Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Learn more

dim

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by dim

  1. I was upset just seeing Gordon for Heaney. Seeing Hernandez and Barnes added to the trade I just about had an aneurysm. This is my least favorite trade since the Willingham/Olsen trade (I know it worked out kinda with Bonifacio, but at the time the head of the trade was PJ Dean...Who retired before ever playing). We got a second baseman...who's eh other than his speed while giving up our top pitching prospect, our top 2B prospect and favorite to win the job outright (and who was beloved as a fun underdog 2B by Astros fans), and Barnes who I've touted in the minors as the most underrated prospect in the system along with Canha. I'm really frustrated here. I like Gordon at the top of the lineup but you gave up a god damn platter of players to get somebody who is in extreme buy high mode. DAMN RAYS GM now DODGERS GM screwing our front office.
  2. Uh oh I mean it would make sense the Marlins would overpay for a package of Miley/Trumbo. When Hill said he had deals that would mean trading "considerable prospects for the present team" I felt like it would be Miley/Trumbo. Marlins have had an infatuation with Trumbo for two and a half years and Miley is the lefty, slightly better version of Eovaldi that the Marlins have coveted in the starting rotation. While they might not necessarily be the best trade options since we'd give up real prospects for a so so first baseman in Trumbo and the lefty slightly better version of Eovaldi, It feels like that is the kind of deal the Marlins see as "game changing".
  3. 2b

    dim replied to pollythewog's topic in Miami Marlins
    I'd probably be willing to part with Conley and another top 20 prospect asset such as Justin Bohn for Gordon, but I don't think I'd be willing to give up the Nicolino/German/Urena's of the team for Gordon. Guys like Williams/Disco are probably important to hold onto to see if they work out (Williams as a #3/4 starter hopefully, Disco as a good set up reliever or #5 starter) rather than trade away for a player like Gordon. But like I've said before, Gordon would be an interesting change of pace style bat to add to the lineup. Just a matter of how much they'd be asking for.
  4. Morneau >>>> morse. Not even a discussion As a player yes we're not denying it. But it would really end up being a discussion of what we'd be giving up to get Morneau who's not signed for any long term length anyway. Is a year or two of Morneau worth a package that'll include Eovaldi/Heaney/Desclafani/German/Nicolino/ potentially or would you rather take the two year gamble on Morse while getting to keep those young assets? I'll take Morse, even if I know he's not as good as Morneau, simply because the front office would look like idiots if they trade Eovaldi/Heaney/Disco for Morneau, Morneau ends up retiring or leaving in a year or two, and whatever pitcher we trade goes on to be a #2 starter that many hoped for while under contract for many, many more years. For me it's no contest. You don't trade assets for short term solutions when you aren't a fringe playoff team or coming off a playoff spot. Teams like the Marlins need to do moves like they did at the last deadline with getting Cosart/Hernandez/Wates. You are allowed to trade good prospects but you also need to get players who'll be signed to cheap contracts for 4-6 years moving forward. Morneau doesn't fit that bill (and Morse doesn't cost assets to get that 1/2 year deal).
  5. The Marlins are Amaro'ing these winter meetings Or, you know, they're not being stupid by trading guys like Heaney for bleh guys. If we leave the Winter Meetings with Morse/Peavy or Masterson/Gordon I think it'll be a successful trip. As much as I think trading for Gordon would be buying high on a so so player, I can't help but think a true leadoff hitter would bring both speed to the lineup, and at the same time makes Yelich a better player by putting him at his natural spot at #2 in the lineup. Michael Morse is the best 1B we wouldn't have to trade prospects for, and Peavy or Masterson would likely be guys we can give one year "prove yourself and get a final big deal next year somewhere else" that are the smart short term signings when you have good depth at the starting pitching spot, especially once Jose comes back. There's still A LOT of time to do stuff. The free agent market this year isn't outstanding but there are still some solid moves to be made.
  6. Guess that went Marlins talk about players taking less $ in any deal they also including the $ in their names. Sorry Michael 'More'.
  7. Wild Card you are just the wuuuuuuuurst this time of year.
  8. Morneau's away splits last year were actually pretty respectable (like 820 ops). I looked it up and that's actually pretty interesting. There's little stability in Morneau's numbers Home/Away throughout his career so I don't know what to really think about that. I'd rather not trade valuable resources for what would end up being a one year rental.
  9. Oooh, burn. Too soon? I think "Oh Snap" would've worked better since that's what actually happened.
  10. I'm sure Morneau's stats were in absolutely no way influenced by Coors Field last year. We wouldn't at all be buying high on a player who will likely hit at a Garrett Jones level (better defense but still) next season. Please just get Michael Morse and call it a day. As the days go by the options the Marlins are targeting become more and more ludicrous.
  11. Damn. What's the trade market like to replace a manager with an ACL tear? Is John Boles available?
  12. Nah dawg. He demanded a stipulation that says he can never close Wilin Rosario has nothing to do with this.
  13. Allison is awesome during games, but I can't help but notice she always looked exhausted when doing broadcasts. Imagine the schedule she was working the last two years really took a toll.
  14. nah dawg
  15. Looking up on it it seems both are still gonna miss time. Wonder if they just re-sign with Atlanta for cheaper or take a minor league deal somewhere mid season.
  16. He also hit in Jupiter. Short sample size yes, but he should become a top 7 prospect in the system before next year's done.
  17. Brandon Beachy too. Medlen was so good in 2013, but Tommy John surgery is no joke X2. I mean if they really are upset with not being tendered, what a better F-U than to sign with a divisional rival and prove that they were wrong right to their face multiple times a year if they can get healthy at some point.
  18. Peavy's coming off a finish to last season where he put up a 2.17 ERA with the Giants (bad World Series but still). I might come off as a bit crazy here but I feel like 3 years $45 million would need to happen to get him to come here (we're not the most desirable location so no discount, and seeing that he's 33 I'd think he wants to go for one more semi long-ish term deal before going back to the year to year format. Basically I see him cashing in on his good 2014 in San Fran where he greatly benefited from a move back to the NL). EDIT: Looking at the article ESPN posted about Peavy I didn't realize teams are really holding his World Series ERA against him (and I guess his Boston beginning too). If that's what could be holding him back (as even Peavy said in the article that he "has a lot to prove") and we can get him for a reasonable deal for two years, I'd absolutely love him in Miami. He's the kind of guy that could actually have an All Star caliber season pitching at Marlins Park.
  19. Long term Barnes projects to likely be a utility player/backup, but his numbers have warranted him being brought up at a better pace. I feel the biggest indictment of this was when he got his chance at Jacksonville, posted a .900+ OPS in a relatively short time there, and immediately was sent back down to Jupiter. Granted he struggled in Jupiter after that so read into it what you may, but I have to imagine proving yourself in AA and being sent back to A+ ball can be a bit demoralizing. If you want to follow an under the radar prospect go check out Chad Wallach in Jupiter next year. He was trashed as our early round pick when we took him (I believe poor bat and nepotism were the biggest complaints) and all he's done is hit since being drafted. If he continues to perform this way and the Marlins don't toy with him he could be a really fast riser in the system. Realmuto probably starts the season in AAA since we'll have Salty/Mathis in the big leagues and it makes little sense to have 3 catchers, Barnes will start at catcher in AA and Wallach in A+ ball. Realmuto has already seen MLB time, Barnes isn't that far behind and Wallach is just one or two good months to start off in A+ ball from a call up. This is the most stacked with decent players we've been at the catcher position in the minors that I can ever remember.
  20. SHHHHH there's never an inappropriate time to post that gif.
  21. Never a more appropriate time to use this
  22. Is Koehler going to be 2013 instead of 2014? I know this is just nitpicking in the post but wouldn't you rather have 2014 Koehler? 2014 Koehler was pretty damn good even when factoring in the four truly bad starts he had all season. I'm not denying that there was a fair amount of luck involved, park factors helping him and so on but Koehler was a pretty fun surprise last season. Not just a surprise, but last season he pitched like a #3 starter (and looked like even with the inevitable worse year in 2015 could still be a pretty effective #4/5 pitcher). To be completely honest I'm far more worried about Eovaldi/Heaney keeping their spots in the rotation next season than I am of Koehler. But that is mainly because I remember that when his stuff was working last season, he pitched like one of the best pitchers on the staff. His biggest issue was that when he left his stuff in the zone it got pummeled and some games he pitched got out of hand in a real hurry. But in regards to the topic at hand you are right. Far too many variables to say we're a rental away. I don't see a Price/Porcello/Shields guaranteeing us at least a Wild Card spot next season when our infield is so utterly disgusting right now. Adding Michael Morse and replacing McGehee with a 3B not an obvious candidate to suck (which won't happen because Comeback Player of the Year blah blah blah) would be better alternatives to making this team competitive going into next season. I've given up arguing over Hechavarria because I know he'll be here forever and I like the chances with a Dietrich/Hernandez at 2B better than the trade or free agent market so those are the things I think the team should be doing to improve.

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.