even 2 1/2 games back on September 26th. None at all.
-
Jeremy Hermida
I think everyone is disappointed with Jeremy Hermida including himself. If he's not he shouldn't be playing MLB. He had a chance to nail a multi-year, multi-millions contract and blew it. Certainly the same could be said of others but none came with the hype and the can't miss promise Hermida came into the league with. It goes to show you how so many (experts) really know so little about the prospects they rank and especially about the intangibles they possess beyond their obvious tools. Part of that is the sheer number of players entering a draft every year and the couple of hundred players every major league team has in their minor league organizations at any one time. I wish more of BA's work or Sickels for examples (and not to hold them up as the only guilty parties, they are just the most recognizable names) spent more time gathering data on players as to their work ethics and desire (perhaps competitiveness would be a better word, I know "desire" is one of those words statheads love to jump all over and ridicule), comments from coaches and scouts on both sides of the diamond regarding maturity, game smarts, etc. This of course is an anathema to statheads but quantifying some of this stuff might lead to a group of "intangibles" stats that could go hand in hand a lot of the stuff we see now. I've always said of stats and why I don't give them the weight others do isn't because they aren't representative of something, they aren't representative ENOUGH. They are incomplete. They mean to be accurate but often equate to half-truths solely because their formulas are incomplete and take too little into account. In horse race handicapping, the condition of the track is a significant factor. Why isn't it in baseball? In golf, courses are rated to adjust handicaps of golfers coming from other courses. When you have an outfield like in Colorado why isn't that a factor to be considered vs say Chicago? But I've strayed far afield. The masses cannot be completely wrong that Hermida (and I don't mean to single him out) makes some very poor choices in the field, gets woeful jumps and gives up on balls way too quickly. Or that for the most part he's timid at the plate, apparently of the belief that his chances are better of drawing a walk than getting a hit (and of course by now pitchers in MLB have figured out how to pitch to someone who thinks that way). These aren't my observations, these are the observations of probably hundreds of thousands of people who watch Marlins baseball regularly and while statheads will just pass it off as "your eyes are lieing to you..." when so many see the same thing so often there has to be some truth to it. My guess is, just from random conversations with people in all walks of life who share a Marlins passion that JH is probably the biggest disappointment on this team in recent years. Hands down. And if he's not with the team in 2009 not a tear will be shed except by his adoring female teeny-bopper fan base. There is of course as I've posted elsewhere a chance at redemption. As with Jacobs, Willingham and others, September is a month for redemption. He's running out of time but he can do it. As a Marlins fan I pray he does. As a realist I don't think a leopard changes its spots.
-
Question: Can a player...?
Can a player (regular player, not 10/5, no contract other than one offered a player during his first three years in the league) be traded from team A to team B and then within say seven or thirty days be traded to team C? I was trying to find the specific rule on this earlier in the morning without success which absent a rule would suggest the answer is yes, but admittedly I could be asking the wrong question (query) or I'm looking in the wrong section of the MLB/MLBPA basic agreement. If someone knows definitively I'd like to know.
-
Maybin or Coghlan getting the Call?
McPherson isn't playing either.
-
Break Up the Marlins!
The fastest way to the Hall of Fame is to fail two out of every three times. I used to be at the ballpark early in the day a few years ago quite regularly and you'd be surprised at the workouts the players go through daily. On the field, in the cages they are (or were) regularly tutored. I can't say that I know that continues but I can't believe it doesn't. I could go on about this but for me what we're seeing with a Hermida is he has reached his level of competency. Hanley may forever be a sucker for that low outside pitch he chases seemingly every time someone spots one there. Or they may each get better. Clearly Hanley has the drive to succeed. Others, for reasons of their own doing or out of their hands not so much. We knew that when this team took the field in 2006 that this upcoming off-season the cream would rise to the top and for many this would be their last season in South Florida. Mike Jacobs has spoken about it since the beginning of spring training, the clarity of the situation, how this season was make or break for all but a small handful of guys who came together what's almost three seasons ago. September is going to be interesting to watch because redemption is there for those who want it. For a ___________ being a role player on some team and making a couple of million a year will seem enough. Others will battle until the last pitch at least having a say in their destiny. I wouldn't miss it for the world.
-
Break Up the Marlins!
Mungo I wouldn't even know where to start with that awful post. Why bother?
-
And his name...is DAN UGLY!
The problem here is (when it comes to draft picks) you're playing the result so the odds are stacked in your favor. The same thing happens on every other club. It's like "firesales". Billy Beane has conducted more firesales than any GM in history. I's almost an annual event, but when he does it he's "retooling". When there's talk of the Marlins jettisoning a underperforming Mike Jacobs (with a Jorge Cantu or Gaby sanchez waiting in the wings) or even a Jeremy Hermida or a Kevin Gregg, it's a "firesale".
-
More Lineup ideas
If you listen to 'Topes games you hear that McPherson, while playing as hard as he can, has run out of gas after a long hot season and a year and half out of baseball. You might not even see him in Sept except as a reward for what he did this season. I think that is best too. I also think they shouldn't play the hell out of Maybin either. Maybin is getting better with every game (a little hyperbole, every player has off games) and he's just about a lock on starting in centerfield next season. He's so ready right now if it weren't for the AA playoffs they might have called him up already. I might be wrong but my sense is the FO wants to see this group of guys win a championship together over the next few weeks. He struck out twice in the last five games (but to be fair he struck six times in the five games before) his OBP keeps improving, he's hitting everything thrown at him now, I really think CF is the least of our problems moving forward.
-
Best tools cited
Gaby Sanchez received best defensive first baseman Gaby just became my favorite... I really don't see why he won't be our first baseman in '09. The same thought may have crossed Mike Jacobs' mind. Trade Jake now and bring up Gabby Sanchez I'm just guessing because the way the August waiver wire works who knows...but you have to think the Marlins put Jacobs out there and he cleared (in other words no takers).
-
More Lineup ideas
If you listen to 'Topes games you hear that McPherson, while playing as hard as he can, has run out of gas after a long hot season and a year and half out of baseball. You might not even see him in Sept except as a reward for what he did this season.
-
And his name...is DAN UGLY!
We should still sign Uggla. The entire team is slumping, lets not pretend it is just Dan Why? Then people won't have a convenient target to hate on. :brigginbounce