Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

dim

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by dim

  1. Well wouldn't be shocking. Jose doesn't deal with the dollar figure. Boras gets him the most money he can, and Jose pitches. That's generally how those relationships work. While I understand asking the question since it's a top news item when it comes to Fernandez, they honestly shouldn't have expected to get a real answer from him.
  2. I'd say between 76 and 84 wins depending on injuries, players outperforming/underperforming projections, etc... Not a playoff team in most scenarios, but not a complete push over. The biggest problem is the farm system provides no leeway for failure among the major league talent. Any injuries or general underperforming at any position and we're sh*t out of luck at that spot. We have some starting pitching depth, but not exactly guys who can put up ERA's in the 3's if called upon towards the end of the rotation. The bigger issue will be the starting lineup. No minor league players are even close to be considered major league starters, so an injury to guys like Yelich, Hechavarria, Gordon, etc... and we have absolutely no good contingency plans. Poor trades, poor drafting, and unwillingness to spend money in a variety of ways (free agents, spending in the draft, international free agents, etc...) has left this team in a really bad position moving forward. The depth isn't bad on this team...it's completely non-existent. With that said, I'd be willing to bet we're close to being in the low 70 wins again than we are to being in the mid 80 wins.
  3. I remember the team having this policy under Girardi in 2006. I'm of the opinion that this is a baseball field, not a Fortune 500 company's corporate office so if you want to grow a beard go ahead. Honestly it doesn't matter, although worrying about facial hair for even a second is a second that isn't being thrown into trying to make the team better.
  4. How could you possibly be willing to pass up the chance to eventually take the fall for poor decisions by higher-up management? That's a dream job if I've ever heard one.
  5. Yes, but Loria is the boss so even if he is the main person responsible there will be others who take the blame. Loria won't fire himself so it's incredibly dumb to point out the obvious.
  6. And I'm with Lou that it's kinda weird that you put Realmuto 2nd. Prado's the obvious #2 candidate. I also think it'll be Nicolino who gets that 5th rotation spot, not Conley. Other than that seems about right.
  7. I mean Koehler deserves a rotation spot from the get go. He's been one of the few consistent rotation spots the last two years. He's been able to stay healthy, provide innings and give the team chances to win. Sure he'll completely bomb every few games and he always lives on the edge with the constant fly balls but he's earned the chance to fail or succeed on his own.
  8. Like I said, I'm in favor of keeping Jose until next offseason, but it isn't because I imagine his value will be higher then. I believe with a good season it will be equal to what it is now, which is a team's top two prospects, a major league starter with good potential, and a throw in piece or two. I'm in favor of keeping him because the team isn't a complete lost cause this year, and with a sizable amount of lucky bounces the Marlins could reach the playoffs in the shaky National League this year. I'm not trading Jose if there is even a tiny chance of the playoffs with him.
  9. I feel like his value is as high as it'll ever be. He's 23 years old, has 3 relatively cheap years left of control, and has already got Tommy John surgery out of the way. I understand the Price comparison, but Price was 29 years old when traded. Any team looking to acquire him knows they have maybe three or four prime years left when trading for him. Jose is 23 years old. Any team trading for him could very easily have a decade of prime pitching ahead of them. The only situation I can ever remember even close to this was when the Mariners were floating around Felix Hernandez's name in trades following his Cy Young Runner up 2009 season. He was also 23 years old then. Hernandez signed a 5 year extension right after for $78 million, but the financial landscape of baseball is completely different than it was then. Jose is would get $130 million+ for those same 5 years if he was available on the open market today. There has never been a player like Jose Fernandez traded this good and this early in his career, and none since Felix that were ever even discussed in trades. This is unique territory we're in.
  10. I get the joke when used for Twine but Hernandez is actually a good starting 2nd baseman.
  11. Don't remember those talks on this board but I remember touting German highly just because it was somewhat rare to see a guy pitch like he did in GBoro. Wasn't a huge loss when we traded him, but the fact that we traded every valuable prospect or young player we had (Heaney, Desclafani, Wallach, Hernandez, Barnes, Hatcher, German, Eovaldi) for a run last year that didn't pay off really sucks. Add the mid season trades that saw the loss of Martes/Moran/Marisnick, and we've basically traded a top 12 MLB farm system in the last year in a half for very little overall return (a good two months of Cosart, a good year of Haren, a league average 3B in Prado and Dee Gordon are the rewards from all those players we let go). Watching the depletion of the Marlins entire farm system over the last year and a half has been horrible.
  12. That's a problem too. Jose puts a lot of stress in his delivery. Another serious injury and his trade value plummets. It can be argued it'll never get higher than it'll be over the next year. Is it worth keeping Jose just to have him pitch the next two years on non-contender teams (this can be argued) or turn him into assets while he's at his highest value. Like I said not an easy answer here. The Marlins got the highest return possible for Cabrera and we know how that turned out. I can't really give a comparison for Jose since there hasn't ever been a player like him in this situation before. Most teams find the money to keep a player of that caliber long term. But the Marlins aren't most teams. I understand the 3 years thing though. The concern though is definitely banking on full health during that time period.
  13. I agree. Deadline gets teams desperate and if we're clearly out, there's really no reason to trot Jose out an unnecessary two months and risk injury.
  14. Don't know if this was a joke post but German missed all of last year after Tommy John surgery. Plus his record was against low A as a 22 year old. He's likely less of a prospect now than he was when we traded him to the Yankees. I'm not sure anybody could've predicted Martes becoming as good as he is. That Cosart trade is definitely turning out to become one sided, especially with Kike Hernandez proving himself hugely valuable for the Dodgers.
  15. Yeah not exactly news. His agent is Scott Boras. I don't think any rational fan actually believes that we have a chance at re-signing Jose. The question becomes when they decide to pull the trigger on a trade. If he Marlins do it now it could be argued they are trading him when they still have prime years they can squeeze out of him and still get similar trade value come 2018. On the other hand, if he gets injured again then the term "injury prone" could become a thing with Jose and drastically kill his value. Not exactly a simple answer here, although I'd say you run with Jose until next offseason to see if we can pull of a miracle run to the playoffs this year. If the Dodgers ever agree to give Seager/Urias/Pedersen all together at any point this season I say you trade Jose immediately. Other than that you hold onto him.
  16. 2013 called and said this is awesome. Actually it's a decent deal since he'll need to perform to even make the team. It also never hurts to have a Yale mind in the locker room.
  17. None of those names seem to say Tommy Hutton, therefore I am against it.
  18. So Kolek isn't even a top 200 prospect now? Would've assumed he'd stay in the top 100 just based on his age and being able to throw 100 MPH. But I agree that he's got a long uphill battle to become a top prospect again. The system is going to be really hard to follow next year. Outside of guys like Naylor/Garrett/Woods I'm not sure who I'm looking forward to watching. The farm is incredibly rough shape. Really wish we would've found a way to sign Matt Krook regardless of the injury a little while back. A guy like him would've helped give the Marlins a top pitching prospect to tout at least.
  19. I'm gonna go on a limb and say guys like Nny and MarlinsLou are beyond being interns.
  20. I know 7 words in that sentence. I feel I'm more than qualified.
  21. Didn't the Marlins Official Twitter tweet out recently advocating threesomes?
  22. dim replied to sdg210's topic in Miami Marlins
    I didn't think the question was all that memorable, but yes it was.
  23. dim replied to sdg210's topic in Miami Marlins
    I had a friend who helped get me the VIP access stuff last year and I even got to ask a question, which ended up being me saying the farm system was made "barren" due to the trades they made in the offseason and if they were worried that could end up backfiring. I got told by Michael Hill that the system wasn't barren (he seemed annoyed I called the system he helped build 'barren') and there was no reason to worry. I will not be attending this year.
  24. You tease me a Cliff Floyd Shark Tank appearance and then tell me I can't watch it. This is just cruel.
  25. The lack of the great Robert Andino in this thread disturbs me.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.